Skip to main content

Full text of "The life of James McNeill Whistler"

See other formats


SMITHSONIAN 
INSTITUTION 


GRR. 


THE LIFE OF JAMES 
McNEILL WHISTLER 


ee, 


a 


Pe 


ae 


ite 


PORTRAIT OF WHISTLER AS A BOY 


By Srre Witiram Boxaty 


THE LIFE OF JAMES 
McNEILL WHISTLER 


BY 
E. R. anp J. PENNELL 


IN TWO VOLUMES 
ILLUSTRATED 


VOLUME I 


PHILADELPHIA 
J.B. LIPBPINCOL?T COMPANY 
LONDON: WILLIAM HEINEMANN 
1908 


Printed by BALLANTYNE & Co. LimiTEp 
Tavistock Street, Covent Garden, London 


oo.) 


Ws7Pt + 


Ff, Pie - 
iGOta 


v.i 


PREFACE 


Our debt is large to the many who have aided us in pre- 
paring our Life of Whistler. His sister Lady Haden, his 
sister-in-law Mrs. William Whistler, his niece Mrs. Charles 
Thynne, his cousins Mrs. Dr. Stanton and Miss Emma W. 
Palmer have kindly supplied us with much information that 
only his family could give, and have allowed us to consult 
family papers. Friends of his earliest years have come to 
our assistance: Mr. George Lucas, Mrs. Kate Livermore, 
and, after her death in 1906, her daughter Mrs. S. P. Sutton, 
Miss Emily Chapman, Mr. Delmar Morgan (who knew the 
Whistlers in St. Petersburg), Mr. Theodore L. Harrison 
(whose father was associated with Major Whistler in his 
engineering work in Russia), the late Mrs. Louise Chandler 
Moulton, Mr. Frederick B. Miles of Baltimore, Mr. Henry 
Labouchere. Nothing could exceed the courtesy of Whistler’s 
old classmates, their representatives and officers now at 
West Point: Col. C. W. Larned (who procured for us the 
official record, sent us numerous details of interest, lists of 
names and addresses, and answered our every appeal), Mr. 
¥. Holden, the Librarian at the Military Academy, Gen. 
Loomis L. Langdon, Gen. C. B. Comstock, Gen. Henry L. 
Abbot, Gen. O. O. Howard, Gen. D. McM. Gregg, Gen. 
G. W. C. Lee, Major Zalinski, Major H. H. Benham, Captain 
Joseph Wheeler, Mr. Thomas Childs. Old comrades of 
Whistler’s days in Paris have been as considerate: Mr. 
Luke Ionides (then and always Whistler’s friend, who has 
spared himself no trouble for our benefit), Mr. Thomas 

v 


PREFACE 


Armstrong, Mr. Joseph Rowley, M. Carolus-Duran, Félix 
Bracquemond, M. Henri Oulevey, Charles Drouet (the 
sculptor, who died only just before our book was finished 
and whose legacy of Whistler’s Old Man Smoking to the 
Luxembourg has been announced since it went to press). 
Friends of the first- London days have been no less generous : 
Mr. W. M. Rossetti (who searched his papers for us, wrote 
his impressions, and made many notes), Miss Greaves, Mr. 
Walter Greaves, Lord Redesdale, Mr. George Meredith, 
Mr. Fred. Jameson, Mr. Arthur Severn, Mr. Percy Thomas. 
We are also indebted to the directors and officials of various 
Academies, Galleries and Societies with which Whistler was 
associated in one way or another: the authorities of the 
Imperial Academy of Science at St. Petersburg, Mr. Sidney 
Colvin and Mr. Campbell Dodgson of the British Museum, 
Mr. E. F. Strange of the Victoria and Albert Museum, Sir 
Richard R. Holmes, late Librarian at Windsor Castle, Heer 
B. W. F. van Riemsdijk, Curator of the Rijks Museum at 
Amsterdam, Mr. William H. Goodyear, Curator of Fine Arts 
at the Brooklyn Museum, the Glasgow Corporation, Sir 
Walter Armstrong of the National Gallery of Ireland, Mr. 
T. W. Lyster of the National Library of Ireland, Mr. Alfred 
Kast, Mr. Watt Cafe and Mr. Carew Martin of the Royal 
Society of British Artists, Mr. John Lavery, Mr. T Stirling 
Lee and Dr.C. Bakker of the International Society of Sculptors, 
Painters and Gravers, Mr. Francis Bate of the New English 
Art Club, Dr. Norman Moore and Dr. Edward Liveing, 
Registrar, of the Royal College of Physicians, Mr. Holker 
Abbott, President of the Copley Society in Boston. 

The sympathetic co-operation of artists is a tribute 
Whistler would have appreciated: Mr. Edwin A. Abbey, 
Mr. Otto Bacher, Mr. and Mrs. Clifford Addams (Whistler’s 
devoted pupils and apprentices), Mr. John W. Alexander, 
Miss Nelia Casella, Miss A. M. Chambers, Mr. William M. 


vil 


PREFACE 


Chase, Mr. J. E. Christie, Mr. Timothy Cole, Mr. Walter 
Crane, Mr. Ralph Curtis, Mr. F. Morley Fletcher, Mr. Walter 
Gay, Mr. T. C. Gotch, Mr. William Graham, Mr. George 
R. Halkett, Mr. J. McLure Hamilton, Mr. Alexander Harrison, 
Mr. George A. Holmes, Mr. W. Ayerst Ingram, Mr. E. P. 
Jacomb-Hood, Mr. Francis James, Mr. J. Kerr-Lawson, 
Mr. E. Lantéri, Hon. Frederick Lawless, Mr. Frederick Mac- 
Monnies, Mr. Mortimer Menpes, Mrs. Anna Lea Merritt, Mr. 
Harper Pennington, M. Rodin, Mr. John S. Sargent, Pro- 
fessor G. Sauter, Mr. Frank Short, Mr. Sidney Starr, Mrs. 
Stillman, Mr. E. A. Walton, Mr. T. R. Way, Mr. J. Alden 
Weir, Mr. Henry Woods, Mr. E. H. Wuerpel. 

We can do no more than give the names of those to whom 
we are debtors in various other ways, to some for important 
facts or loans, to others for a few words illuminating a certain 
subject or period: Mr. W. C. Alexander, Mrs. George Boughton, 
Mr. Ernest G. Brown, Mr. Alan S. Cole (who placed his diary 
in our hands, with a generosity for which we cannot be 
too grateful, so invaluable is it as a record of years 
before we knew Whistler, when dates are difficult to 
fix and his movements to follow), Lady Archibald 
Campbell, Lady Colin Campbell, Mr. Fitzroy Carrington, 
Mrs. D’Oyly Carte, the late Dr. Moncure D. Conway, Mr. 
J. J. Cowan, Mr. S. R. Crockett, Rev. R. W. Davies, Mr. 
Randall Davies, Miss Annie Davis, Mr. Charles W. Des- 
champs, Mr. Walter Dowdeswell, M. Durand-Ruel, M. 
Théodore Duret (whose own book was never a check upon 
his liberality in helping us with ours), Mr. Fred. Eaton, 
Secretary of the Royal Academy, the late Mrs. Edwin 
Edwards, Messrs. Ellis, Mr. S. M. Fox, Mr. Albert E. Gallatin, 
Mrs. J. L. Gardner, Mr. Edmund Gosse, Mr. Frederick 
Goulding, Mr. Algernon,Graves, M. Gérard Harry, Mr. J. P. 
Heseltine, Mr. E. J. Horniman, M.P., Mr. Samuel Hammond 


(who let us select from his interesting and, as far as we know, 
vii 


PREFACE 


unrivalled series of early Whistler drawings), Mr. Charles 
Holme, Messrs. Houghton Mifflin Co., Mrs. Alfred Hunt, 
Miss Violet Hunt, Mr. Constant Huntington, Mr. E. G. 
Kennedy (and few have so intimate a knowledge of Whistler 
and his work), Mr. Frederick Keppel and Mr. David Keppel 
(who, with their partner Mr. FitzRoy Carrington, have gone 
to endless trouble in collecting material and verifying facts 
for us), Mr. Gustav Kobbé, Mr. O. O. Kyllmann, Lady Lewis, 
Mrs. Leyland, Mr. Lazenby Liberty, Mr. C. H. McCall, Mr. 
Howard Mansfield, Mr. William Marchant, Mr. Murray 
Marks, Mrs. Marzetti, Mrs. Lynedoch Moncrieff, Mr. Arthur 
Morrison, Mrs. Sydney Morse, Mrs. John Newmarch, 
Messrs. Obach, Mr. S. S. Pawling, Mr. W. Booth Pearsall, 
Mr. Bliss Perry, Editor of the Ailantic Monthly, M. 
Edmond Picard, Mr. W. G. Rawlinson, Mrs. Richmond 
Ritchie, Mrs. F. Robb, Sir Rennell Rodd, Mr. Robert 
Ross, Countess Rucellai, Mr. Malcolm S. Salaman, Mrs. 
Spring-Rice, Mr. A. Strahan, Sir Thomas Sutherland, Mr. 
Arthur Symons, the American Ambassador, Hon. Van 
L. Meyer and the Third Secretary of Legation Mr. Basil 
Miles, at St. Petersburg, Mr. H. S. Theobald, K.C., Mr. D. 
Croal Thomson (who has permitted us to consult his in- 
valuable Whistler papers), Mr. and Mrs. T. Fisher Unwin, 
Mr. Emery Walker, Rev. Lionel J. Wallace (Vicar of Goring 
Church where the Whistlers lie buried), Mr. Pickford Waller 
(whose extraordinary collection of Whistleriana he entrusted 
to us while our work was in progress), Mrs. Westlake, Lord 
and Lady Wolseley, Dr. C. Hagberg Wright. 

It is not easy when so many have been induced by their 
interest in Whistler or affection for him to help us, to explain 
just what each and every one has done. In a great number 
of cases the pages of our book will give some idea of the 
extent of our indebtedness, and at least we can say how deep 
and sincere is our sense of obligation. One special word 
viii 


PREFACE 


of thanks, however, we must add. To no one do we owe 
more than to our publisher, Mr. William Heinemann, who 
has drawn upon his own friendship with Whistler to enrich 
us, who has aided us with his counsel, worked with us 
through difficulties, and faced the not light task of reading 
our book in manuscript and proof, giving us the advantage 
of his criticism and advice. 


JOSEPH PENNELL. 
ELIZABETH ROBINS PENNELL. 


3 AprLeat TERRACE Hovsz, 
Lonpon, W.C. 


CT ‘ON ,Aaaing 9sn09 ay.z y mous pabhanjuy) 
“ SHUNT HILL 


CONTENTS 


INTRODUCTION 


CHAPTER I. THE WHISTLER FAMILY. THE YEARS 
EIGHTEEN THIRTY-FOUR TO EIGHTEEN FORTY- 
THREE 

Whisiler’s Ancestors—His Parents—Birth—Early Years 


CHAPTER II. IN RUSSIA. THE YEARS EIGHTEEN 
FORTY-THREE TO EIGHTEEN FORTY-NINE 


Life in Russia—Schooldays—Begins His Art Studies in the Imperial 
Academy of Fine Aris—Death of Major Whistler—Return to America 


CHAPTER III. SCHOOL-DAYS IN POMFRET. THE 
YEARS EIGHTEEN FORTY-NINE TO EIGHTEEN 
FIFTY-ONE 

The Pomfret School and School-Mates—Early Drawings 


CHAPTER IV. WEST POINT. THE YEARS EIGHTEEN 
FIFTY-ONE TO EIGHTEEN FIFTY-FOUR 


Whistler as Cadet in the U.S. Military Academy—His Studies—Failure 
—Stories Told of Him—His Estimate of West Point 


CHAPTER V. THE COAST SURVEY. THE YEARS 
EIGHTEEN FIFTY-FOUR TO EIGHTEEN FIFTY-FIVE 


Lije inWashington—Obtains Position as Draughtsman in the U.S. Coast 
and Geodetic Survey—First Plates—Resignation—Starts for Paris 


be 


26 


30 


39 


CONTENTS 


CHAPTER VI. STUDENT DAYS IN THE LATIN 
QUARTER. THE YEARS EIGHTEEN FIFTY-FIVE 
TO EIGHTEEN FIFTY-NINE 


Arrival in Paris—Enters as Student at Gleyre’s—His Fellow Students— 
Adventures—Journey to Alsace 


CHAPTER VII. WORKING DAYS IN THE LATIN 
QUARTER. THE YEARS EIGHTEEN FIFTY-FIVE TO 
EIGHTEEN FIFTY-NINE CONTINUED 


His Studies—Work at the Louvre—Visit to Art Treasures Exhibition 
at Manchester—Hichings— Paintings— Rejection at the Salon and 
Exhibition in Bonvin’s Studio 


CHAPTER VIII. THE BEGINNINGS IN LONDON. THE 
YEARS EIGHTEEN EC Sees a E TO EIGHTEEN 
SIXTY-THREE ° 


In London with the Hadens—First appearance at Royal Academy— 
Kindness to French Fellow Students—Shares Studio with Du Maurier 
—Gaieties—Mr. Arthur Severn’s Reminiscences—W ork on the River— 
Joe—Eitchings published by Mr. Edmund Thomas 


CHAPTER IX. THE BEGINNINGS IN LONDON. THE 
YEARS EIGHTEEN FIFTY-NINE TO EIGHTEEN 
SIXTY-THREE CONTINUED 
Paintings and Exhibitions—The Music Room—Mr. Frederick Goulding 
on his Printing—Visits to Mr. and Mrs. Edwin Edwards—Summer in 


Britiany—‘ The White Girl” —Berners Street Gallery—Baudelaire on 
his Hichings—Ilustrations—Salon des Refusés—First Gold Medal 


CHAPTER X. CHELSEA DAYS. THE YEARS EIGHTEEN 
SIXTY-THREE TO EIGHTEEN SIXTY-SIX 


Settles with his Mother at No. 7 Lindsey Row, Chelsea—The Greaves 
Family—The Limerston Street Studio and Mr. J. E. Christie—Rossetti 
—The Tudor House Circle, Swinburne, Meredith, Frederick Sandys, 
Howell—" Blue and White” —W. M. Rossetti’s Reminiscences 


xii 


PAGE 


48 


66 


76 


88 


106 


CONTENTS 


CHAPTER XI. CHELSEA DAYS. THE YEARS EIGH- 
TEEN SIXTY-THREE TO EIGHTEEN SIXTY-SIX 
CONTINUED 


The Japanese Pictures—‘ The Princesse du Pays de la Porcelaine’’— 
Japanese Influence—‘‘ The Litile White Girl’ —Fantin’s ‘‘ Hommage 
& Delacroiz’’—‘*The Toast’”’—Arrival in London of Dr. Whistler— 
At Trouville with Courbet-—Journey to Valparaiso 


CHAPTER XII. CHELSEA DAYS CONTINUED. THE 

YEARS EIGHTEEN HUNDRED AND SIXTY-SIX TO 

EIGHTEEN HUNDRED AND SEVENTY-TWO 
Return to London—Removal to No. 2 Lindsey Row—The House and its 
Decorations—The 1867 Exhibition in Paris—Affair at the Burlington 
Fine Arts Club—‘: Symphony in White, No. III,” the First Picture 
Exhibited as a Symphony—Theories—Development—Discouragement 
—Mr. Fred. Jameson’s Reminiscences — Decoration — Hamerton’s 
*‘ Hiching and Hichers’’—LHitchings and Dry-Points—Exhibitions— 
Rejection at the Royal Academy—First Exhibition of Picture as a 
Nocturne—Relations to the Royal Academy 


CHAPTER XIII. NOCTURNES. THE YEARS EIGHTEEN 
SEVENTY-TWO TO EIGHTEEN SEVENTY-FOUR 


Nocturnes—Extent of Debt to Japanese—Methods and Materials— 
Subjects—Origin of Titlh—His Explanation in ‘‘ The Genile Art’? 


CHAPTER XIV. PORTRAITS. THE YEARS EIGHTEEN 
SEVENTY-TWO TO EIGHTEEN SEVENTY-FOUR 
“The Mother” —‘ Carlyle” —‘' Miss Alexander’’—Mr. and Mrs. 


Leyland—Mrs. Louis Huth—Show of his own Work in Pall-Mall— 
Indignation Roused by His Titles 


CHAPTER XV. THE OPEN DOOR. THE YEAR 
EIGHTEEN SEVENTY-FOUR AND AFTER 
Whistler’s Gaiety and Hospitality—His Amusement in Society—His 


Dinners and Sunday Breakfasts—Reminiscences of his Entertainments 
—His Talk—Clubs—Restaurants—The Theatre 


PAGE 


121 


137 


161 


168 


182 


xiii 


CONTENTS 


CHAPTER XVI. THE PEACOCK ROOM. THE YEARS 
EIGHTEEN SEVENTY-FOUR TO EIGHTEEN SEVENTY- 
SEVEN 
Work at Exhibitions and in the Studio—Portrait of Irving—< Rosa 
Corder” —“‘The Fur Jacket”’—‘* Connie Gilchrist’’-—The Peacock 
Room—Mr. Leyland’s House in Prince’s Gate—Its Decoration— 


Whistler’s Scheme for the Dining-Room and its Development—The 
Work Finished—Quarrel with Leyland 


CHAPTER XVII. THE GROSVENOR GALLERY. THE 
YEARS EIGHTEEN SEVENTY-SEVEN TO EIGHTEEN 
SEVENTY-EIGHT 


Sir Coutt Lindsay’s New Gallery—First Exhibition at the Grosvenor— 
Whistler’s Contributions—Ruskin’s Criticism of ‘‘ The Falling Rocket’? 
in ‘* Fors Clavigera’’—Whistler sues Him for Libel—Etchings— 
Lnthographs—Drawings of Blue and White for Sir Henry Thompson’s 
Catalogue—Caricatures—Sends a Second Time to the Grosvenor 


CHAPTER XVIII. THE WHITE HOUSE. THE YEAR 
EIGHTEEN SEVENTY-EIGHT 


Paris Universal Exhibition of 1878—Harmony in Yellow and 
Gold— Whistler as Decorator—Lady Archibald Campbell’s Appreciation 
—Plan of Opening an Atelier for Students—No, 2 Lindsey Row given 
up—E. W. Godwin Builds ithe White House for Him—His Mother’s 
Health—She Leaves Him for Hastings—Money Difficulties—Mezzo- 
tints of the ‘‘ Carlyle”’ and ‘‘ Rosa Corder”? 


CHAPTER XIX. THE TRIAL. THE YEAR EIGHTEEN 
SEVENTY-EIGHT 


Whistler’s Reasons for the Action against Ruskin—His Position and 
Ruskin’s compared—Refusal of Artists to Support Whistler—Trial in 
the Exchequer Chamber, Westminster—Verdict—The General Criticism 
—Mr. T. Armstrong and Mr. Arthur Severn on the Trial—Collection to 
pay Ruskin’s Expenses—Failure to raise one for Whistler 


CHAPTER XX. BANKRUPTCY. THE YEARS EIGHTEEN 
SEVENTY-EIGHT TO EIGHTEEN SEVENTY-NINE 
Caricatures and Comments—‘' Whistler v. Ruskin : Art and Art Critics” 


—Whistler again at the Grosvenor—His Critics—His Financial 
xiv 


PAGE 


198 


219 


229 


246 


CONTENTS 


Embarrassments—His Manner of Meeting Them—Declared Bankrupt 
—‘*The Gold Scab’’—Commission from the Fine Art Society for the 
Venetian Htchings—Starts for Venice—The Sale of the White House— 
Sale of Blue and White, Pictures, Prints, etc., at Sotheby’s 


CHAPTER XXI. VENICE. THE YEAR EIGHTEEN 
SEVENTY-NINE TO EIGHTEEN EIGHTY 


Whistler’s Arrival in Venice—First Impressions, Disappointments and 
Difficulttes—His Friends in Venice and Their Memories of Him— 
Duveneck and his “‘ Boys”’—Whistler’s Hard Work—His Lodgings 
and Restauranis—The Cafés—Stories Told of Him—Reminiscences of 
Mr. Harper Pennington and Mr. Ralph Curtis 


CHAPTER XXII. .VENICE. THE YEAR EIGHTEEN 
SEVENTY-NINE TO EIGHTEEN EIGHTY CONTINUED 


His Work in Venice—Pastels and his Methods—LHtchings—Printing 
—Mr. Frank Shorts Appreciation of Him as Printer—Japanese 
Method of Drawing—Water-Colours and Paintings 


CHAPTER XXIII. BACK IN LONDON. THE YEARS 
EIGHTEEN EIGHTY TO EIGHTEEN EIGHTY-ONE 


Return to London and Sudden Appearance at Fine Art Society’s— 
Prints Venice Plates—Exhibition of ‘‘The Twelve’? at the Fine Art 
Society’s—LExhibition of Venice Pastels—Decoration of Gallery— 
Bewilderment of Critics and the Public—Death of his Mother—*‘ The 
Piker Papers’’—The Portrait of his Mother Exhibited in Phila- 
delphia—Etchings begin to be shown in America 


CHAPTER XXIV. THE JOY OF LIFE. THE YEARS 
EIGHTEEN EIGHTY-ONE TO EIGHTEEN EIGHTY- 
FOUR 


Takes a Studio at 13 Tite Street-—His “ Joyousness ”’—Letters to the 
Press—His “Amazing ”’ Costumes—Portraits of Lady Meux—His Other 
Sitiers—Mrs. Marzetti’s account of the painting of ‘‘ The Blue Girl’? — 
Lady Archibald Campbell’s Reminiscences of the Sittings for her 
Portrait—Portrait of M. Duret—‘‘The Paddon Papers’’—Second 
Exhibition of Venice Hichings at the Fine Art Society’s—Excitement 
it Created—The ‘‘ Carlyle” at Edinburgh—Proposal to buy it for 
Scottish National Portrait Gallery—Comes to nothing—Whistler In- 
volved in a Church Congress 


1:6 


PAGE 


261 


276 


289 


300 


XV 


JOE 
(Dry-point) 


LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS 


PorTRAIT oF WHISTLER AS A Boy BY Sir WILLIAM Boxa.i 
Fronttspiece 


To face 


Dr. Dantet Wuister (1619-1684) 
From the picture in the Royal College of Physicians 


Masor George WasHineTon WuisTLer (Whistler's Father) 
By permission of Mrs. Dr. George D. Stanton and Miss Emma W. 
Palmer 

House IN wuicH WuisTLer was Born, Lowe i, Mass. 
From a photograph supplied by Mrs. Dr. George D. Stanton and Miss 
Emma W. Palmer 

OxLp Corner House, STONINGTON 
From a photograph supplied by Mrs, Dr. George D. Stanton and Miss 
Emma W. Palmer 

St. Anne’s Cuurcu, Lowe.t, Mass. 
From a photograph supplied by Mrs. Dr. George D. Stanton and Miss 
Emma W, Palmer 

Dr. Cuartes Donatp McNett (done in Hair) 
From a miniature in the possession of Mrs. Dr. George D. Stanton 
and Miss Emma W. Palmer 

Mrs. Cuartes Donatp McNEILL 


From a miniature in the possession of Mrs. Dr. George D. Stanton 
and Miss Emma W. Palmer 


Major GrorGe WasHINGTON WHISTLER AS A Youne Man (Whistler's 
Father) 


From a miniature in the possession of Mrs. William Whistler 


Mrs, Grorce WasHiNaTon WuistT ier (Whistler's Mother) 


In the possession of Mrs Dr. George Stanton and Miss Emma W, 
Palmer 


page 
2 


12 


12 


XVil 


(, ‘ 


" Ag i 
Cf. Peso 


To face 
page 

Tue Two Broturrs 26 
From a miniature formerly in the possession of Mrs. Dr. George D. 
Stanton and Miss Emma W. Palmer 

DrawineGs MADE AT PomFRET 28 
In the possession of Samuel Hammond, Esq. 

Drawine mabe at West Point (Copy of a Print) 32 
From the original at West Point by permission of Colonel C. W. 
Larned | 

TiTLe-PaGe FROM ScHoo.-Book, wiTH SKETCHES MADE BY WHISTLER 34 
In the possession of Thomas Childs, Esq. 

09 33x Sam Wetter’s Loveine iN THE Freer Prison (Water-Colour) 36 
: In the possession of Mrs. William Whistler 

On Post Dury at West Point (An Encampment) 36 
From the original at West Point by permission of Colonel C. W. 
Larned 

Tue Coast Survey, No. 1 (Eiching) 44 

Coast Survey, No. 2, Anacapa Istanp (Etching) 44 

La Mitre Gérarp 58 
Formerly in the possession of A. C. Swinburne, Esq. 

Tite pe PaysaNNE 68 
Now in the possession of Madame la Comtesse De Bearn 

Diana at THE Poot (Copy of a picture by Boucher) 72 
In the possession of Louis W. Winans, Esq. 

AT THE PIANo 76 
In the possession of Edmund Davis, Esq. 

DesiaN ror ProcraMME BY Du Maurier 84 
In the possession of Mrs. John Newmarch 

WapPiING 88 
In the possession of Mrs. Hutton 

Tue Music Room (Harmony in Green and Rose) 90° 
Now in the possession of Colonel Frank Hecker 

Tue Coast or Britrany 94 
Formerly in the possession of Ross Winans, Esq. 

Tue Biug Wave (Blue and Silver) 94 
Now in the possession of Alfred Attmore Pope, Esq. 

Tue Tuames IN Ice (The 25th of December 1860, on the Thames) 96 


pie LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS 


Re < 


ye 


Now in the possession of C. L. Freer, Esq. 
XViii 


LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS 


To face 
page 

ILLustRATIONS To “ THE First Sermon” (From “ Good Words’’) 98 
In the possession of Harold Hartley, Esq. 

ILLUsTRATIONS FROM “ ONcE A WEEK” 100 
By permission of Messrs. Chatto and Windus 

Souvenir or Vetasquez (Chalk Draning) 104 
In the possession of H. Graves, Esq. 

Linpsey Row 108 
From a photograph lent by Mrs. Sydney Morse 

No. 7 Linpsey Row (First House) 108 

No. 2 Linpsey Row (Second House 108 

Ture Wuire Giri (Symphony in White, No. 1) 112 
Now in the possession of Harris Whittemore, Esq. 

One or THE Boarp (Caricature made at West Point) 116 
In the possession of Thomas Childs, Esq. 

West Point Drawine 116 
In the possession of Samuel Hammond, Esq. 

On Post 1n Camp (An hour in the life of a Cadet) 120 
From the originals at West Point by permission of Colonel C. W. 
Larned 

Tue Lance Leizen—or TuE Six Marks (Purple and Rose) 122 


Now in the possession of J. G. Johnson, Esq. 
Hommace A Dexacroix (From the picture by Fantin-Latour. Salon, 
1864) 130 


In the Moreau-Nélaton collection now at the Musée des Arts 
Décoratifs, Paris 


Vatparatso (Nocturne, Blue and Gold) FGA. OFADY 184 
Formerly in the possession of George McCulloch, Esq. 

Vatparalso (Study for the large picture) 134 
Now in the possession of T. R. Way, Esq. 

Stupy or Barrersea Bringer (Chalk Drawing) 134 
In the possession of H. J. Pollitt, Esq. 

Porrrair or Wuistier (Chalk Draning) 136 
In the possession of T. Way, Esq. 

Stupies in Brack anp Wuite Cuax (For the Six Projects) 138 ¢ 

Sea-Bracn anp Figures (Pastel—Study for the Six Projects) 140 

Stupy oF nupe (Chalk Draning—Studies for the Six Projects) 140 

Nope (Chalk—Study for the Six Projects) 142 


xix 


f" 
Sam 4 i é 


Ob, (af 


OL 100, 6b, 


eet 


| Qime 


OS 


LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS 


Tue Liry (Pastel—Study for the Six Projects) 

Dzsien For a Fan (Water-colour—Study for the Six Projects) 
True : A Mover (Dry-point—Study for the Six Projects) 
Stupigs rox THE Six Prosxcts 


Sympuony 1n Wuire (No. JIL.) 
Now in the possession of Edmund Davis, Esq. 


Turee Figures (Pink and Grey) 
Now in the possession of Alfred Chapman, Esq. 


Desicn For Mosaic ror Sourn Kenstnaton (Pastel) 
Now in the possession of Graham Robertson, Esq. 


VaRIATIONS IN VIOLET AND GREEN 
Now in the possession of Sir Charles MacClaren, Bt. 


Nocturne, Batrersea Brings (Arrangement in Grey and Gold) 


In the Shakespeare Memorial Gallery, Stratford-on-Avon 


Nocturne (Blue and Green) 
Now in the possession of W. C, Alexander, Esq. 


Cremorne, No. I, (Nocturne) 
Now in the possession of Mrs. Argenti 


Cremorne (Nocturne, in Green and Gold) 
Formerly in the possession of W. Heinemann, Esq. 


Op Barrersea Bripee (Nocturne Blue and Gold) 
In the Tate Gallery 


Portrait or THE Patntrer’s Moruer (Arrangement in Grey and 


Black) 


In the Musée du Luxembourg 


Portrait or Tuomas CartyLe (Arrangement in Grey and Black 


No, II.) 
Sf . ei the Glasgow Gallery " 
Og 


? 


At? } ce} oh 


o | » >t WO h 
7 a whe en a> CLAW =~ Tb & 
Portrart or Miss Cicety Henrierra ALexaNnper (Harmony in 


Grey and Green) 
In the possession of W. C. Alexander, Esq. 


Stupigs For “Tue Biur Giri” (Miss Florence Leyianp) 
In the possession of W. C. Alexander, Esq. 


Sxetcues oF Miss Grace ALEXANDER 
In the possession of W. C, Alexander, Esq. 
xx | 


To face 
page 
142 


144 
144 
146 
146 


148 


150 


156 


162 


162 


164 


164 


166 


168 


170 


172 


174 


174 


LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS 


To face 
page 

Portrait or Mrs. F. R. Leytanp (Symphony in Flesh Colour and 
Pink) 176 


In the possession of Mrs. F. R. Leyland 


Portrait or F. R, Leytanp (Arrangement in Black) 178 
Now in the possession of C. L. Freer, Esq. 

Portrait or Mrs, Louis Hutu (Arrangement in Black No. II.) 180 
In the possession of Mrs. Louis Huth 

WHISTLER IN HIS STUDIO 184 
Now in the possession of Douglas Freshfield, Esq, 

Portrait oF Luke A. Ionipes 188 
In the possession of Luke A. Ionides, Esq. 

Portrait oF WHISTLER WITH Hat 190 
Now in the possession of C. L. Freer, Esq. 

Lapy Hapen (From a Photograph) 192 

SKETCHES FOR THE Peacock Room 200 
In the possession of Mrs. John L. Gardner 

Tue Peacock Room 204 

Tue Peacock Room 208 

SketcueEs ror Biue anp WHITE 216 
In the possession of Murray Marks, Esq. 

Tue Wurte House, Tire Street, CHELSEA 224 

Tue Two Broruers as Boys anp Men 230 
By permission of Mrs. William Whistler and W. M. Rossetti, Esq. 

Tue Fauuine Rocket (Nocturne in Black and Gold) 232 


Now in the possession of Mrs. Samuel Untermeyer 


Nocturne IN Buu AnD SILver, No. 1 236 
Now in the possession of Mrs. F. R. Leyland 


Tue Goxp Scas, or Eruption 1n Frirtuy Lucre 250 
Now in the possession of E. P. Jacomb Hood, Esq. 


Portrait or Miss Connie Gitcurist (Harmony in Yellow and Gold, 


The Gold Girl) 258 
Formerly in the possession of H. Labouchere, Esq. 
St. Mark’s (Nocturne, Blue and Gold) 262 
Now in the possession of J. J. Cowan, Esq. 
Tue Base or THE Tower, VENicE (Pastel) 264 


In the possession of J. P. Heseltine, Esq. 


a pune = 
L\S, (OO 


Os, Sod 


LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS 


To face 

page 

Cate, Venice (Pastel) 268 
In the possession of J. P. Heseltine, Esq. 

Mars_e Parace, Venice (Pastel) 278 


In the possession of Thomas Way, Esq. 


Portrait or Sir Henry Irvine as Pump II. or Spain (Arrange- 
ment in Black No. III.) 288 
Now in the possession of G. Thomas, Esq. 
Portrait or Miss Rosa Corper (Arrangement in Black and Brown) 296 
Now in the possession of R. A. Canfield, Esq. 


Tue YeLLow Buskin—Porrrair or Lapy ArcuipaLp CAMPBELL 
(Arrangement in Black) 305 
In the Wilstach Collection, Philadelphia 


Portrait or Lapy Mevx (Arrangement in White and Black) 308 
In the possession of Lady Meux 


ILLUSTRATIONS IN THE TEXT 


Littte Figures Page x 
Joe (Drypoint) ate. 4 2! 
EaRLY DRAWING OF A Duck ne, Wee 
AunT Kate te Oe 
Sr. AuausTINE 4) 89 


XX 


INTRODUCTION 


It was Whistler’s theory that the artist, like art, “‘ happens.” 
Both are accidents, and not the result of preparation. 
But though his art lives so long as his work remains, the 
creator himself is forgotten, unless those who knew 
him tell what they know. Only the masters of the past 
who left records of their own lives, or who figure in the 
chronicles of their contemporaries, survive as more than 
names signed to their pictures or their prints. ‘“ Nobody 
can write the life of a man,’’ Dr. Johnson said to Boswell, 
‘“‘ but those who have eaten and drunk and lived in social in- 
tercourse with him.”’ In the case of a nature so complex, 
so primitive, and yet so full of perplexing subtleties, as was 
Whistler’s, in the case of an artist so persistently mis- 
understood, so long unrecognised, the constant, yet, un- 
intentional, maker of “enemies,” a faithful account of the 
real man as he appeared to his personal friends, of the 
supreme artist at his work, must be of value hereafter. 

We had the privilege of seeing much of Whistler during 
his last years, and when he was giving us his reminiscences 
we came to know the Whistler we had never met—the 
Whistler of Lowell and St. Petersburg, Stonington and West 
Point, the Latin Quarter and Chelsea. As he talked to us, 
dates became more than dates, facts more than facts, and 
everything we learned from him seemed of importance in 
the record he asked us to write—the story of his life. We 
realised, at the same time, that everything we could learn 
from others concerning him was valuable, especially from 

I°c XXII 


INTRODUCTION 


those who knew him well, and we have spared no pains to 
gather together all available information from his friends 
and from people whom work, or other interests, brought into 
close contact with him. It is our good fortune to have 
found for every period of his life some one qualified and 
willing to help us. 

We have felt our responsibility the more because, as we 
undertook to write his biography at his request, we looked 
upon it after his death as a sacred trust, and still more because, 
in carrying out his wishes, we met with difficulties which 
neither he, nor we, could have foreseen. His friends have re- 
sponded to our appeal with a sympathy, a generosity, it is not 
easy to overestimate. Practically, the only refusal to help in 
the fulfilment of his wishes, came from Whistler’s heir and 
executrix, Miss Rosalind Birnie Philip, who not only withheld 
such assistance as she might have given us, but put serious 
hindrances in our way. As our story of Whistler’s last 
years will show, his illness was an inevitable interruption 
to the book in which his enthusiasm equalled ours. He 
supplied us with a great deal of material and he recalled 
for us many facts about himself and his work, of which 
we took careful notes in his presence, or immediately 
after parting. His private correspondence would, unques- 
tionably, have been devoted to our official biography, 
although in the absence of a signed agreement (the need 
for which under the intimate circumstances, we overlooked) 
we are restrained from reproducing his letters. We have 
felt this to be no light loss. We know from the many letters 
Whistler wrote to us, his charm as correspondent and the many 
others we have seen reveal the same gaiety in friendship and 
brilliancy of wit, also his perfect courtesy and consideration 
in business affairs of which there is small trace or hint in 
The Gentle Art, and his inexhaustible attention to every 
detail concerning his work. Hundreds of letters have been 
XXIV 


INTRODUCTION 


placed at our disposal, and if only their substance is here 
embodied we hope we have at least given an idea of the 
freshness of his mind, the quickness of his wit and his readi- 
ness of expression. 

Great as was our disappointment when Miss Birnie Philip 
declined to sanction the publication of Whistler’s letters, 
we should never have made the fact public, had she not 
brought the matter into the law courts. It is known how 
easily we there established our authority, while Miss Birnie 
Philip clearly showed that the volume of letters which she 
and her sister, Mrs. Whibley, were authorised to issue was to 
be virtually on the lines of The Gentle Art, in the prepara- 
tion of which Mrs. Whibley had helped. The Gentle Art 
contained nothing but letters and documents previously 
published—his public utterances in fact with occasional 
reflections and comments—but no private correspondence, 
so desirable in any biography. After Mr. Justice Kekewich 
had declared our authority conclusively proved, Mr. 
Heinemann made a further attempt to persuade Miss 
Birnie Philip to assist in the carrying out of Whistler’s 
wishes. He was unfortunately not able to induce her to 
change her attitude, and it was left therefore for us to 
fulfil, unaided and to the best of our ability, the task 
which we had undertaken with no little apprehension seven 
years before. In the absence of the letters, the various 
contributions from Whistler’s friends will go far, we hope, 
to counteract the impression that Whistler’s name alone is suf- 
ficient to sow discord and arouse quarrels. These friends may 
differ as to the qualities of his art, of his wit, of his personality, 
but they agree in their memory of him as a man to whom 
affection was natural, who was a good companion, and the 
best of friends until he was provoked into ‘‘ making enemies.”’ 
Some of their impressions may seem a contradiction to 
others because of differences in detail, but we print them all 

XXV 


INTRODUCTION 


as they are, and as a rule without comment, because, in their 
sincerity, they must contribute to a better knowledge and 
truer appreciation of Whistler than if an endeavour were 
made to reduce them to uniformity. 

One other word of explanation remains to be said. The 
trust Whistler confided in us does not end with his biography. 
The original plan had been to publish one volume of biography 
and one dealing with his work which naturally now could 
not be complete if it did not include a catalogue. The 
first volume has expanded into the two now issued. It 
remains for us to complete our task at a future period 
when difficulties of dates to which he was so indif- 
ferent, and of identification of pictures, whose titles he so 
capriciously changed, will have been overcome. As Whistler 
placed his confidence in us, we do not consider any 
effort on our part too great to enable his wishes to be 
carried out, and to honour one whom we must ever re- 
member as the greatest artist of his generation, the most 
wonderful man we have ever known, and the most delightful 


friend we have ever made. 
EK. & J. P, 


XkVi 


CHAPTER I. THE WHISTLER FAMILY. 
THE YEARS EIGHTEEN THIRTY-FOUR 
TO EIGHTEEN FORTY-THREE 


AMES ABBOTT McNEILL WHISTLER was born on 
July 10, 1834, at Lowell, Massachusetts, in the United 
States of America. 

Whistler, in the witness-box, during the suit he brought 
against Ruskin in 1878, gave St. Petersburg as his birthplace 
—or the reporters did—and he never denied it. Baltimore 
was given by M. Duret, in an article in the Gazette des Beaux 
Aris (April 1881), and M. Duret’s mistake, since corrected 
by him, has been many times repeated. Mrs. Livermore, 
who knew Whistler as a child at Lowell and lived to tell us 
of those times—she died in November 1906—said, that 
when she asked him why he did not contradict this, he 
answered, “‘ My dear Cousin Kate, if any one likes to think 
I was born in Baltimore, why should I deny it? It is of 
no consequence to me!” M. Duret suggests that, at the 
time of the Ruskin trial and of his article, Whistler probably 
was not sure where he was born. On entering West Point 
he stated that his place of birth was Massachusetts. But 
he would most likely have met any one indiscreet enough 
to question him or offer him information on the subject, as 
he did an American, who came up to him one evening in 
the Carlton Hotel, London, and by way of introduction 
said, ‘‘ You know, Mr. Whistler, we were both born at Lowell, 
and at very much the same time. There is only the difference 


of a year—you are sixty-seven and I am sixty-eight.” ‘ And 
1834] re I 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


I told him,” said Whistler, from whom we had the story the 
next day, “ Very charming! And so you are sixty-eight 
and were born at Lowell, Massachusetts! Most interesting, 
no doubt, and as you please! But I shall be born when 
and where I want, and I do not choose to be born at Lowell, 
and I refuse to be sixty-seven!’” That was Whistler’s 
attitude. His own vagueness affected other authorities 
until it is said that the compiler of one catalogue hesitated 
to venture upon anything more definite than “ McNeill 
Whistler, born in the United States.” 

Whistler was christened at St. Anne’s Church in Lowell, 
on November 9, 1834. ‘* Baptized, James Abbott, infant 
son of George Washington and Anna Mathilda Whistler : 
Sponsors, the parents—signed J. Edson ”’; so it is recorded 
in the church register. He was named after James Abbott, 
of Detroit, who had married his father’s elder sister, Sarah 
Whistler. General Loomis L. Langdon tells us that the 
MeNeill (his mother’s name) was added shortly after he 
entered West Point. 


“There is not a college in the land where a student sooner 
gets a nickname. The initials of Whistler’s name, combined with 
the self-knowledge of his fluency of speech, quickly suggested to 
him the use that would be made of them, and he instinctively 
shrank from the combination. The cadets had no access to the 
records, and before any cadet knew his initials, Whistler had 
christened himself with his mother’s name McNeill.” 


The Abbott he always preserved for legal and official 
documents. But eventually, he dropped it for all other 
purposes, “‘ J.A.M.” pleasing him no better than “ J.A.W.,” 
and he signed himself “‘ James McNeill Whistler,” or “ J. M. N. 
Whistler.” 

_ Among the papers placed at our disposal by Lady Haden 
and Mrs. William Whistler are the family history and the 
family tree. The Rev. Rose Fuller Whistler, in his Annals 
2 [1834 


DR. DANIEL WHIS 
(1619-1684) 


Ls 


tobi : 


aoe Lin 
enn: , 
Mah tisiG 
Thjad) to 


e bridget Whe race, Sey said atk ety bye 


gue ead Diese 2 Se $i sei CR: 
: Nagetites of igh bi ones wih pater rreg 

wal leiake? sk twa bo aod AL ceil ee eee 
decimal ely. ie ett at wali shi oags Aaa pinet KaneD 


pele tt ar me pie eh Sanita St 
ae aes lea cava: ahh er aha 
s Peay bh bo Seabhentay: 4 se boas an: aes 5 
* wietal aus ¢ Seb, 4s eet Win sact Saas achagitne naa eqioh iF 
Bake it pu, SaAh te AUG. id Beatie tagline? va 
a pitageg Ui eens’ fast iat Hea peaiaa ee mee 
BS oh: pet Aegaptnes ; 
a demi eee (ne ee para. Sis stl? tix: snenais 
tend ae eu Ee che: vs 
Stee 708! Dag floats iat me, 


THE WHISTLER FAMILY 


of an English Family (1887), states that Joha le Wistler 
de Westhannye (1272-1307), was the founder of the family. 
Another record starts with Rodolphus Whistler of Fowles- 
courte, Berkshire, about 1494. A third begins with John 
Whistler of Goring, Berkshire, born in 1609, and it is with 
his descendants that we come on something more than a 
string of names. The Whistlers, though there were well- 
known branches in Essex and Sussex, lived mainly in Goring, 
Whitchurch and Oxford, and are buried in many a church 
and churchyard of the Thames Valley. Brasses and tablets 
to the memory of several of the Fowlescourte branch, are, 
after various vicissitudes, now set up in the church of St. 
Mary at Goring. There is a stone tablet to Elinor Whistler, 
who died in January 1630, leaving money to the poor of the 
village, and she is buried in the same grave with her sister 
Margaret. ‘There is a brass to Hugh Whistler, and he stands 
side by side with his wife, hands joined in prayer, while their 
three sons and five daughters are grouped below. A second 
brass is to “‘ Hugh Whistler, the son of Master John Whistler 
of Goring, who departed this life the 17 Day of Januarie 
Anno Dominie 1675 being aged 216 years.” * An amazing 
statement, but there it is in the parish church, durable as 
brass can make it. This remarkable ancestor also figures as 
a family ghost at Gatehampton, where he is said to have 
been originally buried with all his money and where he still 
walks, guarding the treasures he had lived so many years to 
gather. The position of the Whistlers entitled them to a 
coat of arms described in the Harleian MSS. No. 1556, and 
thus in Gwillim’s Heraldry: ‘‘ Gules, five mascles, in bend 
between two Talbots passant argent;’? and the motto 
was “ Forward.” 


* We give the inscription, already printed elsewhere, because it is just the sort 
of thing Whistler would have delighted in. It is a pity to spoil it by explaining 
it. But there is an explanation, simple enough, the 21 of the 216 being nothing 
but a badly engraved 4. 

1834] 3 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


The men were mostly soldiers and clergymen. A few? 
one way or another, made names for themselves. Gabriel 
Whistler of Combe, Sussex, in the sixteenth century, was so 
good a friend to King’s College, Cambridge, that his shield 
is one of six worked into the wood-carving of the chapel ; 
Anthony Whistler, poet, friend of Shenstone, belonged to the 
Whitchurch family; Dr. Daniel Whistler (1619-1684), of 
the Essex branch, was a Fellow of Merton, an original Fellow 
of the Royal Society, a member and afterwards president of 
the College of Physicians, the friend of Evelyn and Pepys. 
Evelyn often met him in “ select companie ”’ at supper, and 
once, he says, ‘‘ Din’d at Dr. Whistler’s at the Physicians 
Colledge,’’ and found him not only learned but “ the most 
facetious man in nature,’”? and so, more than in name, the 
legitimate ancestor of Whistler. Pepys, who also dined 
and supped with him many times, pronounced him “ good 
company and a very ingenious man.” He, however, fell 
under a cloud with the officials of the College of Physicians, 
and his portrait has been consigned to a back stairway of 
the College in Pall Mall. In the seventeenth century, Ralph 
Whistler, under the Salter’s Company of London, was one 
of the English colonisers of Ulster, and, to this day, the 
ruins of ‘‘ Whistler’s Castle” stand on the shores of Lough 
Neagh. Francis Whistler, under the Second Charter, was 
one of the early settlers of Virginia. When Whistler saw 
the name ‘“ Francis Whistler, Gentleman,” in the Genesis 
of the United States, he said to us, “‘ that there was an ancestor, 
with the hall-mark F.F.V. (First Families of Virginia), who 
tickled my American snobbery, and washed out the taint 
of Lowell.” 

The American Whistlers are descended directly from John 
Whistler, of the Irish branch. In his youth, he ran away 
from home and enlisted in the British army as a private, 


and the legend is that Sir Kensington Whistler, an English 
4 [1834 


MAJOR GEORGE WASHINGTON WHISTLER 
(WUISTLER’S FATHER) 


“ alegh oak at 
pected ee p00) > aaethans 


Ledd-a 
Abe anes 


dh ees dives Bestia VY 
Re Wee age 


4 


Sai ke ad tg 


1 RAED ‘ ere 


THE WHISTLER FAMILY 


cousin, an officer in the same regiment, objected to having 
a relative in the ranks. John Whistler, therefore, was trans- 
ferred to another regiment, in which he was colour-sergeant, 
just starting for the American colonies to join Burgoyne’s 
army. He arrived in time to surrender at Saratoga, October 
17, 1777. After this, he went back to England, received 
his honourable discharge from the army, and later eloped 
with Anna, daughter of Sir idward Bishop, or Bischopp. He 
liked what he had seen of the colonies and, with his wife, 
returned and settled at Hagerstown, Maryland. He again 
enlisted, this time in the United States army. He was 
wounded in St. Clair’s defeat by the Indians, November 4, 
1791, rose to be captain in the First U.S. Infantry, with the 
brevet rank of major and served in the war of 1812 against 
Great Britain. In 1803 he was stationed at Detroit ; later 
at Fort Dearborn, which he helped to build ; and Fort Wayne, 
in what was then the North-West-Territory, later Indiana. 
According to Mr. Eddy, Whistler once said to a visitor from 
Chicago: 

“Chicago, dear me, what a wonderful place! I really ought 
to visit it some day—for, you know, my grandfather founded 
the city and my uncle was the last commander of Fort 
Dearborn !”’ 

In 1815, upon the reduction of the army, Major John 
Whistler was retired—two of his sons were already officers 
carrying on the family tradition-—and he was given the post 
of military storekeeper at Newport, Kentucky, and then at 
Jefferson Barracks, St. Louis. He died in 1817, at Belle- 
fontaine, Missouri, leaving the reputation of a good linguist, 
good musician, good soldier, good father. In his family 
it is said of him that he “ united firmness with tenderness ”’ 
and “ impressed upon his children the importance of a faithful 
and thorough performance of duties in whatever position 
they should be placed.” 

1834] 5 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Of Major Whistler’s large family of fifteen children, three 
sons are remembered as soldiers, and three daughters married 
army Officers. The sons were William, a colonel in the 
United States army, who died at Newport, Kentucky, in 
1863; John, a lieutenant, whose death was due to wounds 
at the battle of Maguago, near Detroit, 1812; George 
Washington, who rose to the rank of major—the most 
distinguished of the three brothers and the father of James 
Abbott McNeill Whistler. 

George Washington Whistler was born on May 19, 1800, 
at Fort Wayne. His childhood was spent at the military 
posts where his father was stationed; he was educated 
mostly at Newport, Kentucky ; and from Kentucky, when 
he was a little over fourteen, he received his appointment to 
the Military Academy, West Point. He remained there for 
five years, graduating on July 1, 1819. From the rank of 
second lieutenant, to which he was appointed in the First 
Artillery, he rose to be first lieutenant in the Second Artillery. 
This was in 1829. Four years afterwards, in 1888, with 
the rank of major, he resigned his commission in the army. 

At West Point he is remembered for his gaiety. Mr. 
George L. Vose, his biographer, and others, tell stories that 
might have been told of his son. One is of some breach of 
discipline, for which he was made to bestride a gun on the 
campus for a certain time. As he sat there, he saw, coming 
towards him, the Miss Swift he was to marry before very long. 
Out came his handkerchief, and, leaning over the gun, he 
set to work cleaning it so carefully that he was ‘“‘ honoured, 
not disgraced,’ in her eyes. He was “‘ number one” in 
drawing, and his wonderful playing on the flute won for him 
the nickname “ Pipes.” After he left West Point, he served 
on topographical duty, and for a few months he was assistant 
professor at the Academy. Under Major Albert he was on 
the Commission that traced the North-West Boundary 
6 [1834 


ST. ANNE’S CHURCH, LOWELL, MASS. 


: sialell piette viacat ritatlace: asaetewe aw mad ies, aa. Oe 
ae eg Qaibvat or, OF, dieters wb Lewiiig soapy ating 
enepitiath wh is) days to GotaY? WRALE: wether =. 
Sahcene Hes Ee pet OAT rage Ds J wine © 
err tk Reece a ene mg Tame Ginna > 
bd. BERENY Sensligi tse! seeele ont id Pte Sb, ese, 
shi igite Repiles wie aid dig PR ALM A iar hak Me with. bales 
Wate Pree? agape igi wah ee Sel ae 
nf art dae diae, geauiis & Hinkle ved wild ae SO hang i ; 
ie ; rowel as Ae hl ede YY ag pe, PA et Ayaan: < 
Ags ma as pends sacks Sy cfaliicd land he Paral Na) 4, ee 
hd Dey Tha cnt md crip ue... wii bt miei 
WIT Ea cate erga ‘nh otthe tio ae yi erity, nA 
sane. oy dee edo, tlie: 2 aarcariry Unegs phere: We | of 
Edy and, Diive JeRbRE Wes sib Miele eid aie galing am Lav h, fit: 
ies. flail codtasieh 3 . ‘i dited: Abide pbtlidigi °, 
gRUT Ch AGATE EE te ete RD sk Pweg apn ny oe fe 
BREN as. eS ap 1 Reina, Jif 2 #, s dhe 
Baio Oi. wil] ‘tone PaceQaas v3) bapa PE 14h He re. ae 
Whi. Deonabie. ult. uate TAG AVR ees) eee Be proakegy/)s othe se og une 
bs} osigiee> eee. holo. ta geaore: Lt nile hea Sith. tae a 
Hal cd) othe SA Bei e er A eee hy Ak ay Kae Ack ray. 4 
(NES RAE NA ann ei Jere tab ld ae Bel dl flaca eeeh deer mes. 
SARIS Aah Bal vids kD: bd D | AA Aaeabl epapsics abi hi Ban pos 
Shed. ey MeV olt Pliviatis evita Drelyes Aes ie KT Chah Ce Lav Bear 
oat. ain Vi koh>? seh wes Sek hank sod ole: saclay Re ae 
BETO. BGA ba) otiern ie jy ped ate snpthiens et MRE ae 
Fling: alin mate etary de ik a Ait 
cies po) Poi. can tf) alt oo) phate ea id ater 
+ date pcdaaicdii Alin hoitnor. fics deomandonk alt nate ite 
ae hig: fuse Bil “eke sain) tan sit nought | 
ba 


THE WHISTLER FAMILY 


between Lake Superior and the Lake of the Woods. There 
was not much fighting for American officers of his generation. 
But railroads were being built throughout the country, and 
so few were the civil engineers available that West Point 
graduates were allowed by Government to work for private 
corporations. Major Whistler was engineer on the Baltimore 
and Ohio Railroad, the Baltimore and Susquehanna and the 
Paterson and Hudson River, now a part of the Erie Railroad. 
For the Baltimore and Ohio he went to England in 1828 to 
examine the English railway system. He was directing the 
construction of the line from Stonington to Providence, an 
extension of the Boston and Providence Railroad, when he 
resigned to carry on his profession as a civil engineer. 

In the meanwhile, he had been married twice. His first 
wife was Mary Swift, daughter of Dr. Foster Swift, of the 
U.S. Army. She left three children : George, who became 
a well-known civil engineer; Joseph, who died in youth; 
and Deborah, now Lady Haden. His second wife was Anna 
Mathilda McNeill, daughter of Dr. Charles Donald McNeill 
of Wilmington, North Carolina, and sister of William Gibbs 
McNeill, a West Point classmate and a constant associate 
in much of Major Whistler’s engineering work. The McNeills 
were descended from the McNeills of Skye, an offshoot from 
the MeNeills of Barra. Their chief, Donald, emigrated 
with sixty of his clan to North Carolina in 1746, after the fall 
of the Stuarts, to whom he and his people had always been 
loyal. He bought land on Cape Fear river, and his estate 
was known as Tweedside. Charles Donald McNeill was the 
grandson of this Donald. Like many men of the family he 
studied medicine at the University of Edinburgh. During 
the Revolutionary War his sympathies were with England 
and he retired for a while to the West Indies. When the 
war was over, he returned, and settled at Wilmington, North 


Carolina. He was twice married: his second wife, Martha 
1834] 7 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Kingsley, was the mother of Anna Mathilda MeNeill, who 
became Mrs. George Washington Whistler. The McNeills 
were related by marriage to the Fairfaxes and other well- 
known Virginia families. And so Whistler, on his mother’s 
side, was the southerner he loved to call himself. 

In 1834, Major Whistler accepted the offer of the important 
post of engineer to the Proprietors of Locks and Canals at 
Lowell, and to this town, then scarcely more than a village, 
he brought his family. There, in what is known as the Paul 
Moody House in Worthen Street, Whistler was born, though 
for other Lowell houses, as for other American towns, the 
honour has been claimed; but the city of Lowell has so 
little doubt on the subject that it has purchased the Worthen 
Street house for a museum, a Whistler Memorial. Two 
years later, the second son, William Gibbs McNeill, was born. 
In 1837, Major Whistler moved to Stonington, Connecticut, 
his continual presence being needed there, and Miss Emma 
W. Palmer and Mrs. Dr. Stanton, his wife’s nieces, still 
remember his “ pleasant house on Main Street.” It is said 
that he had at this time a chaise fitted with car wheels in 
which he and his family, when there were no trains, drove 
every Sunday on the tracks to church at Westerly ; also that 
a locomotive named “* Whistler ” was in use on the road until 
recently. His work was mainly on the Stonington Railroad, 
but he was consulted in regard to many other new lines. 
Among these was the Western Railroad of Massachusetts, for 
which, with his brother-in-law, William Gibbs McNeill, he 
was consulting engineer from 1836 to 1840. In 1840, he was 
made chief engineer, and he removed to Springfield, Massa- 
chusetts, where, with his family, he lived in what is now known 
as the Ethan Chapin Homestead, on Chestnut Street, north 
of Edward Street. A third son, Kirk Booth, who had been 
born at Stonington in 1838, died at Springfield in 1842, and 


here a fourth son, Charles Donald, was born in 1841. 
8 [1842 


TIIQNOW GIVNOd SATYUVHO Sant TITIGNOW GIVNOG SATUVHADO “Ad 


oehe. eterig: 
Lieb aty get 


Bo yitien # saath Stott tes 
Oe % i te 


eh 


ee eee 
eg 
re A be 


eee 


jaa Py 
; Suglts 


THE WHISTLER FAMILY 


In 1842, the Emperor Nicholas I. of Russia sent a Com- 
mission, under Colonel Melnikoff, round Europe and to 
America to find the best methods and the best man to build 
the railroad from St. Petersburg to Moscow, and they chose 
for this work the American civil engineer and the United 
States officer, George Washington Whistler. The honour 
was great and the salary large, $12,000 a year. He accepted, 
and started for Russia in midsummer 1842. Until his plans 
were settled, he left his family at Stonington, under the 
charge of Dr. George E. Palmer, his brother-in-law. 

The life of a child, for the first nine years or so, is not of 
much interest to any one save his parents. An idea can 
be formed of Whistler’s training up to this period. His 
father was a West Point man, with all that is fine in the 
West Point tradition. Mrs. Whistler was “‘ one of the saints 
upon earth,” as she has been called. But she was strict, 
‘ puritanical,” as uncompromising in matters of duty and 
religion as if she had been born and bred in Puritan New 
England. Dr. Whistler—Willie—often told his wife of 
the dread with which he and Jimmie, when very little, 
looked forward to Saturday afternoon, with its overhauling 
of clothes, emptying of pockets, washing of heads, putting 
away of toys, and. general preparation for Sunday, when the 
Bible was the only book they were allowed to read. Every 
line Whistler wrote was evidence of his familiar knowledge 
of the Bible. Ignorance of King James’ version may be 
the reason why so many literary critics have found fault 
with his English. 

Of the actual facts and incidents of Whistler’s early child- 
hood there are few to record. Mrs. Livermore, gc Pha 
who wrote to the Times (August 28, 1903) to settle the dispute 
as to the place of Whistler’s birth, lived many years in Lowell. 
She was a great friend of the Whistlers, and was all her life 
“Cousin Kate’ to Whistler and his brother. She was 
1842] 9 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


fourteen years older than Whistler, and she could tell of his 
baby beauty, so great that her father used to say “it was 
enough to make Sir Joshua Reynolds come out of his grave 
and paint Jemmie* asleep.” Mrs. Livermore dwelt especially 
on the child’s beautiful hands ‘‘ which belong to so many of 
the Whistlers—I attribute them to his Irish blood.”” When she 
returned to Lowell in 1836, from the Manor School at York, 
England, Mrs. Whistler’s son, Willie, had just been born : 


** As soon as Mrs. Whistler was strong enough she sent for me 
to go and see her boy, and I did see her and her baby in bed! 
and then I asked, ‘ Where is Jemmie, of whom I have heard so 
much?’ She replied, ‘He was in the room a short time since, 
and I think he must be here still” So I went softly about the 
room till I saw a very small form prostrate and at full length 
on the shelf under the dressing-table, and I took hold of an arm 
and a leg and placed him on my knee, and then said, * What 
were you doing, dear, under the table?’ ‘ Tse drawrin’,’ and 
in one very beautiful little hand he held the paper, in the other 
the pencil.” 

The drawing of a duck, lent us by Mrs. Livermore, is 
curiously firm and strong for the child of four he was when 


he made it. } 

These memories, in their slightness, indicate the years 
between the child’s birth in 1884 and the year 1843, when 
Major Whistler sent for his wife and children to join him in 
Russia, and Whistler was just nine years old. 


* In Whistler’s childhood, he was called Jimmie, Jemmie, Jamie, James and 
Jim, and we have used these names as we have found them in the letters written 
to us and the books quoted. 


10. [1843 


CHAPTER II. IN RUSSIA. THE YEARS 
EIGHTEEN FORTY-THREE TO EIGHTEEN 
FORTY-NINE 


RS. WHISTLER sailed from Boston in the Arcadia on 
August 12, 1843, taking with her Deborah, Major 
Whistler’s only daughter (now Lady Haden), and the three 
boys, James, William and Charles. George Whistler, Major 
Whistler’s eldest son, and her “ good maid Mary” went 
along to take care of them. The story of their journey 
and their life in Russia is recorded in Mrs. Whistler’s 
journal. 

They arrived at Liverpool on the 29th of the same month. 
Mrs. Whistler’s two half-sisters, Mrs. William Winstanley 
and Miss Alicia McNeill, lived at Preston, and there they 
stayed a fortnight. Then, after a few days in London, they 
sailed for Hamburg. 

The journey that followed explains why Major Whistler 
was so much needed in Russia. There was no railroad from 
Hamburg, and so they drove by carriage to Liibeck, by stage 
to Travemiinde, where they took the steamer Alexandra for 
St. Petersburg, and where George Whistler left them. 
Between Travemiinde and Cronstadt, Charles, the youngest 
child, fell fatally ill of sea-sickness, and died within a day. 
There was just time to bury him at Cronstadt—temporarily, 
he was afterwards buried at Stonington—and his death 
saddened the long-looked-for Bane between Major Whistler 
and his wife and children. 


Mrs. Whistler objected to living in hotels and to boarding, 
1843] II 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


and a house was found in the Galernaya. She did her best 
to make it not only a “comfortable,” but an American 
home, for Major Whistler’s attachment to his native land, 
she said, was so strong as to be almost a religious sentiment. 
Their food was American as far as could be managed, Ameri- 
can holidays were kept as nearly as possible in American 
fashion. Many of their friends were Americans. Major 
Whistler was nominally, or technically, consulting engineer 
to Colonel Melnikoff, but practically he was in charge of the 
line, both in its construction and in its equipment, and 
as the materials were supplied by the firm of Winans of 
Baltimore, Mr. Winans and his partners, Mr. Harrison and 
Mr. Eastwick of Philadelphia, with their families, were also 
in Russia. 

Mrs. Whistler’s strictness did not mean an opposition to 
all pleasure. At times she became afraid that her boys were 
not “keeping to the straight and narrow way.” There 
were evenings of illuminations in St. Petersburg that put off 
bedtime indefinitely ; there were afternoons of skating and 
coasting; Christmas gaieties, with Christmas dinners of 
roast turkey and real pumpkin pie; visits to American 
friends ; parties at home, when the two boys “ behaved like 
gentlemen, and their father commended them upon Ps 
there were presents of guns from the father, returning from 
long absences on the road and in Moscow; there were 
dancing lessons, which Jemmie would have done almost 
anything rather than miss. 

Whistler, as a boy, was exactly what those who knew him 
as a man would expect: gay and bright, absorbed in his 
work when that work was in any way related to art, brave 
and fearless, selfish, if selfishness is another name for 
ambition, considerate and kindly, above all to his mother. 
The boy, like the man, was delightful to those who under- 
stood him, “ startling,” “‘ alarming,” to those who did not. 
12 [1843 


UAHLONW ANY YAHLVA 


NVW DNOOA V SV 
UMIISIH AA NOLONIHSVAA DOUOAY ‘SUT UAILSIH AA NOLONIHSV AA ADNOTH VOLVIV 


For corrections to v.I, pp.1l2-23, see 


Whistler's Father, by Albert Parry, p.346ff 


IN RUSSIA 


Mrs. Whistler’s Journal soon becomes extremely interesting 
as the following quotations show : 


March 29 (1844).—‘‘I must not omit recording our visiting 
the Gastinnoi to-day in anticipation of Palm Sunday. Our two 
boys were most excited, Jemmie’s animation roused the wonder 
of many, for even in crowds here such decorum and gravity 
prevails that it must be surprising when there is any ebullition 
of joy.” 

April 22 (1844).—“‘ Jemmie is confined to his bed with a 
mustard plaster on his throat; he has been very poorly since 
the thawing season commenced, soon becoming overheated, 

- takes cold; when he complained of pain first in his shoulder, 

then in his side, my fears of a return of last year’s attack made 
me tremble, and when I gaze upon his pale face sleeping, con- 
trasted to Willie’s round cheeks, my heart is full; our dear 
James said to me the other day, so touchingly, ‘ Oh, I am sorry 
the Emperor ever asked father to come to Russia, but if I had 
the boys here,. I should not feel so impatient to get back to 
Stonington,’ yet I cannot think it the climate here affects his 
health ; Willie never was as stout in his native land, and James 
looks better than when we brought him here. At 8 o’clock I am 
often at my reading or sewing without a candle, and I cannot 
persuade James to put up his drawing and-go to bed while it 
is light.” 

The Journal shows that Whistler began as a boy to suffer 
from the severe rheumatic attacks that weakened his heart 
and caused his death. Major and Mrs. Whistler rented a 
country house on the Peterhoff Road in the spring of 1844. 
There is an account of a day spent at Tsarskoé Selo, when 
Colonel Todd, the American Minister to Russia, took them 
to see the Catherine Palace : 


May 6 (1844).—“‘ Rode to the station, and took the cars upon 
the only railroad in Russia, which took us the twenty versts to 
the pretty town. It would be ungenerous in me to remark how 
inferior the railroad, cars, etc., seemed to us Americans. The 
boys were delighted with it all. Jemmie wished he could stay 
to examine the fine pictures and know who painted them, but 

1844] 13 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


as I returned through the grounds I asked him if he should wish 
to be a grand duke and own it all for playgrounds: he decided 
there could be no freedom with a footman at his heels.” 

July 1 (1844).—“. . . I went with Willie to do some shopping 
in the Nevski. He is rather less excitable than Jemmie, and 
therefore more tractable. They each can make their wants 
known in Russ., but I prefer this gentlest of my dear boys to go 
with me. We had hardly reached home when a tremendous 
shower came up, and Jemmie and a friend, who had been out in 
a boat on a canal at the end of our avenue, got well drenched. 
Just as we were seated at tea, a carriage drove up, and Mr. Miller 
entered, introducing Sir William Allen, the great Scotch artist, 
of whom we have heard lately, who has come to St. Petersburg 
to revive on canvas some of the most striking events from the life 
of Peter the Great. They had been to the Monastery to listen 
to the chanting at Vespers in the Greek chapel. Mr. Miller con- 
gratulated his companion on being in the nick of time for our 
excellent home-made bread and fresh butter, and, above all, the 
refreshment of a good cup of tea. His chat then turned upon 
the subject of Sir William Allen’s painting of Peter the Great 
teaching the mujiks to make ships. This made Jemmie’s eyes 
express so much interest that his love for the art was discovered, 
and Sir William must needs see his attempts. When my boys 
had said good-night, the great artist remarked to me, ‘ Your 
little boy has uncommon genius, but do not urge him beyond 
his inclination.’ I told him his gift had only been cultivated as 
an amusement, and that I was obliged to interfere, or his appli- 
cation would confine him more than we approved.” 


Of these attempts there remain few examples. One is 
the portrait of his Aunt Alicia McNeill, who visited them 
in Russia in 1844, sent to Mr. Palmer at Stonington, with 
the inscription: “‘ James to Aunt Kate.” Mrs. Livermore 
has said that in an excellent letter in French Jemmie 
sent her from St. Petersburg when he was ten or eleven, 
“he enclosed some pretty pen-and-ink. drawings, each on a 
separate bit of paper, and each surrounded by a frame of 
his own designing.” Whistler told us he could remember 
wonderful things he had done during the years in Russia. 
14 [1844 


IN RUSSIA 


Once, he said, in London with his father, he had not been 
well, and he had been given a hot foot-bath, and he could 
never forget how he sat looking at his foot, and then got his 
paper and colours and set to work to make a study of it, 
“and in Russia,” he added, ‘“‘ I was always doing that sort 
of thing.” ped 

July 4 (1844).—“‘ I have given my boys holiday to celebrate 
the Independence of their country. ... This morning Jemmie 
began relating anecdotes from the life of Charles XII. of Sweden, 
and rather upbraided me that I could not let him do as that 
monarch had done at seven years old—manage a horse! I 
should have been at a loss how to afford my boys a holiday, 
with a military parade to-day, but there was an encampment 
of cadets, about two estates off, and they went with Colonel 
T.’s sons to see them.” 

July 10 (1844).—‘* A poem selected by my darling Jamie 
and put under my plate at the breakfast-table, as a surprise on 
his tenth birthday. I shall copy it, that he may be reminded of 
his happy childhood, when perhaps his grateful mother is not 
with him.” 

August 20 (1844).—“‘. . . Jemmie is writing a note to his 
Swedish tutor on his birthday. Jemmie loves him sincerely and 
gratefully. I suppose his partiality to this Swede makes him 
espouse his country’s cause and admire the qualities of Charles XII. 
so greatly to the prejudice of Peter the Great. He has been 
quite enthusiastic while reading the life of this king of Sweden 
this summer, and too willing to excuse his errors.” 

August 23 (1844).—“ I wish I could describe the gardens at 
Peterhof, where we were invited to drive to-day. The fountains 
are perhaps the finest in the world. The water descends in sheets 
over steps, all the heathen deities presiding. Jemmie was 
delighted with the figure of Samson tearing open the jaws of 
the lion, from which ascends a jet d’eaw one hundred feet. . . . 
There are some fine pictures, but Peter’s own paintings of the 
feathered race ought to be most highly prized, though our Jemmie 
was so saucy as to laugh at them.” 

August 28 (1844).—“ I availed myself of Col. Todd’s invitation 
to visit Tsarskoé Sel6 to-day with Aunt Alicia, Deborah and the 


two dear boys, who are always so delighted at these little 
1844] I5 


ee ee 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


excursions. ... My little Jemmie’s heart was made sad by 
discovering swords which had been taken in the battle between 
Peter and Charles XII., for he knew, from their rich hilts set in 
pearls and precious stones, that they must have belonged to 
noble Swedes. ‘Oh!’ he exclaimed, ‘I’d rather have one of 
these than all the other things in the armoury! How beautiful 
they are!’ ... I was somewhat annoyed that Col. Todd had 
deemed it necessary, to entertain us, to have a dinner party for us. 
One was a Russian general who spoke English, but the captain 
of the Chevalier Guards, who sat next Deborah, was the greatest 
acquisition to the party, he had so much vivacity and politeness. 
The colonel proposed the Emperor’s health in champagne, 
which not even the Russian general, who declined wine, could 
refuse, and even I put my glass to my lips, which so encouraged 
my little boys that they presented their glasses to be filled, and, 
forgetting at their little side-table the guests at ours, called out 
aloud, ‘ Santé &@ VEmpereur!’ The captain clapped his hands 
with delight, and afterwards addressed them in French. All 
at the table laughed and called the boys ‘ Bons sujets.’”’ 
They were in St. Petersburg again in September, preparing 
their Christmas gifts for America. Whistler, sending one 
to his cousin, Amos Palmer, wrote with it a letter to say, in 
an outburst of patriotism, that the English were going to 
America to be licked by the Yankees: it was at the time 
of the threatened disagreement over the Oregon Territory. 
In another letter from Russia, he gives the Fourth of July 
as his birthday. 

Ash Wednesday (1845).—‘“‘I avail myself of this Lenten 
season to have my boys every morning before breakfast recite a 
verse from the Psalms, and I, who wish to encourage them, am 
ready with my response. How very thankful I shall be when 
the weather moderates so that Jemmie’s long imprisonment may 
end, and Willie have his dear brother with him in the skating 
grounds and ice-hills. Here comes my good boy Jemmie now, 
with his history in hand, to read to me, as he does every afternoon, 
as we fear they may lose their own language in other tongues, 
and thus I gain a half-hour’s enjoyment by hearing them read 
daily.” 

April 5 (1845)—‘‘ Our boys have left the breakfast-table 

16 [1845 


IN RUSSIA 


before 8 o’clock to trundle their new hoops on the Quai with 
their governess, and have brought home such bright red cheeks and 
buoyant spirits to enter the schoolroom with and to gladden my 
eyes. Jemmie began his course of drawing lessons at the Academy 
of Fine Arts just on the opposite side of the Neva, exactly 
fronting my bedroom window. He is entered at the second room. 
There are two higher, and he fears he shall not reach them, 
because the officer who is still to continue his private lesson at 
home is a pupil himself in the highest, and Jemmie looks up to 
him with all the reverence an artist merits. He seems greatly 
to enjoy going to his class, and yesterday had to go by the bridge 
on account of the ice, and felt very important when he told me 
he had to give the Isvéshtclék 15 copecks silver instead of 10.’’* 


On May 14 (1845) there was a review of troops in St. Peters- 
burg, and a window in the Prince of Oldenburg’s palace 
overlooking the Champ de Mars was reserved for the Whistlers : 


‘“‘ Jemmie’s eagerness to attain all his desires for information 
and his fearlessness often makes him offend, and it makes him 
appear less amiable than he really is. The officers, however, 
seemed to find amusement in his remarks in French or English 
as they accosted him. They were soon informed of his military 
ardour and that he hoped to serve his country. England? No, 
indeed! Russia, then? No, no, America, of course!” 

*“On September 18, 1845, the new tutor, M. Lamartine, was 
installed, and the freedom with which the boys chatted with him 
soon made me comfortable, for Jemmie and he are both such 
talkers. Great has been the demand for patience on his part, 
until they were broken of their wild pranks in the school and 
street, for the Russian lads are drilled from infancy to politeness 
and submission.” 

May 2 (1846).—‘‘ The boys are in the school-room now, 
reading the Roman history in French to M. Lamartine, promising 
* The official record of Whistler as an art student in St. Petersburg has been 

sent us from the Imperial Academy of Science, through the kind intervention 
of the American Ambassador to Russia, the Hon. Mr. Meyer. In the Archives 
of the Imperial Academy of Science there is a “ List of Scholars of the Imperial 
Academy of Fine Arts,” and in this and the “‘ Class Journal of the Inspector ” 
for 1845, James Whistler is entered as “‘ belonging to the drawing class, heads 
from Nature.’ In 1846 he was, on March 2, examined and passed as “ first ”” 
in his class, his number being 28. From 1845 to 1849, Professor Vistelious and 
Voivov were the masters in the life class. 

1846] I:B 17 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


themselves the pleasure of reviewing the pictures at the Academy 
of Fine Arts at noon, which they have enjoyed almost every day 
this week. It is the Triennial Exhibition and we like them to 
become familiar with the subjects of the modern artists, and to 
James especially it is the greatest treat we could offer. I went last 
Wednesday with Whistler and was highly gratified. I should 
like to take some of the Russian scenes so faithfully portrayed to 
show in my native land. My James had described a boy’s portrait 
said to be his likeness, and although the eyes were black and the 
curls darker, we found it so like him, that his father said he 
would be glad to buy it, but its frame would only correspond 
with the furniture of a palace. The boy is taken in a white shirt 
with crimped frill, open at the throat; it is half-length and no 
other garment could show off the glow of the brunette complexion 
so finely.” 

May 30 (1846).—‘* Aunt Kate sent Jamie some marbles which 
have delighted his heart, and I fear he will read less than ever, 
loving play as he does.... Yesterday the Empress was 
welcomed back to St. Petersburg. Last night the illumination 
which my boys have been eagerly expecting took place. When 
at 10.30 they came in, Jamie expressed such an eager desire that 
I would allow him to be my escort just to take a peep at the 
Nevski that I could not deny him. The effect of the light from 
Vasili Ostrow was very beautiful, and as we drove along the Quai, 
the flowers and decorations of large mansions were, I thought, 
even more tasteful. We had to fall into a line of carriages in the 
Isaac Square to enter that Broadway, and just then a shout from 
the populace announced to us that the Empress was passing. I 
was terrified lest the poles of their carriages should run into our 
backs, or that some horses might take fright or bite us, we were 
so close, but Jamie laughed heartily and aloud at my timidity. 
He behaved like a man. With one arm he guarded me, and with 
the other kept the animals at a proper distance; and, I must 
confess, brilliant as the spectacle was, my great pleasure was 
derived from the conduct of my dear and manly boy.” 

July 7 (1846).—‘‘ This is the Empress’s fiftieth anniversary 
and the Court are all at Peterhof. My two boys found much 
amusement in propelling themselves on the drawbridge, to and 
from the fancy island in the pond at Mrs. G.’s, where we went to 
spend the day ; they find it such a treat to be in the country, and 
just run wild, chasing butterflies and picking the wild flowers so 

18 [1846 


IN RUSSIA 


abundant. But nothing gave them so much pleasure as their 
4th July, spent with their little American friends at Alexandrovsky, 
the Eastwicks ; the fireworks, percussion caps, muskets, horseback 
riding, &c., make them think it the most delightful place in Russia. 
In some way James caught cold, and his throat was so inflamed 
that leeches were applied, and he has been in consequence con- 
fined to his room. Our lazy dominie has taken a vacation, so I 
have had the boys on my hands entirely. We spend our mornings 
in reading, drawing, &c. Then the boys take their row with 
good John across the Neva, to the morning bath, and in the cool 
of the afternoon a drive to the island or a range in the summer 
gardens, or a row on the river.” 

July 27 (1846).—“ Last Wednesday, they had another long 
day in the country, and got themselves into much mischief. 
They had at last broken the ropes of the drawbridge, by which 
it was drawn to and from the island, and there were my wild boys 
prisoners on it. I thought it best for them to remain so, as they 
were so unruly, but the good-natured dominie was pressed into 
their service, and swimming to their rescue, ere I could interfere ; 
Jemmie was so drenched by his efforts that dear Mrs. R. took 
him away to her room to coax him to lie down awhile and to rub 
him dry, lest his sore throat return to tell a tale of disobedience. 
... On Thursday, there was another grand celebration of the 
birthday of the Grand Duchess Olga. I gladly gave Mary per- 

mission to take the boys in our carriage, while I stayed at home 
with baby—they were gone so long that I grew anxious about 
them, but finally they arrived very tired, and poor Mary said she 
never wanted to go in such a crowd again. James had protected 
her as well as he was able, but she was glad to get home safely. 
The boys, however, enjoyed it immensely, as they saw all the 
Imperial family within arm’s length, as they alighted from their 
pony chaises to enter the New Palace. . . . We were invited to 
go to the New Palace, and went immediately to the apartment 
occupied by his lamented daughter. On one side is the lovely 
picture painted by Buloff, so like her in life and health, though 
taken after death, as representing her spirit passing upwards to 
the palace above the blue sky. She wears her Imperial robes, 
with a crown on her head; at the back of the crown is a halo of 
glory—the stars surround her as she passes through them. No 
wonder James should have thought this picture the most interest- 
ing of all the works of art around us.” 

1846] 19 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


In the autumn of 1846, Major Whistler 

** placed the boys, as boarders, at Mons, Jourdan’s school. My 
dear boys almost daily exchange billet-dowx with mother, since 
their absence of a week at a time from home. James reported 
everything ‘ first-rate,’ even to brown bread and salt for breakfast, 
and greens for dinner, and both forebore to speak of home-sickness, 
and welcome indeed were they on their first Saturday at home, 
when they opened the front door, and called ‘ Mother, Mother !’ 
as they rushed in all in a glow, and they looked almost handsome 
in their new round black cloth caps, set to one side of their cropped 
heads, and the tight school uniform of grey trousers and black 
jacket makes them appear taller and straighter; Jamie found 
the new suit too tight for his drawing lesson, so he sacrificed 
vanity to comfort, and was not diverted from his two hours’ 
drawing by the other boys’ frolics, which argues well for his deter- 
mination to improve, as he promised his father. How I enjoyed 
having them back and listening to all their chat about their school 
—they seemed to enjoy their nice home tea. When it came time 
for them to go back, Willie broke down and told me all he had 
suffered from home-sickness, and when I talked to my more 
manly James, I unfortunately said, ‘ You do not know what 
he feels.’ Then Jamie’s wounded love melted him into tears, 
as he said, ‘Oh! mother, you think I don’t miss being away from 
home !’ he brushed away the shower with the back of his hand 
as if he was afraid of being seen weeping. Dear boys, may 
they never miss me as I miss them!” * 

November 14 (1846).—“‘ Jamie was kept in until night last 
Saturday, and made to write a given portion of French over 
twenty-five times as a punishment for stopping to talk to a class- 
mate after their recitation, instead of marching back to his seat 
according to order—poor fellow, it was rather severe when he had 
looked only for rewards during the week ; as he had not had one 
mark of disapprobation in all that time, and was so much elated 
by his number of good balls for perfect recitations that he forgot 
disobedience of orders is a capital offence under military discipline. 
He lost his drawing lesson, and made us all unhappy at home. 
We tried to keep his dinner hot, but his appetite had forsaken 
him, although only having eaten a penny roll since breakfast— 
he dashed the tears of vexation from his eyes at losing his drawing 


* Shortly after this, Mrs. Whistler’s youngest son, John Bouttatz, born in the 
summer of 1845, died, and his body was sent for burial to Stonington. 
20 [1846 


IN RUSSIA 


lesson, but his cheerfulness was soon restored and we had our 
usual pleasant evening.” 

January 23 (1847).—“‘ It is three weeks this afternoon since 
the dear boys came home from school to sp:nd the Russian 
Christmas and holidays, and it seems not probable that they shall 
return again to Mons. Jourdan’s this winter. James was droop- 
ing from the close confinement, and for two days was confined 
to his bed. Then Willie was taken. They are quite recovered 
now, and skate almost daily on the Neva, and Jamie often crosses 
on the ice to the Academy of Fine Arts to spend an hour or two. 

.. Jamie was taken ill with a rheumatic attack soon after 
hier and I have had my hands full, for he has suffered much with 
pain and weariness, but he is gradually convalescing, and to-day, 
January 30, he was able to walk across the floor; he has been 
allowed to amuse himself with his pencil, while I read to him ; 
he has not taken a dose of medicine during the attack, but great 
care was necessary in his diet.” 

February 27 (1847).—‘‘ Never shall I cease to record with deep 
gratitude dear Jamie’s unmurmuring submission these last six 
weeks. He still cannot wear jacket or trousers, as the blistering 
still continues on his chest. What a blessing is such a contented 
temper as his, so grateful for every kindness, and rarely complains. 
He is now enjoying a huge volume of Hogarth’s engravings, so 
famous in the Gallery of Artists. We put the immense book 
on the bed, and draw the great easy-chair close up, so that he can 
feast upon it without fatigue. He said, while so engaged 
yesterday, ‘Oh, how I wish I were well, 1 want so to show these 
engravings to my drawing-master, it is not every one who has a 
chance of seeing Hogarth’s own engravings of his originals,’ and 
then added, in his own happy way, ‘and if I had not been ill, 
mother, perhaps no one would have thought of showing them to 


292 


me. 


From this time until his death, Whistler always believed 
Hogarth to be the greatest English artist who ever lived 
and he seldom lost an opportunity of saying so. The long 
attack of illness in 1847 is therefore memorable as the begin- 
ning of his love of Hogarth which became an article of 
faith with him, and also as a proof of his early and right 
appreciation of great art. 

1847] 21 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


March 23 (1847).—‘‘ After many postponements, the Emperor 
finally inspected the Railroad department, the héritier, the Grand 
Duke Constantine, and many of the Court were invited. The 
day after his visit to the works, the Court held a levée, my husband 
was invited; when he arrived was summoned to a private 
audience in an inner apartment, the Emperor met him with 
marked kindness, kissed him on each side his face, and hung an 
ornament suspended by a scarlet ribbon around his neck, saying 
the Emperor thus conferred upon him the Order of St. Anne. 
Whistler, as such honours are new to Republicans, was some- 
what abashed, but when he returned with the Court to the 
large circle in the outer room, he was congratulated by the 
officers generally.” 


It is said that Major Whistler had been asked to wear the 
Russian uniform, but had refused. The decoration, however, 
he could not decline. 

Whistler told us, as have others, that the Emperor was 
most impressed with the way Major Whistler met every 
difficulty and emergency. When he asked the Czar how the 
line should be built, showing him the map of the country 
between St. Petersburg and Moscow, the Czar, as everybody 
knows, took a ruler, drew a straight line from one city to the 
other, ignoring everything in the way: and the railroad 
virtually follows that line to-day. But, everybody does not 
know that when the rolling-stock was ready, it was found 
that it had been made of a different gauge from the rails. 
The people who supplied it demanded to be paid. Major 
Whistler not only refused, but burnt it, and took the entire 
responsibility. 

Mrs. Whistler and the three children spent the summer 
of 1847 in England, where Major Whistler joined them. They 
visited their relations, and before their return, the daughter, 
Deborah, was married. She had met Seymour Haden, then 
a young physician, while she was staying with her aunts 
and their friends, the Chapmans, at Preston. Whistler told 
us that his father came to England especially to see Haden, 
22 [1847 


IN RUSSIA 


and Whistler was with his father when they met. Haden 
was ‘like a schoolmaster,”’ patted him on the shoulder, and 
said it was high time the boy went to school. 

The wedding was on October 10, 1847: ‘* Deborah’s 
wedding-day,” Mrs. Whistler wrote in her Journal. ‘ Bright 
and pleasant. James the only groomsman, and very proud 
of the honour.” 

The next summer (1848) Mrs. Whistler went back to 
England. Jamie had had another of his bad attacks of 
rheumatic fever, cholera broke out in St. Petersburg, and 
at its very name, she wrote, her heart failed her. On July 6 
she was on board the Camilla, bound for London, with her 
boys. Jamie was better already, and anxious to take a 
portrait of a young Hindu aboard. 

July 22 (1848).—‘* Shanklin, Isle of Wight. This is Willie’s 
twelfth birthday and has been devoted to his pleasure, and poor 
Jamie was envious that he could not bathe with us in the beautiful 
summer sea, for the doctors think the bracing air as much as he 
can bear, we three had a seaside ramble and then returned to 

‘rest at our cottage. I plied the needle, while my boys amused 
themselves, Willie in making wax flowers, and Jemmie in 
drawing.” 

Monday [no date].—‘ This day being especially fine, Mrs. P. 
took the boys on a pedestrian excursion along the shore to Culver 
Cliffs. In the hope that Jamie might finish his sketch of Cook’s 
Castle, we started the next day after an early dinner, taking a 
donkey with us for fear of fatigue, for James or Deborah... . 
We availed ourselves of a lovely bright morning to take a drive, 
said to be the most charming in England along the south coast 
of the isle as far as ‘ Black Gang Chine, where we alighted at 
the inn. Jamie flew off like a sea fowl, his sketch-book in hand, 
and when I finally found him, he was seated on the red sandy 
beach, down, down, down, where it was with difficulty Willie 
and I followed him. He was attempting the sketch of the 
waterfall and cavern up the side of the precipice ; he came back 
later, glowing with the exercise of climbing, with sketch-book in 
hand, and laughing at being ‘ Jacky last,’ as we were all assembled 
for our drive back.” 

1848] 23 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Jamie did not return with Mrs. Whistler. It was feared 
his health would not stand another Russian winter, and 
he was left in England. He lived with his sister and her 
husband in London at 62 Sloane Street, and studied with a 
clergyman, who had but one other pupil. It was then that 
Boxall, commissioned by Major Whistler, painted his portrait 
—* when he was fourteen years old—when he was living 
with us in Sloane Street,’’ Mrs. Thynne, his niece, writes to 
us. And it was then he began to make London friends. 
From Mr. Alan S. Cole we have this memorandum : “‘ Whistler 
as early as 1849, was staying with the Hadens in Sloane Street, 
and went to one or two children’s parties given by the 
old Dilkes. To these also went my elder sisters and Miss 
Thackeray, and so met Jimmy. Seymour Haden was our 
family doctor—with whose family ours was intimate—very 
much on account of the early relations between my father, 
his brothers and Seymour Haden, dating from school-days 
at Christ’s Hospital.” 

Major Whistler, through the summer of 1848, continued 
his regular inspections of the railroad, though cholera raged. 
In November he had a bad attack. He recovered, but his 
health was shaken. Letting neither illness nor weakness 
interfere with his work, he overtaxed his strength, and on 
August 9, 1849, he died: the immediate cause heart trouble, 
which his son inherited from him. He had been employed 
or consulted in other important undertakings: the iron 
roof of the Riding House at St. Petersburg and the iron 
bridge over the Neva, the improvement of the Dvina at 
Archangel, the fortifications and Naval Arsenal and Docks 
at Cronstadt. Major Whistler is buried in Evergreen Cemetery, 
Stonington, where three of his sons have their graves. There 
is a monument erected to his memory by his friends and 
fellow officers in Greenwood Cemetery, Brooklyn. 

The Emperor suggested, Whistler always said, that the 
24 [1849 


IN RUSSIA 


two boys should be brought up in the school for the pages 
of the Court. But Mrs. Whistler determined to take them 
to their native land, and the Emperor sent her in his private 
barge as far as; the Baltic. She went to the Hadens in 
Sloane Street, where she found Jamie grown tall and 
strong. One event in London that helped them to forget 
for a moment their sorrow was the exhibition at the Royal 
Academy (1849), then in Trafalgar Square, of Boxall’s portrait 
of Whistler, which they went to see. A short visit to Preston 
followed, the two boys carried off by “kind Aunt Alicia” 
to Edinburgh and Glasgow, and at last they all met at 
Liverpool in August. Mrs. Whistler was undecided between 
steamer and sailing-packet, the necessity of economy being 
somewhat urgent on her present income of fifteen hundred 
dollars a year. By the advice of George Whistler and friends, 
she took the steamer America, and on July 29, 1849, they 
left Liverpool for New York, where they arrived on August 9, 
at once taking boat for Stonington. 


eas Be 
(ea 
TBS 
gi 
A A\{; 


BETTY 
YK ; 
v 


Ht, 


SS 
\ oie ner 
Ki 


AUNT KATE 


1849] 25 


CHAPTER III SCHOOL-DAYS IN 
POMFRET. THE YEARS EIGHTEEN FORTY- 
NINE TO EIGHTEEN FIFTY-ONE 


‘ HE boys were brought up like little princes until after 

their father’s death, which changed everything,” 
Miss Emma W. Palmer, their cousin, writes us. Major 
Whistler’s salary was large, so were his expenses; we have 
never heard that there was a pension. He left his family 
poor: the income of twelve thousand dollars reduced to 
fifteen hundred. 

For her own sake, Mrs. Whistler would have preferred to 
stay at Stonington. For that of her two sons, she settled 
at Pomfret, Connecticut, where there was a good school, 
Christ Church Hall. The principal, Rev. Dr. Roswell Pate, 
was a West Point man and like Major Whistler, an engineer, 
before he became a minister and school teacher. At Pomfret, 
as at St. Petersburg, Mrs. Whistler busied herself at once to 
make a home for herself and her children. She could not 
find, or afford, anything more luxurious than part of an old 
farmhouse and, in Connecticut, as in Russia, winter is severe. 
She felt very keenly the discomforts of the new life for her 
boys, but she spared them nothing of the old discipline. On 
her first Christmas Day there, she wrote to her mother that 
she had kept them busy all morning bringing in wood for the 
fire and listing the draughty doors, though, as a concession 
to the holiday, she allowed them to lighten their task by 
hanging up evergreens and to sweeten it with “ Stuart’s 
Candy.” Part of their morning’s duty at other times was, 
26 [1849 


THE TWO BROTHERS 
(From a Miniature) 


to: shanti: ot of oer: 


— tee Hise eae re 


ag ieee 
sy ‘ 
ie Be ie eee: 


om vata, on Hie at 


aie’ wy ‘tn aut shine 
el dvieh Lhe ian 


ay T PO ie Coe ris one pei vila a aren s 
rie ASG 1 PRA ps 
feet 
snexatd sail ee. Lise shad: 
aig Mcaenl * shes — 
hs ties | we sues 


pore carga nen es Sh 
 gome prea ans daniel coal 8, sess 
yok nia: Alt: ‘oat is hans vagy ne 


SCHOOL-DAYS IN POMFRET 


after a snowstorm, to shovel a path from the house to the 
pig-pen and to feed the pig, even if it sent them back with 
their hands blue and cold and their feet frost-bitten. While 
they were thus hardened physically, they were not permitted 
to neglect their studies. Jimmie was still an ‘“ excitable 
spirit with little perseverance,” she wrote to her friends at 
Alexandrovsky ; however, she would not faint but labour, she 
said, she urged him on daily, and she “ could see already his 
exertions to overcome habits of indolence.” The Scripture 
studies were continued, and the two boys were made to recite 
a verse every morning before breakfast. Miss Palmer, who 
often visited her cousins in the old Pomfret farmhouse 
and who was their schoolmate during the winter of 1850, 
remembers above all, that Mrs. Whistler “ was very strict 
with them.” 
Miss Palmer describes Whistler at this period as 


“tall and slight with a pensive, delicate face, shaded by soft 
brown curls, one lock of which fell over his forehead. ... He 
had a somewhat foreign appearance and manner, which, aided 
by his natural abilities, made him very charming even at that 
age. ... He was one of the sweetest, loveliest boys I ever 
met, and was a great favourite.” 


The deepest impression he seems to have left on those 
who knew him at Pomfret was of his talents as a draughtsman, 
though his fame afterwards may have strengthened and 
coloured this impression in their memory. He is said to 
have been always drawing: at times caricatures and comic 
subjects, at others, illustrations to the books he read, or 
portraits of his friends, or the Pomfret landscape. Many 
of his sketches have been preserved, so that their actual 
merit is not a mere question of hearsay. Some were sent 
recently to the Buffalo Art Gallery by Miss Park, daughter 
of Dr. Roswell Park. One is owned by Mrs. Louise 
Chandler Moulton, who was also one of his schoolmates. 
1850] 27 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Whistler told us how he used to walk to school with her, 
carrying her books and basket, and she writes us that he 
“was very attentive and kind.” She also dwells on his 
great charm, which, “from the beginning, every one who 
saw him recognised,” and his gaiety. 

“He was full of fun inthosedays. The master of the school— 
Rev. Dr. Roswell Park—was one of the stiffest and most precise 
of clergymen, and dressed the part most punctiliously. One day 
Whistler came to school with a high, stiff collar, and a tie or stock 
precisely copied from Dr. Park’s. Of course the school-room was 
full of suppressed laughter. The reverend gentleman was very 
angry, but he could hardly take open notice of an offence of that 
sort. So he bottled up his wrath; but when ‘ Jimmy ’—as we 
used to call him in those schooldays—gave him some trifling cause 
of offence, the Rev. Dr. went for him with a ferrule. The school 
was in two divisions—the girls sitting on one side of the large 
hall, and the boys on the other. Jimmy (pursued by the Dr. 
and the ferrule) went round back of the girls’ row, and threw 
himself down on the floor, and the Dr. followed him and 
whacked him, more, I think, to Jimmy’s amusement than to his 
discomfort.” 

Mrs. Moulton has further recollections of the maps he 
drew in geography class, which “‘ were at once the pride and 
the envy of all the rest of us—they were so perfect, so delicate, 
so exquisitely dainty in workmanship.” He gave her a 
number of drawings, all lost except one, in sepia, called The 
Light at the Door, which she lent to the Whistler Memorial 
Exhibition at Boston, 1904. 

Other drawings done at Pomfret were in the same exhibi- 
tion. Twenty-two in black and white and water-colour 
were lent by Dr. Samuel Hammond, whose father was another 
schoolmate of Whistler’s. They suggest no small acquaint- 
ance with the French illustrators of the day. To the 
London Memorial Exhibition, 1905, Mrs. William Whistler 
sent two water-colours of this period and a pen drawing: 
A School House on Fire, Sam Weller’s Lodging in the Fleet 
28 [1850 


ee Peo : WI Frimeton ase hea, Wmbatte |) 


DRAWINGS MADE AT POMFRET 


SCHOOL-DAYS IN POMFRET 


Prison, and Benedictine Monks. Many more, no doubt, 


could be traced. But the early work of Whistler, which 
we have seen, does not strike us as remarkable. It has its 
historic importance, but shows no more evidence of genius 
than the early work of any other great artist. 


p 
14 
U4 


eae, 


IAN NAR ere 
a =; ae 


meetin 


i 


‘. 
; "a 
NY SwFARL 
ai REO} XJ 
\ vs “ 
SSSA Wie eo ‘i Se 
nee eS SN Rey eH 
\\\ a Nppecsiot act RS 
- Soe ‘ AF. i bY 
SS BOSE uss ae 


S 
ae 
— on 
ae ee 


1850] 


29 


CHAPTER IV. WEST POINT. THE YEARS 
EIGHTEEN FIFTY-ONE TO EIGHTEEN 
FIFTY-FOUR 


HOUGH Whistler’s mother took pride and pleasure in 
his drawing, she did not see in art a career for him. 
He inherited a profession more distinguished in her eyes. 
Many Whistlers and McNeills had been soldiers. West 
Point had made of them the men—the Americans—they 
were; West Point must do the same for him. Through 
the influence of George Whistler with Daniel Webster, it is 
said, his appointment as cadet At Large was obtained from 
President Fillmore, and on July 1, 1851, after Whistler had 
been two years at the Pomfret school, within ten days 
of his seventeenth birthday, he entered the United States 
Military Academy at West Point, where General Robert E. 
Lee was Commandant. 

Miss Palmer thinks he went against his will, though he 
never regretted having gone. He was not made for the army, 
any more than Giotto for Tuscan pastures or Corot for a 
Paris shop. It was reasonable that his family should try 
to make him a soldier; it was inevitable that they should 
fail. But his three years at West Point were an experience 
he would not have missed. 

Officially, the experiment was disastrous. The record 
sent to us from West Point by Colonel C. W. Larned is 
meagre, because, as Whistler did not graduate, his biography 
is not in the Cullum Registry of Graduates, nor in the gradua- 
ting records of the Adjutant’s Office. 


30 [1851 


WEST POINT 


“* He entered July 1, 1851, under the name of James A. (Abbot) 
Whistler; aged at the time sixteen years and eleven months. 
He was appointed At Large and his place of residence was in 
Pomfret, Windham Co., Connecticut. At the end of his second 
year’s course, in 1853, he was absent with leave on account 
of ill health. On June 16, 1854, he was discharged from the 
Academy for deficiency in chemistry. At that time he stood 
at the head of his class in drawing and No. 39 in philosophy, 
the total number in the class being 43. He recorded his place 
of birth as Massachusetts.” 


The Professor of Drawing at the time was Robert W. Weir, 
who always held Whistler in high esteem. Mr. J. Alden Weir, 
his son, writes us: 


“TI remember, as a boy, my father showing me his work, which 
at that time hung in what was known as the Gallery of the 
Drawing Academy. There were about ten works by him framed. 
From the start he showed evidences of a talent which later 
proved to be unique in those fine and rare qualities, hard to be 
understood by the majority.” 


Brigadier-General Alexander S. Webb, one of Whistler’s 
class-mates, who for long sat next him in the drawing-school, 
told a story of master and pupil to Mr. Gustave Kobbé : 


““In the art class one day, while Whistler was busy over an 
India ink drawing of a French peasant girl, Weir walked, as 
usual, from desk to desk, examining the pupils’ work. After 
looking over Whistler’s shoulder he stepped back to his own desk 
filled his brush with India ink (General Webb says he can see 
him now, rubbing the colour on a plate before ‘loading’) and 
approached Whistler with a view of correcting some of the lines 
in the latter’s drawing. When Whistler saw him coming, he 
raised his hands as if to ward off the strokes of his brush and 
called out, ‘Oh, don’t sir, don’t! You'll spoil it!’ ” 


Mr. William M. Chase, who read, or heard, the story, says 
that he told it to Whistler and asked if there was any truth 
in it? ‘* Well, you know, he would have!” was Whistler’s 
answer. And the best part of it all is that Professor Weir 


understood. He is reported to have said nothing, but, 
1854] Eke 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


smiling, to have let the drawing go uncorrected. He was 
not always so forbearing, however, as Colonel Larned explains : 

**T have here two drawings made by Whistler in his course of 
instruction in drawing, one of which is a water-colour copy of a 
coloured print, without special merit or interest, and evidently 
much touched up by Professor Weir, as was his wont; another, 
a pen-and-ink copy taken from a coloured print, quite brilliant 
and masterful in execution, which I presented to the officers’ mess. 
I do not set much stock by the coloured sketch, for the reason 
that it bears the ear-marks all overit of Weir’s retouching finish. 
It was his habit to touch up all water-colour efforts of the cadets 
for the examination exhibition, and I don’t believe Whistler at 
that time had any such facility in colour work as is indicated in the 
touching-upin this drawing. With my knowledge of my prede- 
cessor’s universal practice in this regard, in which we instructors 
followed suit to the best of our ability, I have always been sus- 
picious of its integrity. At the same time Whistler was head in 
drawing, and it may be that Weir forbore in his case and allowed 
it to stand. The pen and ink, however, must have been his own 
interpretation of a coloured lithograph, and shows such facility 
that it makes me hesitate regarding my libel of the other. 

‘** Whistler did another water-colour of a monk seated at a table 
by a window writing. This is also a copy of an old print which 
was used by Weir, with the others, through successive classes. 
I think it was who saw the thing and wrote a lot of tommy-rot 
and hifalutin about its subjective qualities, and Whistler’s 
satiric genius, and his introduction in the monk’s face of that of 
his room-mate, and a whole lot of esoteric subtleties, assuming 
it to have been an original production. As a matter of fact, I 
have copies of the same thing by cadets in my souvenir gallery, all 
touched up by Weir, and I fancy about as good as Whistler’s.”’ 
Of these two West Point drawings, copies probably of 

lithographs by Nash or Haghe, only one gives more promise 
than the earlier Pomfret performances. The water-colour 
is of no account at all. The pen drawing has in it the begin- 
ning of the handling of his etchings.* 


* Five drawings, four of An Hour in the Life of a Cadet in pen-and-ink and 
one of An Encampment in wash, have lately been found at West Point. The 
Cadet drawings are far the best of his early work that we have seen and we 
reproduce them. 

32 [1854 


ssssseaheencetastopeieantcscmammaranmanceenennssscanis Dialetliinimttanintestanisnaecnstiisunenstetitinatemsiitii 


DRAWING MADE AT WEST POINT 
(Copy of a Print) 


DAN, ae Ey 2B ey Baily 
HAs Bee ant Lobes chet eee ony 


De AF NS TT 


y 


Phebe ag Pada 


whit 


WEST POINT 


Of his other studies there is little to record except his 
failure. In his third year he was found deficient in chemistry, 
and we give Colonel’s Larned’s account of the incident : 

“Whistler said: ‘ Had silicon been a gas, I would have been 

a@ major-general.’ He was called up for examination on the 
subject of chemistry, which also covered the studies of mineralogy 
and geology, and given silicon to discuss. When called upon to 
recite, he started: ‘I am required to discuss the subject of 
silicon. Silicon is a gas.’ ‘That will do, Mr. Whistler,’ and 
he retired quickly to private life.” 


Another story is of an examination in history. ‘ What!” 
said his examiner, “‘ you do not know the date of the Battle 
of Buena Vista ? Suppose you were to go out to dinner and 
the company began to talk of the Mexican War, and you, 
a West Point man, were asked the date of the battle. What 
would you do?” “Do,” said Whistler, “why, I should 
refuse to associate with people who could talk of such things 
at dinner !” 

Whistler’s horsemanship is said to have been hardly better 
than his chemistry. It was not wholly unusual, according 
to General Webb, for Whistler at cavalry drill to go sliding 
over his horse’s head. On such occasions, Major Sackett, 
then in command, would call out: ‘‘ Mr. Whistler, aren’t 
you a little ahead of the squad ?”’ According to Whistler’s 
version to us, Major Sackett’s remark was: ‘‘ Mr. Whistler 
I am pleased to see you for once at the head of your class ! ”’ 
** But I did it gracefully,” Whistler always insisted. There 
are traditions of his fall when trotting in his first mounted 
drill, and the astonishment of the dragoon who ran to carry 
him off to hospital, on his rising unhurt with the one com- 
plaint that he didn’t “‘ see how any man could keep a horse 
for amusement.” Once Whistler had to ride a difficult horse 
called “ Quaker.” ‘‘ Dragoon, what horse is this?” 
** Quaker,”’ said the soldier. ‘‘ Well, he’s no friend!” said 
Whistler. 

1854] Lee 3 


Ws 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


His observance of the regulations was often as bad as his 
horsemanship, and his excuses for it were worse. General 
Ruggles, a class-mate, tells of the discovery of a pair of boots 
which were against the regulation, and of his writing a long 
explanation, winding up with the argument that, as this 
demerit added but a little to the whole number, ‘“ what 
boots it ?” 

General Langdon writes us : 


“The widow of a Colonel Thompson occupied a set of officer’s 
quarter’s at the ‘ Point,’ and, to eke out her slender pension, had. 
been allowed to take ten or twelve cadets to board, furnishing 
meals only. Very soon after his admission to the Academy, 
Whistler discovered that the fare of the cadets was not up to his 
delicate taste, and he applied for permission to take his meals 
at Mrs. Thompson’s. Now, though her house was in the row of 
the officers’ quarters and the nearest to the cadet barracks, being 
only a few steps distant, it was ‘ off cadet limits’ except for the 
boarders there when at their meals. One balmy evening, long 
after supper, our friend Whistler was discovered by Mrs. Thompson, 
leaning over her rear fence, engaged in an animated discourse in 
the French language with her pretty French maid. Mrs. Thomp- 
son, in a severe tone, inquired his business there at that hour. 
Whistler promptly replied: ‘I am looking for my cat!’ It 
was well known that cadets were not allowed to keep cats, dogs or 
other pets. The absurdity of Whistler’s answer deprived it of all 
turpitude, but the old lady, between amazement and anger, nearly 
had a fit. As soon as she could recover her powers of speech, 
she gasped out: ‘Young man, go ’way!’ and cut short the 
harmless confab by sending the pretty maid indoors. Of course, 
poor Whistler took no more meals at Mrs. Thompson’s, but was, 
instead, ordered to take his nourishment in the cadet’s mess hall, 
where the fare in those days was far from being inviting.” 


Sir Rennell Rodd tells us another story that he had from 
Whistler : 

“The cadets were out early one morning, engaged in surveying 

round the college. It was very cold and raw, and Jimmy, finding 


a line of deep ditch through which he could make a retiring move- 
ment, got back into college and his warm quarters unperceived. 


34 [1854 


UATLSIHM AD ACV SHHOLAMS HLIM ‘MOOd-IOOHOS KOU ADVA-WTLIL 


Mie aioe noe 


‘TCST e 

"OO ? AMUAA M A VTLYN pune ese. 

? “EAAULS-NHOL 19 "ON 

00 Ff SUNUVEA “S “¥-AA CHUHSITH Ad 
ef *MUOA-MOAN 


{- 


‘WAuDwasHaa ‘dew Ssoavis 
‘S3aVHS aXY SainoIva “IvadguNt aN ‘IvILS 
SINANAT 'WIEROSS TVOLLCTVYNY 40S aN¥ TATLAUOSG 
‘NE TVOMOVU BOA SOILYNANLV TV: Onova: wagarrrv 


oe “q-Tl ‘SalAVa ga RIV we 


‘SALV.LS OF.LINA AHL 
xi NOMLDOMISNE TVOLLY NALLY AO ASYAOO BAL 


ee 


“FS stom an wows” 
. ade 
“PERWOXOSTIL CNY WULTN0TD 


Eas 


ao 


mS  weys womeed ap y Pee my yu vy 


- SINIWATE 


eZ ag 


a ht, 


ae AD 
HR SER 


bear Like win mien ieee cele 
ae a. 4 =e ¥ ‘anf ae oad iv) - 
a Ge ae aly Sh hein aes ee plant 4 a5 43 
AME: PRISE Bae he aT AmB cate nat a es 

rs ‘ 7 ‘ + Fes "pe 
se LTS ty | vty Ear RN Ne Ns 
Ap) Ye Payee $2 ane? 5 RT es ’ 


re tyres Ca aot i ou ay nl 
EL ep eR Se Bah oa da LY 
H ay 4 . r rs Lely 


‘ , Pt rd 
peutiaae . ea 
1 RA ENTE 9 

IT eo 


a = . fn og 
Adis big te? 


aii Lise a ey Lid 
Bee hi eR bath Fake a wees 
- > Pi “J gz i = ta aia e, F 
LMA tee OPE MO ttsE 
Dae a 


yee eee 


gli 


WEST POINT 


By an untortunate accident a roll-call was held that morning 
Cadet Whistler not being present, a report was drawn up sending 
in his name to the commanding officer for being absent from 
parade without the knowledge or permission of his instructor ; 
the report was shown him, and he said to the military instructor : 

* Have I your permission to speak?’ ‘ Speak on, Cadet Whistler.’ 

‘ You have reported me, sir, for being absent from parade without 

the knowledge or permission of my instructor—well, now, if 

I was absent without your knowledge or permission, how did 

you know I was absent ?” They got into terms after that, and 

the incident was closed.” 

The stories about Whistler at West Point might be multi- 
plied indefinitely. Many have been already published. 
Those we tell suffice to show that at the Military Academy, 
as wherever he passed, the impression he left was vivid. 
We have a stronger proof of this in the letters written 
to us by several officers who were Whistler’s fellow 
cadets. It is half a century since they and Whistler 
studied together, and, with one exception, they never 
saw him in later years, yet their memory of him is still 
fresh. General D. McN. Gregg and General C. B. Comstock, 
his classmates, General Loomis L. Langdon, General Henry 
L. Abbot, General Oliver Otis Howard, General G. W. C. 
Lee, in the class before his, have all sent us recollec- 
tions of Whistler at West Point. Their letters are too 
valuable not to give in full, but too long to insert here, and 
we reserve them therefore for an Appendix. The great 
interest is to find that these distinguished officers agree 
thoroughly in their affection for Whistler, their appre- 
ciation of his gaiety and charm, and their respect for the 
drawings he made even in those early days. He was “a 
vivacious and likeable little fellow,’’ as General Comstock 
describes him, and we get a picture of him, short and slight, 
not over military in his bearing, somewhat foreign in appear- 
ance, near-sighted, and with thick black curls that won him 
the name of “ Curly ’” among the Cadets. His old friends 
1854] 35 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


remember his wit, his “‘ pranks”; his fondness for cooking 
and the excellence of his dishes; his excursions “ after 
taps,” for buckwheat cakes and oysters or ice-cream and 
soda-water to ‘“ Joe’s”’ and, for heavier fare, to “ Benny 
Haven’s,”” a mile away, where to be found was a serious 
offence ; they remember his indifference to discipline, and 
the number of his demerits which they are at pains to excuse 
as “not indicating any moral obliquity,” but due to such 
harmless faults as ‘lates,’ “‘ absences,” “ clothing out of 
order”’; best of all, they remember his drawings: his 
caricatures of the cadets, the Board of Visitors, the masters, 
his sketches of all kinds scribbled over the margins of his 
text-books, his illustrations to Dickens, to Dumas, to Victor 
Hugo. General Langdon recalls a picture that he and 
Whistler painted in collaboration, Whistler putting in the 
figures. Whistler gave his drawings away generously, and 
many have been preserved. Even the cover of an old 
geometry book, in which he sketched at odd moments and 
once noted some boyish bets with General Webb, was always 
kept by his room-mate, Frederick L. Childs (Les Enfants, 
Whistler nicknamed him), and is now kept as carefully by 
Mr. Thomas Childs, his son, who has kindly lent it to us. All 
these things point to the affection in which Whistler was held. 

Whistler looked back to West Point with equal affection. 
He failed, but West Point coloured his after-years and was 
the basis of his code of conduct. As a ‘“‘ West Point man ” 
he met every emergency, and his bearing, his carriage, showed 
the influence of those days when, as he liked to look back to 
himself, he was “ very dandy in grey.” For the discipline, 
the tradition, the tone of the Academy, he never lost his 
respect. He knew what it could do in making men of the 
boys appointed to it. ‘“‘ From the moment we came,” he 
said, when telling us of West Point, “‘ we were United States 
Officers, not school-boys, not college students. We were 
36 [1854 


SAM WELLER’S LODGING IN THE FLEET PRISO 
(Water-Colour) 


DUTY AT WES 
AN ENCAMPMENT 


, i Sant oe 
Me hase a i 
RAH LE RR 


or be 
es | 
2) da aang 


ee eer 


yr 


tr 


va 


te 


CS aid ae rome oh 


SIAR ie aaa Say Pigane te: 


opine’ nc babatn 


WEST POINT 


ruled, not by little school or college rules, but by our honour, 
by our deference to the unwritten law of tradition.”” He 
resented the least innovation that threatened the hold of 
this tradition over the cadets. To take a cadet into court 
was destruction to the whole morale of West Point, he declared, 
the old way was better, when it was such a disgrace to offend 
against the unwritten laws that the offender’s career was 
ruined. In the most trivial matters, he deplored any devia- 
tion from the old standard. That was the reason of his 
indignation when he heard that the cadets were playing 
football, and, worse, were having matches with college 
teams: to put themselves on the level of students was 
beneath the dignity of officers of the United States. During 
our war with Spain, during the Boers’ struggle in South Africa, 
there was not an event, not a rumour, that he did not refer 
for judgment to West Point and its code. The Spanish War, 
though “no doubt, we should never have gone into it, was 
quite the most wonderful, the most beautiful war since 
Louis XIV.; never in modern times has there been such a 
war, and all because it was conducted on correct West 
Point principles, with the most perfect courtesy and dignity 
on both sides, and the greatest chivalry.”” When he came 
back to London from Corsica in 1901, and was telling us of 
the people and the way they clung to old custom and cere- 
monial, he said that really he had found “ the Roman tradition 
almost as fine as the West Point tradition,” and this was 
indeed a concession. We never knew him to show the 
least desire to return to Lowell or Stonington, to Pomfret 
or Washington, but he always said, “If I ever make 
the journey to America, I will go straight to Baltimore, 
then to West Point, and then sail for England again.” 
One evening we asked him to meet an officer who had 
just come from West Point. His interest could not have 
been keener had he left the Academy the day before. 
1854] 37 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


He wanted to know about everything—the buildings, the 
life, the discipline. He resented each and every innovation, 
above all football. West Point to him was in danger when 
cadets could stoop to dispute “ with college students for 
a dirty ball kicked round a muddy field.” This was the 
shadow thrown over his pleasure when he heard of the pride 
the Academy took in claiming him, and of his reputation 
there: his drawings hanging in places of honour, a room 
always ready for him. It was the military side of the 
Academy, however, that stirred him to enthusiasm. His 
face fell, when, asking the officer who, like Major Whistler, 
was in the Artillery, ‘“ Professor of Tactics, I suppose ? ” 
and the officer answered, ‘‘ No, of French.’ One other way 
he showed his affection for the Military Academy was by send- 
ing to the library a copy of Whistler v. Ruskin: Art and 
Art Critics. In it, Mr. Holden, the librarian, informs us, 
are autograph notes, and on the title-page the inscription : 
‘** From an old cadet whose pride it is to remember his West 
Point days.” This is signed with the Butterfly, and at the 
end of the book he pasted in newspaper cuttings about the 
trial. The authorities at West Point, on their side, have 
honoured him by allowing a memorial tablet, one of St. 
Gaudens’ last works, to be placed in the library of the 
Academy. 

But it needs more than respect and love for the Military 
Academy to make a soldier, and Whistler was, as Poe had 
been before him, an alien at West Point. It was no question 
of the number of his demerits or of his ignorance of chemistry 
and history: he had something else to do in life. 


38 [1854 


CHAPTER V. THE COAST SURVEY. THE 
YEARS EIGHTEEN FIFTY-FOUR TO 
EIGHTEEN FIFTY-FIVE 


HEN Whistler left West Point in 1854, he had not 

only to face the disappointment of his mother, but 

to find another career. Miss Davis writes us that she re- 
members seeing Whistler at Scarsdale, West Chester County, 
New York, where Mrs. Whistler had a house for the summer, 
‘* sitting very quietly in a dark corner of the piazza, and I 
have thought since that he had probably just come from 
West Point.” It was bad enough to have disappointed his 
mother; to make it worse, the new plan now was to ap- 
prentice him to Mr. Winans in the locomotive works at 
Baltimore. . 

Mr. Frederick B. Miles writes us : seb atal | 


“ Tt was in 1854 that I first met him in Baltimore, when he had 
just left West Point, at the house of Thomas Winans, who had 
returned from Russia and built a beautiful house on the very 
grounds where I had been for several iyears at the French school 
of M. Boursaud. I was then apprenticed to the loco works of 
old Mr. Ross Winans, Thomas Winans’ father. Jem Whistler’s 
elder brother, George Whistler, was a friend of my family; had 
been superintendent of the New York and New Haven Railroad 
(was an engineer) and had married Miss Julia Winans, sister of 
Thomas Winans, then came into the loco works as partner 
and superintendent. I was in the drawing-room under him. 

“Whistler was staying with Tom Winans mainly, and some- 
times with his brother, George Whistler. They were all perplexed 
at his ‘ flightiness ’"—wanted him to enter the loco works, His 
younger brother William was an apprentice in the works along 


1854] 39 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


with me, and also a cousin, John McNeill. But Jem never really 
worked in the locomotive business. He spent much of his several 
short stays and two long ones in Baltimore loitering in his 
peculiar bizarre way about the drawing office and shops, and at 
my drawing desk in Tom Winans’ house. We all had boards 
with paper, carefully stretched, which Jem would cover with 
tentative sketches to our great disgust, obliging us to stretch fresh 
ones, but we loved him all the same! He would also ruin all 
our best pencils! sketching not only on the paper, but also on 
the smoothly finished wooden backs of the drawing-boards which, 
I think, he preferred to the paper side. We kept some of the 
sketches for a long time. I had a beauty—a cavalier in a 
dungeon cell, with one small window high up—Rembrandt effects 
and a little bird on the window, @ la Silvio Pellico’s Rondinello 
Pellegrino !—perhaps inspired by it? I think he afterwards 
painted a picture like it, but I could never find it. In all his 
work at that time he was very Rembrandtesque, but of course 
only amateurish. Nevertheless he was studying and working out 
effects.” 


Whistler saw enough of the locomotive works to know 
that he did not want to be an apprentice, and it was not long 
before he left Baltimore for Washington and the Coast 
Survey. When he told us of his experiences there, he spoke 
as if he had gone to Washington straight from West Point. 
He was with us on the evening of September 15, 1900, after 
the news had come from the Transvaal of President Kruger’s 
flight, and our talking of it led him back to West Point, and 
so to the story of his days in the service of the Government. 
He had followed the Boer War with intense interest. 


“ The Boers are as fine as Southerners—their fighting would be 
no discredit to West Point [and’ he was indignant with us for 
looking upon Kruger’s flight as, diplomatically, a blunder]. 
Diplomatically it was right, you know; the one thing Kruger 
should have done, just as, in that other amazing campaign, 
flight had been the one thing for Jefferson Davis, a southern 
gentleman—who had the code. I will always remember the 
courtesy shown me by Jefferson Davis, through whom I got my 
appointment in the Coast Survey. 

40 [1854 


THE COAST SURVEY 


“Tt was after my little difference with the Professor of Chemistry 
at West Point. The professor would not agree with me that 
silicon was a gas, but declared it was a metal,—and as we could 
come to no agreement in the matter, it was suggested—all in 
the most courteous and correct West Point way—that perhaps 
I had better leave the Academy. Well, you know, it was not a 
moment for the return of the prodigal to his family or for any 
slaying of fatted calves.—I had to work, and I went to Washington. 
—There, I called at once on Jefferson Davis, who was Secretary 
of War—a West Point man like myself. He was most charming 
and I—well, from my Russian cradle, I had an idea of things, 
and the interview was in every way correct—conducted on both 
sides with the utmost dignity and elegance. I explained my 
unfortunate difference with the Professor of Chemistry—repre- 
sented that the question was one of no vital importance—while 
on all really important questions I had carried off more than the 
necessary marks. My explanation made, I suggested that I 
should be re-instated at West Point, in which case, as far as I 
was concerned, silicon should remain a metal. The Secretary, 
courteous to the end, promised to consider the matter, and 
named a day for a second interview. 

** Before I went back to the Secretary of War, I called on the 
Secretary of the Navy, also a Southerner, James C. Dobbin, of 
South Carolina, suggesting that I should have an appointment in 
the Navy. The Secretary objected that I was too young. In 
the confidence of youth, I said age should be no objection; I 
‘could; be entered at the Naval Academy, and the three years 
at West Point would count at Annapolis.’ The Secretary was 
interested, for he too had a sense of things. He regretted, with 
gravity, the impossibility. But something impressed him; for 
later, he reserved one of six appointments he had to make in the 
Marines and offered it to me. In the meantime, I had returned 
to the Secretary of War, who had decided that it was impossible 
to meet my wishes in the matter of West Point; West Point 
discipline had to be observed, and if one cadet were re-instated, 
a dozen others who had tumbled out after me, would have to be 
re-instated too. But if I would call on Captain Benham, of the 
Coast Survey, a post might be waiting for me there.” 


Captain Benham was an old friend of Major Whistler’s, 
and Whistler was engaged in the drawing division of the 
1854] AI 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


United States Coast and Geodetic Survey, at the salary of a 
dollar and a half a day. This appointment he received on 
November 7, 1854, six months after he had left West Point. 

Of this place, and his work in it, Whistler said but little. 
His adventures with the Secretaries of War and of the Navy 
amused him—they were ordered so entirely after the West 
Point code. There was nothing whatever to appeal to him 
in the routine of an office. What he had todo, he did, but 
with no enthusiasm. 


“I was apt to be late, I was so busy socially. I lived in a small 
room, but it was amazing how I was asked and went everywhere 
—to balls, to the Legations, to all that was going on. Labouchére, 
an attaché at the British Legation, has never ceased to talk of 
me, SO gay, going everywhere, and, when I had not a dress suit 
pinning up the tails of my black frock-coat, and turning it into 
a dress-coat for the occasion. Shocking.” 


Mr. Labouchére has told this story in print, and also in a 
letter to us: 


“I did know Whistler very well in America about fifty years 
ago. But he was then a young man at Washington, who—if I 
remember rightly—had not been able to pass his examination 
at West Point and had given no indication of his future fame. 
He was rather hard up, I take it, for I remember that he’ pinned 
back the skirt of a frock-coat to make it pass as a dress-coat at 
evening parties. Washington was then a very small place 
compared with what it is now, where everybody—so to say— 
knew everybody, and the social parties were of a very simple 
character. This is really all that I remember of Whistler at that 
time, except that he was thought witty and paradoxically 
amusing ! ” 

But long before this, there was something in his dress 
which drew attention to him. Though he was never seen 
in the “‘ high-standing collar and silk hat” of the time, some 
remember him in a Scotch cap and grey shawl, then the 
fashion ; others recall a slouch hat and circular cloak, his 


coat, unbuttoned, showing his waistcoat; while traditions 
42 [1854 


THE COAST SURVEY 


of his social charm and gaiety come from every side. Ad- 
jutant-General Breck is responsible for the story of Whistler 
having once invited the Russian Minister—others say the 
Chargé d’ Affaires—Edward de Stoeckl, to dine with him, 
carrying the Minister off in his own carriage, doing the 
marketing by the way, and cooking the dinner before his 
guest in the room in the house where he lived. And it has 
been said that never was the Minister entertained by so 
brilliant a host while in Washington. 

Mr. Kobbé obtained much information from the late A. 
Lindenkohl, a fellow draughtsman in the Coast Survey. 
Whistler lodged in a house at the north-east corner of E. and 
Twelfth Streets : “ a two-story brick building with attic. He 
occupied a plainly but comfortably furnished room, such as 
could then have been rented for about ten dollars a month.” 
The office records show that he worked six and one half days 
in January, and five and three-fourth days in February. 
And he usually arrived late ; but, he would say, really it was 
not his fault; he was not too late, it was the office that 
opened too early. Lindenkohl described an effort to reform 
him : 

‘** Captain Benham, who was then in charge of the office, took 
occasion to tell me that he felt great interest in the young man, 
not only on account of his talents, but also on account of his 
father, who was his particular friend, and he told me that he 
would be highly pleased if I could induce Whistler to be more 
regular in his attendance. ‘Call at his lodgings on your way to 
the office,’ he said, ‘ and see if you can’t bring him along.’ 

** Accordingly, one morning, I called at Whistler’s lodgings at 
half-past eight. No doubt he felt somewhat astonished, but 
received me with the greatest bonhomie, invited me to make 
myself at home and promised to make all possible haste to comply 
with my wishes. Nevertheless he proceeded with the greatest 

. deliberation to rise from his couch and put himself into shape 
for the street and prepare his breakfast, which consisted of 


a cup of strong coffee brewed in a steam-tight French machine, 
1854| 43 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


then a novelty ; and also insisted upon treating me with a cup of 
coffee. We made no extra haste on our way to the office, which 
we reached about half-past ten—an hour and a half after time. 
I did not repeat the experiment. . . . Whistler was possessed 
of an elegant figure with an abundance of black curly hair, soft 
lustrous eyes, finely cut features, fair complexion, well-shaped 
hands and a graceful tournure. I thought him about the hand- 
somest fellow I ever met ; but for some reasons I did not consider 
him a perfect model of manly beauty—his mouth betokened 
more ease than firmness, his brow more reserve than acute 
mental activity, and his eyes more depth than penetration. 
Sensitiveness and animation appeared to be his predominating 
traits.” 


Lindenkohl also said that Whistler already spoke of Paris 
with enthusiasm, that he made landscapes, sketched ‘some- 
times from the office windows, and studies of people, always 
taking the greatest interest in the arrangement and folds of 
their clothes. Whistler showed him “several examples 
done with the brush in sepia, in old French or Spanish styles,” 
whatever this may mean. Another draughtsman in the 
office recalled Whistler sketching even on the walls as he 
went downstairs. And, though in Washington only a few 
months, he left there, as everywhere, an impression of his 
gaiety, his charm, his indifference to work except in the one 
form in which work interested him. 

If nothing else were known of this period, it would be 
memorable for the technical instruction he received in the 
Coast Survey. His work was the drawing and etching of 
Government topographical plans and maps, which have 
to be made with the utmost accuracy and sharpness of line. 
His training, therefore, was in the hardest and most perfect 
school of etching in the world, a fact never, until now, 
clearly pointed out. The work was dull, altogether me- 
chanical, and he sometimes relieved the dulness by filling 
empty spaces on the plates with sketches of his own. Captain 
Benham told him plainly, Whistler said, that he was not 
44 [1854 


THE COAST SURVEY, No. 1 we, 
(Etching) 


PLATE Wo. 414, 


U.S.COAST SURVEY 


AD.BACHE Supde 


Sketch of 
Anacapa Inland i dua f Satta Cruz tstand in 
fapprax)jLat.24 00 are 1g UP LEW frora Greenwich 


fappres: Li ANACAPA TSELAND 


Variation of tha Maynete. Neadle aS at ~ ON 
SANTA BARBARA CHANNEL 
By Lieut TH. STEVENS US.N-AssistU SUS. 


1854 


Yiew of the Eastern tremity of Anaeapa Island from the Seuthward 


COAST SURVEY, No. 2, ANACAPA ISLAND 
(Etching) 


een eee ern ca narra eh 


4 
"4 yi 

f é 

og “a 
¢& . 


eee 
U Als ary 
aie 


Rae roles a | Saeed ov seals 
Says ae ie wari i RR acca pertiees 
7 at a7 5 Yad a" 

=i | bari ‘aliccahe aor od ‘ 


Bis | es AS Astin: DT jib a. Bee: inh cits 
«Mase a bale Ni Lies hid} Syste or 
abate, i aeielicaM tt aa 
ne RE pe 
) pals ec Pies ae | dey wi onan 
| sare “tt eh ot sh ms 58 oy * tee one we, 
oe en 
on sat “a. eee 2 ; ict el tele F atk 
ei ebhintiya ane: Te, a MQW dhe use — 
ba aces tai Appa, Mug NCR ioe 
: yards: «ie HIT Tet eae i ey 
cla ni 
7 ee gud fs ear lei  tacpante 
i ager ee Fore aber oe . 


t 
iif 5 Ay 


he oa 


7 
a " 


dahl 
‘+ 

Ee - 

hid + 


THE COAST SURVEY 


there to spoil Government coppers, and ordered all the designs 
to be immediately erased. Other accounts have been given 
but this was Whistler’s account to us.* Only two plates 
have been as yet, or probably ever will be, found that can be 
attributed to him, wholly or in part. These are Coast 
Survey, No. 1, and Coast Survey, No. 2, Anacapa Island. 
They are undescribed by Mr. Wedmore, though referred to 
in his preface to the Catalogue of Whistler’s Etchings. They 
were first described in the Catalogue of the Whistler Memorial 
Exhibition in London, 1905. The Coast Survey, No. 1, 
brought him neither credit nor into the graces of the Coast 
Survey officials. It is a plate giving two parallel views, one 
above the other, of the coast line of a rocky shore, the lower 
showing a small town in a deep bay, with, below them both 
to the extreme left, the profile of the same coast. Whistler 
was unable to confine himself to the Government require- 
ments. In the lower design, chimneys are gaily smoking, 
and on the upper part of the plate, several figures, obviously 
reminiscent of prints and drawings he had seen, are sketched : 
an old peasant woman, a man in a tall Italian hat, another 
in a Sicilian bonnet, a mother and child in an oval, a battered 
French soldier, a bearded monk in an elaborate cowl. The 
drawing is schoolboy-like, though it shows certain observation, 
but the biting is remarkable. The little figures are bitten 
as well and in the same way as in La Vieille aux Loques, 
etched three or four years afterwards: to look at them is to 
know that Whistler was a consummate etcher technically 
before he left the Coast Survey. There is no advance in the 
biting of the French series. So astonishing is this mastery 
that, if the technique in some of the French plates were not 
so similar, one would be tempted to doubt whether Whistler 


really etched those little figures in Washington, especially 

* Since this was written, Mr. John R. Key has published an article, Recollections 
of Whistler in the Century Magazine for April 1908, in which he says that this 
plate was merely an experimental one, such as beginners were allowed to work upon. 


1854] 45 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


as the plate is unsigned. The plate escaped by chance. 
Whistler’s friend and fellow draughtsman, Mr. John R. Key, 
to whom it was given to clean off and use again, asked to 
keep it, and it was sold to him for the price of old copper. 
The second plate, Anacapa Island, is signed by several 
engravers. Whistler, most likely, etched the view of the 
eastern extremity of the island, for many lines on the rocky 
shore resemble the work in the French series, and also the 
two flights of birds which, though they enliven the design, 
have no topographical value. This plate was finished and 
published. There is said to be a third plate, a chart of the 
Delaware River, but we have never seen it and can find out 
nothing about it. Mr. E. G. Kennedy and Mr. Frederick 
Keppel have shown us tiny drawings and prints of soldiers 
and other figures which they believe were done at this 
time. 

One other record of Whistler at the Coast Survey remains, 
but of a very different kind. He liked to tell the story. 
Captain Benham used to come and look through the small 
magnifying glass each draughtsman in this department had 
to work with. One day, Whistler etched a little devil on 
the glass, and Captain Benham looked through it at the plate. 
Whistler described himself to us, at the moment, lying full : 
length on a sort of mattress or trestle, so as not to touch 
the copper. But he saw Captain Benham give a jump. 
The Captain said nothing. He pocketed the glass, and that 
was all Whistler heard of it until many years afterwards 
when, one day, an old gentleman appeared at his studio in 
Paris, and by way of introduction took from his watch-chain 
a tiny magnifying glass, and asked Whistler to look through 
it—“‘ and,” he said, ‘“‘ well—we recognised each other 
perfectly.” 

Captain Benham is dead, but his son, Major H. H. Benham, 
writes us: ‘“ I have heard my father tell the story. He was 
46 [1854 


THE COAST SURVEY 


very fond of Whistler and thought most highly of his great 
ability—or rather genius, I should say.” 

Genius like Whistler’s served him as little at the Coast 
Survey as at West Point. He resigned in February 1855. 
His brother, George Whistler, and Mr. Winans tried harder 
than ever to make him enter the locomotive works in Balti- 
more. He was now about twenty-one, old enough at last 
to insist upon what he wanted, and what he wanted was to 
study art. Already at St. Petersburg, his ability had struck 
his mother’s friends. At Pomfret and at West Point, he 
owed to his drawing whatever distinction he had attained. 
And there had been things done outside of school and 
Academy and office work he told us : 

“ Portraits of my cousin Annie Denay and of Tom Winans, 
and many paintings at Stonington that Stonington people 
remembered so well they looked me up in Paris afterwards. 
Indeed, all the while, ever since my Russian days, there had 
been always the thought of art, and when at last I told the 
family that I was going to Paris, they said nothing. There was 
no difficulty. They just got me a ticket. I was to have three 
hundred and fifty dollars (seventy pounds) a year, and my step- 
brother, George Whistler, who was one of my guardians, sent it 
to me after that regularly every quarter.” 


1855] 47 


CHAPTER VI. STUDENT DAYS IN THE 
LATIN QUARTER. THE YEARS EIGHTEEN 
FIFTY-FIVE TO EIGHTEEN FIFTY-NINE 


HISTLER arrived in Paris before the end of the 
summer 0f 1855. There he fell among friends. The 
American Legation was open to the son of Major Whistler. 
It was the year of the first great French Exhibition, and 
Sir Henry Cole, the British Commissioner, as well as the 
Thackerays, were in Paris. Mrs. Richmond Ritchie, who 
remembers meeting him, writes : 


“I wish I had a great deal more to tell you about Whistler. 
I always enjoyed talking to him when we were both hobbledehoys 
at Paris; he used to ask me to dance, and rather to my dis- 
appointment perhaps, for, much as I liked talking to him, I 
preferred dancing, we used to stand out while the rest of the 
party polkaed and waltzed by. There was a certain definite 
authority in the things he said, even as a boy. I can’t remember 
what they were, but I somehow realised that what he said 
mattered. When I heard afterwards of his fanciful freaks and 
quirks, I could not fit them in with my impression of the wise 
young oracle of my own age.” 


According to Mr. F. B. Miles, Whistler’s brother George 
wanted him to study at the Ecole des Beaux-Arts, but there 
is no record of his ever having been admitted. He went 
instead to the studio which Gleyre inherited from Delaroche 
and afterwards handed down to Géréme, and which drew to 
it the students who did not crowd to Couture and Ary Scheffer. 
It was not extraordinary, as some have said, that Whistler 
should have gone there; it would have been extraordinary 
48 [1855-59 


IN THE LATIN QUARTER 


had he stayed away. He arrived in Paris just when Courbet, 
refused at the Exhibition, was defying convention with his 
first show and his first “‘ Manifesto,’’ and many of the younger 
men were throwing over Romanticism to follow him as 
Realists. Whistler quickly found himself more in sympathy 
with the followers of Courbet than with Gleyre’s pupils, and 
he became so intimate with the group, among whom were 
Fantin and Degas, who studied under Lecocq de Boisbaudran 
that it is sometimes thought he must have been their fellow 
student. But on his arrival in Paris, the young American 
probably had heard neither of Lecocq de Boisbaudran nor 
Courbet, and Gleyre was the popular teacher. Fantin- 
Latour, in some notes made shortly before his death, which 
have been handed to us, and M. Duret both say that they 
seldom, if ever, heard Whistler speak of Gleyre’s. When 
we asked him about it, he seemed to have nothing to recall 
save the dignified principles upon which the afelier was 
conducted. There was not even the usual tormenting of 
the nouveau. ‘“‘ If a man were a decent fellow, and would 
sing his song, and take a little chaff, he had no trouble,” and 
this agrees with Du Maurier’s description in T'rilby of Carrel’s, 
which was Gleyre’s. Whistler could remember only one 
disagreeable incident, and that was not in connection with 
a nouveau, but with a student who had been there some time, 
and was putting on airs. One morning he came to the studio 
late, 

“and there were all the students working away very hard, the 

unpopular man among them, and there, at the end of the room, 

on the model’s stand, was an enormous catafalque, the unpopular 


one’s name on it in big, staring letters. And no one said a word. 
But that killed him. He was never again seen in the place.” 


Gleyre was by no means colourless as a teacher. He is 
now remembered chiefly as a legitimate successor to David 


and the Classicists, but he held theories disquieting to the 
1855-59] Le 49 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


academic mind. He taught that, before a picture was begun, 
the colours should be arranged on the palette: in this way, 
he said, difficulties were overcome, for once the work was 
started, attention could then be given unreservedly to the 
drawing and modelling of the subject on the canvas in colour. 
It was the system Whistler endeavoured to follow all his life.* 
He taught also that ivory black is the basis of all tones, which 
was a heresy to those who listened. Upon this preparation 
of the palette and this basis of black—black “‘ the universal 
harmoniser ”—thought a heresy in his case too, Whistler 
founded his life-long practice as painter and his teaching 
when he, in his turn, became a master, and visited the pupils 
of the Académie Carmen. In fact, as he has told us over 
and over, his practice of a lifetime was founded on what he 
learned as a bey, on the methods he never abandoned. He 
only developed methods, misunderstocd by all those prophets, 
who have said he had but enough knowledge for his own 
needs. 

Whistler spoke often to us of the men he met at Gleyre’s : 
Poynter, Du Maurier, Lamont, Joseph Rowley. Leighton, 
in 1855, was studying at Couture’s, developing his theory 
that “the best dodge is to be a devil of a clever fellow.” 
Mrs. Barrington says Leighton made Whistler’s acquaintance 
at the time and admired Whistler’s etchings. But Whistler 
never recalled Leighton among his fellow students, though 
he spoke often, and with affection, of Thomas Armstrong, 
who worked at Ary Scheffer’s, and Aleco Ionides, not an 


* “ Tl recommendait de faire des tons d’avance sur la palette,”’ Clément writes 
in his life of Gleyre, 1878; ‘‘ on mélait les couleurs, on faisait des paquets de 
couleur de chair, et on s’en servait comme on se serait servi d’un ton d’ambre 
monochrome. Ceci avait pour but de séparer les difficultés. La question de la 
couleur devait étre plus ou moins résolue par ces préparations préalable, et l’atten- 
tion pouvait se porter plus directement sur le modile et sur le dessin. . . . Parfois 
il disait des choses qui ressemblait & des hérésies ; on se les répétait, car on savait 
bien que c’étaient des hyperboles. Ainsi, un jour, il dit: ‘Le noir d’ivoire est 
la base des tons.’ ”’ 


50 [1855-59 


IN THE LATIN QUARTER 


art student but studying, no one seemed to know what or 
where. This is the group of Trilby, Du Maurier’s sentimental 
echo of La Vie de Bohéme. Lamont, “ the Laird” of Trilby, 
and Aleco Ionides, ‘“‘ the Greek,’’ are dead. It is regrettable 
that Du Maurier published his spite against Whistler and 
‘so wrecked what Whistler had imagined a genuine friendship. 
Sir Edward J. Poynter, Mr. Armstrong and Mr. Rowley 
remain. The two latter have given us their impressions of 
Whistler at the time, and so has Mr. Luke Ionides, then 
studying for the Diplomatic Service : 


“T first knew Jimmie Whistler in Paris. It was in the month 

of August 1855. My younger brother was staying there with a 
tutor, and had made friends with Jimmie. He was just twenty- 
one years old, full of life and ‘ go,’ always ready for fun, good- 
natured and good-tempered—he wore a peculiar straw hat 
slightly on the side of his head—it had a low crown and a broad 
brim.” 

Whistler etched a portrait of himself in this hat, which 
startled even artists and students and became a legend in 
the Quartier. 

Mr. Rowley (‘‘ Taffy ’’) writes us: 


“It was in 1857-8 that I knew Whistler, and a most amusing 
and eccentric fellow he was, with his long, black, thick, curly 
hair, and large felt hat with a broad black ribbon round it. I 
remember on the wall of the atelier was a representation of him, 
I believe done by Du Maurier, a sketch of him, then a fainter 
one, and then merely a note of interrogation—very clever it was 
and very like the original. In those days he did not work hard, 
and I have a faint recollection of seeing a head painted by him 
in deep Rembrandtish tones which was thought very good 
indeed. He was always smoking cigarettes, which he made 
himself, and his droll sayings caused us no end of fun. I don’t 
think he stayed long in any rooms. One day he told us he had 
taken a new one, and he was fitting it up peu & peu, and he had 
already got a tabouret and a chair. He told me tales of being 
invited to a reception at the American Minister’s, but, as he had 

yno dress-suit to go in, he had to borrow Poynter’s, who fitted 
1855-59] 51 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


him out, all except his boots. So he waited until the guests 
at the hotel had retired for the night, when he went round the 
corridors, found what he wanted, and left them at the door on 
his return from the reception. It was more his manner and 
the clever way he told the tale that amused us all. You see it is 
nearly fifty years since all this happened, and I find it rather 
difficult to recall scenes which occurred so long ago. I have his 
first twelve etchings, which he did in 1858. I never saw him after 
I left Paris in 1858! He was never a friend of mine, and it was 
only occasionally he came to see us at the atelier in Notre-Dame- 
des-Champs.” 


Whistler lived at one time with Sir Edward J. Poynter, 
who, however, scarcely seems to have understood him. 
Their methods of study and work were different, and, to 
Poynter, Whistler was something of the “‘ Idle Apprentice.” 
In his speech at the first Royal Academy Banquet (April 30, 
1904) after Whistler’s death, Poynter said: 

“Thrown very intimately in Whistler’s company in early 
days, I knew him well when he was a student in Paris—that is, 
if he could be called a student, who, to my knowledge, during 
the two or three years when I was associated with him, devoted 
hardly as many weeks to study. His genius, however, found its 
way in spite of an excess of the natural indolence of disposition 


and love of pleasure of which a certain share has been the 
hereditary attribute of the art student.” 


“ Whistler was never wholly one of us,” Mr. Armstrong 
told us once in talking of him. It seems that Whistler 
laughed at the Englishmen and their ways, above all at the 
boxing and sparring matches in their studios; he could not 
see why they didn’t hire the concierges to do the fighting 
for them. The rush of American artists to Paris had not 
yet begun, and Whistler was more closely associated with 
the French than with any other students. He could speak 
their language, he knew Murger by heart before he came to 
Paris, and there he got to know him personally. Mr. Ionides 
says that once, walking along a street on the rive gauche with 
52 [1855-59 


IN THE LATIN QUARTER 


Whistler and Lamont, they met Murger, and Whistler intro- 
duced them. Paris, in the Latin Quarter, was still the Paris 
of Murger, where the young artist still led the easiest, merriest, 
dirtiest existence possible, where, with his long hair and 
beard and wonderful clothes, he still continued to épater le 
bourgeois ; where he toiled away all day in the schools or 
galleries, and played away all night in the cafés and balls ; 
where he was the friend of the grisette ; where he met poverty 
with the gaiety of Marcel and failure with the swagger of 
Rodolphe, where the extravagant was for him the normal ; 
where courage and hope saved him from disaster; and 
where, through all his absurdities and follies and blague, art 
was the beginning and end of his every thought and ambition. 
Whistler delighted in the fantastic humour and _picturesque- 
ness of it all, and was always quoting Murger, even late in life. 
The Englishmen at Gleyre’s could not understand his pleasure 
in his “‘ no shirt friends,’ as he called one group of students. 
Every now and then their society palled, even on him, and 
he would then tell the Englishmen that he “‘ must give up 
the ‘no shirt’ set and begin to live cleanly.” The end 
came when, during an absence from Paris, he lent them his 
room, luxurious from the student standpoint, with a bath, 
and full of beautiful china. The “no shirt friends ” could 
not change their habits with their surroundings. They 
made grogs in the bath; they never washed a plate, but, 
when one side was dirty, ate off the other, and Whistler 
had not bargained to make his own rcoms the background 
for such a scene in the Vie de Bohéme. But this was later 
on, after his adventures with them had been the gossip of 
the Quartier, and had confirmed the Englishmen in their 
impressions of his idleness. 

Among the many French students who were his companions, 
he had a few intimate friends: Aubert, the first man he 
knew in Paris, a clerk in the Crédit Foncier ; Fantin ; Legros ; 
1855-59] 33 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Becquet, a musician; Henri Martin, son of the historian ; 
Drouet * the sculptor ; Henri Oulevey and Ernest Delannoy, 
painters. Only two of these friends survive to-day. From 
Fantin we have the notes made just before his death. Legros 
prefers to remember nothing, the friendship in his case 
ending irrevocably many years since. MM. Drouet and 
Oulevey have told us almost as much as Whistler did of 
those days. When Oulevey first knew him, Whistler lived 
in a little hotel in the Rue St. Sulpice; then he moved to 
No. 1 Rue Bourbon-le-Chateau, near St. Germain des Prés ; 
and then to No. 3 Rue Campagne-Premiére, where Drouet 
had a studio. For a while, when remittances ran out, he 
climbed his six flights and shared a garret with Delannoy, 
the “ Ernest” of the stories Whistler liked best to tell. 

Whistler’s lodgings and restaurants, a matter of course 
to his fellow students, startled the friends from home. Mr. 
Miles writes us an account of his experience in May 1857, 
when he came to Paris with letters from Whistler’s family 
and a draft for his allowance. 

“ At the Beaux-Arts he was not to be found; he had given 
it up, but I got his address. He had left it without leaving 
any record of his new one. I was in despair, but went to the 
Luxembourg, hoping to find him or some trace of him. In looking 
at a picture, I backed into an easel, heard a muttered ‘damn’ 
behind me—and there was Whistler himself, painting busily. 
He took me to his quarters in a little back street, up ten flights 
of stairs—a tiny room with brick floor, a cot bed, a chair on which 
were a basin and pitcher—and that was all/ We sat on the cot, 
and talked as cheerfully as if in a palace—and he got the draft. 
‘Now,’ said he, ‘I shall move downstairs, and begin all over— 
furnish my room comfortably. You see, I have just eaten my 
washstand and borrowed a little, hoping the draft would arrive. 
Have been living for some time on my wardrobe. You are just 
in time, don’t know what I should have done, but it often happens 


* M. Drouet died in May 1908, just as we were going over our proofs. Only 
the spring before, we had seen him in Paris when he had told us a great deal of 
Whistler and student life in the Fifties. Now, only Legros and Oulevey remain. 


54 [1855-59 


IN THE LATIN QUARTER 


this way! I first eat a wardrobe, and then move upstairs a flight 

‘or two, but seldom get so high as this before the draft comes !’ 
How true this is I can’t say, but it sounds probable and very like 
Whistler—at that age—he was then about twenty-three or just 
twenty-four at most—May 1857. Then Whistler showed me 
Paris; met some of his painter friends. I remember only 
Lambert (French) and Poynter (English)—now a great swell. 
Whistler didn’t care much for Poynter at that time, but was 
witty and amusing, as usual. He dined with me at the best 
restaurant in Paris, which he had not done for a long time, and 
dined me, the next day, at a little crémerie * to show what his 
usual fare had been, and, indeed, usually was when the time 
was approaching for the arrival of his allowance—the back ones 
being exhausted !” 


The restaurant where they all usually met was Lalouette’s, 
near the Rue Dauphine, famous to them for a wonderful 
Burgundy at one franc the bottle, le cachet vert, called for 
only on great occasions, and more famous now for Bibi 
Lalouette of the etching, the child of the patron. Lalouette, 
like Siron at Barbizon, understood the artist and gave un- 
limited credit. Whistler, when he left Paris, owed Lalouette 
three thousand francs, every sow of which was paid, though 
it took along time. They also dined at Madame Bachimont’s 
in the Place de ia Sorbonne, a crémerie, where Whistler 


* This erémerie may have been Madame Bachimont’s or else “ the clean little 
place” described by Major W. L. B. Jenney. The patronne made wonderful 
pumpkin pies, and Whistler, who never lost his appetite for American dishes, 
came to eat them. ‘ Young Whistler, then an art student, bright, original and 
amusing,” Major Jenney thinks, gave “no promise of any particular ability as 
an artist,” but had made a reputation as the leader of disorder at the Louvre, and 
the organiser of nigger minstrels. ‘“ Among the habitués at Madame Busque’s 
was a student from the School of Mines, Vinton, afterwards Professor of Mining 
at Columbia College, and during the war a brigadier-general. He told me the 
following story in 1866. One night in South Carolina an officer wandered into 
his camp. He sent word to the general, by the sergeant of the guard, that he 
was an officer who had lost his way, that he asked permission to pass the rest of 
the night in his camp, adding that he had known General Vinton when a student 
in Paris. General Vinton sent for the officer, whom he failed to recognise. After 
some thought, he asked the question, ‘Who was the funniest man we knew in 
Paris?’ ‘ Whistler!’ instantly answered the officer. ‘ All right,’ says Vinton, 
‘take that empty cot, you are no spy.’ ” 


1855-59] 55 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


once gave a dinner to the American Consul, and invited 
“‘ Canichon,” the daughter of the house, and bought her a 
new hat for the occasion—a tremendous sensation through 
all the Quartier. 

M. Drouet does not think that Whistler worked much, 
certainly not in usual student fashion at the schools. “ He 
was every evening at the students’ balls, and as he never 
got up until eleven or twelve in the morning, where was the 
time for work?” M. Oulevey cannot remember his doing 
much at Gleyre’s or the Luxembourg, or the Louvre, but 
he was always drawing, in the manner of Gavarni, the people 
and the scenes of the Quartier his subjects, often des sujets 
presque enfantins. In the memory of both, his work is 
overshadowed by his gaiety and by his wit, his blague, his 
charm : “ tout d fait un homme 4 part,” is M. Oulevey’s phrase, 
with “‘ wn ceur de femme et une volonié @homme.” Anything 
might be expected of him, and M. Drouet adds that he was 
quick to resent an insult, always un petit rageur. George 
Boughton, of a younger generation, when he came to the 
Quartier, found that all stories of larks were put down to 
Whistler. Mr. Luke Ionides writes : 

“He was a great favourite among us all, and also among the 

grisettes we used to meet at the gardens where dancing went on. 
I remember one especially—they called her the tgresse. She 
seemed madly in love with Jimmie and would not allow any 
other woman to talk to him when she was present. She sat to 
him several times with her curly hair down her back. She 
had a good voice, and I often thought she had suggested Trilby 
to Du Maurier.” 

She was the model for Fumette, Eloise, a little modiste, 
who knew Musset by heart and would recite his verses to 
Whistler, and who one day in a rage tore up, not his etchings 
as Mr. Wedmore says, but the Gavarni-like drawings. 
Whistler was living then in the Rue St. Sulpice, and when 
he came home, to find the pieces piled high on his table, 
56 [1855-59 


IN THE LATIN QUARTER 


he wept over the ruin, literally wept, according to 
Oulevey. 

A figure as familiar in the memory of his friends is La 
Mere Gérard. He loved to talk about her himself. She 
was very old and almost blind, was said to write verse, had 
come down in the world, and sold violets and matches at 
the gate of the Luxembourg Gardens. She was very pic- 
turesque, as she sat huddled up on the steps, and he got her 
_ to pose for him many times. She insisted that she had a 
tapeworm, and if in the studio he asked her what she would 
eat or drink, her invariable answer was “ Du lait: il aime 
ca!” a story that recalls one told by Flaubert. They used 
to chaff him about her in the Quartier. Once, Lalouette 
invited all his clients to spend a day with him in the country, 
and Whistler accepted on condition that he could bring La 
Mere Gérard. She arrived, got up in great style, sat at his 
side in the carriage when they all drove off together, and grew 
livelier as the day went on. He painted her in the course 
of the afternoon, the portrait was a success, and he promised 
it to her, but first took it back to the studio to finish. Then 
he fell ill and was sent to England. When he returned and 
saw the portrait again, he thought it much too good for La 
Meére Gérard. He madeacopy for the old lady, who saw the 
difference and was furious. Not long after he was walking 
past the Luxembourg, arm in arm with Lamont. The old 
woman, huddled on the steps as usual, did not look up: 

“Eh bien, Madame Gérard, comment ca va?’ Lamont 
asked. 

** Assez bien, Monsieur, assez bien.°’ 

“* Ki votre Américain ?’’ To which she replied, not looking 
up, “Lui? On dit qwil a craqué! Encore une espéce de 
canaille de moins !”’ : 

And Whistler laughed, and then she knew him, as so many 
were to know him by that laugh all his life. 

1855-59] 37 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


For ages after, in the Quartier, he was called “‘ Espéce de 
canatlle.” And this is where Du Maurier got the story 
which he tells in Trilby. 

Another character in the Quartier, of whom Whistler never 
tired of telling us, was the Count de Montezuma, the delightful, 
inimitable, impossible Montezuma, not a student, not a 
painter, not anything so far as we could discover, but an 
adventurer after Whistler’s own heart. He never had a sou, 
but he always had cheek enough to see him through. Whistler 
told us of him: 


“This is the sort of thing he would do, and with an air— 
amazing! He started one day for Charenton on the steamboat, 
his pockets, as usual, empty, and he was there for as long as he 
could stay. The boat broke down, a sergent de ville came on 
board and ordered everybody off except the captain and his 
family, who happened to be with him. The Montezuma paid 
no attention. With arms crossed, he walked up and down, 
looking at no one. They waited, but he walked on, up and 
down, up and down, looking at no one. The sergent de ville 
repeated : ‘ Tout le monde a terre!’ The Montezuma gave no 
sign. ‘Ht vous?’ the sergent de ville asked at last. ‘Je suis 
de la famille!’ said the Montezuma. Opposite, staring at 
him, stood the captain with his wife and children. ‘ You see,’ 
said the sergent de ville, ‘ the captain does not know you, he says 
you are not of the family. You must go.’ ‘ Moi,’ and the 
Montezuma drew himself up proudly—‘ Moz / je suis lebdtard !’” 


Though frequently hard up, Whistler had an income 
which seemed princely to students who lived on nothing 
at all. If Whistler had money in his pockets, Mr. Ionides 
says, he spent it royally on others. If his pockets were 
empty, he managed to refill them in a way that still amazes 
M. Oulevey who, in proof of it, told us of the night when, 
alter the café where they had squandered their last sous on 
kirsch had closed, he and Lambert and Whistler adjourned 
to the Halles for supper, ordered the best and ate it. Then 


he and Lambert stayed in the restaurant as hostages, while 
[1855-59 
58 


LA MERE GERARD 


IN THE LATIN QUARTER 


Whistler, at dawn, went off to find the money to pay. He 
was back when they awoke, with three or four hundred 
francs in his pocket. He had been to see an American 
friend, he said, a painter: ‘‘ And do you know, he had the 
bad manners to abuse the situation—he insisted on my 
looking at his pictures ! ” 

There were times, however, when everybody failed, even 
Mr. Lucas, George Whistler’s friend, who was living in Paris 
and often came to his rescue. One summer day he pawned 
his coat when he was penniless and wanted an iced drink in 
a buvette just across the way from his rooms in Rue Bourbon- 
le-Chateau. ‘‘ What would you?” hesaid. “ Itis warm!” 
And for the next two or three days he went in shirt sleeves. 
From Mr. Ionides we have heard how Whistler and Ernest 
Delannoy carried their straw mattresses to the nearest Mont 
de Piété—stumbling up three flights of stairs under them 
to be refused any advance at all by the man at the window. 
“ C’est bien,’ said Ernest, with his grandest air—‘‘ Crest 
bien. J’enverrai un commissionnaire!”’ And they dropped 
the mattresses and walked out with dignity, to go supperless 
home. Then there was a bootmaker to whom Whistler 
owed money, and who appeared with his bill, refusing to 
move unless he was paid. Whistler was courtesy itself, and 
regretting his momentary embarrassment, begged the boot- 
maker to accept an engraving of Garibaldi which he ventured 
to admire. The bootmaker was so charmed that he spoke 
no more of his bill, but took another order on the spot, and 
made new shoes into the bargain. 

Many of the things now told of Whistler, he used to tell us 
of Ernest or some of the others: with such joy that not to 
repeat his stories would be to give but a poor picture of him 
as student. Ernest, he always said it was—though others 
say it was Whistler—who, having a commission to copy a 
picture in the Louvre, and not having any canvas or paints 
1855-59] 59 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


or brushes, or a sou to buy them with, went boldly to the 
gallery one morning. The first to arrive, he carried himself 
with a businesslike air that would have disarmed any gardien 
and picked out what he needed : an easel, a nice clean canvas, 
a palette, a brush or two, and a stick of charcoal, wrote his 
name in large letters on the back of the canvas, sketched 
in his copy with the charcoal, and when artists and students 
began to drop in, was too busy to see anything but his work. 
Presently there was an outcry. What ?—an easel missing, 
a canvas gone, brushes not to be found. The gardien bustled 
round. Everybody talked at once. Ernest looked up in a 
fury—shameful ! why should he be disturbed in this fashion ? 
What was it all about anyhow ? When he heard what had 
happened no one was louder in denunciation. It had come 
to a pretty pass in the Louvre when you couldn’t leave your 
belongings over night without having them stolen! Things 
at last quieted down, Ernest’s picture was sketched in, but 
his palette was bare. He stretched, jumped down from his 
high stool, strolled about, stopped to criticise here, to 
praise there, until he saw the colours he needed. The copy 
of the man who owned them ravished him. Astonishing ! 
He stepped back to see it better. He advanced to look at 
the original, he grew excited, he gesticulated. The man, 
who had never been noticed before, grew excited too. Ernest 
talked the faster, gesticulated the more wildly, until down 
came his thumb on just the white or the blue or the red he 
wanted, and with another sweep of his arm, a big lump of it 
was on his palette. Further on another supply offered itself. 
In the end, his palette well set, he was back at his easel, 
painting his copy. In some way he had supplied himself 
most plentifully with ‘“turps” so that several times the 
picture was in danger of running off the canvas. At last 
it was finished and displayed to his patron, who utterly 
refused to have it. Whistler, however, succeeded in selling 
60 [1855-59 


IN THE LATIN QUARTER 


it for Ernest to a dealer; and, “Do you know,” he said, 
‘““1 saw the picture years afterwards, and I think it was 
rather better than the original!” 

Oulevey’s version is that it was Whistler who helped himself 
to a box of colours, and, when discovered by its owner, was 
all innocence and surprise and apology: why, he supposed 
of course, the boxes of colour were there for the benefit of 
students. 

On another occasion when Ernest, according to Whistler, 
had finished a large copy of Veronese’s Marriage Feast at 
Cana, he and a friend, carrying it jauntily between them, 
started out to find a buyer. They crossed the Seine and 
offered it for five hundred franes to the big dealers on the 
right bank. Then they offered it for two hundred and fifty 
on the left. Then they went back and offered it for one 
hundred and twenty-five. Then they came across to the 
left and offered it for seventy-five. And back again for 
twenty-five and across once more for ten. And they were 
crossing still again, to try to get rid of it for five when, on 
the Pont des Arts, they lifted the huge canvas: “‘ Un,” they 
said with a great swing, “ deux, trois—v’lan!” and over it 
went into the water with a splash. There was a cry from 
the crowd, a rush to their side of the bridge, sergents de ville 
came running, omnibuses and cabs stopped on both banks, 
boats pushed out on the river—altogether it was an immense 
success, and they went home enchanted. 

Ernest was Whistler’s companion in the most wonderful 
adventure of all, the journey to Alsace, when several of the 
French Set of etchings were made. Mr. Luke Ionides thinks 
it was in 1856. Fantin, who did not meet Whistler until 
1858, remembered him, just back from a journey to the Rhine, 
coming to the Café Moliére, and showing the etchings he 
had made on the way. The French Set was published in 
November of that year, and as Whistler returned late in the 
1855-59] 61 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


autumn, the series could scarcely have appeared so soon. 
However, more important than the date is the fact that on 
his journey the Liverdun, the Street at Saverne and The Kitchen 
were etched. He had made a little money somehow, two 
hundred and fifty francs, or it was a present from an uncle, 
Sir Rennell Rodd suggests, and he and Ernest started out 
for Nancy and Strasburg. At Cologne they woke up one 
morning to find the money all gone. ‘* What is to be done ? ” 
asked Ernest. ‘‘ Order breakfast,’ said Whistler, which 
they did. There was no American Consul in the town, and 
after breakfast he wrote to everybody who could help him : 
to a fellow student, a Chilian he had asked to forward letters 
from Paris, to Seymour Haden in London, to Amsterdam 
where he thought letters might have been sent by mistake. 
Then they settled down to wait. Every day they would go 
to the post office for letters, every day the officials would 
say “‘ Nichits! Nichts!” until they got to be known in the 
town—Whistler, with his long hair, Ernest with his brown 
holland suit and straw hat now fearfully out of season. The 
boys of the town would be in wait and follow them to the 
post office where, hardly were they at the door, before the 
official was shaking his head and saying “ Nichis! Nichts!” 
and all the crowd would yell “ Nichis! Nichis!” At last, 
to escape the constant attention, they would spend the day 
sitting on the ramparts. It began to look desperate. Whistler 
was reduced to washing his own shirt, and, with a little iron 
he had bought on the way, to iron it at night in his room. 

At the end of ten days, Whistler took his knapsack, put 
his plates in it and carried it to the landlord, Herr Schmitz, 
whose daughter, “* Little Gretchen,” he had etched—probably 
the plate called Gretchen at Heidelberg. He said frankly 
that he was penniless, but here were his copper plates in a 
knapsack upon which he would set his seal. What was to 
_be done with copper plates? the landlord asked. They 
62 [1855-59 


IN THE LATIN QUARTER 


were to be kept with every care as the work of a distinguished 
artist, Whistler answered, and when he was back in Paris, 
he would send the money to pay his bill and then the landlord 
would send him the knapsack. Herr Schmitz hesitated, 
while Whistler and Ernest were in despair over the necessity 
of trusting such masterpieces to him. The bargain was 
struck after much talk. The landlord gave them a last break- 
fast. Lina, the maid, slipped her last groschen into Whistler’s 
_ hand, and the two set out to walk from Cologne, with paper 
and pencils for their baggage. 

Whistler used to say that, had they been less young, they 
could have seen only the discomfort of that long tramp. A 
portrait was the price of every plate of soup, every egg, 
every glass of milk they could get on the road. The children 
who hooted them had sometimes to be drawn before a glass 
of water, or a bit of bread, was given to them. They slept 
in straw. And they walked until Whistler’s light little 
Parisian shoes got rid of a portion of their soles and most of 
their upper leather, and Ernest’s hollands grew shabbier and 
shabbier. But they were young enough to laugh and, one 
day, Whistler, seeing Ernest tramping ahead solemnly through 
the mud, the rain dripping from his straw hat, his linen 
coat a rag, shrieked with laughter as he limped. ‘“‘ What 
would you?” Ernest said mournfully, “ les saisons m’ont 
toujours devancé!” Fortunately, it was the time of the 
autumn fairs, and, joining a lady who played the violin and 
a gentleman who played the harp, they gave entertainments 
in every village they passed, beating a big drum to attract 
the crowd, announcing themselves as distinguished artists 
from Paris, offering to draw portraits, three francs the half- 
length, five francs the full-length. At times they beat the 
big drum in vain and Whistler was reduced to charging five 
sous apiece for his portraits, but he did his best, he said, and 
there was not a drawing to be ashamed of. 

1855-59] 63 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


At last, they came to a town where there was an American 
Consul, who knew Major Whistler, and advanced fifty francs 
to his son. At Liége, poor, shivering, ragged Ernest got 
twenty from the French Consul, and the rest of the journey 
was made in comfort. On his return, Whistler’s first appear- 
ance at the Café Moliére was a triumph. They had thought 
him dead, and here he was, le petit Américain! And what 
blague, what calling for coffee pour le petit Whistler, pour 
notre petit Américain! And what songs! 

“Car il n’est pas mort, larifla! fla! fla! 
Non, cest quwil dort. 

Pour le réveiller, trinquons nos verres ! 

Pour le réveiller, trinquons encore !” 

That Herr Schmitz was paid and delivered up the plates, 
the prints are the proofs. Some years after, Whistler went 
back to Cologne, where he was travelling with his mother. 
In the evening, he slipped away to the old, little hotel, 
where the landlord and the landlord’s daughter, grown up, 
recognised him and rejoiced. 

These stories, and hundreds like them, still float about the 
Quartier, told, as we have heard them, not only by Whistler, 
but by les vieuw, who shake their heads over the present 
degeneracy of students and the tameness of student life— 
stories of the clay model of the heroic statue of Géricault, 
left, for want of money, swathed in rags, and sprinkled every 
morning until at last even the rags had to be sold, and then, 
when they were taken off, Géricault had sprouted with 
mushrooms that paid for a feast in the Quartier and enough 
clay to finish the statue; stories of a painter, in his empty 
studio, hiring a piano by the month, that the landlord might 
see it carried upstairs and get a new idea of his tenant’s 
assets ; stories of the monkey tied to a string, let loose in 
other people’s larders, then pulled back, clasping loaves of 
bread and bottles of wine to its bosom; stories of students, 
64 [1855-59 


IN THE LATIN QUARTER 


with bedclothes all pawned, sleeping in chests of drawers 
to keep warm ; stories of Courbet’s Baigneuse in wonderful 
Highland costume at the student’s balls; stories of practical 
jokes at the Louvre. It was the day of practical jokes, les 
charges; and Courbet, whom they worshipped, was the 
biggest blagueur of them all, eventually signing his death 
warrant with that last terrible charge, the fall of the Column 
of Vendéme,* which Paris never forgave. 

In this atmosphere, Whistler’s excitable spirit, so alarm- 
ing to his mother, found a new stimulus, and it is not to be 
wondered at, if his gaiety struck every one in Paris as in 
St. Petersburg and Pomfret, West Point and Washington. 


* During the Commune, when Courbet was Directeur des Beaux-Arts, the order 
was given for the destruction of the Column. It was well known that, in his 
republican fury, he had urged its removal, representing that Paris should be purged 
of all traces of the Empire. He was afterwards held responsible for the vandalism, 
and some went so far as to say that he had taken actual part in pulling down the 
Column. At all events he was condemned to six months’ imprisonment, and to 
paying the cost of putting it up again, and there is no doubt that all this trouble 
hastened his death in 1877. 


1855-59] I:E 65 


CHAPTER VII. WORKING DAYS IN THE 
LATIN QUARTER. THE YEARS EIGHTEEN 
FIFTY-FIVE TO EIGHTEEN FIFTY-NINE 
CONTINUED 


HE stories cannot be left out of Whistler’s life as a 
student, so living a part of it were theyin his memory. 

His fellow students brought back to England the impression 
that he was an idler; and it is hard to-day to make people 
believe that he was anything else in his youth. And yet he 
worked in Paris as prodigiously as he played. The con- 
victions, the preferences, the prejudices he kept to the end 
were formed during those early years. His lifelong admira- 
tion for Poe, who as a West Point man would in any case 
have commanded his regard, was no doubt strengthened by 
the hold Poe had taken on the imagination of French men 
of letters. His disdain of Nature, his contempt for anecdote 
in art as a concession to an ignorant public, his translation 
of painting into musical terms—this, and much else so often 
charged against him as deliberate eccentricity or pose, can 
be traced by the curious to Baudelaire. To us, it was 
incomprehensible how he found time to read as a student, 
and yet he knew the literature of that period thoroughly. 
With its artists, and their tendencies and revolts, he was 
more familiar. He identified himself with their leading 
movements; he mastered all that Gleyre could teach on 
the one hand and Courbet on the other; through his friends 
he came under the influence of Lecocq de Boisbaudran, who, 


more than any other teacher then, was occupied with the 
66: [1855-59 


IN THE LATIN QUARTER 


study of values and the effects of night. In a word, it seems 
impossible for any one to imagine that Whistler idled away 
his four full years in Paris. 

The younger men of the moment, in their rebellion against 
the academic, the official, in art, were not so foolish as to 
disdain Old Masters. They went to the Louvre to learn 
how to use their eyes and their hands, and to be independent 
enough to depend upon themselves. They copied the old 
pictures there, and there they met and got to know each 
other. To Whistler the Frenchmen were more sympathetic 
than the English in his serious, as in his lighter hours, and 
he joined them at the Louvre. Respect for the great tradi- 
tions of art always remained his standard: ‘‘ What is not 
worthy of the Louvre is not art,” he said again and again. 
Rembrandt and Velasquez were the masters by whom he 
was most influenced. There are only a few pictures by 
, Velasquez in the Louvre, and Whistler’s early appreciation 
of him has been a puzzle to some critics, who, to account 
for it, have credited him with a journey, when a student, 
to Madrid. But that journey was not made in the ’fifties, 
nor at any other period, though he planned it more than once. 
A great deal could be learned about Velasquez without going 
to Spain. Whistler knew the London galleries, and in 1857 
he visited the Art Treasures Exhibition at Manchester, taking 
a friend with him. Miss Emily Chapman has looked up her 
diaries for us, and writes that on September 11, 1857, 
Rose, her sister, “‘ went to Darwen and found Whistler 
and Henri Martin staying at Earnsdale”’ with another 
sister, Mrs. Potter—‘‘ a merry evening,” the note finishes. 
There were fourteen fine examples of Velasquez in the 
Exhibition, lent from private collections in England, among 
them the Venus, Admiral Pulido Pareja, Duke Olivarez 
on Horseback, Don Balthazar in the Tennis Court, several 
of which are now in the National Gallery, London. 

1855-59] 67 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Whistler once described himself to us as 


“a surprising youth, suddenly appearing in the midst of the 
French students from no one knew where, with my Mere Gérard 
and the Piano Picture [At the Piano] for introduction, and making 
friends with Fantin and Legros, who had already arrived, and 
Courbet, whom they were all raving about, and who was very 
kind to me.” 


The Piano Picture was painted toward the end of his 
student years, the Mére Gérard a little earlier, so that this 
description agrees with Fantin’s notes. In 1858, Fantin 
says, he was copying the Marriage Feast at Cana in the 
Louvre when he saw passing one day a strange creature— 
‘* Personnage étrange, le Whistler en chapeau bizarre,’ who, 
amiable and charming, stopped to talk, and this was the 
beginning of their friendship, strengthened that evening 
when they met again at the Café Moliére. Carolus Duran 
writes us, from the Académie de France in Rome, that 
he and Whistler met when they were students in Paris ; 
after that he lost sight of Whistler until the days of the new 
Salon, but, though there were a few meetings then, his 
memories are altogether of the student years. Bracquemond 
has recalled for us that he was making the preliminary 
drawing for his etching after Holbein’s Erasmus in the Louvre, 
when he first saw Whistler. Their meetings were cordial, 
but never led tointimacy. With Legros, Whistler’s friendship 
did become intimate, and the two, with Fantin, formed 
what Whistler called their little Society of Three. 

Fantin was somewhat older, had been studying much 
longer, and already had, among students, a reputation for 
wide and sound knowledge: “as a learned painter,” in Mr. 
Armstrong’s words. M. Bénédite thinks that the friendship 
between the two men had its interest for Fantin, to whom 
Whistler was useful at the start, but that it was of the 


greatest importance to Whistler, on whose art, in its develop- 
68 [1855-59 


EK PAYSANNE 


a 


TETE D 


IN THE LATIN QUARTER 


ment, it had a marked influence. Mr. Luke Ionides, on the 
other hand, insists that “‘ even in those early days, Whistler’s 
influence was very much felt. He had very decided views, 
which were always listened to with much respect and regard 
by many older artists who seemed to recognise his genius.” 
The truth probably is that Whistler and Fantin influenced 
each other, as fellow students will. They worked in sym- 
pathy, and the understanding between them was complete. 
They not only studied together at the Louvre, but both 
joined the group who went to Bonvin’s studio to work from 
the model under the direction of Courbet. 

With Courbet, we come to an influence which cannot be 
doubted, much as Whistler regretted it as time went on. 
M. Oulevey remembers Whistler going to call on Courbet 
once, and saying enthusiastically as he left the house: “ C’est 
un grand homme!” and certainly, for several years, his 
pictures showed how strong this influence was. M. Duret 
thinks this influence is revealed in another way, and sees 
in Courbet’s ‘‘ Manifestoes”’ forerunners of the letters 
Whistler wrote at a later date to the papers. Courbet, 
whatever mad pranks he might play with the bourgeots, 
was seriousness itself when there was any question of art, 
and the men who studied under him learned to be serious, 
Whistler no less than the rest of them. 

The best proof of Whistler’s industry is his work; his 
pictures and prints, which are truly amazing in quality 
and quantity for the student who, Sir Edward Poynter 
would have us believe, worked in two or three years only 
as many weeks. It would be nearer the truth to say that 
he never stopped working. Everything he enjoyed as 
student he turned to his profit as artist. The women he 
danced with at night were his models by day: Fumetie, 
who, as she crouches, her hair loose on her shoulders, in 
that early etching, looks the tigresse, capable of tearing up 
1855-59] 69 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


anything in a passion; and Fineite, the dancer in a famous 
quadrille, who, when she came to London, was announced 
as ‘‘ Madame Finette in the cancan, the national dance of 
’ France.” All his friends had to pose for him: Drouet, in 
that fine plate, done, he says, in two sittings, one of two 
and a half hours, the other of an hour and a half; Axenfeld, 
the brother of the famous physician ; Becquet, the sculptor- 
musician, dead a few months now, the greatest man who 
ever lived to his friends, to the world unknown ; Astruc, 
painter, sculptor, poet, editor of L’ Artiste, of whom his wife 
said that he was the first man since the Renaissance who 
combined all the arts, but who is onlyremembered in Whistler’s 
print; Delatre, the printer; Riault, the engraver. Bibi 
Valentin was the son of another engraver. And there is 
the amusing pencil sketch of Fantin, in bed on a bitter winter 
day, working away in his overcoat, muffler and top hat, 
trying to keep warm. The streets where Whistler wandered, 
the restaurants where he dined became his studio for the time. 
At the house near the Rue Dauphine he etched Bib: Lalouette ; 
his Soupe & Trois Sous * was done in a cabaret kept by Martin, 
whose portrait is in the print and who was famous in the 
Quartier for having won the Cross of the Legion of Honour 
by his bravery at an earlier age than any man ever decorated, 
and then promptly losing it by some shameful deed. And 
so we might go through Whistler’s etchings of this period. 
There is hardly one that is not a record of his daily life and 
of the people among whom he lived, though to make it such 
a record was the last thing he was thinking of. But he took 
his work with him everywhere, and not one of the young 
men of his generation who set out to find their subjects in 
the world they knew and the things about them, succeeded 
so consistently and so brilliantly. 


* Mr. Ralph Thomas says, “‘ While Whistler was etching this, at twelve o’clock 
at night, a gendarme came up to him and wanted to know what he was doing. 
Whistler gave him the plate upside down, but officialism could make nothing of it.”’ 
79 [1855-59. 


IN THE LATIN QUARTER 


Whistler’s first set of etchings was published in November 
1858, when he had been in Paris only a little more than 
three years. The prints were not the first he made after 
leaving Washington; a portrait of himself, another of his 
niece, Annie Haden, the Dutchman holding the Glass are as 
early, if not earlier; but they were the first published as a 
set—the French Set—a form of publication he repeated 
several times. There were twelve prints, some done in 
Paris, some during the journey to the Rhine, some in London." 


Liverdun Little Arthur 

La Rétameuse La Vieille aux Loques 

En Plein Soleil Annie 

The Unsafe Tenement La Marchande de Moutarde 
La Mere Gérard Fumette 

Street at Saverne The Kitchen 


There was also an etched title, with his portrait, for which 
Ernest, putting on the big hat, sat. Whistler dedicated the 
set to mon vieil ami Seymour Haden, and issued and sold it 
himself for two guineas. Deldtre printed the plates for him, 
and, standing at his side, M. Drouet says, Whistler learned the 
art. Deldtre’s shop was at 171 Rue St. Jacques, the room 
described by the De Goncourts, with the two windows 
looking out on a bare garden, the wheel, the man in grey 
blouse standing by it, the old noisy clock in the corner, and 
the sleeping dog, and the children peeping in at the door ; 
the room where they waited for their first proof with the 
emotion they thought no other occupation or amusement 
could give. Drouet says that Whistler himself never printed 
at this time. But Oulevey remembers a little press in the 
Rue Campagne-Premiére, and Whistler pulling the proofs 
for the occasional friend who came to buy them. He was 
then already hunting for beautiful old paper, loitering at the 
boxes along the quais, tearing out the fly-leaves from the fine 
old books he found there. Passages in many plates of the 
1855-59] qt 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


series, especially in La Mére Gérard and La Marchande de 
Moutarde, are precisely like his work in The Coast Survey, No. 1. 
For the only time, and as a result of his training at Washington, 
his handling threatened to become mannered. But in some 
of the prints, the Street at Saverne for instance, he had already 
overcome his mannerism, while in others not in the series 
but done during these years, like the Drouet, Soupe & Trois 
Sous, Bibi Lalouette, he had perfected his early style of 
drawing, biting and dry-point. We never asked him how 
the French plates were bitten, but, no doubt, it was in the 
traditional way by biting all over and stopping out. They 
were drawn directly from Nature, as can be seen in his 
portraits of places which are reversed in the prints. So far 
as we know, he scarcely ever made a preliminary sketch. 
We can recall none of his etchings at any pericd that might 
have been done from memory, except the Street at Saverne, 
the Venetian Nocturnes, and the Dance House, Amsterdam. 
He sometimes suggested points on the plate with Chinese 
white or water-colour, but this was all. 

His first paintings in Paris undertaken as definite com- 
missions were, he told us, copies he made in the Louvre. 
They were done for Captain Williams, a Stonington man, 
more familiarly known as “ Stonington Bill,” whose portrait 
Whistler said he had painted before leaving home. ‘‘ Stoning- 
ton Bill” must have liked it, for, when he came to Paris 
shortly afterwards, he gave Whistler the commission to 
paint as many copies at the Louvre as he chose, for twenty- 
five dollars apiece. Whistler said he copied a snow scene 
with a horse and a soldier standing by and another at its 
feet, and never afterwards could remember who was the 
painter; the busy picture detective may run it to ground 
for the edification of posterity. There was also a St. Luke 
with a halo and draperies; and a woman holding up a child 
towards a barred window beyond which, seen dimly, was the 
72 [1855-59 


(wayonog fig aanjoid » fo fidoD) 
100d HHL LY VNVIG 


PMs a 


IN THE LATIN QUARTER 


face of a man; and an inundation, no doubt The Deluge or 
The Wreck. He was sure he must have made something 
interesting out of them, he knew there were wonderful things 
even then—the beginnings of harmonies and of purple 
schemes—he supposed it must have been intuitive. An- 
other Stonington man commissioned him to paint Ingres’ 
Andromeda chained to the rock—probably this was the 
Angelina * of Ingres which he and Tissot are said to have 
copied side by side; and for all he knew, all these were still 
at Stonington and shown there as marvellous things by 
Whistler. To the list we had from him may be added the 
Diana by Boucher in the London Memorial Exhibition, 
owned by Mr. Louis Winans, and the group of cavaliers after 
Velasquez, the one copy Fantin remembered his doing. A study 
of a nun was sent to the London Exhibition, but not shown, 
with the name “ Wisler”’ on the back of the canvas, not by 
any means a bad study of drapery, which may have been, de- 
spite the name, another of his copies, or done in a sketch class. 
The first original picture painted in Paris was, he always 
assured us, the Mére Gérard, in white cap, holding a flower, 
that is now the property of Mr. Swinburne. There is another 
portrait of her in the possession, we believe, of Messrs. 
Colnaghi, and from M. Drouet we have heard of a third 
which, for the moment anyhow, has vanished. Whistler 
painted a number of other portraits, some it would probably 
be impossible’ to trace, and a few are well known. One, a 
difficult piece of work, he said, was of his father, after a 
lithograph sent him for the purpose by his brother George. 
_ A second was of himself in his big hat, the portrait owned by 
Mr. Avery and catalogued as Whistler with Hat in the Paris 
Memorial Exhibition. Two were studies of models : the Téte 
de Paysanne, a woman in a white cap, younger than Mére 
* We hear, however, that a copy of an Andromeda by him was shown at Mr. 


Keppel’s gallery in New York. 
1855-59] 73 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Gérard, but her face much sterner, that belongs to the Com- 
tesse de Béarn; and the Head of an Old Man Smoking, an 
old pedlar of crockery whom Whistler came across one day 
by chance in the Halles, brought to his studio and painted, 
a full face with large brown hat, for long the property of 
M. Drouet. But the best known and, in many ways, the 
finest painting of this period, is The Piano Picture, as Whistler 
calledit. It contains the portrait of his sister At the Piano, 
and of his niece, the “‘ wonderful little Annie ”’ of the etchings, 
now Mrs. Charles Thynne, who gave him many sittings for 
it, and to whom, in return, he gave the pencil sketches made 
on the Rhine journey, which she lent to the London Memorial 
Exhibition. The portraits “‘ smell of the Louvre.’’ The 
method is acquired from close knowledge of the Old Masters. 
*“ Rembrandtish” is the usual criticism passed on these 
early canvases, with their paint laid thickly on and their 
heavy shadows. Indeed, it is evident that the portrait of 
himself must have been done after long and careful study 
of Rembrandt’s Young Man in the Louvre. To his choice 
and treatment of subjects, in his pictures as in his etchings, 
he brought the uncompromising realism of Courbet, painting 
only the people he knew, as he saw them, and not in clothes 
borrowed from the classical and medizval wardrobes of the 
fashionable studio. Yet at this stage, there is already the 
personal touch: Whistler does not efface himself entirely 
in his youthful devotion to his chosen masters. You feel it in 
the way a simple head or a figure is placed on the canvas, but 
especially where there is an opportunity for more elaborate 
composition. ‘The arrangement of the lines of the pictures 
on the wall and the mouldings of the dado in Ait the Piano, 
the harmonious balance of the spaces of black and white in 
the dresses of the mother and her little girl, show the sense 
of design, of pattern, which he brought to perfection in the 
Mother, Carlyle and Miss Alexander. There was nothing 
74 [1855-59 


IN THE LATIN QUARTER 


like it in the painting of the other young men, of Degas, 
Fantin, Legros, Ribot, Manet ; nothing like it, for that matter, 
in the work of the older man, their leader, who painted 
L’Enterrement#a Ornans and Bonjour, Monsieur Courbet. 
M. Duret says that Whistler’s fellow students, who had 
immediately recognised his talent as etcher, now admitted 
as generously his accomplishment as painter, which agrees 
with Whistler’s statement to us. 

At the Piano was ready to be sent to the Salon of 1859. 
He submitted it, together with two etchings.* The etchings 
were accepted, the picture was rejected. It may have been 
because of what was personal in it ; a hint of strong personality 
in the young usually fares that way at official hands. Fantin’s 
story is: 

“One day, Whistler brought back from London the Piano 
Picture, representing his sister and niece. He was refused with 
Legros, Ribot and myself at the Salon. Bonvin, whom I knew, 
interested himself in our rejected pictures, and exhibited them 
in his studio, and invited his friends, of whom Courbet was one, 


to see them. I recall very well that Courbet was struck with 
Whistler’s picture.” 


Side by side with it hung Les Deux Seurs, one of the finest 
pictures ever painted by Fantin, who also was exhibiting 
in public for the first time ; some studies of still life by Ribot ; 
and Legros’ portrait of his father. The whole affair made 
a scandal. The injustice of the rejection was flagrant, the 
exhibitors at Bonvin’s became famous, and Whistler’s picture 
impressed many artists besides Courbet. With its exhibition 
Whistler’s real student years ended. In one sense, he was 
a student all his life—it was only in his last years that he 
felt he was “‘ beginning to understand,” he often said. But 
with the exhibition at Bonvin’s he ceased to be simply the 
student studying in the schools; he was the artist working 
in his own studio. Lf 


* We have been unable to find out their titles. 


1855-59] 75 


CHAPTER VIII. THE BEGINNINGS IN 
LONDON. THE YEARS EIGHTEEN FIFTY- 
NINE TO EIGHTEEN SIXTY-THREE 


A’ this period, Whistler was continually coming and 

going between Paris and London, where he stayed with 
his sister, Lady Haden, at 62 Sloane Street, sometimes 
bringing friends with him, Henri Martin, Legros or Fantin. 
In 1859 he first invited Fantin, promising him glory and 
fortune, in a letter which M. Bénédite thinks lyrical in its 
enthusiasm, and which was the beginning of an intimate 
correspondence between the two friends. Whistler’s letters, 
now at the Luxembourg, published in part by M. Bénédite 
in the Gazetie des Beaux Arts, are not only delightful but 
largely autobiographical. ‘‘ Whistler talked about me at 
this moment to his brother-in-law, Seymour Haden, who urged 
me to come to London; he had also talked about me to 
Boxall,” Fantin says in his notes. “I should like it 
known that it was Whistler who introduced me to 
England.” 

Fantin arrived in time for them to go together to the 
Academy, which still gave its exhibitions in the east end 
of the National Gallery. Whistler was exhibiting there 
for the first time. He had no pictures, but T'wo Etchings 
jrom Nature, a perplexing title for all his etchings were 
‘* from Nature,” were accepted and hung in the little octagon 
room, or ‘* dark cell,” as the critics called it, reserved for 
black-and-white. ‘Les souvenirs les plus vifs que 7 at 


66 2 


conservés de ce temps a& Londres,’”’ Fantin wrote, “ étaient notre 
76 [1859 


‘ ; sy 

aes, 

i ay 
phar SA) 

oy Navas 


Se 


ee 9 
eh tae ps 


- Haaieige Speers 


oh. 1 Aor epee BH etait | 
~ "cal com gen noer. aueneee ieee 
i canal imantatweecsmeni gpm 
iP aceath Ppa ae.’ bs prt veh 
Thre “eats a: wes 
; Boi ei aide dates 
canaries | 
nate ag hy veanitboate staged 


ee ise 


peep. ae: ee Apa sh ee eh 


ALE eve! ea 9 the mee, ' oenagi 
lai pismo Peat eae ab 


ve wrist eS ai Falkenw 
bt ee ‘ Le en sai s y, 


be 48 ‘a et 


ag 
aaet sf | 
lana apg fetes 


lea eh ing wt Si 


THE BEGINNINGS IN LONDON 


admiration pour Vexposition des tableaux de Millais a 
? Academy.” 

Millais was showing The Vale of Rest, abused, except “ by 
the Rossettis and their clique,” to a degree he thought “‘ never 
equalled in the annals of criticism.’’ He had not then quite 
abandoned Pre-Raphaelitism, and the two young men, fresh 
from Paris studios, recognised in his work the realism which, 
though conceived and expressed so differently, was the aim 
of the Pre-Raphaelites as of Courbet. 

Seymour Haden, who had already etched some of his finest 
plates, was kind and helpful to his young visitors. He 
bought copies from Fantin, among them one of the many 
Fantin made of Veronese’s Marriage Feast at Cana. He also 
purchased the pictures of Legros, who was “ at one moment 
in so deplorable a condition,’ Whistler said to us, “ that 
it needed God or a lesser person, to pull him out of it. And 
so I brought him over to London, and for a while he worked 
in my studio.” He had, before coming, sold a church 
interior to Haden, who liked it, though he found the floor 
out of perspective. One day he took it to the room upstairs 
where he did his own etchings, and turned the key. When 
it reappeared the floor was in perspective according to Haden. 
A new gorgeous frame was bought, and the picture was 
hung conspicuously in the drawing-room. Whistler thought 
Haden seemed restive when he heard that Legros was coming, 
but nothing was said. The first day Legros was impressed : 
he had been accustomed to seeing himself in cheap frames, 
if in any frame at all. But, gradually, he looked beyond 
the frame, and Haden’s work dawned upon him—that he 
could not stand. What was he to do? he asked Whistler. 
Run off with it, Whistler suggested. They got it down, 
called a four-wheeler and carried it away to the studio— 
“our own little kopje,”’ for Whistler told us the story in the 
days of the Boer War. Haden discovered his loss as soon 
1859] 77 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


as he got home and, in a rage, hurried after them to the 
studio. But when he saw it there on an easel, when, instead 
of attempting to hide it, Legros was openly restoring the 
perspective according to his idea, well, there was nothing to 
say. All the same, it must have been aggravating. 

Haden even endured Ernest, who had not yet caught up 
with the seasons, and who went about in terror of the butler, 
taking his daily walks in slippers rather than expose his boots 
to the servants, and enchanting Whistler by asking: ‘‘ Mais, 
mon cher, quest que ¢’ est que cette espéce de cataracte de Niagara?”’ 
when Haden turned on the shower-bath in the morning. 

Whistler fell in at once with the English students and their 
friends whom he had known in Paris: Poynter, Arm- 
strong, Luke and Aleco Ionides. Du Maurier came back 
from Antwerp in 1860, and for several months he and Whistler 
lived together in Newman Street. Mr. Armstrong remembers 
their studio, with a rope like a clothes-line stretched across, 
and, floating from it, a bit of brocade no bigger than a hand- 
kerchief, which was their curtain to shut off the corner used 
as bedroom. There was hardly ever a chair to sit on, and 
often with the brocade a towel hung from the line: their 
decoration and drapery. Du Maurier’s first Punch drawing 
—in a volume full of crinolines and Leech (vol. xxxix., 
October 6, 1860)—shows the two friends, shabby, smoking, 
calling at a photographer’s, to be met with an indignant 
““No smoking here, sirs!’’ followed by a severe ‘ Please 
to remember, gentlemen, that this is not a common Hartist’s 
Studio!” The figure at the door, with curly hair, top hat, 
glass in his eye, hands behind his back holding the forbidden 
cigarette, is unmistakably Whistler: a portrait even to 
those who did not know him in his youth. 

** Nearly always, on Sunday, he used to come to our house,”’ 
Mr. Ionides tells us, and there was no more delightful house 
in London. Mr. Alexander Ionides, the father, was a wealthy 
78 1860 


THE BEGINNINGS IN LONDON 


merchant with a talent for gathering about him all the 
interesting people in town or passing through, especially 
artists, musicians, actors and authors. Mr. Luke Ionides 
says that Whistler came also to their evenings and took part 
in their private theatricals, and there remains the record of 
one performance in a programme designed by Du Maurier, 
with a drawing of himself, Whistler and Aleco Ionides at the 
top, while Luke Ionides and his sister, Mrs. Coronio, stand 
below, with the scroll of the dramatis persone between them. 
He delighted in their masquerades and fancy dress balls, 
once mystifying everybody by appearing in two different 
costumes in the course of the evening, and winding up as a 
sweep. He himself never lost his joy in the memory of Alma- 
Tadema, on another of these occasions, as an “ Ancient 
Roman,” in toga and eye-glasses, crowned with flowers— 
‘* amazing,’ Whistler said, “‘ with his bare feet and St. John’s 


Wooden eye!” 
Mr. Arthur Severn writes us: 


** My first recollection of Whistler was at his brother-in-law’s, 
Seymour Haden (he and Du Maurier were looking over some 
Inber Studiorum engravings), and then at Arthur Lewis’ parties 
on Campden Hill, charming gatherings of talented men of all 
kinds, with plenty of listeners and sympathisers to applaud. It 
was at these parties the Moray Minstrels used to sing, conducted 
by John Foster, and when they were resting any one who could 
do anything was put up. Du Maurier with Harold Sower used 
to sing a duet, Les Deux Aveugles ; Grossmith half-killed us with 
laughter (it was at these parties he first came out). Stacy 
Marks, too, was always a great attraction, but towards the end 
of the evening, when we were all thoroughly in accord about 
everything, there used to be drowning yells and shouts for Whistler, 
the eccen ric Whistler! He used to be seized and stood up on 
a high stool, where he assumed the most irresistibly comic look, 
put his glass in his eye, and surveyed the multitude, who only 
screamed and yelled the more. When silence reigned he would 
begin to sing in the most curious way, suiting the action to the 
words with his small, thin, sensitive hands. His songs were in 

1860] 79 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


argot French, imitations of what he had heard in low cabarets on 
the Seine when he was at work there. What Whistler and 
Marks did was so entirely themselves and nobody else, so original 
or quaint, that they were certainly the favourites.” 


** Breezy, buoyant and debonnair, sunny and affectionate,”’ 
he seemed to George Boughton, who could not remember 
the time when “ Whistler’s sayings and doings did not fill 
the artistic air,’ nor when he failed to give a personal touch, 
a “‘ something distinct ’’ to his appearance. His “‘ cool suit 
of linen duck and his jaunty straw hat ”’ were then conspicuous 
in London, where any eccentricity of dress is more startling 
than in Paris. In the Latin Quarter, Whistler had been able 
to develop a peculiarity, or individuality, already noticeable 
before he left America. Boughton refers to a flying trip to 
Paris at this period, when he was “ flush of money and lovely 
in attire.” Other old friends recall meeting him, armed with 
two umbrellas, a white and a black, his practical, if sensational, 
preparation for all weathers. Val Prinsep speaks of the 
pink silk handkerchief stuck in his waistcoat, but this must 
have been later. “‘ A brisk little man, conspicuous from his 
swarthy complexion, his gleaming eye-glass, and his shock 
of curly black hair, amid which shone his celebrated white 
lock”? is Val Prinsep’s further description of him in the 
fifties. But the white lock is not seen in any contemporary 
painting or etching. It was first introduced, as far as we can 
discover, in his portrait owned by Mr. McCullough and in 
the etching, Whistler with the White Lock, 1879, though there 
may be some earlier drawings showing it. We never asked 
him about it, and his family, friends and contemporaries, 
whom we have asked, cannot explain it. Some say that it 
was a birth-mark, others that he dyed all his hair save the 
one lock. Many, seeing him for the first time, mistook it 
for a floating feather. He used to call it the Méche de Silas, 
and one explanation it amused him to give was that the 
80 [1860 


THE BEGINNINGS IN LONDON 


Devil caught those whom he would preserve by a lock of hair 
which turned it white. Whatever its origin, Whistler always 
cherished it with the greatest care. 

Whistler had stumbled upon a period in England when, 
though painters prospered, art was at a low ebb. Pre- 
Raphaelitism was on the wane. Millais’ election to the 
Royal Academy had dissolved the Round Table, as Rossetti 
said. Rossetti had dissociated himself from any phase or 
movement. Holman Hunt was being approached to write 
a history of Pre-Raphaelitism, as of something quite past. 
No younger group of independents had come to take their 
place. Of course here and there were interesting young men, 
each working in his own fashion: Charles Keene, Boyd 
Houghton, Albert Moore, and, a little later, Fred Walker 
and George Mason. But with the exception of Charles 
Keene, whom he always liked, and Albert Moore, whom he 
was soon suggesting to Fantin as Legros’ successor in the 
Society of Three, Whistler saw little of them. He certainly 
said little about them. Academicians were then at the high 
tide of mid-Victorian success and sentiment. They puzzled 
Whistler no less than he puzzled them. 


“Well, you know, it was this way. When I came to London 

I was received graciously by the painters. Then there was 
coldness, and I could not understand. Artists locked them- 
selves up in their studios—opened the doors only on the chain ; if 
they met each other in the street they barely spoke. Models went 
round silent, with an air of mystery. When I asked one where 
she had been posing, she said, ‘ To Frith and Watts and Tadema.’ 
‘Golly ! what a crew!’ Isaid. ‘ And that’s just what they says 
when I told ’em I was a’posing to you!’ Then I found out the 
mystery : it was the moment of painting the Royal Academy pic- 
ture. Each man was afraid his subject might be stolen. It was 
the great era of the subject. And, at last, on Varnishing Day, 
there was the subject in all its glory—wonderful! The British 
subject! Like a flash the inspiration came—the Inventor !—and 
in the Academy there you saw him: the familiar model—the 
1860] I:F 81 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


soldier or the Italian—and there he sat, hands on knees, head 
bent, brows knit, eyes staring ; in a corner, angels and cogwheels 
and things ; close to him his wife, cold, ragged, the baby in her 
arms—he had failed! The story was told—it was clear as day— 
amazing !—the British subject ! ” 


Into this riot of subject in the Academy of 1860, Az the 
Piano was sent, with five prints: Monsieur Astruc, Rédacteur 
du Journal l’ Artiste, an unidentified portrait, and three of 
the Thames set. Whistler had given At the Piano, the 
portrait of his sister and niece, to Seymour Haden: in a way, 
he said, 


“Well, you know, it was hanging there, but I had no particular 
satisfaction in that. Haden just then was playing the authority 
on art, and he could never look at it without pointing out its 
faults and telling me it never would get into the Academy— 
that was certain.” 


However, at the Academy it was accepted, Whistler’s first 
picture in an English exhibition. The Salon was not held 
then every year, and he could not hope to repeat his success 
in Paris. But in London, 4t the Piano was as much talked 
about as at Bonvin’s. It was bought by John Phillip, the 
Academician (no relation whatever to the family into which 
Whistler afterwards married). Phillip had just returned 
from Spain, with, 


“Well, you know—Spanish notions about things, and he 
asked who had painted the picture, and they told him, a youth 
no one knew about, who had appeared from no one knew where. 
Phillip looked up my address in the catalogue, and wrote to me 
at once to say he would like to buy it, and what was its price? I 
answered in a letter which I am sure, even then, must have been 
very beautiful. I said that, in my youth and inexperience, I did 
not know about these things, and I would leave to him the question 
of price. Phillip sent me thirty pounds; when the picture was 
last sold, to Mr. Davis, it brought two thousand eight hundred ! ” 


Thackeray, Mrs. Richmond Ritchie tells us, ‘“‘ went to see 
the picture of Annie Haden standing by the piano, and 
82 [1860 


THE BEGINNINGS IN LONDON 


admired it, beyond words, and stood looking at it with real 
delight and appreciation.”’ It was the “ only thing ” George 
Boughton ‘“ brought vividly away in his memories ” of the 
Academy. The critics could not ignore it. “It at once made 
an impression,’”’ Mr. W. M. Rossetti wrote. As “‘ an eccentric 
uncouth, smudgy, phantom-like picture of a lady at a piano- 
forte, with a ghostly looking child in a white frock looking 
on,” it struck the Daily Telegraph. But the Atheneum, 
having discovered the ‘“‘ admirable etchings ”’ in the octagon 
room, managed to see in the 


“* Piano Picture, despite a recklessly bold manner and sketchi- 
ness of the wildest and roughest kind, a genuine feeling for colour 
and a splendid power of composition and design, which evince 
a just appreciation of nature very rare among artists. If the 
observer will look for a little while at this singular production, he 
will perceive that it ‘ opens out’ just as a stereoscopic view will 
—an excellent quality due to the artist’s feeling for atmosphere 
and judicious gradation of light.” 


We quote these criticisms because the general idea is that 
Whistler waited long for notice. He was always noticed, 
both praised and blamed, never ignored, after 1859. 

Whistler went back to Paris late in that year. December 
1859 is the date of his Isle de la Cité, etched from the Galerie 
d’Apollon in the Louvre, with Notre Dame in the distance, 
and the Seine and its bridges between. It was his only 
attempt to rival Méryon, and he succeeded very badly. The 
fact that he gave it up when half done shows that he thought 
so himself. Besides, he was much less in Paris now, for 
though he always preferred life there, he had found his subjects 
in London, and that was why his visits gradually lengthened, 
why he could never stay away for long, why he soon made 
London his home, as it continued to be, except for a few 
intervals, until his death. It was not the people he cared 
for, nor the customs. He was drawn by the beauty of the 
1860] 83 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


place that not even Constable or Turner had felt with the 
same intensity and understanding. 

He was already at work on the river. In these first years 
he dated his prints and pictures, as he seldom did later, and 
1859 is bitten on one after another of the Thames plates. 
He saw the river as no one had seen it before, in all its grime 
and glitter, with its forest of shipping, its endless procession 
of barges, its grim warehouses, its huge docks, its little 
waterside inns. And, as he saw it, so he rendered it, as no 
one ever had before—as it is. It was left to the American 
youth to do for London what Rembrandt had done for 
Amsterdam. There were eleven plates on the Thames 
during this year alone. To make them, he wandered from 
Greenwich to Westminster; they included etchings like 
Black Lion Whar}, Tyzac, Whiteley and Co., which he never 
excelled at any period ; and in each the warehouses or bridges, 
the docks or ships, or whatever incidents of river life appealed 
to him by the way, are worked out with a mass and marvel 
of detail. The Pre-Raphaelites, in their first ardour, had 
never been more faithful to Nature and more minute in their 
study of her. The series was a wonderful achievement for 
the young man of twenty-five, never known to work by his 
English fellow students, a wonderful achievement for an 
artist of any age. 

Those who thought he idled in Paris were as sure of his 
application in London. “On the Thames, he worked 
tremendously,’ Mr. Armstrong says, “not caring then to 
have people about or to let any one see too much of his 
methods.” He stayed for months at Wapping, to be near 
his subjects, though not cutting himself off entirely from 
his friends. Sir Edward Poynter, Mr. Ionides, M. Legros, 
Du Maurier visited him. Mr. Ionides recalls long drives, 
down by the Tower and the London Docks to get to the place, 


as out of the way now as then. He says Whistler lived in 
84 [1860 


a wet may FF, 
ai = a AS ZA 
ar 


—= 


ee ear Mr John Cova 


Riseetta: (hui daavgiter) M™ Coronce 

Temry Ominous (his wep heas).A Tire Waster 

oe “ Mi Lucos Jon ides 
Cont sashes 

: MAlccolonsdes 


N’K du Mo unter, 
2 Bee 


SB Stamey pom Lyon eminent unbanen 
\ 


DESIGN FOR PROGRAMME BY DU MAURIER 


THE BEGINNINGS IN LONDON 


a little inn, rather rough, frequented by skippers and bargees, 
close to Wapping steamboat pier. But there is no doubt 
that much of his work was done from Cherry Gardens, on the 
other side of the river. Unfortunately it was not until after 
his death that we looked into this matter. At any rate, if 
he lived at Wapping, he worked a great deal at Cherry Gardens, 
also often from boats and barges, he told us, and this one 
can see in the prints. Sometimes he would get stranded in 
the mud, and at others cut off by the tide. ‘‘ When his 
friends came,’ Mr. Armstong writes us, “ they dined at an 
ordinary there used to be. People who had business at the 
wharves in the neighbourhood dined there, and Jimmie’s 
descriptions of the company were always humorous.” Mr. 
Ionides drove down once for a dinner-party Whistler gave at 
his inn: 

“The landlord and several bargee guests were invited. Du 
Maurier was there also, and after dinner we had songs and 
sentiments. Jimmie proposed the landlord’s health—he felt 
flattered, but we were in fits of laughter. The landlord was 
very jealous of his wife, who was rather inclined to flirt with 
Jimmie, and the whole speech was chaff of a soothing kind 
that he never suspected.” 

Another and more frequent visitor to Wapping was 
Sergeant Thomas, one of those patrons who recognise the 
young artist and appear when this recognition is most needed. 
He bought drawings and prints from Holman Hunt and 
Legros when they were scarcely known, and he helped Millais 
through difficult days. Whistler had issued his French Set 
of etchings in London in 1859: Twelve Etchings from Nature 
by James Abbott Whistler, London. Published by J. A. 
Whistler. At No. 62 Sloane Street, which was Haden’s 
house. The price, as in Paris, was for Artist’s Proofs on 
India, two guineas. Sergeant Thomas saw the prints and 
their merit, got to know Whistler, and arranged for the 
further publication of the French Set, and the Thames 
1860] 85 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


etchings, at first issued separately from the shop at No. 39 
Old Bond Street, where he had established his son, Edmund 
Thomas, as art dealer. 

Mr. Perey Thomas, a younger son, has told us that, as a 
little fellow, he used to go with his father by boat to Wapping, 
and that his father and brother posed for two of the figures 
—the third is Whistler—in The Litile Pool. He has also 
told us that much of the printing was done at 39 Old Bond 
Street, where the family lived in the upper part of the house. 
A press was in one of the small rooms, and Whistler would 
come in the evening, when he happened to be in town, to 
bite and try his plates. Sometimes he would not get to work 
until half-past ten or eleven. In those days, he always put 
his plate in a deep bath of acid, still keeping to the technical 
methods of the Coast Survey.* Sergeant Thomas, in his 
son’s words, was “ great for port wine,” and he would fill 
a glass for Whistler, and Whistler would put the glass by the 
bath, and then work a little on the plate and then stop to 
sip the port, and he would say: ‘“ Excellent! very good 
indeed !”’ and they never knew whether he meant the wine 
or the work. And always, the charm of his manner and his 
courtesy made it delightful to do anything for him. Sergeant 
Thomas brought Delatre over from Paris. He was the only 
man, according to Thomas, who could print Whistler’s 
etchings as the artist would have printed them himself. 
‘** Nobody,” the son wrote in his catalogue, “ has ever printed 
Mr. Whistler’s etchings with success except himself and 
M. Delatre,”’ and to-day many people are of the same opinion. 
Whistler’s relations with Sergeant and Edmund Thomas 
were pleasant while they lasted. But they did not last long. 
The son cared less for art than the law, and in his shop he 


* We have since learned that the Coast Survey plates were banked up with wax 
and the acid poured over them. This is supposed to have been the method of 
Rembrandt. 


86 [1860 


THE BEGINNINGS IN LONDON 


would sit at his desk reading his law books, never looking 
up nor leaving them, unless some one asked the price of a 
print or drawing. A successful business is not run on those 
lines, and in the course of a few years he gave up art altogether 
for the law, to his own great advantage. 


CHAPTER IX. THE BEGINNINGS IN 
LONDON. THE YEARS EIGHTEEN 
FIFTY-NINE TO EIGHTEEN SIXTY- 
THREE CONTINUED 


HISTLER, in 1860, devoted much time to painting on 

the river and less to etching, though the fine Rother- 

hithe belongs to this year. One picture he described in a 
letter to Fantin. ‘“ Chut! men parle pas ad Courbet”’ was 
his warning, as if he was afraid to trust so good a subject 
to any one. It was to be a masterpiece, he had painted it 
already three times, and he sent a sketch, which M. Duret 
has reproduced in his Whistler. M. Duret, unable to trace 
the picture, thought he might perhaps never have carried it 
beyond the sketch. But it was finished: the Wapping 
shown in the Academy of 1864, a proof of how long, even then, 
Whistler often kept his pictures before exhibiting them. 
In 1867, he sent it to the Paris Exhibition. It was bought 
by Mr. Thomas Winans, taken to Baltimore, where it is 
now the property of his daughter, Mrs. Hutton. Whistler 
wanted to exhibit it at Goupil’s in 1892, but could not get 
it overin time. Never seen in England, nor on the Continent, 
since 1867, it has been practically forgotten. It was painted 
from an inn, The Angel, on the water-side at Cherry Gardens, 
which exists to-day, one of a row of old houses with over- 
hanging balconies. In the foreground, in a shadowy corner 
of the inn balcony, is a sailor, for whom a workman from 
Greaves’ shipbuilding yard, Chelsea, sat; next to him, 
M. Legros, and, her back turned to the Thames, the girl with 
88 [1860 


ONIdd VM 


THE BEGINNINGS IN LONDON 


copper-coloured hair, of whose strange beauty Whistler 
wrote to Fantin, “ Joe,’ the model afterwards for The 
White Girl and The Little White Girl. Beyond, on the river, 
are the little square-rigged ships that so often anchor there, 
and on the opposite side is the long line of Wapping ware- 
houses, which gave the name to the picture. One who saw 
it then writes that artists feared “‘ Joe’s ” slightly open shirt 
would prevent the picture being hung in the Royal Academy. 
But Whistler insisted that, if it was rejected on that account, 
he would open the shirt more and more every year until he 
was elected and hung it himself. 

He also painted The Thames in Ice this year (1860), ap- 
parently, from the same inn at Cherry Gardens. It was 
called, when first exhibited, The Twenty-fifth of December, 
1860, on the Thames. For an Idle Apprentice, it was a curious 
way of spending Christmas Day. Whistler told us that Haden 
bought it for ten pounds, ample pay, he thought: three 
pounds for each of the three days Whistler spent in painting 
it, and a pound over. To Whistler, the pay seemed anything 
but ample. ‘‘ You know,” he said to us, “‘ my sister was in 
the house, and women have their ideas about things, and 
I did what she wanted, to please her!’ The picture is now 
in Mr. Freer’s collection. 

Two other pictures of 1860 are the portrait of Mr. Luke 
Tonides with long, brown beard, and The Music Room. In 
both, the influence of the Louvre and Courbet is evident. 
The portrait has the heavy painting of Aé the Piano, though 
it is much more brilliant. But the other picture marks a 
tremendous advance. 

Fantin could not have been more conscientious in rendering 
the life about him exactly as he found it than Whistler was 
in The Music Room; only, the room in the London house, 
with its gay chintz curtains and draperies, has none of the 


sombre simplicity of the interior where Fantin’s sisters sit 
1860] 89 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


with their embroidery and books. Fantin’s home gave him 
an austerity he knew how to make beautiful; to Whistler, 
the Hadens’ house gave colour—Harmony in Green and 
Rose was his later title for the picture—and clear, cool light. 
He emphasised the gaiety by introducing a strong black 
note in the riding-habit of the standing figure, Miss Boot, 
a connection of the Hadens by marriage, repeating it in the 
reflection of Lady Haden in the mirror, while the cool light 
from the window falls on “ wonderful little Annie,’ in the 
same white frock she wears in The Piano Picture. Mrs. 
Thynne (Annie Haden) writes us: 

““T was very young at the time of the music-room pictures 
being painted, and beyond the fact of not minding sitting, in 
spite of the interminable length of time, I do not know that I 
can say more. It was a distinctly amusing time for me. He 
was always so delightful and enjoyed the ‘no lessons’ as much 
as I did. One day in The Morning Call [the first name of The 
Music Room] * picture, I did get tired without knowing it, and 
suddenly dissolved into tears, whereupon he was full of the most 
tender remorse, and rushed out and bought me a lovely Russia 
leather writing set, which I am using at this very moment! The 
actual music-room still exists in Sloane Street, though the present 
owners have enlarged it, and the date of the picture must have 
been in ’60 or ’61, after his return from Paris. It was then he 
gave me the pencil sketches I lent to the London Memorial 
Exhibition. I had kept them in an album he had also brought 
me from Paris, with my name in gold, stamped outside, of which 
I was very proud. We were always good friends, and I have 
nothing all through those early days but the most delightful 
remembrance of him.” 

The picture became the property of Whistler’s niece, Mrs. 
Réveillon, George Whistler’s daughter, and was carried off 
to St. Petersburg, never to return to London until Whistler’s 
exhibition at the Goupil Gallery in 1892. It is now owned 


by Colonel Hecker of Detroit. /Gift frm Col. Wed ty C. 


* It will be noted that this picture, within a very few years, was described 
under three titles. The confusion now existing in titles made or accepted by 
Whistler was the result of his own vagueness. 


go [1861 


SIC ROOM 


THE MU 


reen and Rose) 


y in G 


(Harmon, 


tance ce ; 
‘sonnet ‘ee sn 
wood ate he 


THE BEGINNINGS IN LONDON 


Lately it has become the fashion to say that Whistler had 
not mastered his trade, and could not manage his materials 
in oils. These early pictures are technically as accomplished 
as the work of any of his contemporaries, and statements 
that he knew just enough for his own needs are altogether 
beside the mark. Whistler never was taught, few artists are, 
the chemistry of his trade, and some of his paintings have 
suffered in consequence. The Music Room and The Thames 
in Ice, so far as we can remember, are wonderfully fresh 
and not cracked at all. They were probably painted more 
directly, certainly more thinly, than the Wapping, in which 
the paint seems to be as thickly piled as in the Piano Picture, 
which is also cracked. This no doubt came from his working 
over them repeatedly, probably on bad grounds. He had 
the painting of Wapping by him four years before he exhibited 
it. Though started down the river in 1860, it contains a 
portrait of one of Greaves’ men, whom he did not see for 
a year or two afterwards. Of two pictures painted at the 
same period, one, like the Wapping, may be badly cracked, 
and another, like the Thames in Ice, may be in _ perfect 
condition, which is probably due to his want of know- 
ledge of the chemical properties of his paints and mediums. 
Later in life, Whistler gave great attention to this matter. 

Mrs. Thynne stood for another portrait in 1860, the 
beautiful dry-point Annie Haden, in big crinoline and soup- 
plate hat, and this was the year when Whistler made the 
portraits of his friend Axenfeld, the wood-engraver Riault, 
and “Mr. Mann.” The next year, 1861, there were more 
plates on the river, now on the Upper as well as the Lower 
Thames. All this work was making him known to English 
etchers and printers. For two of the plates of 1861, the 
Junior Etching Club found a place when, a year later, they 
published Passages from Modern English Poets, with their 
etchings as illustrations ; and Whistler, occasionally trying 
1861] of 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


his plates at the press of Day and Son, came into contact 
with the man, then a lad, he afterwards called “ the best 
printer in England,” Mr. Frederick Goulding, who sends us 
the following recollections of the time : 


“What can I say about Whistler printing? I mind me I 
first knew him about 1859, when he used to come to the printing 
house where I was apprenticed (the old firm of Day and Son— 
in Gate Street, Lincoln’s Inn Fields) and print himself at my 
father’s press. I used some imes to act as his ‘ devil’ grinding 
the ink, and turning the press, and so on. 

“I think the first plate I actually ‘ proved’ for him was in 
1861—The Punt—he used to come frequently in the eighteen- 
seventies, and I then printed a good many plates for him. 

“* After that he had a printing and etching room at the top of 
his house in Cheyne Walk, where I used to go and print with 
him, and afterwards at the White House at Tite Street, where 
we spent many a pleasant hour printing, and many a bit of fun 
we had in experimenting and printing in different ways. 

“* After that he practically took to printing his plates himself, 
and put into the printing his own individuality as much as in 
all the other work he did. No two proofs were ever alike—nor 
do I expect he intended them to be—but they were all Whistler. 

** Of course, at different periods of his life, he varied the way 
of printing, as he did his etching. Sometimes it was very ‘ fat’ 
printing—at other times he would depend absolutely on his 
etched lines. This more especially during the latter part of his 
life—but wherever, or whatever, he printed, it was aiways 
individual, and always Whistler.” 


Whistler once told us that he worked about three weeks 
on each of the Thames plates. He therefore must have 
spent on dated plates alone thirty-six weeks in 1861, leaving 
but fourteen weeks for other work and for play. Some of 
them are much less elaborate than the Drouet which, 
M. Drouet says, was done in five hours, so that it seems 
difficult to reconcile the two statements. But then it was 
about the Black Lion Wharf}, one of the fullest of detail, that 


we especially asked Whistler. We had many discussions 
92 [1861 


THE BEGINNINGS IN LONDON 


with him about them. Whistler always maintained that they 
were very youthful performances, and J. as strongly 
maintained that that had nothing to do with the matter ; 
that he never surpassed the wonderful drawing and com- 
position and biting. He always insisted that his later 
work in Venice and in Holland was a great development, a 
great advance, and his final answer always was: “ Well, you 
like them more than I do!” But there is no doubt that 
the Thames plates, notably the Black Lion Wharf, have, for 
artistic rendering of inartistic subjects, and for perfect biting, 
never been approached by anybody. 

Whistler saw something of the Upper Thames when he 
stayed with Mr. and Mrs. Edwin Edwards, whose house at 
Sunbury, was always a pleasant one to visit. There he was 
sure to meet friends, two of whom figure in his dry-point 
Encamping: W. M. Ridley, the artist and Traer, Haden’s 
assistant, not “‘ Freer,’’ as he has long masqueraded in Mr. 
Wedmore’s pages. Whistler introduced Fantin to Mr. and 
Mrs. Edwards. To the “‘jolies journées chez Edwards a 
Sunbury ” Fantin refers in a note for 1861. Mrs. Edwards 
wrote us shortly before her death : 


‘“ Whistler often came to see me, turning up always when 
least expected, perhaps driving down in a hansom cab from 
London. At that time there was no railway at Sunbury ; 
Hampton Court three miles distant. He might send a line to 
be met by boat at Hampton Court. He was always very eccentric.” 


Doubtless the driving down was an eccentricity. But 
Whistler knew he might see some “ foolish sunset,” or a 
Nocturne, on the way, and so the drive was worth it to him. 
‘We had a large boat with waterproof cover,”’ Mrs. Edwards 
added; ‘‘my husband and friends several times went up 
the river and slept in the boat. Whistler went once,’’ when 
he probably did the plate Encamping, and certainly, in 
Mrs. Edwards’ words, ‘“‘ got rheumatism.” It had been his 
1861] 93 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


trouble ever since the St. Petersburg days. He could not 
risk exposure. 

Whistler, though not yet settled in London, sent work 
regularly to the Academy, where it was an unfailing cause of 
difference among the critics. He showed his Mére Gérard 
(Mr. Swinburne’s picture) in 1861. It is curious to read 
some of the criticisms. The Atheneum described the picture 
as “a fine, powerful-toned and eminently characteristic 
study.” The Daily Telegraph thought it 

“far fitter hung over the stove in the studio than exhibited at 

the Royal Academy, though it is replete with evidence of genius 

and study. If Mr. Whistler would leave off using mud and clay 
on his palette and paint cleanly, like a gentleman, we should be 
happy to bestow any amount of praise on him, for he has all the 
elements of a great artist in his composition. But we must 
protest against his soiled and miry ways.” 
It seemed a good, serious study of an old woman, and nothing 
more, when we saw it in the London Memorial Exhibition, 
and the appallingly low level of the Academy alone can 
explain the attention it attracted. 

Whistler was back in France in the summer of 1861, painting 
The Coast of Brittany, a picture that might have been signed 
by Courbet, an arrangement in brown under a cloudy sky, a 
stretch of sand in the foreground, black and brown rocks 
where a peasant girl sleeps, and a blue sea beyond. It was 
‘a, beautiful thing,” Whistler said once when writing of it 
years afterwards. At Perros Guirec he made his splendid 
dry-point, The Forge. Another print of this year is the 
rare dry-point of “ Joe,” who, for a while, reappeared in 
Whistler’s work as often as Saskia in Rembrandt’s. She 
was Irish, a Roman Catholic. Her father has been described 
to us as a sort of Captain Costigan, and ‘“ Joe ”—Joanna, 
Mrs. Abbott—as a woman of next to no education, but of 
keen intelligence who, before she had ceased to sit to Whistler, 
knew more about painting than many painters, had become 
94 [1861 


THE COAST OF BRITTANY 


THE BLUE WAVE 


tee 


me a is 


frets oe P| 
. Paptiars irs 
a aie ai dh bas 


sah 1B Ais ca | 


hagere et 33 wile) : poeta RE et} Sty: oes: I 5s oy 


Wigs 
Hi el ali oe any nih rit nes yeh i 


Sesethaisey shy. RU cPidinch wl 
| Rape ites ee ee 5 


oP, ied: 


x niet ig 
: srees 


a 4S 


Ut ee 
Monty 4 =, 


Ly! 
Sees 


THE BEGINNINGS IN LONDON 


well read, and had great charm of manner. Her value to 
Whistler as a model was enormous, and she was an important 
element in his life during the first London years. She was 
with him in France in 1861-2, going to Paris in the winter 
to give him sittings for the big White Girl, which he had begun 
and was painting in a studio he took for the purpose in the 
Boulevard des Batignolles, and hung, it is said, all in white. 
Courbet met her, and, looking at the copper-coloured hair, 
was forced to see beauty in the beautiful. He painted her 
twice, though perhaps not that winter; once as La Belle 
Irlandaise, and once as Jo, femme d’Irlande. Whistler’s 
small study of Joe, Note Blanche, lent by Mrs. Sickert to the 
Paris Memorial Exhibition, was doubtless done in the Boule- 
vard des Batignolles in 1861, for the technique is not only 
like Courbet’s, but somewhat resembles that of the Pzano 
Picture. M. Drouet remembers breakfasts in the studio, 
Whistler cooking. 

’ He fell ill before the end of the winter. Miss Chapman 
says he was poisoned by the white lead he used in the picture. 
Her brother, a doctor, recommended a journey to the Pyrenees, 
where some of his family were spending the winter. At 
Guéthary, Whistler was almost drowned when bathing, 
carried out by the undertow, as he wrote to Fantin. It was 
sunset, the sea was very rough, he was 


“caught in the huge waves, swallowing gallons of salt water. 
I swam and I swam, and the more I swam the less near I came to 
the shore. Ah! my dear Fantin, to feel my efforts useless and 
to know people were looking on saying, ‘ But the Monsieur amuses 
himself, he must be strong!’ I cry, I scream in despair—I 
disappear three, four times. At last they understand. A brave 
railroad man rushes to me, and is rolled over twice on the sands. 
My model hears the call, arrives at a gallop, jumps in the sea like 
a Newfoundland, manages to catch me by the foot, and the two 
_ pull me out.” * 


* See Duret’s Whistler. 
1862] . 95 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


At Biarritz, he painted The Blue Wave, a great sea rolling 
in and breaking on the shore under a fine sky, but quite 
unlike the Coast of Brittany, though Courbet’s influence is 
still evident in the technique. Whistler painted few pictures 
in which the composition the arrangement, is more obvious. 
It is altogether an extraordinary piece of work and is owned 
now by Mr. Alfred Attmore Pope. At Fuenterrabia Whistler 
was in Spain, for the first and only time; Spaniards from 
the Opéra-Comique in the street, men in béret and red blouse, 
children like little Turks. He wanted to go further, to 
Madrid, and he urged Fantin to join him. Together they 
should look at The Lances and The Spinners, as together 
they had studied at the Louvre. In another letter, he 
promised to describe Velasquez to Fantin, to bring back 
photographs. Such “glorious painting” is to be copied. 
* Ah! mon cher, comme il a du travailler,” he winds up in 
his enthusiasm. But the journey ended at Fuenterrabia. 
Fantin could not join him. Madrid was put off for another 
spring, for ever, as it turned out, though the journey was 
for ever being planned anew. 

Whistler sent The White Girl to the Academy of 1862, with 
The Twenty-fijth of December 1860 on the Thames, Alone with 
the Tide, the first title of The Coast of Brittany, and one etching, 
Rotherhithe. The White Girl was rejected. The two other 
pictures and the print were accepted, hung and praised. The 
Atheneum compared the Rotherhithe to Rembrandt. Whistler 
could scarcely be mentioned as an etcher without this com- 
parison ; since Rembrandt his were “the most striking and 
original ” etchings, every one then agreed, Mr. W. M. Rossetti 
being among the first in England to say so boldly. Alone 
with the Tide was approved as “ perfectly expressed,” and 
The Twenty-fijth of December, as broad and vigorous, though 
perhaps vigour was pushed over “the bounds of coarseness 
to become mere dash.” Other work he showed elsewhere 
96 [1862 


THE THAMES IN ICE 
(The 25th of December 1860, on the Thames) 


THE BEGINNINGS IN LONDON 


was also praised. The Punt and Sketching, published in 
Passages from Modern English Poets, were at once singled out 
for admiration. Thames Warehouses and Black Lion Wharf 
won him immediate recognition as “the most admirable 
etcher of the present day,’’ when sent to South Kensington 
Museum where International Exhibitions were held during 
several years. The White Girl alone failed to please. 

In nothing had he been so completely himself as in this 
picture. The artist is born to pick and choose, and group with 
science, the elements contained in Nature that the result may 
be beautiful, he wrote long afterward in the Ten o’Clock, and 
The White Girl was his first attempt to conform to a principle 
no one ever put so clearly into words. It was simply an 
attempt, we know now, comparing the painting to the sym- 
phonies and harmonies that came after. But at the time it 
was disquieting in its defiance of accepted formulas. It was 
without subject, according to Victorian standards, and the 
arrangement of white upon white was more bewildering even 
than the minute detail of the Pre-Raphaelites. This summer 
(1862) the Berners Street Gallery was opened, “ with the 
avowed purpose of placing before the public the works of 
young artists who may not have access to the ordinary 
galleries.’ Maclise, Egg, Frith, Cooper, Poynter worked 
their way in. But the manager had the courage to exhibit 
The White Girl, stating in the catalogue that the Academy 
had refused it. The Atheneum was independent enough 
to say that it was the most prominent picture in the collection, 
though not the most perfect, for, 

“able as this bizarre production shows Mr. Whistler to be, we 

are certain that in a very few years he will recognise the reason- 

ableness of its rejection. Itis one of the most incomplete paintings 
we ever met with. A woman in a quaint morning dress of white, 
with her hair about her shoulders, stands alone in a background 
of nothing in particular. But for the rich vigour of the textures, 
we might conceive this to be some old portrait by Zucchero, or 
1862] 1:G 97 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


a pupil of his, practising in a provincial town. The face is 
well done, but it is not that of Mr. Wilkie Collins’ Woman in 
White.” 

This criticism is not only characteristic of contemporary 
opinion, but interesting as having brought in answer, from 
Whistler, the first, as far as we can discover, of his long series 
of letters to the press. He wrote that he had no intention 
of illustrating Mr. Wilkie Collins’ novel, which it happened 
he had never read, and that his picture represented merely 
a girl in white standing in front of a white curtain. The 
critics, not yet his enemies, were spared the sting of his wit. 
They, however, expressed disapproval strongly enough for 
him to tell his friends that The White Girl enjoyed a succés 
@ exécration. 

A very different sort of success awaited his Thames etchings 
in Paris, where they were shown in a dealer’s gallery. Baude- 
laire saw them, and understood, as he was the first to under- 
stand the work of Manet, Poe, Wagner, and so many others. 
He wrote : 


“Tout récemment, un jeune artiste américain, M. Whistler, 
exposait a la galerie Martinet une série d’eaux fortes, subtiles, 
éveillées comme Vimprovisation et Vinspiration, représentant les 
bords de la Tamise ; merveilleux fouillis d’agrés, de vergues, de 
cordages ; chaos de brumes, de fourneaux et de fumées tire-bouchon- 
nées ; poésie profonde et compliquée dune vaste capitale.” 


According to Mr. W. M. Rossetti, Whistler was then living 
in Queen’s Road, Chelsea. He writes us: 


“I fancy that the houses in Queen’s Road have been much 
altered since Whistler was there in 1862-63. They were then 
low (say two-storied), quite old-fashioned houses, of a cosy, homely 
character, with small fore-courts. I have a kind of idea that 
Whistler’s house was No. 12, but this is quite uncertain to me.* 


* Not only have the houses been much altered, but the very name of the street 
has changed, and Queen’s Road is now Royal Hospital Road. The present No. 12 
corresponds to Mr. Rossetti’s description, but we think it more likely—and he 
does too—that Whistler lived in one of the little brick cottages of Paradise Row. 
98 [1862 


(,.8P4OM, POOH ,, WONT) 
.NOWUAS LSNIA AHL» OL SNOILVULSATII 


THE BEGINNINGS IN LONDON 


As my brother and I were much in that neighbourhood, to and 
fro, prior to settling down in No. 16 Cheyne Walk, we came into 
contact with Whistler, who every now and then accompanied 
us On our jaunts. I forget how it was exactly that we got intro- 
duced to him; possibly by Mr. Algernon Swinburne, who was 
also to be an inmate of No. 16. Either (as I think) before meeting 

Whistler or just about the time we met him, we had seen one 

or two of his paintings. At the Piano must have been one; and 

we most heartily admired him, and discerned unmistakably 
that he was destined for renown.” 

The friendship may have led to Whistler’s active interest 
in the black-and-white then being produced in England, for 
Rossetti and his little group had, in a way, revolutionised 
English illustration, and it was now held to be as dignified 
and as serious a form of art as any other. All the more 
brilliant of the younger men were working for the illustrated 
magazines, and it was natural that Whistler found a place 
among them. He made six drawings in all, and they were 
done in 1862. Four appeared in Once a Week: The Major’s 
Daughter, The Relief Fund in Lancashire, The Morning before 
the Massacre of St. Bartholomew, and Count Burckhardt. Two 
were published in Good Words, illustrations to The First 
Sermon. They are drawn in pencil, pen and wash, are all 
full of character, and, in the use of line, are like his etchings. 
They were engraved by the Dalziel Brothers and Mr. Joseph 
Swain, the art editors. Mr. Strahan, the publisher of Once 
a Week, writes us: 

“* These illustrations were arranged for by Edward Dalziel, and 

I cannot say how he came to know the artist or his work, as Mr. 

Whistler was young then, and, as far as I know, had not contri- 

buted to any magazine. The average price we paid to artists 

was nine pounds, and we reckoned that the same amount had 
to be paid for engraving. As a matter of fact, the sum paid to 

Mr. Whistler was nine pounds for each drawing.” 


In any case, we doubt if he had more than rooms or lodgings. He gave us to 
understand that the house he took shortly after, in Lindsey Row, was his first 
in London. 


1862] 99 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


We showed Whistler once The Morning before the Massacre 
of St. Bartholomew. “ Well, now—not bad, you know—not 
bad even then!” he said, following, with that expressive 
finger of his, the flowing line of the pose, and pointing to the 
hand lost in the draperies. This drawing and The Major’s 
Daughter were the two he preferred in after years, and when 
J. was preparing The History of Modern Illustration, 
Whistler picked them out as “‘ very pretty ones,” that should 
be reproduced, though we remember his saying that, if but 
a single example of his work could be used, The Morning 
before the Massacre should be selected, for it was ‘‘ as delicate 
as an etching, and altogether characteristic and personal.” 
The Count Burckhardt he did not care for, insisting that he 
would rather not be represented at all if this were to be the 
only example given in the book. It was never a favourite 
of his, he added. 

The four drawings of Once a Week were reprinted in Thorn- 
bury’s Legendary Ballads in 1876. Thornbury implies that 
the drawings were made for it, and says of them : 

“Some startling drawings by Mr. Whistler prove his singular 
power of hand, strong artistic feeling, and daring manner.” 
Our copy belonged to George Augustus Sala. On the 
margin of The Morning before the Massacre he wrote : 


“Jemmy Whistler.—Clever, sketchy and incomplete, like 
everything he has done. A loaf of excellent fine flour, but slack- 
baked.” 


So Sala thought in 1888, and it is typical of the times. 

Another important work of 1862 was The Last of Old 
Westminster. Mr. Arthur Severn knows more about it than 
any one, as his account to us explains : 

“On my return from Rome to join my brother in his rooms in 
Manchester Buildings, on the Thames at Westminster Bridge, 
(where the New Scotland Yard now is), I found Whistler beginning 
his picture of Westminster Bridge. My brother had given him 
permission to use our sitting-room, with its bow-windows looking 

100 [1862 


A WEEK” 


x 
vj 


“ONCI 


FROM 


NS 


TRATIO 


LUS 


IL 


penne 
cr 


- 
Uhre 


car ea dee ee. 


“yoi oe 
Led ares nee ey capt 


lake Lig ap 
elenee aa? gl bit +3 
en MP e) ea ; 
wire) isc vie 


eey ll 

ee eee af 
spe orpanth |S igheteth fraskiayier ie ¢ 
ee oe ee ae 
aaehar caren Ha: dhebae ngecnt catalan 

f # oer Tehioieealt 


THE BEGINNINGS IN LONDON 


over the river and towards the bridge. He was always most 
courteous and pleasant in manner, and it was most interesting 
to see him at work. The bridge was in perspective, still surrounded 
with piles, for it had only just been finished. It was the piles 
with their rich colour and delightful confusion that took his fancy, 
not the bridge, which hardly showed. He would look steadily 
at a pile for some time, then mix up the colour, then holding 
his brush quite at the end, with no mahlstick, make a downward 
stroke and the pile was done. I remember once his looking very 
carefully at a hansom cab that had pulled up for some purpose 
on the bridge, and in a few strokes he got the look of it perfectly. 
He was a long time over the picture, sometimes coming only once 
a week, and we got rather tired of it. One day some friends 
came to see it. He stood it against a table in an upright position 
for them to see, it suddenly fell on its face, much to my brother’s 
disgust, as he had just got a new carpet. Luckily Whistler’s 
sky was pretty dry, and I don’t think the picture got any damage, 
and the artist was most good-natured about my brother’s 
anxiety lest the carpet should have suffered. 

‘““T had done some work at Rome. One of my drawings was 
of an evening subject on the Aventine Hill, reflected in the Tiber. 
It was very yellow—in fact, when I was painting it, a French 
corporal and two privates came to look over me, and I heard 
them ask their corporal what he thought of it. He shrugged his 
shoulders, and said: ‘For my part, it is like an omelette.’ I 
fancy Whistler rather thought the same, but was very kind in 
saying what he could. Then he asked me if I had any raw umber, 
to which I answered, no. Then he said: ‘How can you ever 
expect to become a Royal Academician without raw umber ?’” 


The Last of Old Westminster was finished for the Academy 
of 1868, to which it was sent with six prints: Weary; Old 
Westminster Bridge ; Hungerford Bridge ; Monsieur Becquet ; 
The Forge; The Pool. The dignity of composition in the 
picture and the vigour of handling, impressed all those who 
saw it in the London Memorial Exhibition, though they had 
to regret the shocking condition it then was in, cracked from 
one end to the other. It failed to impress Academicians in 
1863, and was badly hung, as the prints also were, repro- 
1863] IOI 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


ductive work being then, as now, preferred to original etching. 
The White Girl, after its Berners Street success, was the 
picture Whistler chose for the Salon. He took it over to Paris 
himself, to Fantin’s studio, there having it unrolled and 
framed. No one can now say, probably no one could then, 
why the strongest work of the strongest younger men was 
rejected from the Salon of 1863. Fantin, Legros, Manet, 
Bracquemond, Jongkind, MHarpignies, Cazin, Jean-Paul 
Laurens, Vollon, Whistler, were all refused. It was a scandal ; 
1859 was nothing to it. The town was in an uproar which 
reached the ears of the Emperor. Martinet, the dealer, 
proposed to show the rejected pictures in his gallery. 
But before this was definitely arranged, Napoleon III. 
ordered that a Salon des Refusés should be held in the same 
building as the official Salon, the Palais de l’ Industrie. The 
announcement was published in the Moniteur for April 24, 
1868. The invitation to show was issued by the Directeur- 
Général of the Imperial Museums, and the exhibition opened 
on May 15. The success was as great as the scandal. The 
exhibition was the talk of the cafés; it was parodied as the 
Club des Refusés at the Variétés ; every one rushed to the 
galleries. The rooms were crowded by artists, because, in 
the midst of much no doubt weak and foolish, the best work 
of the day was shown; by the public, because of the stir it 
made. The public laughed from a vague idea that it was a 
duty to laugh. The show was caricatured as the Exposition 
des Comiques, and it was said that never was a succés pour 
rire better deserved. Zola described, in L’Ciuvre, the gaiety 
and cruelty of the crowd, always convulsed and hysterical in 
front of La Dame en Blanc. Hamerton wrote in the Fine 
Arts Quarterly : 
“The hangers must have thought her particularly ugly, for 
they have given her a sort of place of honour, before an opening 


through which all pass, so that nobody misses her. I watched 
102 [1863 


THE BEGINNINGS IN LONDON 


several parties, to see the impression The Woman in White made 
on them. They all stopped instantly, struck with amazement. 
This for two or three seconds, then they always looked at each 
other and laughed. Here, for once, I have the happiness to be 
quite of the popular way of thinking.” 


On the other hand, Fernand Desnoyers, who wrote a 
pamphlet on the Salon des Refusés, thought that Whistler 
was “le plus spirite des peintres,” and the picture the most 
original that had passed before the jury of the Salon, altogether 
remarkable, at once simple and fantastic, the portrait of a 
spirit, a medium, though of a beauty so peculiar that the 
public did not know whether to think it beautiful or ugly. 
Paul Mantz wrote that it was the most important picture in 
the exhibition, full of knowledge and strange charm, and his 
article in the Gazette des Beaux-Arts is the more interesting 
because he there describes the picture as a Symphonie du 
Blanc some years before Whistler called it so himself, seeing 
in it instead of eccentricity, only a carrying on of French 
traditions, for had not, a hundred years earlier, painters shown 
in the Salon similar studies of colour, of tone—of white upon 
white ? 

The picture hardly explained the sensation of its first 
appearance when we saw it with Miss Alexander, the Mother, 
Carlyle, The Fur Jacket and Irving, in the London Memorial 
Exhibition. But it seemed revolutionary enough in the 
’sixties, to become the clou of the Salon des Refusés, though 
this was the last thing Whistler wanted it to be. It eclipsed 
even Manet’s big Déjewner sur Vherbe, then called Le Bain. 

Whistler was in Amsterdam with Legros, looking at the 
Rembrandts with pleasure, at the Van der Helsts with dis- 
appointment, etching Amsterdam from the Tolhuis, no doubt 
hunting for old paper, and adding to his collection of blue 
and white, when the news came of the sensation his pictures 
had made in Paris, and he wrote at once to Fantin. He 
1863] 103 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


longed to be in Paris and in the movement. It was a delight 
that the picture, slighted in London, should be honoured in 
Paris. He was all impatience to know what was said in the 
Café de Bade, the café of Manet and his friends, and by the 
critics. 

To add to his triumph in Paris, official honours were falling 
to him in Holland and England. Some of his etchings were 
in an exhibition at The Hague, though he always said he 
did not know how they got there, and he was given one of 
three gold medals awarded to foreigners: his first medal. 
Though atrociously hung at the Academy, his prints were 
honoured at the British Museum, where as many as twelve 
were bought for the Print room in this one year. 

The excitement did not keep him long from work, to which, 
as he wrote to Fantin, wandering was a drawback. He felt 
the need of his studio, of “‘ the familiar all about him.” The 
** familiar ’’ he loved best was in London, and when he returned 
he began to look for a house of his own. It was fortunate for 
him that his mother was now persuaded to leave America and 
come to England. She had passed through the arduous times 
of the Civil War, in which Whistler took the keenest interest as 
a patriot and a “‘ West Point man.”’ She had been in Rich- 
mond with her younger son, William, a surgeon in the southern 
army, had run the blockade, and arrived in England just at 
this critical moment. 

Whistler no longer made the Hadens’ house his home. 
The relations of the brothers-in-law had become strained, 
as it was unavoidable they should, both being men of strong 
character and personality. There had been disputes about 
pictures, and descents upon the conventional household of 
’ strange creatures from Paris. Haden had had much to put 
up with, while Whistler, the artist, resented the criticism of 
Haden, the surgeon. One story we have from Whistler 
explains the relations between the two, and though he never 
104 [1863 


SOUVENIR OF VELASQUEZ y 
(Chalk Drawing) 


THE BEGINNINGS IN LONDON 


gave a date, it can be appropriately told here. Haden was 
always a little of the schoolmaster Whistler found him when 
they first met ; one’s older relatives have a way of forgetting 
one can grow up. Once, when Whistler had done something 
more enormous than ever in Haden’s eyes, he had been 
summoned to the mysterious room upstairs, and lectured 
until he refused to listen to another word. He started down 
the four flights of stairs, with Haden close behind, still 
lecturing. At last the front door was reached. And then— 
““ Oh, dear!” said Whistler, “ I’ve left my hat upstairs, and 
now we have got to go all through this again!” 

As there was no further question of Whistler living with 
the Hadens, it was decided that he and his mother should 
live together, and some of his most delightful years were 
those that followed. 


1863 105 


CHAPTER X. CHELSEA DAYS. THE 
YEARS EIGHTEEN SIXTY-THREE TO 
EIGHTEEN SIXTY-SIX 


HISTLER’S first house in London was No. 7 Lindsey 
Row, Chelsea, now 101 Cheyne Walk. It adjoins the 
old palace of Lord Lindsey, which still stands, the original 
building divided into several houses, stuccoed and modernised, 
much of its stateliness gone, though the spacious stairway 
and part of the panelling have been preserved. Whistler’s 
was a three-story house, with a garden in front, humble when 
compared with the palaces Academicians were building. 
*““ All these artists complain of nothing but the too great 
prosperity of the profession in these days,” Hamerton wrote 
to his wife on one of his visits to London; “they tell me 
an artist’s life is a princely one now.” But Whistler lived 
his own life, and from his windows he could paint what he 
wanted. Only the road separated the house from the river ; 
opposite was Battersea Church and a group of factory chim- 
neys; old Battersea Bridge stretched across; and at night 
he could see the lights of Cremorne. 

At the end of the Row, two doors from Whistler’s house, 
the boat-builder, Greaves, lived. He had worked in Chelsea 
for years. He had rowed Turner about on the river, and his 
two sons were now to row Whistler. One of the sons, Mr. 
Walter Greaves, has told us that Mrs. Booth, a big, hard, 
coarse Scotchwoman, was always with Turner when he came 
for his boat. Turner would ask Greaves what kind of a 
day it was going to be, and if Greaves answered “ Fine,” 
106 [1863 


CHELSEA DAYS 


he would get Greaves to row them across to Battersea Church, 
or to the fields, now Battersea Park. IfGreaves was doubtful, 
Turner would say: ‘‘ Well, Mrs. Booth, we won’t go far; ” 
and afterwards, for the sons—boys at the time—Turner in 
their memory was completely overshadowed by her. They had 
also known Martin, the painter of big, Scriptural machines, 
whose house was in the middle of the Row. It had a balcony, 
and on fine moonlight nights, or nights of dramatic skies, 
Greaves or one of the sons would knock him up, and keep 
on knocking until they saw the old man in his night-cap on 
the balcony, where he would get to work and paint the sky 
until daylight. Greaves remembered, too, Brunel, who 
built the Great Eastern, living at the end of the Row. Of 
other associations, dating a couple of centuries before his 
time, the little Moravian graveyard at the back was a reminder, 
for the old Lindsey palace had been one of the first refuges 
of Zinzendorf and the Brotherhood. The Row, indeed, was 
a place of history. But Whistler was to make it more famous 
than it ever had been. 

The two Greaves, Walter and Harry, painted, and he had 
them in his studio, teaching them by letting them work with 
and for him. We have often heard him speak of them as 
his “first pupils.” From them he learned to row—‘‘ He 
taught us to paint, and we taught him the waterman’s jerk,”’ 
Mr. Walter Greaves says. Whistler would start with them 
in the twilight, and sometimes stay on the river all night, 
lingering in the lights of Cremorne, drifting into the shadows 
of the old bridge, or else he was up with the dawn, throw- 
ing pebbles at their windows to wake them, and make 
them come and pull him up or down stream. At night, 
on the river and at Cremorne, he was never without brown 
paper, and black and white chalk, with which he made 
his notes for the Nocturnes and the seemingly simple, but 
really complicated, fireworks pictures. In the Gardens it 
1863] 107 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


was easy to put down what he wanted under the lamps. 
On the river, he had to trust almost entirely to his 
memory, sometimes only noting the reflections in white 
chalk. 

At one time, master and pupils attended a life class held 
in the evening by M. Barthe, a Frenchman, in Limerston 
Street, not far from the Row. Mr. J. E. Christie, another 
student in the same class, writes us: 


“Whistler was not a regular attender at the Limerston Street 
Studio, but came occasionally, and always accompanied by two 
young men—brothers—Greaves by name. They let out rowing- 
boats on the Thames and Battersea Park. They simply adored 
Whistler, and were not unlike him in appearance, owing to an 
unconscious imitation of his dress and manner. It was amusing 
to watch the movements of the trio when they came into the 
studio (always late). The curtain that hung in front of the door 
would suddenly be pulled back by one of the Greaves, and a trim, 
prim little man, with a bright, merry eye, would step in with 
‘Good evening,’ cheerfully said to the whole studio. After a 
second’s survey, while taking off his gloves, he would hand his 
hat to the other brother, who hung it up carefully as if it were a 
sacred thing—then he would wipe his brow and moustache with 
a spotless handkerchief, then in the most careful way he arranged 
his materials, and sat down. Then, having imitated in a general 
way the preliminaries, the two Greaves sat down on either side 
of him. There was a sort of tacit understanding that his and 
their studies should not be subjected to the rude gaze of the general. 
I, however, saw, with the tail of my eye, as it were, that Whistler 
made small drawings on brown paper with coloured chalks, that 
the figure (always a female figure) would be about four inches 
long, that the drawing was bold and fine, and not slavishly like 
the model. The comical part was that his satellites didn’t 
draw from the model at all, that I saw, but sat looking at 
Whistler’s drawing and copying, as far as they could, that. 
He never entered into the conversation, which was unceasing, 
but occasionally rolled a cigarette and had a few whiffs, the 
Greaves brothers always requiring their whiffs at the same 
moment. The trio packed up, and left before the others 
always.” 

108 [1863 


LINDSEY ROW 


No. 7 LINDSEY ROW No. 2 LINDSEY ROW 
(First House) (Second House) 


eae 


pee rah 


eneyiue oe! ae See 
Pe fare Fel 


ye rhe ee 


CHELSEA DAYS 


Sometimes, in the evening, Whistler, with his mother, 
would go to the Greaves’ house after dinner, and work there. 
Often he sent in dessert, that they might enjoy and talk 
over it together. Then he would bring out his brown paper 
and chalks, and make studies of different members of the 
family, and of himself, or sketches of pictures he had seen, 
working until midnight and after. He told Mr. Way once that, 
in those days, he never went to bed until he had drawn a por- 
trait of himself. Many of those portraits are in existence 
and one is here reproduced. The sister was an accomplished 
musician, and Whistler delighted in music, though he was 
not too critical, for he was known to call the passing hurdy- 
gurdy into his front garden, and have it ground under his 
windows. Occasionally, the brothers played, so that Whistler 
might dance. He was always full of drolleries and fun. He 
would imitate a man sawing, or two men fighting at the door, 
so cleverly that Mrs. Greaves never ceased to be astonished 
when he walked into the room alone and unhurt. He 
delighted in American mechanical toys, and his house was 
full of Japanese dolls. One great doll, dressed like a man, 
he would take with him, not only to the Greaves’, but to 
dinners at Little Holland House, where the Prinseps then 
lived, and to other houses, where he put it through amazing 
performances. 

Dante Gabriel Rossetti was, by this time, well settled at 
Tudor House (now Queen’s House, the original name) not 
far from Lindsey Row, and Mr. Swinburne and Mr. George 
Meredith were living with him. Mr. W. M. Rossetti came 
for two or three nights every week, and Frederick Sandys, 
Charles Augustus Howell, William Bell Scott, and, several 
years later, Mr. Theodore Watts-Dunton were constant 
visitors. 

For Rossetti, Whistler had a genuine affection. “A 
charming fellow, the only white man in all that crowd of 
1863] 109 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


66 


painters,’’ we have heard him say again and again: ‘ not 
an artist, you know, but charming, and a gentleman.” Mr. 
Watts-Dunton says, on the other hand, that Rossetti got 
exceedingly tired of Whistler after a while, and considered 
him a brainless fellow, who had no more than a malicious 
quick wit at the expense of others, and no real philosophy 
orhumour. But Whistler certainly never knew of any change 
in Rossetti’s failings towards him. Mr. Meredith writes us: 
**T knew Whistler and never had a dissension with him, though 
merry bouts between us were frequent. When I went to live in 
the country, werarely met. He came down to stay with me once. 

He was a lively companion, never going out of his way to take 

offence, but with the springs in him prompt for the challenge. 

His tales of his student life in Paris, and of one Ernest, with whom 

he set forth on a holiday journey with next to nothing in the 

purse, were impayable.” 

It was inevitable that Whistler and Rossetti should disagree 
in matters of art. Whistler asked Rossetti why he did not 
frame his sonnets. Rossetti thought that “ the new French 
School,’? in which Whistler had been trained, was “ simple 
putrescence and decomposition.” It is said that Rossetti 
influenced Whistler. Whistler influenced him just as much. 
They influenced each other in the choice of models, in a 
certain luxuriance of type and the manner of presenting it, 
an influence which was wholly superficial and transitory. 

Upon many other subjects they did agree. Rossetti shared 
Whistler’s delight in drollery and his love of the fantastic. 
No one understood better than Whistler why Rossetti filled 
his house and garden with strange beasts. It was from 
Whistler we heard of the peacock and the gazelle, who fought 
until the peacock was left standing desolate with his tail 
apart upon the ground ; the origin, we have always believed, 
of the monkey and the parrot story. From Whistler, too, we 
had the story of the bull—the bull of Bashan—bought at 
Cremorne, and tied to a stake in the garden, where Rossetti 


IIo [1863 


CHELSEA DAYS 


would come every day and talk to him, until once the bull 
was so excited by this talk that he pulled up the stake and 
made for Rossetti, who went tearing round and round a tree, 
a little fat person with coat-tails flying, finally, by a supreme 
effort, rushing up the garden steps just in time to slam the 
door in the bull’s face. Rossetti called his man and ordered 
him to tie up the bull, but he, who had looked out for the 
menagerie, who had gone about the house with peacocks 
and other creatures under his arms, who had rescued arma- 
dilloes from irate neighbours, who had captured monkeys 
from the tops of chimneys, struck when it came to tying up 
a bull of Bashan on the rampage, and gave a month’s warning. 
From Whistler also, we first had the story of the wombat, 
bought at Jamrack’s by Rossetti for the sake of its name. 
Whistler was dining at Tudor House, and the wombat was 
brought on the table with coffee and cigars. It was an 
amazing evening, Meredith talking with, if possible, more 
than his usual brilliancy, and Swinburne reading aloud 
passages from the Leaves of Grass. But Meredith was 
witty as well as brilliant, and the special target of his wit was 
Rossetti, who, as he had invited two or three of his patrons, 
did not appreciate the jest. The evening ended less amiably 
than it had begun, and no one thought of the wombat until 
a late hour, and then it had disappeared. It was searched 
for high and low. Days passed, weeks passed, months 
passed, and there was no wombat. It was regretted, for- 
gotten. Long afterwards, Rossetti, who was not much of 
a smoker, got out the box of cigars he had not touched since 
that dinner. He opened it. Not a cigar was left, but there 
was the skeleton of the wombat. 

Whistler and Rossetti also agreed about many of the group 
who met at Tudor House, though Whistler acutely felt what 
appeared to him the disloyalty shown at a later time by 
Swinburne and Burne-Jones. He was never, at any 
1863] III 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


time so intimate with Burne-Jones as with Swinburne, who 
often came to the house in Lindsey Row, not only for 
Whistler’s sake, but out of affection for Whistler’s mother. 
Miss Chapman tells us that Swinburne was once taken ill 
there suddenly, and Mrs. Whistler nursed him until he was 
well. Miss Chapman also remembers Swinburne sitting at 
Mrs. Whistler’s feet, and saying to her: ‘“ Mrs. Whistler, 
what has happened? It used to be Algernon!” Mrs. 
Whistler, though always the Puritan of old, had accepted 
Whistler’s friends and their ways in a surprisingly short time, 
and said quietly, ‘‘ You have not been to see us for a long 
while, you know. Ifyou come as you did, it will be Algernon 
again.” And he came, and the cordiality of their relations 
lasted until the ’eighties when he published the article in the 
Fortnighily Review which Whistler could not forgive. 

Quarrels and distrust could never make Whistler deny the 
charm of Charles Augustus Howell, a remarkable man, who 
will always be remembered for the part he played in the 
lives of some of the most distinguished people of his genera- 
tion. Who he was, where he came from, his friends do not 
seem to have known. He was supposed to be mysteriously 
associated with high, but nameless, personages in Portugal, 
and sent by them on a secret mission to England; he was 
said to have been involved in the Orsini conspiracy, and 
obliged to fly for his life across the Channel. The unquestion- 
able fact is that he was a man of unusual personal charm 
and business capacity. Mr. W. M. Rossetti has written of 
him : 

““ As a salesman—with his open manner, winning address, and 
his exhaustless gift of amusing talk, not innocent of high colouring 
and of actual blagwe—Howell was unsurpassable.”’ 

He was, for a time, secretary to Ruskin; he was Rossetti’s 
man of affairs; he became Whistler’s, though on a less 
definite basis. He appears in published reminiscences of 
I12 [1863 


THE WHITE GIRL 
(Symphony in White, No. 1) 


Lies ae 
ay Pl ge, ere | 


tages 


aeam wie ‘ues 


‘ 
=. il 


a 


_— . er do Made va Sew Lie Tih Uaiee al * aeerr™ "| *\ me 
if . ft ; ‘ ’ J : “ra 
7 i = ; sure ‘A = safle way? aed a al i he - ‘ Ein ; a 
if - - ' . - ii a 
a La! Damen #1 inet cine ' Tes cesalny or) ee eh 
q2* : ie POY Ay . oy [- Rite 
_ ic to) , i” i th ' if ; i, ear wart a a tt y “ rT sy 
. in i + 'e'v , . a a : lp 
le | BAe Boe Catia se! aol ein ely dak ee ine | ae 
J ; . i ‘ 
mY, Gee a © ae l . » i by tga iy 
u M oats ye ls ary ar, ee he aj teed 1 tues rage atte re Pe 
Bel Baten etl i a aeetnamte' ae 
af f oe bars Ji Op eat : iat sal ae ae | j feud 
fs i . ra ee i A ost ome a ‘eth lovee JS : ‘i 
Ps cs J . Jue aie eh posi rie ht 
via ; or einai eal Lie age aire ty mh nuchal dn v7 a i 
F ree US oe Ae bn t Ahi tae eee 
ra o ory i i i nn Trt; <Y im am Aw i — ay 


a > Guer i ; Ay vr ih ~s wi * oA hte att. oe ee 


| Wares wh . wet? aye - poe retin agi * art os 

ot . wher A as b i tr ARE iby F : > i 
+ i OF ss ak : J 

a ee oa om 


ms Pe jas Pe ak ol eae Te ave he. 
r ; Slee © ede fee deco eA ee a 


1 = an , . abe 4 —« wht abLticg, } Vs al oF daw mache 5 a8 ad oa ie ine 
a Oe ee ee ee eee th teh elaae a iL ae =e 
ar wh Rate (Ge Cyety el “i nee 4 i rly 1 Smads ie ‘ " 

= : ats is . * iy! - VMs . an : 7 ? re . re te a 
i” i, . * ks . MM wae t is! r rt ¢ E 
a i A er = Ws call? hice ai gs" tis 
? = 


= 1, ”) Rarh 1 fi Lk uf vi ah ary" | yt i ‘, - 
Cae. wl ok iy Eee oat me ae ei haley 7 
— ont: Tey? e ra Lime +f a" Lfi - y ee quny Be | "7 pa ait ‘bone Jae ge 


aed 

—_ :) 
+ = 
. 
fe 

* 


2 


a ti phe : p ry, ie wh a au a i 
; — bs 


we, 


ii in - 
a0) 2 Se 
=. 


Ls eo 


CHELSEA DAYS 


him as the magnificent prototype of the author’s agent of 
to-day. His talk was one of his recommendations to both 
Rossetti and Whistler. Rossetti always rejoiced in Howell’s 
“‘ Niagara of lies,” and immortalised them in the following 
limerick : 
“‘There’s a Portuguese person called Howell, 
Who lays on his lies with a trowel ; 
When I goggle my eyes, 
And start with surprise, 
Tis at the monstrous big lies told by Howell.” 
Howell had just the qualities to enchant Whistler, who 
described him as 
“‘The wonderful man, the genius, the Gil Blas-Robinson 
Crusoe hero out of his proper time, the creature of top-boots and 
plumes, splendidly flamboyant, the real hero of the Picaresque 
novel, forced by modern conditions into other adventures, and 
along other roads.” 


There is something of the creature of top-boots and plumes 
in Dunn’s sketch of Howell in a letter to D. G. Rossetti lent 
to us by his brother. Whistler gave Howell credit for more 
than picturesqueness. He had the instinct for beautiful 
things, Whistler said : 

“He knew them and made himself indispensable by knowing 
them. He was of the greatest service to Rossetti—he helped 
Watts to sell his pictures and raise the prices—he acted as 
artistic adviser to Mr. Howard, now Lord Carlisle. He had the 
gift of intimacy—he was at once a friend, on closest terms of 
confidence. He introduced everybody to everybody else, he 
entangled everybody with everybody else, and it was easier to 
get involved with Howell than to get rid of him.” 


Many years passed before there was any wish on Whistler’s 
part to get rid of him. He was soon as frequent a visitor at 
Lindsey Row as at Tudor House. When he lived at Putney 
Whistler used to take his morning pull up the river to break- 


fast with him. Of none of his friends in those early Chelsea 
1863] I:H II3 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


days did Whistler so often talk to us as of Howell, telling us, 
one after another, the adventures of this modern rival of 
Gil Blas and Pablo of Segovia: adventures in pursuit of old 
furniture and china until he was known to, and loved and 
hated by, every pawnbroker in London, until he seemed to 
spend all his time in cabs filled with rare and beautiful things ; 
adventures with creditors and bailiffs, one in especial, when 
his collection of blue pots was saved by a device only Howell 
could have invented, forty blue pots carried off in forty 
four-wheelers ; adventures in the law-courts, where he was 
complimented by the judge and awarded heavy damages by 
the jury for nothing in particular ; adventures as vestryman, 
giving teas to hundreds of school children; adventures at 
Selsea Bill, where three cottages were turned into a house for 
himself and he swaggered in the village as a great personage, 
finding an occupation in stripping the copper from an old 
wreck that had been there for years, but never touched before ; 
adventures ending eventually in the Paddon Papers, of which 
there will be something to say when the date of their 
publication is reached. 

For Sandys, Whistler had a real, if humorous, affection, 
though the two lost sight of each other during many years. 
Sandys’ work never interested Whistler, but Sandys, the 
man, was a perpetual delight to him as the English counter- 
part of his friends of the Latin Quarter. Like them, Sandys 
was usually without a penny in his pocket, and, like them, 
he faced the situation with calm and swagger, but he added 
a magnificence they never, in their maddest moments, 
pretended to. Accidents never separated him from his white 
waistcoat, though he might have to carry it himself to the 
laundry, or get his model, “the little girl,” he called her, 
to carry it for him. You were always meeting them with 
the brown paper parcel, Whistler said, and at the nearest 
friend’s house he would stop, and five minutes later come 
II4 [1863 


CHELSEA DAYS 


out splendid in another immaculate white waistcoat. In 
money matters he reckoned like a Rothschild. It was always : 
‘* Huh! five hundred,” that he wanted. Late one afternoon, 
as Whistler was going to Rossetti’s, he met Sandys looking 
unusually depressed. He stopped Whistler : 

“Do, do try and reason with Gabriel, huh! He is most 
thoughtless. He says I must go to America, and I must have 
five hundred, huh! and go! But, if I could go, huh! I could 
stay!” 

Whistler got to know others among Rossetti’s friends, 
drifting, with many artists, to Madox Brown’s evenings 
in Fitzroy Square: 

** Once in a long while, I would take my gaiety, my sunniness, 
to Madox Brown’s receptions. And there were always the most 
wonderful people—the Blinds, Swinburne, anarchists, poets and 
musicians, all kinds and sorts, and, in an inner room, Rossetti 
and Mrs. Morris sitting side by side in state, being worshipped, 
and, fluttering round them, Howell with a broad red ribbon 
across his shirt front, a Portuguese decoration hereditary in 
the family.” 

Whistler also shared Rossetti’s interest in spirits and the 
manifestations that, during several years, agitated the little 
circle at Tudor House. He told us once of the strange things 
that happened when he went to séances at Rossetti’s with 
‘¢ Joe,” and also when he and “‘ Joe”’ tried the same experi- 
ments in his studio. Once, a cousin from the South, long since 
dead, talked to him, and told him much that no one else 
could have known. He believed, but he gave up all such 
practices when they threatened to become too engrossing, 
for he felt that he would be obliged to sacrifice to them the 
real work he had to do in this world. 

Nothing, however, brought Whistler and Rossetti into 
closer sympathy than their love for blue and white china, 
Japanese prints, and Japanese design. Whistler was in Paris 
in 1856, when Bracquemond “ discovered ” Japan in a little 
1863] II5 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


volume of Hokusai, used for packing china, and rescued by 
Delatre, the printer. It passed into the hands of Laveille, 
the engraver, and from him Bracquemond obtained it. 
After that, Bracquemond had the book always with him, 
showing it to everybody, talking about it to everybody ; 
and when, in 1862, Madame Desoye, who, with her husband, 
had lived in Japan, opened her Oriental shop under the 
arcades of the Rue de Rivoli, the enthusiasm spread at once 
to Manet, Fantin, Tissot, Jacquemart and Solon. Baudelaire 
and the De Goncourts were as ardent. In England, Japanese 
and Chinese art, at a much earlier period, had been known 
and appreciated, but only by the few. Rossetti was for 
long supposed to have made it the fashion with the many. 
But the excitement in Paris had begun before Rossetti 
owned his first blue pot or his first Japanese colour-print. 
Whistler brought the knowledge and his love for the art of 
Japan with him to London. “ It was he who invented blue 
and white in London,’ Mr. Murray Marks assures us, and 
Mr. W. M. Rossetti is as certain that his brother was inspired 
by Whistler, who bought not only blue and white, but 
sketch-books, colour-prints, lacquers, kakemonos, embroideries, 
screens. “In his own house in Chelsea, facing Battersea 
Bridge,” Mr. Severn writes, “‘ he had lovely blue and white, 
Chinese and Japanese.” The only decorations, except the 
simple harmony of colour everywhere, were the prints on the 
walls, a flight of Japanese fans in one place, in another shelves 
of blue and white. People, afterwards, copying him un- 
intelligently, stuck up fans anywhere, and hung plates from 
wires as ornaments. Whistler’s fans were arranged for a 
beautiful effect of colour and line. His decorations be- 
wildered people even more than the work of the then new 
firm of Morris, Marshall, Faulkner and Co. The popular 
Victorian artist covered his walls with tapestry, filled his 
studio with costly things, and taught the public to measure 
116 [1863 


WEST POINT DRAWING 


CHELSEA DAYS 


beauty by its price, a fact overlooked by Whistler, though 
not by the decorators in Red Lion Square. 

Rossetti threw himself into the pursuit of blue and white 
with his usual impetuosity. Henry Treffy Dunn, in his 
Recollections of Rossetti, whose assistant he was, writes 
that Rossetti and Whistler “‘ each tried to outwit the other 
in picking up the choicest pieces of blue to be met with” ; 
that both were for ever hunting for ‘‘ Long Elizas,”’ a name 
in which, Mr. W. M. Rossetti thinks, “‘ possibly a witticism 
of Whistler’s may be detected.” Howell joined in the 
pursuit, and, as we should know without Dunn’s assurance, 
met with the “ most astounding experiences and adventures.” 
A little shop in the Strand was one of their favourite haunts, 
another was near London Bridge, where a Japanese print 
was given away with a pound of tea. Farmer and Rogers 
had an Oriental Warehouse in Regent Street. The firm 
has long been dissolved, but the manager was Mr. Lazenby 
Liberty, who afterwards opened his own shop on the other 
side of Regent Street, and here, too, Whistler went, intro- 
duced to Mr. Liberty by Rossetti. Mr. Liberty rendered 
him many a service, and visited him to the last. Mr. 
Murray Marks also imported blue and white, and he has 
told us how the fever spread from Whistler and Rossetti to 
the ordinary collector. Rossetti asked Mr. Marks one day 
if he knew anything about blue and white. Mr. Marks 
said, yes; he could get Rossetti all he wanted, a ship-load 
if he chose. Mr. Marks often ran over to Holland where 
blue and white was quite common and still cheap, and he 
picked up a lot of it, offering it to Rossetti for fifty pounds. 
Rossetti happened to be hard up at the time, and could not 
afford the price. But he came with Mr. Huth, who bought 
all that Rossetti could not take, and the rage for it began in 
England, Sir Henry Thompson, among others, commencing 


to collect. The rivalry between Whistler and Rossetti lasted 
1863] LIZ 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


for several years, until Rossetti, ill and broken, hardly saw 
his friends, and until Mr. Marks, in the early ’seventies, bought 
back from Whistler and Rossetti all he had sold them. 

We cannot better finish the story of Whistler’s relations 
with the group at Tudor House than by giving the impression 
left on one of them, whom Whistler always liked. Mr. 
W. M. Rossetti, in November 1906, wrote specially for us 
an account of his acquaintance with Whistler, and, though 
it goes beyond this period, we quote it all here, as his estimate 
of Whistler was formed during these early years. 


** From this time [1862] onward, up to 1871 or 1872, we saw 
Whistler continually, and on the most intimate footing. It may, 
I dare say, have happened now and again that Dante Rossetti 
saw him every day for a fortnight or so together—Whistler being 
in his house, or he, rather seldomer, in Whistler’s ; and the same 
would be true of myself, but for the fact that I did not spend 
the whole week, but only three days out of the seven, in the 
Cheyne Walk house. Whistler was, as every one knows, a most 
amusing talker and pleasant companion—full of good-humoured 
and genial camaraderie ; and, so far as my brother and I are 
concerned, he took everything as it came, and never exhibited 
any short temper or readiness at taking offence. We knew, 
through him, his brother, Dr. Whistler, and his mother, Alphonse 
Legros, and perhaps some members of the Greek community in 
London, such as the Ionides family. There were various other 
persons known to Whistler, whom we also knew independently 
of him. 

“Tt was through Whistler that my brother and I became 
acquainted with Japanese woodcuts and colour-prints. This 
may have been early in 1863. He had seen and purchased some 
specimens of those works in Paris, and he heartily delighted in 
them, and showed them to us; and we then set about procuring 
other works of the same class. I hardly know that any one in 
London had paid any attention to Japanese designs prior to this. 

** After leaving Queen’s Road, Whistler was in three other 
houses, all in the Chelsea district ; the last was the White House 
in Tite Street. I knew him in all these residences; but my 
brother, I fancy, was not ever in the White House. 

118 [1863 


CHELSEA DAYS 


“Thus things went on between us, always to our mutual 
satisfaction, until the summer of 1872, when my brother had a 
severe illness, and then, up to the summer of 1874, he lived out 
of London—first in Scotland, and afterwards at Kelmscott, 
Oxfordshire. After returning to London, he saw, I think, very 
little of Whistler ; the chief reason being that he had then adopted 
a habit of not going about to see any one, and even in his own 
house he kept very much to a restricted circle of intimate friends. 
I never heard that any dissension had arisen between the two, 
but they ceased to be in the way of meeting. I myself continued 
seeing Whistler pretty frequently ; but, having married in 1874, 
I was then much less among old bachelor friends than I had 
previously been. He was occasionally in our house, and I in 
his, up to the date, say 1879, when he left London after the Ruskin 
libel action. 

* After the trial in the Ruskin action had taken place, with its 
very disputable verdict, Whistler lived abroad for a while. I 
saw him, with the same cordiality as of old, once after he had 
returned to London from Venice; and this, it appears to me, 
was the last time. 

‘“‘ Whistler is known to the world, by direct evidence and by 
rumour, principally in three characters: (1) As a painter and 
etcher, &c.; (2) as a wit and humorist ; (3) as a man of a pug- 
nacious or litigious turn. I will say a few words on each of 
these three points, sufficient for expressing my own opinion, 
which is all that I have to do with. 

(1) People have found out by this time, however their pre- 
decessors may have doubted it, that Whistler was in many 
respects a most admirable artist and master—an initiator and 
leader, incomparable from his own point of view. That there 
was a certain element of whimsicality in his art, as in his mind 
and character generally, appears to be true. One is not bound 
to assume that all his productions are blemishless, nor that a 
portrait of a woman is most efficiently defined as * an arrangement 
in pearl and green.’ 

**(2) As a wit and humorist Whistler certainly excelled all 
the other artists I have known, and, with an exception here and 
there, all the men of whatsoever class. His wit and humour 
consisted partly of general sprightliness, and partly of a natural 
gift for epigram and repartee. All came with a spontaneous, 
impromptu air. There are some people whom he scorned, and 

1863] IIg 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


to them he would say sharp things which they would not have 
liked to hear; but, broadly speaking, his sallies were not of an 
ill-natured kind. 

“* (3) Whistler’s pugnacious or litigious turn gave rise every 
now and then to acts which I decidedly did not approve—neither 
did my brother. I shall not enter into any details, for this is 
not my affair. In general terms, it may be said that Whistler 
in such matters had the feelings of an American or a Frenchman, 
much rather than of an Englishman. He had a touchy sense 
of self-regard, or indeed of self-assertion, and was not inclined 
to yield an inch to any gainsayer. His Gentile Art of Making 
Enemies gives a very speaking picture of his mind in this respect ; 
and, after making all fair allowances contrariwise, I think it may 
be truly said that, in the various controversies embalmed in this 
diverting book, Whistler was essentially in the right in almost 
every instance.” 


120 (1863 


Wal) KER. 


Second 


\.our 


Waoll ‘a 


Fiest 


“Last hel Ceres 


iste i ad half hour 


ON POST IN CAMP 
AN HOUR IN THE LIFE OF A CADET 


De ee se 


A nes don? 


CHAPTER XI. CHELSEA DAYS. THE 
YEARS EIGHTEEN SIXTY-THREE TO 
EIGHTEEN SIXTY-SIX CONTINUED 


“N Whistler’s correspondence with Fantin, which was 
most active between 1860 and 1865, it can be seen 
how completely he was outgrowing the influence of Courbet, 
and how bitter he was in his reaction against Realism. In 
his first revolt he went to the other extreme. He deliberately 
built up subjects for himself that had nothing to do with life 
as he knew it, and the motives for these he borrowed from 
Japan. 

It was in the studio at No. 7 Lindsey Row, no huge, 
gorgeous, tapestry-hung, bric-d-brac crowded hall, but a 
modest little second story, or English first floor, back room, 
that the Japanese pictures were painted. The method was 
still that of his earlier work, the paint thickly laid on, with 
the richness he later sacrificed to other and more subtle 
qualities. The difference was in his subjects. He did not 
endeavour to conceal his “‘ machinery.” The Lange Leizen, 
The Gold Screen, The Balcony, the Princesse du Pays de la 
Porcelaine were so many excuses for him to render a beauty 
foreign to Western life and English atmosphere. There was 
no attempt at the learned accuracy of Tadema and Leighton 
in their classical compositions, or of Holman Hunt in 
his scriptural records. Whistler’s models were frankly 
not Japanese. The lady in the Lange Leizen—of the Six 
Marks sits on a chair as she never would have sat in the 
land from which her draperies came, and the pots and trays 
1863] 121 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


and flowers around her are in a profusion unknown in the 
houses of Tokio or Canton. In The Gold Screen, pose and 
arrangement are equally inappropriate. The Princesse, in 
her trailing robes, is as little Japanese or Chinese as she is 
English. Once, when he left the studio and took his canvas 
to the front of the house and painted The Balcony, though he 
clothed the English models in Eastern dress and gave them 
Eastern instruments to play, placed them before Japanese 
screens and Anglo-Japanese railings, their background was 
the Thames with the chimneys of Battersea. These things 
did not matter to Whistler. It was not Japan he wanted to 
paint, but the beautiful colour and form of Japanese detail, 
as the titles he afterwards found for the pictures explain : 
Purple and Rose, Caprice in Purple and Gold, Harmony in 
Flesh Colour and Green, Rose and Silver. Harmony was 
what he sought, though no Dutchman ever surpassed their 
delicacy of detail, truth of texture, intricacy of pattern. 
And yet we are always conscious in them of the artificial 
structure as in none of his other work; the models do not 
live in their Japanese draperies ; Eastern lutes and hangings 
are out of place on the mist-laden banks of the Thames ; 
the device is too obvious. 

The Princesse du Pays de la Porcelaine is the portrait of 
Miss Christine Spartali, daughter of the Consul-General 
for Greece in London, whom Whistler met at Mr. Ionides’ 
house, and to whose dinners and parties he often went. 
There were two daughters, Christine (afterwards the Countess 
Edmond de Cahen) and Marie (Mrs. W. J. Stillman), both 
very beautiful, with a beauty as foreign to England as the 
colour of Japanese stuffs, and the conventions of Japanese 
artists. Whistler, no less than Rossetti, was struck by their 
beauty, and asked the younger sister, Christine, to sit to 
him. Mrs. Stillman, who always accompanied her for the 
sittings, has told us the story of the picture. The first 
122 [1863 


THE LANGE LEIZEN—OF THE SIX MARKS 
(Purple and Rose) 


CHELSEA DAYS 


day, when they arrived in the studio, Whistler had his 
scheme prepared. The Japanese robe was ready, the rug 
and screen were in place, and he gave the pose at once. 
There are a number of small studies and sketches in oil and 
pastel that show how he had perfected the idea beforehand. 
They used to come to him twice a week, and this continued 
through the winter of 1863-64. At first the work went 
quickly, but soon it began to drag. Whistler often scraped 
down the figure just as they thought it all but finished, and 
day after day they returned to find that everything was to 
be done over again. Their parents got tired of it in the end, 
but not the two girls, who shared Whistler’s enthusiasm. 
Mrs. Stillman remembers that Whistler partly closed the 
shutters so as to shut out the direct light; that her sister 
stood at one end of the room, the canvas beside her; that 
Whistler would look at the picture from a distance, then 
suddenly dash at it, give one stroke, then dash away again. 
She remembers too that, as a rule, they arrived about half- 
past ten or a quarter to eleven, that he painted steadily, for- 
getting everything else, that it was often long after two before 
they lunched. When lunch at last was served, it was brought 
into the studio, placed on a low table, and they sat on stools. 
There were no such lunches anywhere else. Mrs. Whistler 
provided American dishes, then strange in London; among 
other things raw tomatoes, a surprise to the two Greek girls, 
who had never eaten tomatoes except overcooked, as the 
Greeks like them, and canned apricots and cream, which 
they had never eaten at all. One menu in particular Mrs. 
Whistler often provided was roast pheasants, followed by 
the inevitable tomato salad, and the apricots and cream, 
usually with champagne. One cannot wonder that there 
were occasional deficits in the bank account at Lindsey Row. 
But it was not merely the things to eat and drink that made 
the hour a delight. Whistler, silent when he worked, was 
1864] 123 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


gay at lunch. Perhaps better than his charm, Mrs. Stillman 
remembers his devotion to his mother, who was calm and 
dignified, with something of the sweet peacefulness of the 
Friends. After lunch work was renewed, and it was four 
and later before they were released. 

The sittings went on until the sitter fell ill. Whistler was 
pitiless with his models. The head in the Princesse gave him 
most trouble. He kept Miss Spartali standing while he 
worked on it, never letting her rest ; she must keep the entire 
pose, and she would not admit her fatigue as long as she 
could help it. During her illness, a model stood for the 
gown, and when she was getting better, he came one day 
and made a pencil-drawing of her head, though where it 
went Mrs. Stillman never knew. There were a few more 
sittings after this, and at last the picture was finished. The 
two girls wanted their father to buy it, but Mr. Spartali 
did not like it. He objected to it as a portrait of his 
daughter. Appreciation of art was not among the virtues 
of the London Greeks. Mr. Alexander Ionides and his sons 
were almost alone in preferring a good thing to a bad one. 

Rossetti, always glad to be of service to a friend, sold the 
picture for Whistler, though this was no easy matter. 
Whistler agreed to take a hundred pounds, and Rossetti 
placed the canvas in his own studio, where it would be seen 
by a rich collector who was coming to look at his work. 
The collector came, saw the Princesse, liked it, wanted it. 
There was one objection: Whistler’s signature in big letters 
across the canvas. If Whistler would change the signature 
he would take the picture. Rossetti, enchanted, hurried 
to tell Whistler. But Whistler was indignant. The request 
showed what manner of man such a patron was, one in whose 
possession he did not care to have any work of his, and that 
was the end of the bargain. However, Rossetti did sell the 
Princesse to another collector, who died shortly afterwards, 
124 [1864 


CHELSEA DAYS 


when it was bought by Frederick Leyland, and so led to the 
decoration of the Peacock Room, one of Whistler’s most 
splendid works. 

It is quite possible that the objection of Rossetti’s collector 
to the Princesse made Whistler realise the discordant effect 
of a large signature on a picture. It is sure that, about this 
time, he began to arrange his initials somewhat after the 
Japanese fashion, and they first appear interlaced in an 
oblong or circular frame exactly like the signatures of Japanese 
artists on colour prints. He signed his name to the 
earliest pictures, even to some of the Japanese. But with 
the Nocturnes and the large portraits the Butterfly begins, 
made from working the letters J. M. W. into a design, which 
became more fantastic until it finally evolved into the 
Butterfly in silhouette, and continued, in various forms. 
In the Carlyle, the Butterfly appears in a round frame, like 
a cut-out silhouette, behind the figure, and repeats the prints 
on the wall. In the Miss Alexander it is in a large semicircle 
and is far more distinctly a butterfly. In time, however, it 
grew like a stencil, though in no sense was it one, as may 
be seen in M. Duret’s portrait, where the Butterfly is made 
simply in silhouette, on the background, by a few touches 
of the rose of the opera cloak and the fan. It was introduced 
as a note of colour, as important in the picture as anything 
else, and at times it was put in almost at the first painting 
to judge the effect, scraped out with the whole thing, put 
in again somewhere else, this repeated again and again until 
he got it right. We have seen many an unfinished picture 
with the most wonderfully finished Butterfly, because it 
was just where Whistler wanted it. 

The same development can be traced in his etchings, in 
which it began to appear asa bit of decoration. He originally 
signed the prints, and signed the plates with his name and 
date bitten in. But later on the prints were signed with the 
1864] 125 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Butterfly, followed by “‘ imp ” while the Butterfly alone was 
etched on the copper or drawn on the stone. He began 
to add the Butterfly to the signature to letters and to dedi- 
cations on prints. Then the Butterfly found its way to his 
invitation cards, and so it went on, until, at last, his corre- 
spondence, public and private, was usually signed with the 
Butterfly alone. This was elaborated in the most ingenious 
manner in The Gentle Art of Making Enemies, the Butterfly 
not only decorating, but actually punctuating the pages. 
On the frames of many of the early pictures, Japanese 
patterns, which always haunted him, were painted in red 
or blue on the flat gold, and a Butterfly placed on them, 
always in relation to the picture. He designed the frames, 
and they were carried out by the Greaves in the beginning, 
while later, shortly before his death, a few were done by his 
stepson, E. Godwin. The Sarasate, in Pittsburg, is an ex- 
cellent example of one of these frames; the Battersea Bridge, 
at the Tate Gallery, is another. Whistler used a similar 
scheme in framing his etchings, water-colours, and pastels, 
reddish lines, and at times the Butterfly, appearing on the 
white or gold of the frames. In after years, he not only 
ceased almost entirely to use these painted frames, but he 
designed a simple gold frame, with parallel reeded lines on 
the outer edge, for the paintings, now universally known as 
““the Whistler frame.” For his etchings and lithographs 
also, he gave up the decoration and employed a plain white 
frame in two planes. His canvases and his panels were 
always of the same sizes; consequently they always fitted 
his frames. And in his studio, as in few, if any, others, 
frequently there might be half a hundred canvases with 
their faces to the wall, and only half a dozen frames. But 
they all fitted, and Whistler never showed a picture un- 
framed. All this was the outcome of the Japanese influence, 
and of his knowledge of the way the Japanese display their 
126 [1864 


CHELSEA DAYS 


art. His deference to Japanese convention went so far that 
he often put a branch of a tree or a reed into the foreground 
of his seas and rivers as decoration, with no reference to the 
picture, sometimes the only Japanese suggestion in the design. 

The Lange Leizen—of the Six Marks went tothe Academy 
of 1864, and so did the Wapping. The Japanese subject 
seemed ‘ quaint” to the critic of the Atheneum, and the 
drawing “‘ preposterously incorrect,” but he could not deny 
the “ superb colouring,” the “ beautiful harmonies”; while 
in Wapping he saw an “incomparable view of the Lower 
Pool of London.” ‘‘ Never before was that familiar scene 
so triumphantly well painted,’ Mr. W. M. Rossetti wrote, 
and he considered Whistler’s 

‘“‘on the whole, the most thoroughly satisfying works in the 

Academic gallery to the artistic sense. His is the art of con- 

cealing art, yet always with so fine an originality that to the 

perceptive eye the art is the one main and supreme constituent 
of the whole, the sum of its total result. He realises, through 

Nature for the sake of art, an aim as legitimate as the more 

usual one of realising through art for the sake of Nature, and even 

more intrinsically pictorial.” 

He was now working out of the frankly artificial scheme 
of the Japanese pictures to a phase in which he was more 
himself than he had ever been before. A year after the 
exhibition of the Lange Leizen, he sent to the Academy of 
1865 the most individual, the most complete, the most 
perfect picture he ever painted at any period: The Little 
White Girl, which artists, with reason, rank as one of the 
few great pictures of the world. It was dated 1864 originally 
and there are reproductions showing the date. But about 
1900 he painted it out. He had been working on the picture 
he told us, and “ did not see the use of those great figures 
sprawling there.” ‘“ Joe” was the model. Now, there 
was no masquerading in foreign finery. Whistler painted 
her, as he must often have seen her, in her simple white 
1865] 127 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


gown, leaning against the mantel, her beautiful face reflected 
in the mirror. The room was not littered purposely with 
his purchases from the little shops in the Strand and the 
Rue de Rivoli. Japan is in the detail of blue and white on 
the mantel ; the girl holds a Japanese fan; a spray of azalea 
trails across her dress. But these were part of Whistler’s 
house, part of the reality he had created for himself, and he 
made them no more beautiful than the mantel, the grate of 
the English house, than the reflection in the mirror. There 
was no building up, he painted what he saw. The things 
actually near and around him were lovelier than any studio 
arrangement. And there was in the method the beginning 
of change. The paint is thinner on the canvas, the brush 
flows more freely. Method and design alike give the repose 
of the perfect work. The Litile White Girl is now owned by 
Mr. Arthur Studd. 

The picture had not gone to the Academy when Swinburne 
saw it, and wrote Before the Mirror: Verses under a Picture. 
The poem is said to have been printed on gold paper, 
fastened somehow to the frame, which has disappeared, 
and two verses were inserted in the catalogue as sub-title. 
These must have been the lines Whistler thought best 
interpreted the beauty he meant to express : 

Come snow, come wind or thunder, 
High up in air, 

I watch my face, and wonder 
At my bright hair ; 

Naught else exalts or grieves 


The rose at heart, that heaves 
With love of her own leaves and lips that pair. 


I cannot see what pleasures 
Or what pains were ; 
What pale new loves and treasures 
New years will bear ; 
What beam will fall, what shower, 
What grief or joy for dower ; 
But one thing knows the flower—the flower is fair. 


128 [1865 


CHELSEA DAYS 


Other lines show as well how sympathetically Swinburne 
felt the beauty of the picture : 


White rose in red rose-garden 
Is not so white ;— 


and again in the verse where he calls The Little White Girl 
‘‘ White sister ” : 


My hand, a fallen rose, 
Lies snow-white on white snows, and takes no care. 


Swinburne’s poem could not make The Little White Girl 
at the Academy better understood than The White Girl had 
been in Berners Street. The rare few could appreciate its 
“charm” and “ exquisiteness ” with Mr. W. M. Rossetti, 
who found that it was “crucially tested by its proximity 
to the flashing white in Mr. Millais’ Esther,” but that it stood 
the test, “‘ retorting delicious harmony for daring force, and 
would shame any other contrast.” But the more general 
opinion was all the other way. The Atheneum distinguished 
itself by regretting this year that Whistler should make 
the “ most ‘ bizarre ’ of bipeds ”’ out of the women he painted. 
There was praise for two of his other three pictures. ‘‘ Subtle 
beauty of colour” and “ almost mystical delicacy of tone ” 
were discovered in The Gold Screen, and ‘colour such as 
painters love ’”’ in the Old Battersea Bridge, afterwards Brown 
and Silver. This is the beautiful grey Battersea, with 
the touch of red in the roofs of the opposite shore, the link 
between the early paintings on the river and the Nocturnes 
that were to follow. The Scar}, a picture we do not recognise, 
attracted less attention, and Whistler, who, only the year 
before, had been declared “‘ one of the most original artists 
of the day,” was now dismissed as one who “ might be 
called half a great artist.” But stranger than this was 
the change in the attitude of the French critics, which we 
cannot account for. In 1863, they overwhelmed him with 
praise. Two years later, they had hardly a good word to 
1865] L-¥ 129 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


say for him. Lévi Lagrange, now forgotten as he merits, 
wrote the criticism of the Royal Academy of 1865 for the 
Gazette des Beaux-Arts, and all he could see in The Little 
White Girl was a weak repetition of The White Girl, a weari- 
some variation of the theme of white; really, he said, it 
was quite witty—fort spirituel—of the Academicians, who 
could have refused this and the two Japanese pictures, to 
give them good places, and so deliver them over to judgment. 
And then he praised Horseley and Prinsep, Leslie and Land- 
seer. The Princesse du Pays de la Porcelaine, exhibited in 
the Salon, made no more favourable impression. It seemed 
nothing but a study of costume to Paul Mantz, who, in the 
Gazette des Beaux-Arts, decided to forget it and remember 
merely the mysterious seduction of The White Girl of two 
years before. Its eccentricity was only possible if taken 
in small doses like the homceopathist’s pills, according to 
Jules Claretie, who in the same article, in L’ Artiste, laughed 
at Manet’s Olympia as a jest, a parody. More than twenty 
years were to pass before, in Paris, praise of Whistler came 
into vogue again. 

Whistler’s only other appearance at the Salon this 
year was in Fantin’s Hommage a la Verité, one of the 
two large groups including Whistler’s portrait which Fantin 
painted. The other, done the year before, was the 
Hommage a Delacroix, who had died in 1868. Whistler 
was among the several admirers whom Fantin repre- 
sented, gathered round the portrait of the dead’ master. 
Whistler wanted Fantin to find a place for Rossetti, and. 
Fantin was willing, but Rossetti could not manage to get 
to Paris, or to stay there, for the necessary sittings, and 
unfortunately for him he was left out of one of the most 
celebrated portrait groups of modern times, now in the 
Moreau-Nélaton Collection in the Louvre. The distinguished 


artists and men of letters in the group were there nominally 
130 [1865 


(F98L ‘Uorvsy “unognT-uuumz fig anqord ay? WoL) 


XIOWOVING VY TOVWNWOH 


ollvpopneg qouryy In0jv'J-UUBT Aqueinqg. 
AOI [VL 9 puowonbowig Armoydueyg TOTISTU AA $0.189'T IOIpIop 


CHELSEA DAYS 


out of respect to the memory of Delacroix, but really to 
enable Fantin to justify his belief in the beauty of life as it 
is, and his protest against the classical dictionary and studio 
properties. Most of the men in the group were, or have 
since become, famous: Whistler, Manet, Legros, Bracque- 
mond, Fantin, Baudelaire, Duranty, Champfleury, Cordier, 
De Balleroy. Fantin painted them in the costume of the 
moment, as Rembrandt and Hals and Van der Helst, from 
whom he is said to have got the idea, painted the regents 
and archers of seventeenth-century Holland. Fantin’s 
white shirt is the one concession to picturesqueness, and the 
one relief to the severity of detail are the flowers on the 
table in front of Whistler, a lithe, erect, youthful figure, 
with fine keen face and abundant hair. That the young 
American should be the centre of the group was a distinction 
he could better appreciate than any one. When Rossetti 
saw the picture, he wrote to his brother that it had “a 
great deal of very able painting in parts, but it is a great 
slovenly scrawl after all, like the rest of this incredible new 
school.”” The picture was shown in the Salon of 1864, 
followed in 1865 by the Hommage a la Verité,—le Toast. 

In this, Fantin strayed so far from the Real as to introduce 
an allegorical figure of Truth, and to allow Whistler to array 
himself in a gorgeous Chinese robe. “ Pense a la robe, 
superbe @ faire, et donne la moi!” Whistler urged from 
London, and Fantin yielded. ‘Je lat encore revu dans 
V atelier en 1865, il me posa dans un tableau aujourd hui détruit 
‘ Le Toast,’ ou il était costumé dune robe J aponaise,” is Fantin’s 
story of it in the notes which we have already quoted, but 
Whistler, writing at the time, speaks of the costume as 
Chinese. He brought it over to Paris for the sittings. 
Fantin was quick to regret his concessions. An allegorical 
figure could not be made real, the whole thing was absurd. 
When he got the canvas back, he destroyed it, all but the 
1865] I31 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


portraits of Whistler, Vollon and himself. Whistler’s is now 
in the New York Public Library, the gift of Mr. Avery. 

In the spring of 1865 Whistler was joined in London by 
his younger brother. Dr. Whistler had distinguished himself 
in the Confederate Army as surgeon, and by his bravery in 
the field. He had served in the Richmond Hospitals and in 
Libby Prison; he had been assistant-surgeon at Drewry’s 
Bluff, and, in 1864, when Grant made his movement against 
Richmond, he had been assigned to Orr’s Rifles, a celebrated 
South Carolina regiment. In the early winter of 1865, a 
few months’ furlough was given him, and he was entrusted 
by the Government in Richmond with important despatches 
for Liverpool. Sherman’s advance prevented his running 
the blockade from Charleston, nor was there any passing 
through the lines from Wilmington by sea. He was obliged 
to go north through Maryland, which meant making his way 
round Grant’s lines. The difficulties and dangers were end- 
less. He had to get rid of his Confederate uniform, and in 
the state of Confederate finance, the most modest suit of 
clothes cost fourteen hundred dollars; for a seat in an am- 
bulance or waggon he had to pay five hundred. The trains 
were crowded by officials and soldiers, and he could get a 
ride in them only by stealth. The roads were abominable, 
for driving, or riding, or walking. Often he was alone, and his 
one companion, toward the last, was more of a hindrance 
than a help. This was a fellow soldier who had lost a leg 
at Antietam, and was now trying to get to Philadelphia for 
repairs to an artificial leg, manufactured there and grown 
rusty. Stanton’s expedition filled the country near the 
Rappahannock with snares and pitfalls; to cross Chesa- 
peake Bay was to take one’s life in one’s hands; and north 
of the Bay were the enrolling officers of the Union, in search 
of conscripts. However, Philadelphia was at last reached, 


and a ticket for New York bought at the railroad depét, 
132 [1865 


CHELSEA DAYS 


where two sentries, with bayonets fixed, guarded the ticket- 
office, and might, for all Dr. Whistler knew, have seen him 
in Libby Prison. This, he said, was the worst moment of 
all. In New York he took passage on the City of Manchester 
and from Liverpool he hurried to London. One week later 
came the news of the fall of Richmond and the Confederacy. 
The furlough was over. There was no going back. It was 
probably about this time, from the costume and the technical 
resemblance to Mr. Luke Ionides’ portrait that Whistler 
painted a very interesting head of Dr. Whistler—Portrait 
of My Brother—owned by Mrs. Dr. Whistler. It is carried 
out in the same solid fashion that characterises the other 
portraits of the period. 

With the end of the war, many other Southern men who 
could not return home drifted into London and to the house 
in Lindsey Row. Adventure was in the air, was before 
long to send Whistler in search of it himself. 

Early in September of 1865, Whistler’s mother was suffer- 
ing from serious trouble with her eyes, and went with her 
two sons to Coblentz, to be under the care of a celebrated 
oculist. This gave Whistler an opportunity to go again 
over the ground of the Rhine journey. After that, he spent 
some time at Trouville, where he was joined by Courbet, 
who had come for his first look at the sea and was so impressed 
that he stayed on. Whistler’s work shows how far he had 
drifted away from Courbet, though the two were always the 
best of friends. But Whistler had ceased to be the pupil. 
He had studied, and experimented, and solved problems 
for himself, since Courbet praised his Piano Picture, since 
he painted his Coast of Brittany with its Courbet-like rocks 
along the shore, and his Blue Wave breaking with Courbet- 
like force on the sands at Biarritz. In Sea and Rain, done 
then at Trouville, there is not a suggestion of Courbet. But 
we have seen seas by Courbet, owned by M. Duret, that 
1865] 133 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Whistler might have signed. ‘“ Joe” was there, too, and 
Courbet found time to paint her with her ‘* copper-coloured 
hair.” Whistler lingered late on the French coast. The 
sea-pieces he had begun, including Courbet on the Shore, now 
owned by Mrs. J. C. Gardner, promised great things, and 
as the autumn went on, the place was more quiet for work, 
and the seas and skies more wonderful. He did not get 
back to London until November. A few months later, early 
in 1866, he sailed for Valparaiso. 

This journey to Valparaiso is the most unaccountable 
adventure in his sometimes unaccountable career. Various 
reasons for it have been given : health, a quarrel, restlessness, 
a whim. But we tell the story as he told it to us: 


“It was a moment when many of the adventurers the war 
had made of many Southerners, were knocking about London, 
hunting for something to do, and, I hardly knew how, but the 
something resolved itself into an expedition to go and help the 
Chilians and, I cannot say why, the Peruvians too. Anyhow, 
there were South Americans to be helped against the Spaniards. 
Some of these people came to me, as a West Point man, and 
asked me to join—and it was all done in an afternoon. I was 
off at once in a steamer from Southampton to Panama. We 
crossed the Isthmus, and it was all very awful—earthquakes 
and things—and I vowed, once I got home, that nothing would 
ever bring me back again. 

“1 found myself in Valparaiso, and in Santiago, and I called 
on the President, or whoever the person then in authority was. 
After that came the bombardment. There was the beautiful 
bay with its curving shores, the town of Valparaiso on one side, 
on the other, the long line of hills. And there, just at the en- 
trance of the bay, was the Spanish fleet, and, in between, the 
English fleet, and the French fleet, and the American fleet, and 
the Russian fleet, and all the other fleets. And when the morning 
came, with great circles and sweeps, one after another sailed out 
into the open sea, until the Spanish fleet alone remained. It 
drew up right in front of the town, and bang went a shell, and 
the bombardment began. The Chilians didn’t pretend to defend 
themselves. The people all got out of the way, and I and the 

134 [1866 


V7 1 {VALPARAISO 
(Nocturne, Blue and Gold) (Study for the large picture) 


Ger As 04,12] 


STUDY OF BATTERSEA BRIDGE 
(Chalk Drawing) 


STUDIES FOR THE SIX PROJECTS 


STUDIES FOR THE SIX PROJECTS 


SYMPHONY IN WHITE, NO. III. 


CHELSEA DAYS 


officials rode to the opposite hills, where we could look on. The 
Spaniards conducted the performance in the most gentlemanly 
fashion ; they just set fire to a few of the houses, and once, with 
some sense of fun, sent a shell whizzing over toward our hills. 
And then I knew what a panic was. I and the officials turned 
and rode as hard as we could, anyhow, anywhere. The riding 
was splendid, and I, as a West Point man, was head of the pro- 
cession. By noon, the performance was over. The Spanish 
fleet sailed again into position, the other fleets sailed in, sailors 
landed to help put out the fires, and I and the officials rode back 
into Valparaiso. All the little girls of the town had turned out, 
waiting for us, and as we rode in called us ‘Cowards!’ The 
Henriquetta, the ship fitted up in London, did not appear till 
long after, and then we breakfasted, and that was the end of it.” 


Mr. Theodore Roussel says Whistler once told him that, 
on another occasion, he got on one of the defending gunboats. 
and had his baptism of fire amid a rain of shot and shell, a 
fact which, fine as it is, he omitted from his story to us. 

He made good use of his time in Valparaiso, and 
painted the three pictures of the harbour which are known 
and two others which have disappeared. These he gave to 
the steward, or the purser of the ship, to bring home, and 
the purser kept them. Once they were seen in his rooms, or 
house, in London by some one who recognised Whistler’s 
work. ‘* Why, they must be by Whistler!” hesaid. “ Who’s 
Whistler ?”’ asked the purser. “ An artist,” said the other. 
‘“* Oh, no,” said the purser, “‘ they were painted by a gentle- 
man.” The purser started back for South America, and 
took them with him. ‘And then a tidal wave met the 
ship and swept off the purser, the cabin and the Whistlers.”’ 

The voyage back was vaguer than the voyage out. From 
this vagueness looms one figure: the Marquis de Marmalade, 
a black man from Hayti, who made himself obnoxious to 
Whistler, apparently by his colour and his swagger. One 
day Whistler kicked him across the deck to the top of the 
companion way, and there sat a lady who proved an obstacle 
1866] 135 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


for the moment. But Whistler just picked up the Marquis 
de Marmalade, dropped him on the step below her, and 
finished kicking him downstairs. After that, Whistler 
spent the rest of the journey, not exactly in irons, but chiefly 
in his cabin. 

The final adventure of the journey was in London. Whistler 
never told us, but everybody else says that when he got out 
of the train at Euston, or Waterloo, some one, besides his 
friends was waiting: whether the captain of the ship, or 
relations of the Marquis de Marmalade, or an old enemy, 
really makes little difference. Somebody got a thrashing, 
and this was the end to the most extraordinary and un- 
accountable episode in Whistler’s life. 


136 [1866 


PORTRAIT’ 


OF WHISTLER 
(Chalk Drawing) 


eet 
aes 


one: Me 7 cont bosiste vt: faakt bie 


adn ae ne alt He ot “ ie 
res eal ann ae sulk io * shored ee ah: i 
£6 abbas 


CHAPTER XII. CHELSEA DAYS CON- 
TINUED. THE YEARS EIGHTEEN 
HUNDRED AND SIXTY-SIX TO 
KIGHTEEN HUNDRED AND SEVENTY- 
TWO. 


T was late in 1866 when Whistler returned from Valparaiso. 
Soon after, he moved into No. 2, at the east end of 
Lindsey Row, now No. 96 Cheyne Walk. It was a three- 
story house with an attic, part of the old palace remodelled, 
and, like No. 7, it looked on the river, only a few yards away. 
Here he lived longer than anywhere else, here he painted 
the Nocturnes and the great portraits, here he gave his 
Sunday breakfasts. He had a friendly house-warming on 
February 5 (1867), when the two Rossettis dined with him, 
and Mr. W. M. Rossetti wrote in his diary: | 
“There are some fine old fixtures, such as doors, fireplaces, 
and Whistler has got up the rooms with many delightful Japanes- 
isms. Saw for the first time his pagoda cabinet. He has two 
or three sea-pieces new to me: one, on which he particularly 
lays stress, larger than the others, a very grey unbroken sea 

[probably Sea and Rain], also a clever vivacious portrait of 

himself begun.” 

No doubt, this is the portrait in round hat, paint-brushes 
in his hand, owned by the late Mr. George McCullough, the 
first oil in which the white lock appears. 

Mr. Greaves says that the dining-room at No. 2 was blue, 
with a darker blue dado and doors, and purple Japanese 
fans tacked on the walls and ceiling ; other friends remember 
“a fluttering of purple fans’: the fans “ broidered_” at the 
1867] 137 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


foot of Fusiyama, to him as beautiful as the marbles of the 
Parthenon. One evening when Miss Chapman was dining 
there, and Whistler wanted her to see the view up the river 
from the other end of the bridge as he was painting it, he 
told her, if she would come out with him, he would show her 
something “as lovely as a fan!’ The studio, again the 
second-story back room, was grey, with black dado and doors ; 
from the Mother and the Carlyle, one knows that there were 
Japanese hangings and prints on the walls; and in it was 
the big screen, which he painted for Leyland but always 
kept for himself, with Battersea Bridge running across the 
top, Chelsea Church beyond, and a great gold moon in the 
blue sky. The stairs were covered with Dutch metal. He 
slept in a huge Chinese bed. Beautiful silver was on his 
table. He ate off blue and white. ‘‘ Suppose one of these 
plates was smashed ?”” Miss Chapman asked Whistler once. 
“Why, then—you know,” he said, “‘ we might as well all 
take hands and go throw ourselves into the Thames!” 
The beauty of the decoration, as at No. 7, was its sim- 
plicity, an innovation when men were wavering between the 
riot of Victorian vulgarity and the overpowering opulence 
of Morris medizvalism. From descriptions, Rossetti’s house 
was a museum, an antiquity shop, in comparison. The 
simplicity seemed the more bewildering because it was the 
growth, not of weeks, but of years. The drawing-room was 
not painted until the day of Whistler’s first dinner-party. 
In the morning he sent for his pupils, the brothers Greaves, 
to help him. “It will never be dry in time!” they feared. 
‘* What matter?” said Whistler, “it will be beautiful!” 
‘* We three worked like mad,” is Mr. Walter Greaves’ account, 
and by evening the walls were flushed with flesh-colour, pale 
yellow and white spread over doors and woodwork, the . 
tapestries were in place, and, we have heard, gowns and 
coats too were touched with flesh-colour and yellow before 
138 [1867 


eek ae 
PRrernapicalesie no 
enact came Birr aseonn So 


a 


eee. 


a 


Ap NNN 


K AND WHITE CHALK 


IN BLAC 


STUDIES 


Projects) 


(Aa 


(For the S 


CHELSEA DAYS 


the evening was at an end. One Sunday morning, Whistler, 
hurrying home after he had taken his mother to Chelsea 
Church, as he always did, again sent for his pupils, and painted 
a great ship with spreading sails in each of the two panels 
at the end of the hall. His mother was not so pleased when, 
on her return, she saw the blue and white harmony, for she 
would have had him put away his brushes on Sunday as once 
she had put away his toys. But she had many other trials 
and revelations: coming into the studio one day, she found 
the parlour-maid posing for “‘ the allover! ’’ The ships were 
in place long before the dado of hall and stairway was covered 
with gold, and sprinkled with rose and white chrysanthemum 
petals. Miss Alexander (Mrs. Spring-Rice) saw Whistler 
at work upon it when she came to sit, and he had lived six 
years at No. 2. Not one of Whistler’s houses was ever 
completely decorated and furnished; they had a look as if 
he had just moved in, or was just moving out; often there 
were packing-cases and trunks about, but as much as was 
finished was always beautiful. 

Whistler was represented at all the important exhibitions 
of 1867, in London and Paris. He began the year by sending 
to the French Gallery, in January, one of the pictures painted 
in Valparaiso: Crépuscule in Flesh Colour and Green it is 
now called, the property of Mr. Graham Robertson. It is 
the long picture of Valparaiso Harbour in the early evening, 
ships moored with partly furled sails; the first painting of 
twilight, and one of the first paintings carried out in the 
liquid manner of the later Nocturnes. In this there is a 
great advance: it is the first of the Nocturnes. There were 
critics then to call it a ‘‘ poem in colour,” though Whistler had 
not yet taught them to look for the “‘ painter’s poetry ”’ in 
his work. The upright Valparaiso, a perfect Nocturne, was 
done at the same time, 1866, but not exhibited until after- 
wards. It was owned by Mr. George McCullough, and 
1867] 139 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


another unfinished version of the same subject, belonged to 
Mr. T. R. Way. ) 

In the Salon of 1867, where it had been rejected eight 
years before, At the Piano was accepted, and also The Thames 
in Ice—Sur la Tamise: UHiver. It was the year of the 
French International Exhibition. Whistler was not invited 
to exhibit in the British section. Mr. W. M. Rossetti notes 
in his diary : 

“March 29 (1867)— .... Whistler looked in. He says 
that he never from first to last received any invitation to con- 
tribute to the British section of the Paris Exhibition. This 
might seem invidious, but the result is that he gets in the American 


section much more space than could have been allotted him 
in the British.” 


Whistler’s name was hardly known in America, and M. 
Duret writes that, probably, Mr. George Lucas spoke of 
Whistler to Mr. Avery, the Art Commissioner for the United 
States at the Exhibition. The result was that a number of 
his etchings and four pictures were hung: The White Girl, 
Wapping or On the Thames, Old Battersea Bridge, Twilight 
on the Ocean, the title then of the Graham Robertson Val- 
paraiso. The Hudson River school dominated American art, 
and Whistler’s paintings had to compete with the big machines 
of Church and Bierstadt. Tuckerman, in his Book of the 
Artists, quotes an unnamed American critic who, in 1867, 
found that Whistler’s etchings differed from his paintings 
in meriting the attention they attracted, for he could see 
in the Marines only “ blurred, foggy imperfections,” and | 
in The White Girl only 


“a powerful female with red hair, and a vacant stare in her 
soullesseyes. She is standing on a wolf-skin hearth-rug, for what 
reason is unrecorded. The picture evidently means vastly 
more than it expresses—albeit expressing too much. Notwith- 
standing an obvious want of purpose, there is some boldness in 
140 [1867 


SEA-BEACH AND FIGURES 
(Pastel) 
(Study for the Six Projects) 


STUDY OF A NUDE 
(Chalk Drawing) 
(Studies for the Six Projects) 


“oad lait dn Saisie nee ahhd Hi C. 
etenise ak peti tio Po, peat Oye 
a ite paige 


& io ne sip ae : 


CHELSEA DAYS 


the handling, and singularity in the glare of the colours which 
cannot fail to divert the eye and weary it.” 


The Americans were not treated with much respect by 
the Hanging Committee. Their work was put in corridors 
and dark corners, and Whistler undoubtedly suffered from 
the hanging. But this does not account for the fact that the 
French critics, enthusiastic four years before, were now hardly 
more appreciative than the American. Paul Mantz no 
longer saw poetry in this “‘ strange white apparition”; he 
was distressed by the head, which had always been to him of 
insupportable ugliness ; and, consistent in his inconsistency, 
he pointed to the charming and rare relations in dress and 
rug, though, when the picture was at the Salon des Refusés, 
the rug had created discord for him. Burty now thought that 
the prints shared the fate of the paintings, that either time 
had not been favourable to them, exaggerating their defects, 
or else critical eyes had lost their indulgence. The etch- 
ings were photographic, and had a dryness and minuteness, 
due, no doubt, to the early training of “ Mr. Whystler.”’ 
Both these men were writing in the Gazette des Beaux-Arts. 

Whistler was, nevertheless, satisfied with his success, and 
to enjoy it he and his brother, Dr. Whistler, went to Paris 
early in April. The enjoyment was interrupted by an event 
of whichwe should say nothing, had not too much been already 
said for it to be ignored. It ought never to have been made 
public, but then Whistler’s affairs always were made public, 
through no fault of his. The incident is to his honour, 
showing that he was generous and staunch to his friends. 

In Paris, the brothers heard of the death of Mr. Traer, 
Seymour Haden’s assistant, a member of the British Jury, 
on which Haden also served. Traer was always liked by 
Whistler, to whom he sat for one of the group in the etching 
of The Music Room, and one of the figures in the dry-point 
Encamping. Circumstances in connection with ‘Traer’s 
1867] . 141 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


death and burial led to a misunderstanding between the 
two brothers and the brother-in-law. Seymour Haden 
was in Paris and the three met. The dispute was short 
and sharp, and the result was a summons for the two 
brothers to appear before a juge de paix. Whistler had 
appeared in the same court only a few days earlier. A 
workman had dropped plaster on him as he passed through 
a narrow street in the Latin Quarter, and he had met the 
offence in the one way possible, according to his code, 
Whistler had then sent for the American Minister, and the 
magistrate had apologised. But when he appeared this 
time, “‘ Connu!” said the juge de paix and there was no 
apology, but a fine. Haden said he fell through a plate-glass 
window, Whistler that he knocked him through. Haden 
maintained that both brothers were against him, Whistler 
that he demolished Haden single-handed. 

It happened just when London gossip got hold of the 
story of the Marquis de Marmalade and Whistler’s arrival 
in London from Valparaiso. Dr. Moncure Conway, in his 
Reminiscences, recalls a dinner given by Dante Rossetti to 
W. J. Stillman, in the winter of 1867, when 


** Whistler (a Confederate) related with satisfaction his fisticuff 
with a Yankee [really the black Marquis] on ship-board, William 
Rossetti remarked: ‘I must say, Whistler, that your conduct 
was scandalous.’ (Stillman and myself were silent.) Dante 
Gabriel promptly wrote : 

‘There’s a combative Artist named Whistler 
Who is, like his own hog-hairs, a bristler : 
A tube of white lead 


And a punch on the head 
Offer varied attractions to Whistler.’ ”’ 


It was at this time, too, that Whistler had a difference 
with Legros, to which no reference would be made had it 
not also become a legend. Friends tried to reconcile them, 


and only succeeded in spreading the report of the difference. 
142 [1867 


(spoafold wig oy) Lof sarpn7g)) 
(22)8Dq) (Y19Y)) 


ATIT GHL AGOLS AGON 


tad 


ae he? 


éF his 
AED 


CHELSEA DAYS 


It is in these matters one regrets that Whistler did not tell 
his own story. The rumours spread, and, within a month 
or two, Whistler began to be talked of as quarrelsome: there 
had been no such talk before the journey to South America. 
Then Haden, back in London, resigned his post as honorary 
surgeon to South Kensington Museum, printed a pamphlet to 
explain, and threatened to resign from the Burlington Fine 
Arts Club, of which both he and Whistler were members, 
unless Whistler was expelled. Mr. W. M. Rossetti’s diary 
furnishes these details : 

“ June 13, 1867.—Whistler . . . has been written to by the 
Burlington Club, if he does not resign on account of the Haden 
row, they would have to consider his expulsion . . . Gabriel 
and I agree in considering this very improper, as it amounts to 
condemning one member unheard on the ipse dixit of the other. 


.. . December 13, 1867.—Whistler’s expulsion was voted by eighteen 
against eight. . . I handed in my resignation to Wornum.” 


Two or three days later, December 17: 

‘‘ Gabriel has now sent in his resignation to the Burlington Club.” 
To us Mr. W. M. Rossetti writes : 

“When a motion was brought on for expelling him from the 
Burlington Fine Arts Club, I moved a counter-resolution, and, 
on the motion for expulsion being carried, I resigned my member- 
ship of theclub. My opinion in that matter was not that Whistler 
had been blameless in the conduct which led to the motion for 
expulsion, but that the club had no claim to interfere in an affair 
which had not occurred in the club premises, nor even in the 
United Kingdom.” 


Whistler’s manner of resenting injury had a great deal to 
do with his future, and with the way he was treated in 
England. People who did not know him became afraid of 
him, and this fear grew, and was the reason of the reputation 
that clung to him for years, and that clings to his memory. 

Before Whistler’s pictures went to the Royal Academy, 
Mr. W. M. Rossetti saw them : 

1867] 143 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


‘“* March 31 (1867).—To see Whistler’s pictures for the R.A. 
To the R.A. he means to send Symphony in White, No. III. 
(heretofore named The Two Inttle White Girls), and a Thames 
picture ; possibly also one of the four sea pictures ; and I rather 
recommended him to select the largest of these, which he regards 
with predilection, of a grey sea and a very grey sky.” 


Battersea, the grey river with barges going up with the 
tide, was the Thames picture decided upon; Sea and Rain, 
painted when Whistler and Courbet worked together at 
Trouville, was the sea picture; and The Two Little White 
Girls, at present in Mr. Davis’ collection, was sent under 
its new name, Symphony in White, No. III.; the first time 
one of his pictures was catalogued as a Symphony, his first 
use of a title borrowed from musical terms to explain his 
pictorial intentions. 

Baudelaire had already given him the hint, and 
Gautier had already written symphonies in verse. One 
of Murger’s Bohemians had already composed a Symphonie 
sur Vinfluence du bleu dans les arts. In 1863 Paul Mantz 
had described The White Girl as a “ Symphony in White.” 
There can be no doubt that from these things Whistler got 
the name that in the Academy passed for a deliberate 
affectation, an insult to the people’s intelligence. The 
picture in itself might not have offended. It was his third 
variation of his study of white upon white. Some of the 
detail of The Little White Girl was repeated. The only 
difference was that now there were two figures instead of 
one, and that the change of his technique, from the use of 
thick to thin flowing paint, was more apparent than ever. 
The offence was in the title. The critic of the Atheneum 
had the sense to thank the “ painter who endeavours by any 
means to show people what he really aims at.”’ But he was 
almost alone. Burty, in noticing the Academy of 1867 for 
the Gazette des Beaux-Arts, thought the Academy’s hanging 
144 [1867 


DESIGN FOR A FAN 


(Water-colour) 


TILLIE: A MODEL 
(Dry-point) 
(Studies for the Six Projects) 


CHELSEA DAYS 


Whistler at all a fine piece of irony, and took the occasion 
to regret the painter’s failure to fulfil his early promise, a 
regret the British critics repeated until the end of the artist’s 
life. 

Hamerton, in the Saturday Review, June 1, 1867, repre- 
sented still better the general feeling of the insulted, solemn, 
bewildered ones : 


“There are many dainty varieties of tint, but it is not 
precisely a symphony in white. One lady has a yellowish dress 
and brown hair and a bit of blue ribbon; the other has 
a red fan, and there are flowers and green leaves. There is a 
girl in white on a white sofa, but even this girl has reddish hair ; 
and of course there is the flesh-colour of the complexions.” 


Whistler answered in a letter, first published, however, 
in the Art Journal for April 1887, and afterwards in the 
Gentle Art of Making Enemies : 


“Bon Dieu! did this wise person expect white hair and 
chalked faces ? And does he then, in his astounding consequence, 
believe that a symphony in F contains no other note, but shall 
be a continued repetition of F FF? ... Fool!” 


Whistler believed that to carry on tradition was the 
artist’s business. Rembrandt, Velasquez, Claude, Canaletto, 
Guardi, Hogarth, Courbet, the Japanese, in turn influenced 
him. Some see, at this period, the influence of Albert Moore, 
which, if it existed at all, was as ephemeral and superficial 
as Rossetti’s. It could be argued with more truth that 
Whistler influenced Albert Moore, who, for at least two 
pictures, Harmony of Orange and Pale Yellow, Variation of 
Blue and Gold, borrowed Whistler’s titles. Whistler also 
believed that the study of the masters could have no other 
end than to evolve something entirely personal, and, in the 
endeavour to develop his personality, he was passing through 
a moment of experiments, difficulties and discouragements. 
1867] wus 145 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


All this we find in his letters to Fantin, to whom he explained 
the study of white upon white, elaborated in his three 
Symphonies in White. A fourth was started: some say 
the Three Figures intended for Leyland. In the Two Girls, 
he wrote to Fantin, the harmony was repeated in line as in 
colour, and he sent a sketch of it. Alternately he exulted 
in the rhythm of the lines, and despaired because he could 
not give this rhythm as he would. The picture was scraped 
down and repainted, and with each fresh difficulty he de- 
plored the mistakes of his early training. Mr. Eddy says 
that Whistler used to call Ingres the “‘ bourgeois Greek.” 
This we never heard him say, nor is there any such want of 
respect in his letters to Fantin, for there he expresses regret 
that he did not study under Ingres, whose work he may 
have liked moderately, but from whom he would have 
learned to draw : which was an absurd piece of modesty for 
he drew better than Ingres, as his etchings prove. He never 
execrated Courbet, nor denounced ce damné Réalisme, so 
violently as in the autumn of 1867, and it was not quite 
fair, for Realism had brought Courbet to the conclusions 
which Whistler, unaided, was now reaching: that study of 
art, ancient and modern, familiarity with tradition, has no 
other object than the development of one’s own individuality, 
and that the artist is to go to Nature for inspiration, but to 
take from it only its life and its beauty. Whistler, in his 
impatience, recalled Realism as practised by the young 
enthusiasts gathered about Courbet, and denied vigorously 
that Courbet could have influenced him. “Ca ne pouvait 
pas étre autrement, parce que je suis trés personnel, et que fat 
été riche en qualités qwil n’avait pas et qui me suffisaient.” 
The cry of “ Nature’ had appealed to his vanity as painter, 
Whistler said, and he had mocked at tradition, and in his 
early pictures had copied Nature with the self-confidence of 
‘* Pécolier débauché.” He chafed over the time he had lost 
146 [1867 


= 


7 : ee eB 


eda 


<< : ae iy 


Sey E ated <u ented 
i ra ie a 
| inate 


a eo oe My Pare i) 


ier BE tw Ie 
‘ k 5 bs | 


alt 
a , woe = x. SS 


a Fis ent at eh 


can 


stat reed Hy 


oes ’ rer ae ee £3 
Wid. 53 # cate aerate be TR See 


} a3 ies . Pee a aan ae ¢ oF -- * 
RNS aye cela aK. sinker Lena ire nay 
. na ‘ ex P - sw 


2 


CHELSEA DAYS 


before discovering for himself that art is not the exact 
reproduction of Nature, but its interpretation, and that the 
artist must seek his motives in Nature, and then weave 
from them a beautiful pattern on his canvas. Pattern, 
harmony, repetition are words ever recurring in his letters, 
as the same tone or colour recurs in his design, and was 
compared by him to the thread of silk running through 
a piece of embroidery. He was loud in praise of Fantin’s 
flowers, because he saw in them this repetition, this pattern. 
Passages in some of the letters might have come out of the 
Ten o’Clock. His definition of the relation of drawing to 
colour—‘‘ son amant, mais aussi son maitre’’—seems the 
-germ of the idea, there worked out, of the artist as the son 
and the master of Nature; ‘‘ her son in that he loves her, 
her master in that he knows her.”’ Whistler had a way of 
using the same idea over and over again, in his talk, in his 
letters, in his pamphlets, perfecting it with use, so that often 
it is impossible to say where a certain expression, phrase 
or doctrine originated. 

It was not only the change in his attitude toward Nature 
that was preocecupying him. He was perfecting the tech- 
nical method of which the beginnings are seen in the Sym- 
phonies in White, No. II. and No. III., and which was brought 
to perfection in the Nocturnes. Altogether, the period was 
one of transition, with its attendant hopes and fears. Those 
who saw him intimately know how hard he worked, and 
how endlessly he was discouraged. For a while he lived 
with Mr. Frederick Jameson, the architect. He never 
spoke to us of this interval away from Lindsey Row, and 
Mr. Jameson is certain only that it was about 1868 or 1869. 
Most likely it was in the winter of 1867-68, when Mrs. 
Whistler went home to visit her family and friends, whom 
the war had left poor and broken. Mr. Jameson was settled 
at!No. 62 Great Russell Street, Bloomsbury, in rooms that 
1868] . 147 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


had first been Burne-Jones’, and then Poynter’s. He 
writes us: 


**The seven months Whistler and I lived there together were 
unproductive and uneventful. He was working at some Japanese 
pictures, one of which, quite unfinished, was hung at the late 
exhibition of his pictures. I have seen that one—at least large 
portions of it—apparently completely finished, but they never 
satisfied him, and were shaved down to the bed-rock mercilessly. 
The man, as I knew him, was so different from the descriptions 
and presentations I have read of him, that I would like to speak 
of the other side to his character. It is impossible to conceive 
of a more unfailingly courteous, considerate and delightful 
companion than Whistler, as I found him. We lived in great 
intimacy, and the studio was always open to me, whatever he 
was doing. We had all our meals together, except when else- 
where engaged, and I never heard a complaint of anything in 
our simple household arrangements from him. Any little failure 
was treated as a joke. His courtesy to servants and models 
was particularly charming, indeed, I can’t conceive of his quarrel- 
ling with any one without real provocation. His talk about his 
own work revealed a very different man to me from the self- 
satisfied man he is usually believed to have been. He knew his 
powers, of course, but he was painfully aware of his defects— 
in drawing, for instance. I can remember with verbal accuracy 
some very striking talks we had on the subject. To my judg- 
ment, he was the most absolutely truthful man about himself 
that I ever met. I never knew him to hide an opinion or a 
thought—nor to try to excuse an action.” 


The picture Mr. Jameson refers to was in the London 
Memorial Exhibition, and there called Three Figures, Pink 
and Grey. It was the same design Whistler used for one 
of his Six Schemes or Projects,* which now all belong to Mr. 
Freer. In them, he was trying to combine Japanese and 
classical motives, expressing a beauty of form and design 
that haunted him, and was perhaps best realised in the little 
pastels of draped figures, classic in feeling, and as wholly 

* Mr. Fenellosa, in an article apparently inspired by Mr. Freer, says there are 


eight. 
148 [1868 


at, dotby. ah agaiders deine boon yaa 


ae 


ee ‘i PASE Ia 
SESE ah eats 
a eo i, Soe a 


5 ed Lee 


mite 
ee Get te 


ee SO 


3 e.. ‘ 2, hehe 


weenie $2, Bieta 
“| Fy $ ' bi REESE 


ia Pt 7 
Re 


4 ae _ \ 4 
Die peat’ Be ox 


HAR 


Por) eee a ee east Wis: Atm 
Ania 3h Fyrom: 


SPW a ot 


sa pastel a 


eee sue 


Dea eres wie sak 
Saat ae, 


CHELSEA DAYS 


his own in invention and arrangement as the Nocturnes and 
the portraits. He never ceased to make these classic studies. 
Years after, he gave Mr. T. R. Way a tiny drawing like a 
cameo, which we reproduce. And there are numbers of 
designs of the same sort owned by others. There are many 
pastels, chalk drawings and several etchings in which the 
separate figures of the Projects may be found, studies for the 
series which never was completed ; one, owned by Mr. C. H. 
Shannon, was worked out as a fan. Of the second version 
of the Three Figures, enlarged from a smaller design, Mr. 
Alan S. Cole remembers Whistler explaining it as an arrange- 
ment of beautiful lines he wanted to carry out, and then 
drawing in, with one sweep of the brush, the back of the 
stooping figure to show what he meant. Whether there 
was any commission for the series we are not sure, though 
Mr. W. M. Rossetti most likely referred to it when he 
wrote in his diary for July 28, 1867: 
*‘ Whistler is doing on a largish scale for Leyland the subject 
of women with flowers, and has made coloured sketches of four 


or five other subjects of the like class, very promising in point 
of conception of colour and arrangement.” 


It is probable, therefore, that the Projects were his first 
scheme of decoration for Leyland. The six canvases are 
all, virtually, the same size. They mark the new develop- 
ment in his technique and are painted with the thinnest, most 
liquid colour, the canvas often showing through, and 
nothing could be fresher and more spontaneous. The work 
in all, save the finished Venus, shown in the Paris Memorial 
Exhibition, and worked on in his later years, is more simple 
and direct than anything in oil he ever did. They have 
the same relation to his finished pictures as the sketches of 
Rubens and Tiepolo to their great decorations. The Venus 
stands alone, but, in the five others, two, three, or four 
women are grouped against a balustrade, round a vase of 
1868] 149 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


flowers, or on the sands with the sea beyond. In one 
especially, No. 8, Symphony in Green and Violet, the figures, in 
their strange beauty, recall Rossetti. Their floating draperies 
give the scheme of colour: No. 1, Symphony in White, the 
study for the larger version of the Three Figures; No. 4, 
Symphony in White and Red—“ full palette’ was his one 
comment on this when he asked Mr. Cole to come round 
and see it one Sunday ; No. 5, Variations in Blue and Green ; 
No. 6, Symphony in Blue and Rose. 

The experience gained by Whistler in making these designs 
was of immense use to him when he painted the Nocturnes, 
for the technique is the same, and the same treatment can be 
seen in the pile of drapery on the left in the Miss Alexander. 
He did not give up, until much later, this method of 
painting. He never, we believe, exhibited the designs, and 
it is doubtful if the complete series had been seen publicly 
before they were shown in Paris in 1905. During all his 
life, till the last when he was given a commission for a panel 
in the Boston Public Library, Whistler hoped to carry out 
some great decorative scheme. When the Central Gallery 
at South Kensington was being decorated by Leighton and 
others, Sir Henry Cole asked him to execute one of the panels 
in mosaic. For this, in the winter of 1873, he made a pastel 
of a richly robed figure carrying a Japanese umbrella. The 
scheme was in blue, purple and gold, and the pastel, owned 
by Mr. Graham Robertson, was shown at the London Memorial 
Exhibition as Design for a Mosaic. He spoke of it at the 
time as The Gold Girl. 'The small design was to be enlarged, 
and put on a big canvas, which his “ pupils,” the brothers 
Greaves, he said, would do for him. He was alive to its 
importance, he wrote to Mr. Alan S. Cole, and his pride in 
it was great. It has been stated that Sir Henry Cole offered 
him a studio in the Museum when he was ready to begin his 


large cartoon. ‘‘ You know, Sir Henry Cole always liked 
150 [1868 


ENSINGTON MUSEUM 


DESIGN FOR MOSAIC FOR SOUTH K 


(Pastel) 


CHELSEA DAYS 


me,” was Whistler’s story to us, “‘ and I told him he ought 
to provide me with a fine studio—it would be an honour to 
me—and to the Museum!’’ But models broke down, the 
fog settled over London, he wanted to get through his Aca- 
demy picture first, he was called to Paris on business. The 
interruptions and delays were many. Whether the large 
eartoon ever was finished, or whether, when finished, it was 
found to be out of keeping with the academic and classic 
machines by Royal Academicians which now fill the Central 
Gallery, is not known. At any rate, this project was never 
realised. 

The year of Whistler’s discouragements as a painter gave 
fresh proof of the position accorded to him as an etcher. 
Hamerton’s EHiching and Etchers was published in 1868. 
Shortly before, he had written to Whistler : . 

““T wonder whether you would object to lend me a set of 
proofs for a few weeks. As the book is already advanced, I should 
be glad of an early reply. My opinion of your work is, on the 
whole, so favourable, that your reputation could only gain by 
your affording me the opportunity of speaking of your work 
at length.” 

The only notice Whistler took of the request was to print 
it years afterwards as the Unanswered Letter of The Gentle 
Art. Hamerton, the critic, was not used to being ignored 
by artists. He could not keep his irritation out of his book : 


““T have been told that, if application is made by letter to 
Mr. Whistler for a set of his etchings, he may, perhaps, if he 
chooses to answer the letter, do the applicant the favour to let 
him have a copy for about the price of a good horse.” 


Eventually, this comment, headed Inconsequences, was 
placed after the Unanswered Letter. Hamerton admitted 
that Whistler 
“has very rare and very peculiar endowments, and may, in a 
certain sense, be called great—that is, so far as greatness may 
1868] I51 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


be understood of faculties which are rather remarkable for 
keenness and originality than range.” 


But the praise is never without qualification. If Whistler 
is a “fine etcher,’? he is a “strikingly imperfect artist.’ 
His work is often ‘‘ admirable,” but it is 
“rarely affecting, because we can so seldom believe that the 
artist himself has been affected. It is very observant, very 
penetrating, very sensitive even, in a peculiar way, but not 
poetically sensitive. ... Whistler’s etchings are not generally 
remarkable for poetical feeling.” 


This last sentence was reprinted by Whistler as part of 
Hamerton’s Inconsequences. Hamerton also thought that 
Whistler was a master of line, though he did not seem to 
love anything, did not seem from his work (‘I do not know 
him personally,’’ Hamerton’s conscience forced him to say) 
to be “ altogether expansive or sympathetic, but self-con- 
centrated and repellent of the softer emotions.” In the end, 
Whistler let Hamerton have a plate, Billingsgate, which, in 
its third. state, was published in the Portfolio for January 
1878, and, two years after, in the third edition of Hiching 
and Etchers (1880), with Hamerton’s original criticisms very 
slightly modified. 

Hamerton, temperate in his estimate of Whistler’s work, 
went to the extreme of exaggeration in his comments on 
Whistler’s prices. His success never induced Whistler 
deliberately to increase the value of his etchings by making 
them rare, in the fashion of the young men of to-day. It 
was different with his dry-points, the number of impressions 
being necessarily limited. Mr. Percy Thomas, in talks of 
the old days and visits to Lindsey Row, has told us that 
Whistler would throw them on the floor and consider them. 
‘“‘T think for this we must say five guineas—and for this 
six—and for this I must say—ten!’’ Only once, however, 
can Mr. Thomas remember an attempt, or a desire, on 
152 [1868 


CHELSEA DAYS 


Whistler’s part to create an artificial price. He had been 
sent from Bond Street to Lindsey Row, with prints to leave 
for Whistler to sign, and the next day he returned for them. 
Whistler and Mrs. Whistler were sitting together, silent and 
unhappy, and Whistler hurried from the studio without a 
word. ‘But what is it? What has happened?” Mr. 
Thomas asked, and then Mrs. Whistler explained that 
Whistler had thrown the prints into the fire—thinking it 
would be a good thing to make them rare, and had been 
miserable ever since. Another incident remembered by 
Mr. Thomas would have altered Hamerton’s idea of Whistler’s 
business methods. Edmund Thomas had gone to the 
studio and offered a certain sum for all the prints in it at 
the time. Whistler accepted the offer: Mr. Thomas drew 
his cheque, satisfied with his part of the bargain, and carried 
offthe prints. A couple of hours later, a messenger appeared 
at the shop with another bundle of proofs. Whistler had 
come upon them in an unexpected corner of the studio ; 
and sent word that, according to the bargain, they belonged 
to Mr. Thomas. 

Toward the end of the ’sixties, or beginning of the seventies, 
shortly after the publication of Hamerton’s book, Mr. Murray 
Marks proposed to start a Fine Art Company with Alexander 
Ionides, Rossetti, Burne-Jones, and Morris. Their object 
was to deal in pictures, prints, blue and white and decorative 
work. They were to have the exclusive right to sell Watts’, 
Burne-Jones’ and Rossetti’s pictures, and Whistler’s etchings, 
possibly also his paintings. JIonides, who was to advance 
some two or three thousand pounds, as were the others, 
bought with his own money the sixteen plates by Whistler 
now known as The Thames Set, and all the prints from them 
in his possession. The sum paid was three hundred pounds. 
A secretary was engaged for the company, but, somehow, 
that was the end of it. The plates were thus left the absolute 
1868] 153 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


property of Mr. Ionides. He had a hundred sets printed ; 
he gave one set to each of his children; the others were 
taken over by Messrs. Ellis and Green, and the series published 
by them as Svxteen Etchings of Scenes on the Thames, in 1871, 
price twelve guineas. Later, the plates came into the posses- 
sion of the Fine Art Society, and they sold the prints unsigned 
as a set, in a portfolio, for fourteen guineas, or, singly, from 
half a guinea apiece to two guineas and a half. Finally 
Mr. Keppel of New York bought the plates, had the steel 
facing removed, for they had been steeled, and got Mr. 
Goulding to print a number of each, when some extremely 
good prints were obtained. The plates were then, we believe, 
destroyed. 

All this while, official recognition of Whistler, the etcher 
had continued. The British Museum kept on buying his 
prints, and only stopped when, suddenly, a few years ago, 
it was discovered that the work of living artists could not be 
bought for the Print Room. The ignorance of this regulation 
up till then was of value to the Museum, where there now 
are one hundred and four prints. At the Victoria and Albert 
Museum, South Kensington, there are sixty-one prints, 
besides several issued in various publications, and there is 
a second Thames Set in the Ionides Collection. For several 
years, dating from this period, Sir Richard R. Holmes 
purchased etchings directly from Whistler for Windsor Castle 
Library: about one hundred and forty in all. A list of 
these is in the London Memorial Catalogue. Sir Richard 
R. Holmes writes us: 


“It is difficult for me to say when, or how, I first began the 
collecting of Whistler’s etchings. I had a few, and then I met 
several while I was engaged in looking after other things at 
Thibaudeau’s, and then, gradually, I found I had so many that 
I thought it best to make the collection as sae ai as I could, 
and got many from Whistler himself. 

154 [1871 


CHELSEA DAYS 


Often Sir Richard went to the studio; often Whistler 
sent prints to Windsor, which he thought should be there, 
and which Sir Richard was only too glad to buy. The Venice 
Set was bought, and the proofs in the Royal Library, or 
some of them, at least, were the finest we have ever seen. 
Curiously, they were sold at what was supposed to be 
the height of the ‘‘ Whistler boom,” and after they had 
been greatly praised at the Memorial Exhibitions in London 
and Paris. As Sir Richard, however, had retired, and as 
the King on his visit to the London Memorial Exhibition 
expressed great surprise at the few he looked at, it is almost 
certain that His Majesty had hitherto been unaware of the 
fact that the collection was at Windsor. Even the Portfolio 
presented by Whistler to Queen Victoria, with his auto- 
graph letter asking her acceptance, was sold in 1906, the few 
prints in Princess Victoria’s apartments only being left. The 
disposal of the collection was so badly managed that 
this Jubilee Series alone brought more, when re-sold a few 
weeks after the King parted with them, than His Majesty 
got for the whole series. During Whistler’s lifetime, 
important collections of his etchings were acquired also 
by the Museums of Dresden, Venice and Melbourne, among 
others. 

The success of Whistler’s plates during 1868 and the 
following years is in strong contrast to the fate of his 
pictures which, from now on for a long period, received 
Officially little but neglect, and popularly little but 
contempt. He had nothing in the Academy of 1868. 
Mr. Jameson has told us of his despair when the Three 
Girls was not finished in time, and of their wandering 
together about town, in and out of galleries and museums, 
until, at last, before Velasquez, in the National Gallery, 
Whistler took heart again. In 1869 he did not have a 
chance to profit by the improvement, when the Academy 
1871] T55 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


moved to Burlington Gardens, and in one of its rare moments 
of reform abolished “top line” and “crinoline line.” In 
1870, he had one picture, The Balcony. In 1871 there was 
nothing. Nor, during these four years, did he have any- 
thing in the Salon. Whistler, like Rossetti, was never 
without his public, though many years passed before he 
received from it Rossetti’s rewards. He could rely on 
practical recognition from the Ionides; from Mr. Leathart, 
the Newcastle merchant; from Frederick Leyland, the 
Liverpool shipowner, a genius in his way, “the Liverpool 
Medici ’”? as Whistler called him to us; from Mr. Huth, Mr. 
Alexander, Mr. Rawlinson, Mr. Anderson Rose, Mr. Jameson, 
the Chapmans, Mr. Potter. But, unlike Rossetti, he wanted 
to show his work in official places, and receive for it official 
honours. His absence from official exhibitions was then 
seldom his fault; he was always getting rejected at the 
Academy. It was his hatred of rejection and fear of being 
badly hung that drove him from exhibitions where he had 
no control. 

The tyranny of the Academy was no new thing. In the 
’sixties and ’seventies, the opening of the Summer Exhibition 
was almost every year the occasion of scandal and of protest 
against an Academy that rejected the most distinguished 
artists, or offered them the greater insult of skying their 
work. One gallery after another took up the cause of 
outsiders, or was established to take it up. After the Berners 
Street Gallery came the Dudley, which, in 1867, added to 
its show of water-colours an independent exhibition of oils ; 
in 1868, the Corinthian Gallery in Argyll Street; in 1869, 
the Select Supplementary Exhibition in Bond Street, but 
both these last were poor affairs, more apt to justify than 
to expose the Academy. Dealers also came to the rescue, 
more especially the directors of the French Gallery in Pall- 
Mall, and the Society of French Artists organised at No. 168 
156 [1871 


beset beri iat ha 


f 


P= 
= 


. 


S IN VIOLET AND GREEN 


VARIATION 


CHELSEA DAYS 


New Bond Street, by M. Durand-Ruel, who came to London 
in 1870, on account of the Franco-German War, bringing 
with him his own collection and Laurent Richard’s, and, who, 
under the management of M. Charles Deschamps, gave 
half-yearly exhibitions until 1877. In the French Gallery 
and with the Society of French Artists, Whistler showed 
many times. He also contributed often to the Dudley, 
beginning in 1871, when he exhibited Variations and a 
Harmony. The next year he exhibited several Symphonies 
and, for the first time, an impression of night with the title 
Nocturne. His use of titles to explain his pictorial intentions 
was now so well established that this same year (1872), when 
The White Girl and the Princesse were in the International 
Exhibition at South Kensington, they were catalogued 
respectively as Symphony in White, No. I., and Variations 
in Flesh-colour, Blue and Grey, later changed to Grey 
and Rose; and he supplied the explanation, printed in 
the Programme of Reception, that they were “the 
complete results of harmonies obtained by employing 
the infinite tones and variations of a limited number of 
colours.” 

His portrait of his mother was sent to the Academy of 
1872 with the title, Arrangement in Grey and Black: 
Portrait of the Painter’s Mother. It was refused at first. 
There was indignation outside the Academy. Madox Brown 
wrote to George Rae: 

‘“‘T hear that Whistler has had the portrait of his mother turned 
out. If so, it is a shame, because I saw the picture, and know 
it to be good and beautiful, though, I suppose, not to the taste 
of Messrs. Ansdell and Dobson.” 

There was indignation also inside the Academy. Sir William 
Boxall threatened to resign from the Council if the portrait 
was not hung, for he would not have it said that a committee 
to which he belonged had rejected it. Similar threats have 
1872] 157 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


been heard in recent years, and the rejected work has stayed 
out, and the Academicians have stayed in. Boxall, though 
an Academician, would not yield, and the picture was 
hung, not well, yet not out of sight; groups, it is said, were 
always gathered before it to laugh. Still, there it was, the 
last picture by Whistler at the Academy, where nothing of 
his was again seen, save one etching in 1879, Putney Bridge, 
published by the Fine Art Society, and perhaps sent by 
them. 

The whole affair made talk. But 1872 is interesting, not 
so much because of this Academic scandal as because it is 
the year when, for the first time, Whistler exhibited a portrait 
as an Arrangement, and an impression of night as a Nocturne. 

As it was the last time he ever showed a picture in the 
Academy, it may be as well to complete here our account 
of his relations with this institution. It is said that he put 
his name down, or allowed it to be put down, for election. 
He was never elected. Other Americans were, for the Royal 
Academy is so broad in its constitution that an artist need 
not be an Englishman, need not be resident in Great Britain, 
need not have shown on its walls, to become a member or 
honorary member. But, though during all these years and 
until the day of his death, Whistler would have accepted 
election, we have never heard that he obtained a single vote. 
George Boughton, an American artist and a member, of 
the Royal Academy, put the matter plainly when he said 
that, if Whistler had ‘* behaved himself ’’—behaved himself, 
that is, according to the Academical idea of behaviour— 
he would have been President. And this concession Boughton 
felt it necessary to qualify. 

““ Now, if any one knowing Whistler and me should go about 
thinking me serious in imagining that he would make a good 


President—even of an East End boxing club—such persons live 
in dense error.” 


158 [1872 


CHELSEA DAYS 


Whistler would have accepted election for one reason, and 
one reason only—because of the official rank it would have 
given him in England. Artistically, he felt himself more 
distinguished than any member of the Royal Academy. 
Though every recognition was withheld during his lifetime, 
several Academicians attempted to secure for the Academy 
a sort of reflex distinction by endeavouring to get together 
a posthumous exhibition of his work—unsuccessfully. It 
would, indeed, have been irony if the Academy had, in 
return for its neglect of Whistler, got the kudos and profit 
such an exhibition was sure to bring. Another instance of 
what Americans call “ graft ’’ is the absence from the Chantrey 
Collection of a picture by Whistler. The Trustees, although 
they have bought their own work, paying as much as one 
thousand pounds to Sir Edward J. Poynter, three thousand 
to Sir Hubert von Herkomer, three thousand and fifty to 
Lord Leighton, two thousand to Sir J. E. Millais, Bart., 
over two thousand to Mr. Frank Dicksee, two thousand to 
Sir W. Q. Orchardson, two thousand to Vicat Cole, who are 
or were members of the Council of the Academy, never 
even offered the sixty pounds for which they might have 
bought Whistler’s Nocturne in Blue and Gold: Old Batter- 
sea Bridge, since purchased for two thousand by public 
subscription, and given to the Tate Gallery. Is it any 
wonder then that Whistler, disgusted with such conduct 
towards him, especially on the part of his fellow countrymen 
who might have elected him, left as his only request relative 
to his pictures, the expressed wish that none of them 
should ever find a place in an English Gallery ? In his case, 
death even did not spare him Academical ‘jealousy. Not 
content with ignoring this man during his lifetime, officially 
insulting his memory after his death, Sir Edward Poynter, 
when he hung Old Battersea Bridge, first in the National 
Gallery, affixed to it, or allowed to be affixed, a label on 
1872] 159 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


which Whistler’s name was misspelt, Whistler himself was 
described as of the British School, and the title of the 
picture was incorrectly given. The picture has since, by 
the irony of fate, been placed in the Gallery of Modern 
British Art ! 


160 [1872 


CHAPTER XIII. NOCTURNES, THE YEARS 
EIGHTEEN SEVENTY-TWO TO EIGHTEEN 
SEVENTY-FOUR 


HISTLER was the first to paint the night. The blue 
mystery that veils the world from dusk to dawn is 
in the colour-prints of Hiroshige. But the wood block cannot 
give the depth of the darkness, the medium makes a con- 
vention of the colour. Hiroshige saw and felt the beauty, 
and invented a wonderful scheme by which to suggest it 
on the block, but he could not render the night as Whistler 
rendered it on canvas. 

If the colour-prints of Japan suggested the Nocturnes, 
they were merely the suggestion. Whistler never imitated 
the Japanese in their technique. Their composition did 
impress him, their arrangement, their pattern, and some of 
their detail. Often the very high or very low horizon, the 
line of a bridge over a river, the spray of foliage across the 
foreground, the golden curve of the falling rocket, the placing 
of the figure on the shore, the signature in its oblong panel, 
will show how much he learned from them. But these are 
details. He abandoned them within a few years, but he 
never gave up, he developed rather, what he always spoke 
of as the Japanese theory of drawing. He translated Japanese 
art—translate is the word—though he would have said he 
“carried on the tradition’; he adapted it to his own 
methods in painting the Nocturnes. His idea was not to 
go back to the Japanese as being greater than himself, but 
to learn what he could from them, to state it in his own way 
1872-74] IiL 16x 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


and to produce another work of art: a work founded on 
tradition no less than theirs, and yet as western as theirs 
was eastern. 

Night, beautiful everywhere from Valparaiso to Venice, 
was never so beautiful as in London. First he painted the 
Thames in the grey day, but, as time went on, he began to 
paint it in the blue or rosy darkness that made of it a wonder- 
land. Only those who have lived by the river for years, as 
we have, can realise the truth as well as the beauty of the 
Nocturnes. He still, like Courbet, “‘ loved things for what 
they were,” but he chose them for their exquisiteness, 
their tenderness, their poetry. The brutality or the “‘ foolish- 
ness’ of Nature made no appeal to him. But Courbet 
was not more of a realist than Whistler in the Nocturnes, 
if realism means truth to Nature. 

The long nights of observation on the river were followed 
by long days of experiment in the studio. In the end, he gave 
up even making notes of subjects and effects. It was impossible 
for him to choose and mix his colours at night, and he was 
compelled to trust to his memory, which he cultivated. In 
his portraits and pictures, and in all work done by daylight, 
he always had a model, or worked from the subject on the 
spot. But, after all, as Mr. Bernhard Sickert has well pointed 
out, looking at colours and their arrangement at night, 
retaining the memory of them until the next morning when 
he put them down, was “simply painting from Nature, the 
only difference being a longer interval between observation 
and execution.”” When he said that “‘ Nature put him out,” 
he meant that the whole arrangement as he found it in Nature 
put him out; it was never exactly as he wanted it. Few 
painters understood better than he did the art of selection, 
and here again Hiroshige and the other Japanese had been 
of use to him. He went to Nature for the suggestion, the 


motive. And yet, it is curious that he never could work 
162 [1872-74 


NOCTURNE, BATTERSEA 
(Arrangement in Grey and Gold) 


NOCTURNE 
(Blue and Green) 


NOCTURNES 


without a model or, except in the Nocturnes, away from 
Nature. This was why, as he said, Nature was at once his 
master and his servant. The Nocturnes looked so simple 
that to a public trained by the Pre-Raphaelites to believe the 
signs of labour the chief merit of a picture, they seemed mere 
sketches, unfinished, as Burne-Jones said. His letters to 
Fantin are full of regret for his uncertainty, his slowness : 
“ Je suis st lent. . . . Les choses ne vont pas vite... . Je 
produis peu parce que 7 efface tout!” The public could know 
nothing of the hard work and study that went to produce the 
simplicity. In no other paintings was Whistler as successful 
in obeying his own precept and concealing every trace 
of effort and toil. One touch less in some of the Nocturnes, 
and you feel that nothing might be left ; in others, one touch 
more and the spell might be broken, and night stripped of 
its mystery. To give the silhouette of bridge or building 
against the sky; the lines of light trailing their gold into 
the water and leading to infinite distance ; the boats, ghosts 
fading into the ghostly river; the fall of rockets through 
shadowy air—to give all these things, and yet to keep them 
enveloped in the transparency of darkness, to preserve the 
feeling of the London night, was the problem he set himself 
and solved in the Nocturnes in blue and silver, blue and gold, 
grey and silver, opal and silver, that were painted in the 
little second-story back room at Chelsea. 

Now every one can see these things, and night is like a 
Whistler, for Whistler made people look at his pictures, 
until it has become impossible to look at Nature at night 
without remembering the Nocturnes. He painted the effect 
that the world at night produced on him, and the great 
artist, like the great author, moves people, makes them 
think they see things as he does. Even in that ever-quoted 
passage from the Ten o’Clock, he does not pretend to see 


Nature as people see her, or as Nature seems to be; his 
1872-74] 163 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


concern is with the impression that Nature at night made 
on him, and in this he was an impressionist. 

The brothers Greaves bought his materials and prepared 
his canvas and colours. ‘‘ I know all these things because 
I passed days and weeks in the place standing with and 
beside him,’’ Walter Greaves has said to us. And so it 
happens that, of the methods and materials of few other 
modern painters, is there so accurate a record as of Whistler’s 
when he painted the Nocturnes. He reshaped his brushes 
usually, heating them over a candle, melting the glue and 
pushing the hairs into the form he wanted. Walter Greaves 
remembers that the colours were mixed with linseed oil 
and turpentine. Whistler told us that he used a medium 
composed of copal, mastic and turpentine. The colours 
were arranged upon a palette, a large oblong board 
some two feet by three, with the Butterfly inlaid in one 
corner and, round the edges, sunken boxes for brushes 
and tubes. The palette was laid upon a table. He had 
at various periods two or three of these, and at least one 
stand, with many tiny drawers, upon which it fitted. At 
times it was slightly tilted. At the top of the palette 
the pure colours were placed, though, more frequently, 
there were no pure colours at all. Large quantities of different 
tones of the prevailing colour in the picture to be painted 
were mixed, and so much medium was used that he called it 
*“‘ sauce.”” Mr. Greaves says that the Nocturnes were mostly 
painted on a very absorbent canvas, sometimes on panels, 
sometimes on bare brown holland, sized. For the blue 
Nocturnes, the canvas was covered with a red ground, or 
the panel was of mahogany, which the pupils got from their 
own boat-building yard, the red forcing up the blues laid 
on it. Others were done on “ practically a warm. black,” 
and for the fireworks there was a lead ground. Or, if the 


night was grey, then, Whistler said, the sky is grey, and the 
164 [1872-74 


CREMORNE 
(Nocturne) 


CREMORNE 
(Nocturne in Green and Gold) 


NOCTURNES 


water is grey, and therefore the canvas must be grey. Only 
once, within Mr. Greaves’ memory, was the ground white. 
The ground, for his Nocturnes, like the paper for his pastels, 
was chosen of the prevailing tone of the picture he wanted 
to paint or of a colour which would give him that tone, not 
to save work, but to save disturbing, ‘‘ embarrassing,’’ his 
canvas. 

When Whistler had arranged his colour-scheme on the 
palette, the canvas, which the pupils prepared, may have 
been stood on an easel, but so much “sauce” was used 
that, frequently, it had to be thrown flat on the floor to keep 
the whole thing from running off. He washed the liquid 
colours on to the canvas, lightening and darkening the tone 
as he worked. In many Nocturnes, the entire sky and water 
are rendered with great sweeps of the brush in exactly the 
right tone. How many times he made and wiped out that 
sweeping tone is another matter. When it was right, there 
it stayed. With his life’s knowledge of both the effects 
he wanted to paint and the way to paint them, at times, 
as he admits himself, he completed a Nocturne in a day. 
In some he got his effect at once, in others it came only 
after innumerable failures. If the tones were right, he took 
them off his palette and kept them until the next day, in 
saucers or dishes under water, so that he might carry on his 
work in the same way with the same tones. Mrs. Anna Lea 
Merritt tells us that when she lived in Cheyne Walk she 
remembers “‘ seeing the Nocturnes set out along the garden 
wall to bake in the sun.” Some were laid aside to dry 
slowly in the studio, some were put in the garden or on the 
roof to dry quickly. Sometimes they dried out like body- 
colour in the most unexpected fashion. He had no recipe, 
no system. The period was one of tireless research. He 
had to “invent” everything, though he profited by the 
technical training he had gained in painting the Six Projects 
1872-74] 165 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Whistler first called his paintings of night ‘“‘ Moonlights.” 
** Nocturne ’’ was Mr. Leyland’s suggestion, as we have heard 
from Mrs. Leyland, and her son-in-law, Val Prinsep, stated 
in the Art Journal (August 1892), that Whistler wrote to 
Leyland : 


“T can’t thank you too much for the name ‘ Nocturne’ as 
the title for my moonlights. You have no idea what an irritation 
it proves to the critics, and consequent pleasure to me ; besides 
it is really so charming, and does so poetically say all I want 
to say and no more than I wish.” 


Whether to mystify, or because he saw something new 
in his pictures, Whistler repeatedly changed their titles, 
especially of the Nocturnes, and repeatedly exhibited different 
pictures with the same title. It is true, as Mr. Bernhard 
Sickert writes : 


“such alterations made by the artist himself stultify the whole 
idea, and prove that the analogy with music does not hold 
consistently. Any musician would tell us that we could not 
change the title of Symphony in C minor to Sonata in G major 
without making it an absurdity.” 


That he should either not have realised this fact, or else 
have disregarded it deliberately, is the more extraordinary 
because every Nocturne represents a different effect rendered 
in a different fashion. Although he altered his titles himself, 
nothing offended him more than when others tampered with 
them or imitated them. 

The painting of the Nocturnes continued for many years, 
and in many places. But the greater number were painted 
when he lived at No. 2 Lindsey Row, many from his own 
windows, while few took him beyond Chelsea and Battersea 
or Westminster. Through most the river flows: several 
were done at Cremorne; one in Trafalgar Square, Chelsea. 


He resented it when people urged literary titles for them, 
166 [1872-74 


Pn ee 


eee 
Reheat 


ONS ae 
sae 
aie etds 4 
* 4 
Bis 


oy 


Mey nse 


ony 
i 
hi 


eG 


~ 


ears 


- rs 
we ys lind oa A Ana 
e si; - r 7 
| . Spey Seating diana Sie Ande 
qreiviet iahey a ql FD Ge Swe es 
. 7 * ’ ' Foes. : 
bh, a eg ait r 


oi eet 
' - 


~ ; 3 a 
FRESE LOR) 44 


b Lense 


a 
>. 
™ 


b] 


: eer 
ry br Nae 


« 


sa * 


= . av 


ere es 


ee a 2 Sa eR Le Fr 
Bs ee ae 
Ses Beh 


hs ' a 


eset Recah a 


af 
A *. 


NOCTURNES 


and he put his resentment into words that “‘ make history ” 
in The Gentle Art: 


“* My picture of a ‘ Harmony in Grey and Gold’ is an illustration 
of my meaning—a snow scene with a single black figure and a 
lighted tavern. I care nothing for the past, present, or future 
of the black figure, placed there because the black was wanted 
at that spot. All that I know is that my combination of grey 
and gold is the basis of the picture. Now this is precisely what 
my friends cannot grasp. They say, ‘Why not call it “‘ Trotty 
Veck,” and sell it for a round harmony of golden guineas ?’” 


Lord Redesdale told us that it was he who suggested this 
title, gaily. Whistler assured another friend that he had 
only to write ‘* Father, dear Father, come home with me now ”’ 
on the painting for it to become the “ picture of the year.”’ 
But he never wanted to put into his pictures of night more 
than was expressed in the title Leyland had given him. 
Subject, sentiment, meaning were for him in the night itself 
—the night in all its loveliness and mystery. There is no 
doubt that he carried tradition further and made greater 
advance in the Nocturnes than in any of his paintings. The 
subjects are usually the simplest: factories, bridges, boats 
and barges, shops; but in his hands they became things of. 
beauty that will live for ever. The Nocturnes are not all 
moonlights ; we remember only one, Southampton Water, in 
which the moon itself appears, and there are others illumined 
only by flickering lamplight. They are not invariably 
pictures of night, but at times of dawn or of twilight. Nocturne, 
however, is the name Whistler chose for all, and by it they 
will always be known. 


1872-74] 167 


CHAPTER XIV. PORTRAITS FROM 
EKIGHTEEN SEVENTY-TWO TO 
EIGHTEEN SEVENTY-FOUR 


HILE Whistler was painting the Nocturnes, he was also 
working on the large portraits. The Mother was the 
first. The charm of Mrs. Whistler’s presence was felt by 
every one who came near her, but by none so deeply as her son. 
We cannot say just when Whistler began the picture; he 
wrote of it to Fantin, promising to send a photograph, in 
1871; but it was not shown until 1872. How many were 
the sittings, how often the work was scraped down, no one 
will ever know. Some interesting technical details we have 
from Mr. Greaves. The portrait was painted on the back 
of a canvas, as J. saw when it was sent to the London Memorial 
Exhibition, as Mr. Otto Bacher also saw when the picture 
was in Whistler’s studio in 1883. 

““T noticed that it was painted on the back of a canvas, on the 
face of which was the portrait of a child. My remark, ‘Why 
you have painted your mother on the back of a canvas !’ received 
simply the reply: ‘Isn’t that a good surface ?’” 


There was scarcely any paint used, Mr. Greaves says, the 
canvas being simply rubbed over to get the dress, and, as 
at first the dado had been painted all across the canvas, it 
even now shows through the black of the skirt. That 
wonderful handkerchief in the tired old hands, Mr. Greaves 
describes as ‘‘ nothing but a bit of white and oil.” 

What Whistler wanted was to place upon a canvas a 


beautiful arrangement, a beautiful pattern, of colour and of 
168 [1872-74 


PORTRAIT OF THE PAINTER’S MOTHER 


Arrangement in Grey and Black 


PORTRAITS 


line. No painter since Hals and Velasquez ever thought 
so much of placing his figure on the canvas inside the frame ; 
not only do the long straight lines of the dado give the figure 
its proper place, but the upright lines are repeated in the 
hangings, and the two framed prints continue the square 
quiet pattern. Better than any painter since Velasquez, 
he understood the value of restrained line and restrained 
colour. The long, vertical and horizontal lines of the back- 
ground, even of the footstool and the matting, even the 
brushwork on the wall, give quietness and peace to the 
portrait, and the pose, that could be kept for ever, is more 
dignified than the frenzied action preferred by certain of his 
predecessors. Hamerton thought he must have found this 
pose, or the hint for it, in the Agrippina at the Capitol in 
Rome, or in Canova’s statue of Napoleon’s mother at Chats- 
worth. If Whistler found it anywhere except in his own 
studio, it could only have been at Haarlem, where Franz 
Hals’ old ladies sit together with something of the same 
serenity and dignity expressed in much the same scheme 
of colour. Whistler had been to Holland, he must then 
have known the beautiful group, and memories of it may 
have haunted him. 

When Whistler wrote of the Mother to Fantin, he said that 
if the picture marked any progress, it was in the science of 
colour, and he made this clear in the title when the portrait 
was exhibited at the Academy, and called Arrangement in 
Grey and Black. Swinburne has not been alone in seeing its 
** intense pathos of significance and tender depth of expres- 
sion.” But this is not what Whistler intended any one, save 
himself, to see. 

“Take the picture of my mother, exhibited at the Royal 
Academy as an ‘ Arrangement in Grey and Black.’ Now that is 
what it is. To me it is interesting as a picture of my mother ; 
but what can or ought the public to care about the identity of 


the portrait ?” 
1872-74] 169 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


And yet friends did sometimes get a glimpse of the other 
side. Mr. Harper Pennington writes us: 


“Did I ever tell you of an occasion when Whistler let me 
see him with the paint off—with his brave mask down? Once 
standing by me in his studio—Tite Street—we were looking?at 
the Mother. I said some string of words about the beauty of 
the face and figure—and for some moments Jimmy looked and 
looked, but he said nothing. His hand was playing with that 
tuft upon his nether lip. It was perhaps two minutes before he 
spoke. ‘Yes,’ very slowly, and very softly—‘ Yes—one does 
like to make one’s mummy just as nice as possible!’ ” 


Some understood at the time, among them Carlyle. Whistler 
told us, one August evening in 1900, that Madame Venturi, 
his friend, and Carlyle’s too, determined that he should 
paint Carlyle. 


“IT used to go often to Madame Venturi’s—I met Mazzini 
there, and Mazzini was most charming—and Madame Venturi 
often visited me, and one day she brought Carlyle. The Mother 
was there, and Carlyle saw it, and seemed to feel in it a certain 
fitness of things, as Madame Venturi meant he should—he 
liked the simplicity of it, the old lady sitting with her hands 
folded on her lap—and he said he would be painted. And he 
came one morning soon after that, and he sat down, and I had 
the canvas ready, and the brushes and palette, and Carlyle 
looking on, said presently : ‘And now, mon, fire away!’ I was 
taken aback—that wasn’t my idea of how work should be done. 
Carlyle realised it, for he added: ‘If ye’re fighting battles or 
painting pictures, the only thing to do is to fire away!’ One 
day he told me of others who had painted his portrait. ‘There 
was Mr. Watts,a mon of note. And I went to his studio, and 
there was much meestification, and screens were drawn round 
the easel, and curtains were drawn, and I was not allowed to 
see anything. And then, at last, the screens were put aside 
and there I was. And I looked. And Mr. Watts, a great mon, 
he said to me, “how do ye like it?” And then I turned to Mr. 
Watts, and I said, ‘Mon, I would have ye know I am in the 
hobit of wurin’ clean lunen!”’ ” 


Carlyle told people afterwards that he sat there talking 
170 [1872-74 


PORTRAIT OF THOMAS CARLYLE 


Arrangement in Grey and Black, No. II. 


eas sAWA\QWA EL \\n 
BAN ca 


STUDY FOR THE “CARLYLE” 


ene ieee: researc oa a oo 
ea Moa iinieca eae reo Wes? 


~ aad 
Eas span cs deal 


= oad Me, 2 ales mrt + sion 2 


rete ie sine ‘eee eae 2; ns sate ‘pers 
LA Sethe, abs 
2 ata a 


Patten: 
Bo hare ‘pie ages 


et oe 
~<— — 

A Pi) 
roe. 


ae a“ — 
“s sienna hes | 
* iosad a Lanpsietae: cabin 2 araad wea 


apse eg Hal Bate 


PORTRAITS 


and talking, and that Whistler went on working and working 
and paid no attention to him whatever. Whistler found 
Carlyle a delightful person, and Carlyle found him a workman. 
And it has been said that they used to take walks together, 
but of this there is no record. 

Before the portrait was finished, Whistler had begun to 
paint Miss Alexander, and another story, often told, is of a 
meeting at the door of No. 2 between the old man coming out 
and the little girl going in. ‘‘ Who is that ?”’ he asked the 
maid. Miss Alexander, who was sitting to Mr. Whistler, 
she said. Carlyle shook his head. ‘ Puir lassie! Puir 
lassie!’ and, without another word, he went out. Mrs. 
Leyland, whose portrait also was begun before Carlyle’s 
was finished, remembered that he grumbled a good deal, 
Whistler, in the end, had to get Phil Morris to sit for the 
coat. Mr. Greaves’ memories are of much impatience in the 
studio, especially when Carlyle saw Whistler working with 
small brushes, so that Whistler, to quiet him, either always 
worked with big brushes or pretended to. William Allingham 
wrote in his diary of the sittings : 


“Carlyle tells me he is sitting to Whistler. If C. makes signs 
of changing his position, W. screams out in an agonised tone: 
‘For God’s sake, don’t move!’ C. afterwards said that all 
W.’s anxiety seemed to be to get the coat painted to ideal per- 
fection; the face went for little. He had begun by asking two 
or three sittings, but managed to get a great many. At last C, 
flatly rebelled. He used to define W. as the most absurd creature 
on the face of the earth.” 


If Carlyle liked the portrait of the Mother, he must have 
liked his own. There is the same quiet, tranquil balance, 
the same careful spacing. Take away either the circular 
print or the Butterfly in its circle, and the repose is gone- 
But with such care has every detail been arranged, that one 
never thinks of the balance, the arabesque, the pattern. It is 
1872-74] 171 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


done, and all traces of the thought and the work are gone. 
One sees only the result Whistler meant should be seen. 
It has been said to show a want of invention. But if the 
background and the general scheme are the same as in the 
Mother, it was because he painted it in the same room and 
was deliberately carrying out the same idea. It was his 
Arrangement in Grey and Black, No. II. In the London 
Memorial Exhibition it hung opposite the Mother, and as 
they were seen together, the pose and colour and design 
belonged as inevitably to the nervous old man as to the old 
lady in her beautiful tranquillity. 

The Harmony in Grey and Green: Portrait of Miss Alex- 
ander, a commission from Mr. W. C. Alexander of Campden 
Hill, was painted at the same time, and proves how little 
Whistler’s invention was at fault. The arrangement was 
now silvery grey and green. There was no repetition. 
The little girl, in her white and green frock, holding at her 
side her feathered hat, butterflies hovering about her, the 
weariness of the pose expressed in the pouting red lips, as 
she stands by the grey wall with its long lines of black, is 
as familiar as Velasquez’ Infantas in wide-spreading hoops. 
Less known is Whistler’s care in every detail to make the 
picture the masterpiece it is. He, or else his mother, 
gave Mrs. Alexander directions as to the quality of the muslin 
for the daughter’s gown, where it was to be bought, the width 
of the frills, the ruffles at the neck, the ribbon bows, the way 
the gown was to be laundried. And, only after repeatedly 
seeing and studying the picture, does one learn his care in 
weaving the same colours through his design. He calls the 
portrait Harmony in Grey and Green, but the colours which 
bind all this arrangement together, which play all though 
it, are green and gold. So wonderfully are these colours used 
like gold threads in tapestry, that one does not see them : 
one simply feels the result. As always, there was the great 
172 [1872-74 


PORTRAIT OF MISS CICELY HENRIETTA ALEXANDER 


Harmony in Grey and Green 


STUDY FOR HEAD OF 
CICELY H. ALEXANDER 


“ae 
a ae 


{ 


ss 


ay 
2 : 


a, 


+ a He : { eat , 
; Reese Es sa Si a ae 
“F a ‘ _ 2 ¥ ; i ae 
¥. ‘gS ae 


oa et 
2S 
er 


Brady . 
Pa tats 
ripe 2a 


‘ 


adel ctl pneg 3 


ae le 
Lo eee 
yas “ee 
we 4 r ‘= rl F 
o paeed 
OO Ppa ue | 


ts * 
> s 


pitta oe 


+ — \ 
aP¥i 

e 
bet fend 


rd cc 


iets 


’ Rae | 
sib Se es 
Sees 


Ae 2 


‘ hes i ae 

- 
ries a. as 
- 


a 


4 


PORTRAITS 


simple design: the pose of Velasquez, the decoration of 
Japan, and all worked out in his own way. The gold runs 
along the top of the dado; tiny gold buckles fasten the 
rosettes of her shoes; there is a gold pin in her hair; the 
gold of the daisies is repeated in the butterflies which flutter 
above her head; a note of gold isin the pile of drapery beside 
her; and the floor has a suggestion of gold in the matting. 
Green plays the same note through the picture. The great 
green sash is carried down by the green feather of her 
hat, lost in the shadow which, also, is filled with green and 
gold. And the green of the daisies is again repeated in the 
green of the drapery. It is not until one has gone all over 
the picture that these things become evident. Her shoes 
look perfectly black, and so does the dado, and yet there is 
no pure black anywhere. The whole is bound together by 
this grey, green, black and gold scheme running though 
the composition. It is a perfect harmony. And so subtle 
is it, that only the result is evident, never the means by 
which it was obtained. 

The story of the sittings we have from Miss Cicely 
Alexander herself (now Mrs. Spring-Rice) : 


“My father wanted him to paint us all, I believe, beginning 
with the eldest (my sister, whom he afterwards began to paint, 
but whose portrait was never finished). But after coming down 
to see us, he wrote and said he should like to begin with ‘ the 
light arrangement,’ meaning me, as my sister was dark. So I 
was the first victim, and I’m afraid I rather considered that I 
was a victim all through the sittings, or rather standings, for he 
never let me change my position, and I believe I sometimes used 
to stand for hours at a time. I know I used to get very tired 
and cross, and often finished the day in tears. This was especially 
when he had promised to release me at a given time to go to a 
dancing class, but when the time came I was still standing, and 
the minutes slipped away, and he was quite absorbed and had 
forgotten all about his promise, and never noticed the tears ; 
he used to stand a good way from his canvas, and then dart at 

1872-74] 173 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


it, and then dart back, and he often turned round to look in a 

_ looking-glass that hung over the mantelpiece at his back—I 
suppose to see the reflection of his painting. Although he was 
rather inhuman about letting me stand on for hours and hours, 
as it seemed to me at the time, he was most kind in other ways: 
if a blessed black fog came up from the river, and I was allowed 
to get down, he never made any objection to my poking about 
among his paints, and I even put charcoal eyes to some of his 
sketches of portraits done in coloured chalks on brown paper ; 
and he also constantly promised to paint my doll, but this pro- 
mise was never kept. I was painted at the little house in Chelsea, 
and at the time he was decorating the staircase ; it was to have 

. a dado of gold, and it was all done in gold leaf, and laid on by 
himself, I believe; he had numberless little books of gold leaf 
lying about, and any that weren’t exactly of the old gold shade 
he wanted, he gave to me. 


“Mrs. Whistler was living then, and used to preside at delightful 
American luncheons, but I don’t remember that she ever came 
into the studio—a servant used to be sent to tell him lunch was 
ready, and then we went on again as before. He painted, and 
despair filled my soul, and I believe it was generally tea-time 
before we went to those lunches, at which we had hot biscuits 
and tinned peaches, and other unwholesome things, and I believe 
the biscuits came out of a little oven in the chimney, though I 
can’t quite think how that could have been. The studio was 
at the back of the house, and the drawing-room looked over the 
river, and we seldom went into it, but I remember that it had: 
matting on the floor, and a large Japanese basin with water, 
and gold-fish in it. I never met Mr. Carlyle in the studio, 
although he was being painted at the same time, but he shook 
hands with me at the private view at the Grosvenor Gallery, 
where the two portraits were exhibited for the first time. [This 
must have been at Whistler’s own exhibition in 1874.] I didn’t 
appreciate that honour at the time, any more than I appreciated 
being painted by Mr. Whistler, and I’m afraid all my memories 
only show that I was a very grumbling, disagreeable little girl. 
Of course I was too young to appreciate Mr. Whistler himself, 
though afterwards we were very good friends when I grew older, 
and when he used to come to my father’s house and make at 
once for the portrait with his eye-glass up.” 

174 [1872-74 


SKETCHES OF MISS GRACE ALEXANDER 


PORTRAITS 


It is said that the tears were not only on the little girl’s 
side, but on Whistler’s, and that there were seventy sittings 
before he finished the portrait. Mrs. Spring-Rice writes 
nothing about the number of times the picture was scraped 
down and re-commenced. He was beginning at this time to 
try to paint the entire work at once, which, on such large 
canvases was of the utmost difficulty. That he succeeded 
is proved by the picture. But the technical record is neither 
full nor satisfactory. What his colours were, how he applied 
.them, whether he used enormously long brushes, no one 
recorded. There is this of interest from Mr. Walter Greaves, 
that the picture was painted on an absorbent canvas, and 
on a distemper ground. 

Whistler was as minute in his directions for the portrait 
of Miss May Alexander. He again explained his scheme 
for the dress; he recommended to Mrs. Alexander a milliner 
who sold wonderful “‘ picture hats’; he suggested that he 
should paint the portrait in Mrs. Alexander’s drawing-room 
at Campden Hill, so that he could see the effect of the picture 
in the surroundings where it was to hang, and this was done. 
But the portrait remains a sketch, of a girl in riding-habit 
drawing on her gloves; at her side is a pot of flowers, the one 
complete passage in the picture. He made a number of 
sketches in oils, chalk, pen and ink, of the children he was 
to paint, and Mr. Alexander has several of these. But only 
the Arrangement in Grey and Green was finished. There is 
also a delightful study for the head. 

At this same time Mr. Leyland gave Whistler commissions 
to paint his four children, Mrs. Leyland and himself. Ley- 
land had not yet bought his London house, but often came 
up to town, usually staying at the Alexandra Hotel, and 
Whistler made long visits at Speke Hall, Leyland’s place 
near Liverpool. Mrs. Whistler spent months there, and her 


kindness in nursing the children through scarlet fever is 
1872-74] 175 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


remembered. The record of these visits is in the etchings 
and dry-points of Speke Hall and Speke Shore, Shipping at 
Liverpool and The Dam Wood and the portraits in many 
mediums. ‘The house was not far from the sea, which he 
loved to paint. But often days passed without his finding 
the effect he wanted. The beach was flat, and, at low tide, 
the sea ran away from him, and at high tide the skies were 
wrong, or the wind blew. But Speke Hall always put him 
in better mood for work, and when the sea failed he turned 
to the portraits. The big canvases travelled with him, back- 
ward and forward, between Speke Hall and London, and the 
sittings were continued in both places. They all sat to him. 
The children hated posing as much as they delighted in 
Whistler. The son, after three sittings, refused to sit again, 
which is a pity, for the pastel of him, lounging in a chair, 
with his big hat pushed back and his long legs stretched out, 
is full of childhood. There are pastels of the three little 
girls, sketches in pen and ink, and the fine group of dry- 
points. Of Elinor Leyland, a large full-length oil was started 
the first of his Blue Girls, in which he wished to paint blue 
on blue as he had painted white on white. Another, of 
Florence Leyland, was we believe never exhibited until it 
was purchased, in 1906, for the Brooklyn Museum, where 
it now hangs. The oil of Mr. Leyland was the only one 
completed. : 

Whistler painted Leyland standing, in evening dress, with 
the ruffled shirt he always wore, against a dark background, 
an arrangement of black on black. Leyland was good about 
standing, Mrs. Leyland says, but he had not much time, 
and few portraits gave Whistler more trouble. Leyland 
told Val Prinsep that Whistler nearly cried over the drawing © 
of the legs. Mr. Greaves says that “‘he got into an awful 
mess over it,” painted it out again and again, and finally 


had in a model to pose for it nude. But it was finished in 
176 [1872-74 


PORTRAIT OF MRS. F. R, LEYLAND 
Symphony in Flesh Colour and Pink 


PORTRAITS 


the winter of 1873. He also painted a study for it, shown 
in the London Memorial Exhibition. In the portrait of 
Leyland he began to suppress the background, to put the 
figures into the atmosphere in which they stood, without 
any accessories. The problem now was the atmospheric 
envelope, to make the figures stand in this atmosphere, as 
far within their frames as he stood from them when he painted 
them, and at this problem he worked as long as he lived. 
The portrait is now owned by Mr. Freer. 

Mrs. Leyland had more leisure than her husband, and the 
sittings were an amusement to her. She had already sat 
to Rossetti, she was to sit to more than one other artist. 
She was a beautiful woman, with wonderful red hair. Whistler 
made a dry-point of her, The Velvet Gown, and in black 
velvet she wanted him to paint her. But he preferred a 
dress in harmony with the hair, and designed soft draperies 
of rose and white falling in sweeping folds, and rosettes of 
a deeper shade to break the simplicity of the flowing lines, 
and he placed her against a rose-tinted wall, with a spray 
of almond blossoms at her side. In no other portrait did 
he attempt a scheme of colour at once so sumptuous and so 
delicate. The pose was as beautiful, one natural to her she 
says, though he made a number of pastel studies before he 
decided upon it. Her back is turned towards you, her arms 
fall loosely, the hands clasped behind her, and her head is in 
profile. Mrs. Leyland remembers days when, at the end of 
the sitting, the portrait looked as if a few hours’ work the 
next day was all it needed. But, in the morning, she would 
find it scraped down, with the work to be done over again. 
Notwithstanding the innumerable sittings she gave, one of 
Whistler’s models, Maud Franklin, whom he now was so 
often to etch and to paint, was called in to pose for the 
draperies. Whistler knew what he wanted, and nothing less 
would satisfy him. It must be beautiful to be worthy of 
1872-74] I: M 177 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


the weariness it caused her, he told Mrs. Leyland, and he 
was trying for the little more that meant perfection. The 
portrait was not finished, and yet, if it were, it could hardly 
be lovelier in line and colour. Here it was a problem, not 
of luminous dark, but of luminous light, and the accessories 
had not been suppressed. The matting on the floor, the 
dado, and the spray of almond blossoms are more elaborately 
carried out than the detail in any other portrait. What 
worried him, and probably prevented the picture being 
finished, are the hands, which are almost untouched. It was 
not that he could not draw hands, for they are beautifully 
drawn in some of the etchings. But there is as little doubt 
that he rarely painted them well. He nearly always left 
them to the last, and some of his later pictures were un- 
finished because he could not get the hands right. The 
Sarasate, The Little White Girl, the Symphony in White, 
No. III., are almost the only ones in which the hands are 
beautifully painted. Some one has said that an artist is 
known by his painting of hands. These three pictures prove 
that Whistler could paint hands, but it is as true that he 
did not paint them when he could help it. 

The portrait of Mrs. Louis Huth was not only begun but 
finished during these years. It is Holbein-like in its dignity, 
its sobriety, the flat modelling, the exquisite rendering of the 
lace at the throat and the wrists. Mrs. Huth wears the 
black velvet Mrs. Leyland wanted to wear, and the back- 
ground is black with a wonderful luminous and intense depth. 
She, too, stands with her back turned, and her head in 
profile. In this portrait, as in the full-length Leyland, 
Whistler carried out his method of putting in the whole 
picture at once. The background was as much a part of 
the design as the face. If anything went wrong anywhere 
the whole picture had to come out and be started again. It 


was a problem of great difficulty, but the system taught by 
178 [1872-74 


PORTRAIT OF F. R. LEYLAND 


Arrangement in Black 


LAND 


1Y 


K.R. Lk 


OF 


= 
BY 
re] 
S) 


STUDY FOR P 


PORTRAITS 


Gleyre, and developed in the Nocturnes, was perfected in 
the portraits of Leyland and Mrs. Huth. The tones, made 
from a very few colours of infinite gradations, were mixed 
on the great palette, with black as the basis. 
_ Mrs. Leyland sometimes met Mrs. Huth as they came and 
went for their sittings, and this fixes the date of the portrait. 
Mrs. Huth was not strong, and Whistler exhausted the 
strongest who posed for him. Almost daily during one summer 
he kept her standing for three hours without rest. At last 
she rebelled. Mr. Watts, she said, who also had painted her 
had not treated her in that way. ‘“ And still, you know, 
you come to me!” was Whistler’s comment. He had some 
mercy, however, and at times a model stood for her gown. 

With the exception of the Mother, not one of these portraits 
appeared in an exhibition for some years. After the Academy 
of 1874 opened with nothing of his in it, he took matters 
into his own hands, and, as Courbet had done in 1855, and 
Manet in 1867, organised a show of his own: his first “‘ one 
man” show. The gallery was at No. 48 Pall Mall. The 
pictures, thirteen in number, included the large portraits, a 
few Nocturnes, one or two earlier paintings and one or two 
of the Projects. There were also fifty prints. The walls, 
as Mrs. Stillman remembers them, were grey, the pictures 
were well spaced, there were palms and flowers, blue pots 
and bronzes, and it was all very beautiful. He designed 
the card of invitation, the simple card he always used, and 
with his mother and his pupils, and their family, wrote the 
names and addresses, “‘ all making Butterflies as hard as we 
could,’”’ Mr. Greaves says, rushing out and posting the cards 
until the letter-boxes of Chelsea were in a state of congestion 
unprecedented in that quiet corner of London. The private 
view was on June 6. 

The exhibition was a shock to London. Such defiance 
might be understood in Paris, though even there the action 
1872-74] 179 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


of Courbet and Manet was questioned; in London, it was 
new, and therefore to be suspected. The decorations were 
an indiscretion; no one had before suggested to people 
whose standard was the Academy that a show of pictures 
might be beautiful. The work was a more serious offence. 
Portraits, called Arrangements or Symphonies scandalised a 
generation who, blinded by the yearly Academic display, 
could not see the beauty of Whistler’s flat modelling, and 
of flesh low in tone, and who would have frankly confessed 
their preference for the “foolish sunset ” to the poetry of 
night. But even the pictures could have been forgiven more 
easily than the titles. From the moment he exhibited 
Arrangements and Nocturnes, his growing reputation for 
eccentricity was established beyond a doubt. 


“I know that many good people think my nomenclature 
funny and myself ‘eccentric.’ Yes, ‘ eccentric’ is the adjective 
they find forme. The vast majority of English folk cannot and 
will not consider a picture as a picture, apart from any story 
which it may be supposed to tell. .. . As music is the poetry 
of sound, so is painting the poetry of sight, and the subject- 
matter has nothing to do with harmony of sound or of colour.’’ 


He had robbed them of their only pleasure in art. Well 
received at first, his position in public favour had, for the 
last few years, hung in the balance. Now, his exhibition 
weighed in the scales against him, and from this time on, 
for almost twenty years, ridicule was his portion. The 
exhibition exasperated the critics. The Atheneum and the 
Saturday Review took no notice of it. The Pall Mail, remem- 
bering Hamerton, saw in the collection more intellect than 
imagination. Here and there was a polite murmur of “ noble 
conception ”’ and “ Velasquez touch.” Of all that was said 
Whistler singled out for notice then, and preservation after- 
wards, the comments of a forgotten journal, the Hour. It 
has been wondered why he noticed papers of such small 
180 [1872-74 


Pas 


ze 


eae 4 


PORTRAITS 


importance. When he answered the critics, and kept the 
correspondence, it was “‘ to make history,”’ he said, and he 
selected what he thought important, though it might come 
from an insignificant source. The Hour suggested that the 
best works in the show were not of recent date; Whistler 
wrote to remove “‘ the melancholy impression ” ; and notice 
and letter “‘ make history,” for it was about this moment 
that it began to be said of him in England, France having 
taken the lead, that he did not fulfil his early promise, and 
it is all recorded in The Gentle Art. 


1872-74 r81 


CHAPTER XV. THE OPEN DOOR. 
THE YEAR EIGHTEEN HUNDRED 
AND SEVENTY-FOUR AND AFTER 


. HISTLER laughed all his troubles away,” it has been 
said. When the Academy rejected him, and the 
critics sneered at his pictures shown in other galleries, and 
the public took the critics seriously, he laughed the louder, 
and felt the more. Polite English ears shrank from his 
laugh—“ his strident peacock laugh,” Mr. Colvin called it. 
** He was a man who could never bear to be alone,” Mr. 
Percy Thomas says; he never could be alone all his life. 
** The door in Lindsey Row was always open,” and Whistler 
liked to think that at his friends’ houses the door was open 
to him. Lord Redesdale, who came to live in the Row in 
1875, says that Whistler was always running in and out. 
Through his own open door strange people drifted. If they 
amused him, he forgave them, however they presumed, and 
they usually did presume. There was a man who, at this 
time, he said, came to dine one evening, and, asking to stay 
over night, remained three years : 


“Well, you know, there he was—and that was the way he 
had always lived—the prince of parasites! He was a genius, a 
musician, the first of the ‘ Austhetes,’ before the silly name was 
invented. He hadn’t anything to do—he didn’t do anything 
for me—but decorate the dinner-table, arrange the flowers, and 
then play the piano, and talk, and make himself amiable. He 
hadn’t any enthusiasm—that’s why he was so restful. He was 
always ready to go to Cremorne with me—it was the time of the 
Nocturnes. At moments my mother objected to such a loafer 

182 [1874— 


THE OPEN DOOR 


about the house. And I would say to her—‘ well—but—my 
dear mummy, who else is there to whom we could say, play, and 
_he would play ; and, stop playing, and he would stop right away !’ 

Then I was ill. He couldn’t be trusted with a message to the 

doctor or the druggist, and he was onlyin the way. But he had 

the good sense to see it, and to suggest it was time to be going 

—so he Jeft for somebody else! It never occurred to him there 

was any reason he shouldn’t live like that.” 

We have heard of many others. One, to whom Whistler 
entrusted the money for the weekly bills, gave lunches to 
his friends and sent flowers and chocolates right and left, 
while Whistler’s debts multiplied into fabulous sums at the 
butcher’s and the grocer’s. 

Artists and art students came through the open door to 
see and to learn and were welcomed. If, however, they 
came to loaf and to play, they paid for it. They ran 
errands, posted letters, sat in the corner, interviewed greater 
bores than themselves. They had to give up all their time, 
and then the end came, and out they went. 

One story in Chelsea is of a Frenchman who taught art 
and sold tapestry. Whistler bought a number of things 
from him. “ But vill he pay, zis Vistlaire, vill he pay ?”’ 
the man asked, and, at last one evening he went to Lindsey 
Row. A cab was at the door. The maid said Whistler was 
not in, but the man heard his voice and pushed past, and 
said afterwards : 

“Upstairs, I find him, before a little picture painting, and 
~ behind him ze bruzzers Greaves holding candles. And Vistlaire, 
he say, ‘ You are ze very man I vant; hold a candle!’ And 

I hold a candle. And Vistlaire he paint, and he paint, and zen he 

take ze picture, and he go downstairs, and he get in ze cab, and 
_ he drive off, and we hold ze candle, and I see him no more. Mon 

Dieu, il est terrible, ce Vistlaire !” 

But he was paid the next day. 

_ Few men depended more on companionship than Whistler, 
and to few was the companionship women alone can give 
1874—] 183 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


more essential. All his life, he retained his ceur de femme 
and most of his friends were women. For years, until her 
health broke down, his mother was always with him. Many 
wondered, with Val Prinsep who thought Whistler ‘“‘ always 
acting a part,’’ whether, 


“behind the poseur, there was not quite a different Whistler. 
Those who saw him with his mother were conscious of the fact 
that the irrepressible Jimmy was very human. No one could 
have been a better son, or more attentive to his mother’s wishes. 
Sometimes old Mrs. Whistler, who was a stern Presbyterian in 
her religion, must have been very trying to herson. Yet Jimmy, 
though he used to give a queer smile when he mentioned them, 
never in any way complained of the old lady’s strict Sabbatarian 
notions, to which he bowed without remonstrance.” 


Whistler seldom painted men except when they came for 
their portraits, and the models, drifting in and out of the 
open door of Lindsey Row, were mostly women. He liked 
to have them with him. Mr. Thomas thinks he felt it 
necessary to see them about the studio, for, as he watched 
their movements, they would take the pose he wanted, or 
suggest a group, an arrangement. An admirable example 
is the Whistler in his Studio, done in the first house in Lindsey 
Row. It was a beautiful study, he wrote to Fantin, for a 
big picture, like the Hommage a Delacroiz, with Fantin, 
Albert Moore, and himself, the ‘‘ White Girl’? on a couch, 
and la Japonaise walking about, grouped together in his 
studio: all that would shock the Academicians. The colour 
was to be dainty,—he in pale grey, “Joe” in white, la 
J aponaise in flesh-colour, Albert Moore and Fantin to give the 
black note. The canvas was to be ten feet by six. If he 
ever did more than make the study of the two girls and him- 
self, it has disappeared. The painting is owned by Mr. 
Douglas Freshfield, and is as dainty as he described it. He 
holds the small palette he sometimes used, with raised edges 
184 [1874— 


WHISTLER IN HIS STUDIO 


THE OPEN DOOR 


to keep the liquid colour from running off, he wears the long 
sleeved white waistcoat in which he usually painted, and he 
put down simply what he saw in the mirror. The two 
women most likely are the two models for Symphony in 
White, No. III. who have just stopped posing. Another 
version of this studio interior, but there is some doubt 
as to its genuineness, is in the City of Dublin Art Gallery. 
Whistler repudiated it at the last. There is nothing else 
of the kind as complete, but there are innumerable studies 
of figures, reading or sewing, really not posing, though 
the minute he started to draw them they had to pose. 
Everybody who was with him, and somebody always was, 
had, sooner or later, to sit to be painted, etched or drawn. 

Refugees from France in 1870 drifted through the open 
door, artists whose work was stopped by the Commune and 
who came to England to take it up again. There were many, 
Tissot, Dalou, Professor Lantéri. Fantin stayed in Paris, but 
later told stories of the siege which Whistler repeated to us. 
He asked Fantin what he did? ‘‘ Me?” replied Fantin, “I 
hid in the cellar. Je suis poltron, moi.” Tissot, within the 
open door, found the inspiration for his pictures on the river. 

Journalists, critics, hurried to Lindsey Row, once they 
knew the door was open. Mr. Walter Greaves, who some- 
times showed the studio, remembers doing the honours for 
Tom Taylor among others. Mr. Sidney Starr says Whistler 
told him that, while the Miss Alexander was in the studio, 
Tom Taylor was there one day : 


“There were other visitors. Taylor said, ‘Ah, yes, um,’ then 
remarked that the upright line in the panelling of the wall was 
wrong, and the picture would be better without it, adding, ‘ Of 
course, it’s a matter of taste.’ To which Whistler replied, ‘I 
thought that perhaps for once, you were going to get away 
without having said anything foolish; but remember, so that 
you may not make the mistake again, it’s not a matter of taste 
at all, it is a matter of knowledge. Good-bye.” 

1874-] 185 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Journalists and critics filled columns with praise of un- 
known masterpieces by forgotten Academicians, but seldom 
spared space for the work in Lindsey Row. Their gossip, 
after the visit, was about the man, not his pictures. 

Poets, the younger literary men, came in through the open 
door. Mr. Edmund Gosse, introduced by Mr. W. M. Rossetti, 
has described to us his impressions of the bare room, with 
little in it but the easel, and of the small, alert, nervous man 
with keen eyes and beautiful hands, who sat before it, looking 
at his canvas, never moving but looking steadily for twenty 
minutes or half an hour perhaps—and then, of a sudden, 
dashing at it, giving it one touch, and saying, ‘‘ There, well, 
I think that will do for to-day!” an all-astonishing ex- 
perience to a generation accustomed to tapestried studios 
and painters more industrious with their hands than their 
brains. 

The fashionable world also began to crowd through the 
open door. Lindsey Row was lined with the carriages of 
Mayfair and Belgravia. Whistler was the fashion, if his 
pictures were not, and he could say nothing, he could do 
nothing, that did not go the rounds of drawing-rooms and 
dinner-tables. “‘Ha ha! I have no private life!’ he told 
aman who threatened him with some sort of exposure. And, 
from this time onward, he never had. 

He knew just how much his popularity meant. It was 
among the people who gathered about him because he was 
the fashion, that he could not afford to have friends. ‘‘ To 
the rare Few, who, early in Life have rid Themselves of the 
Friendship of the Many,” The Gentle Art is dedicated, and 
he got rid of all unnecessary friends at the start, he often 
said. It was thought that he could not live without fighting, 
that to him “ battle was the spice of life.” But he never 
fought until fighting was forced upon him. There were no 
fights, Just as there was no mystery, at first. Every man 
186 ~ [1874— 


THE OPEN DOOR 


was a friend until he proved himself an enemy. When 
the fighting began, Whistler got pleasure out of it, no doubt, 
‘the springs in him prompt for the challenge.” He liked a 
fight, enjoyed it, roared over it, would shake himself joyously 
to and fro in talking of it, Lord Redesdale has told us of the 
Lindsey Row days, when Whistler would come to him in the 
morning at breakfast, or in the evening after dinner, to read 
the latest correspondence, and laugh over the dulness of the 
enemy. Though Whistler could not afford friends, he 
delighted in society, finding in it the change most men find 
in sport or travel. He hated to go away or to stop his work. 
Hunting and fishing were no pleasure to him. We never 
heard of his attempting to shoot, except once at the Ley- 
lands’ when, he said: ‘“‘ I rather fancied I had shot part of 
a hare, for I thought I saw the fluff of its fur flying. I knew 
I hit a dog, for I saw the keeper taking out the shots!”’ His 
solicitor, Mr. William Webb, tried once to teach him to 
ride a bicycle. ‘‘ Learn it? No,” he said to us. ‘* Why, 
I fell right off—but I fell in a rose-bush!” Motoring 
offended him, and he always abused J. for taking it up. 
But people amused him, and he enjoyed the “ parade of 
hig.” 

From the first, at Lindsey Row, he gave his breakfasts 
and dinners. Mr. Luke Ionides remembers calling one early 
afternoon when 


‘“‘ Jimmy was busy putting things straight—he asked me if 1 
had any money. I told him I had twelve shillings. He said 
that was enough. We went out together, and he bought three 
chairs at two and sixpence each, and three bottles of claret at 
eighteenpence each, and three sticks of sealing-wax of different 
colours at twopence each. On our return he sealed the top of 
each bottle with a different coloured wax. He then told me he 
expected a possible buyer to dinner, and two other friends. When 
we had taken our seats at the table, he very solemnly told the 
maid to go down and bring up a bottle of wine, one of those 
1874-] 187 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


with the red seal. The maid could hardly suppress a grin, but 
I alone saw it. Then, after the meat, he told her to fetch a bottle 
with the blue seal; and with dessert the one with the yellow 
seal was brought, and all were drunk in perfect innocence and 
delight. He sold his picture, and he said he was sure the sealing 
wax had done it.” 


This was very like him. All his life he invented wines 
and was continually making “ finds.”” We remember his 
discovery of a wonderful Crotite Mallard at the Café Royal, 
and an equally wonderful Pouilly supplied by his French 
barber, who had been one of Napoleon III.’s generals, or 
Maximilian’s aides-de-camp. Another thing at the Café 
Royal, besides the menu that interested him, was the N on 
the wine-glasses which were said to have come from the 
Tuileries in 1870, but, no matter how many have been 
broken, is still there. 

We have the story of his first dinner-party from Mr. Walter 
Greaves, one of whose workmen was sent to Madame Venturi’s 
to borrow and came back hung about with pots and kettles 
and pans, and from Mrs. Leyland, who lent her butler, and 
who, at the last moment, with her sister, put up muslin 
curtains at the windows. Different guests remember 
Whistler’s alarm when a near-sighted young lady in white 
mistook the Japanese bath, filled with water-lilies, for a divan, 
and tried to sit in it; and Leyland’s disgust when Grisi’s 
daughter, whom he took in to dinner, would talk to him 
not of music, but of Ouida’s novels. Every one found the 
menu ‘*‘ a little eccentric, but excellent.”’ The earliest menu 
we have seen is one, in Mr. Walter Dowdeswell’s possession, 
of a dinner in the ’eighties, not in the least eccentric, but as 
simple as it is characteristic of Whistler,and so we give it now: 
Potage Potiron ; Soles Frites; Beeuf ala Mode; Chapon au 
Cresson; Salade Laitue; Marmalade de Pommes; Omelette 


au Fromage. 
188 [1874— 


THE OPEN DOOR 


Mr. Alan S. Cole’s diary is the record of other dinners in 


the ’seventies, of the company, and the talk: 

“ November 16, 1875.—Dined with Jimmy; Tissot, A. Moore 
and Captain Crabb. Lovely blue and white china—and capital 
small dinner. General conversation and ideas on art unfettered 
by principles. Lovely Japanese lacquer. 


“ December 7, 1875.—Dined with Jimmy ; Cyril Flower, Tissot, 
Storey. Talked Balzac—Pére Goriot—Cousine Bette—Cousin 
Pons—Jeune Homme de Province a Paris—lIllusions perdues. 


“ January 6, 1876.—With my father and mother to dine at 
Whistler’s. Mrs. Montiori, Mrs. Stansfield and Gee there My 
father on the innate desire or ambition of some men to be creators, 
either physical or mental. Whistler considered art had reached 
a climax with Japanese and Velasquez. He had to admit 
natural instinct and influence—and the ceaseless changing in 
all things. . 


“ March 12, 1876.—Dined with Jimmy. Miss Franklin there. 
Great conversation on Spiritualism, in which J. believes. We 
tried to get raps—but were unsuccessful, except in getting noises 
from sticky fingers on the table. 


“ March 25, 1876.—Round to Whistler’s to dine. Mrs. Leyland 
and Mrs. Galsworthy, and others. 


“ September 16, 1876.—Dined with W. Eldon there. Hot 
discussion about Napoleon (Napoléon le petit, by Hugo). The 
Commune, with which J. sympathised [some old fellow feeling 
for Courbet, the reason perhaps].—Spiritualism. 


“ December 29, 1876.—To dine with J.—the Doctor.—Goldfish 
in bowl. Japanese trays.—Storks and birds. He read out two 
or three stories by Bret Harte—Luck of Roaring Camp,—The 
Outcasts of Poker Flat—Tennessee’s Partner. Chatted as to 
doing illustration for a Catalogue for Mitford, and to his Japanese 
woman, and a decorated room for the Museum. 

“ February 18, 1878.—To Whistler’s——Mark Twain’s haunting 
jingle in the tramcar: * Punch—punch—punch with care— 
punch in the presence of the passenger (jaire). 

“ March 27, 1878. Dined with Whistler, young Mills and 
Lang, who writes. He seemed shocked by much that was said 
by Jimmy and Eldon.” 

1874-] 189 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Whistler delighted not only in Mark Twain’s, but in all 
jingles. He had an endless stock, and recited them in the 
most unexpected places and at the most inappropriate 
moments. He went to the trouble once to write down for 
us the lines of the Woodchuck, and now, as we read them in 
the familiar writing, we can only wonder why they never 
seemed foolish but quite right as he chanted them. In the 
Haden correspondence, published in The Gentle Art, a new 
version of Peter Piper may be found. He loved to quote 
the Danbury News man and the Detroit Free Press. He 
never lost his joy in certain forms of American humour, 
and it was because there was something of the same spirit 
in them that Rossetti’s limericks appealed to him. 

Whistler “invented ’’ Sunday breakfasts. The day was 
unusual in London, and also the hour, twelve instead of nine. 
** Nothing exactly like them have ever been seen in the 
world. They were as original as himself or his work, and 
equally memorable,” George Boughton wrote. Whistler 
took with them infinite pains. He designed the card of 
invitation, he arranged the table, and he saw that every- 
thing placed on it was beautiful: the blue and white he was 
years in collecting, the silver, the linen, the Japanese bowl 
of goldfish, or the jar of flowers in the centre. If his own 
resources failed, he borrowed from Lord Redesdale, two 
doors off, or, after his brother was married, from Mrs. William 
Whistler, whose beautiful pieces of Japanese lacquer were his 
admiration. He prepared the menu, partly American, partly 
French, and wholly bewildering to joint-loving Britons. His 
buckwheat cakes are not yet forgotten. He would make 
them himself, if the party were quite informal, and he never 
spoke again to one man who ventured to dislike them. 

Sometimes eighteen or twenty sat down to breakfast, more 
often half that number. All were people Whistler wanted 
to meet, people who talked, people who painted, people who 
190 [1874— 


PORTRAIT OF WHISTLER WITH HAT 


THE OPEN DOOR — 


wrote, people who bought, people who were distinguished, 
people who were royal, people who were friends. From Mr. 
Cole, again, we have notes of the company and talk at some 
of the breakfasts : 

* June 17, 1877.—To breakfast at J.’s. F. Dicey, young 
Potter and Huth there. He showed some studies from figures 
—light and elegant—to be finished. 

“ June 29, 1879.—To Whistler’s for breakfast. Much talk 
about Comédie-Francaise and Sarah Bernhardt. 

“ July 8, 1883.—Breakfast at W.’s. Lord Houghton, Oscar 
Wilde, Mrs. Singleton, Mrs. Moncrieff, Mrs. Gerald Potter, Lady 
Archie Campbell, the Storeys, Theodore Watts, and some others. 
Mrs. Moncrieff sang well afterwards. Lord Houghton asked me 
about my father’s memoirs. Margie sat by him.” 


6¢ ’ 


The breakfasts remain ‘‘ charming ’”’ in Mrs. Moncrieff’s 
memory. And “charming” is Lady Colin Campbell’s 
word ; the charm in the blue and white, the old silver, the 
distinctive little touch Whistler gave to everything. Lady 
Wolseley writes us that she remembers “a flight of fans 
fastened up on the walls, and also that the table had a large 
flat blue China bowl, or dish, with gold-fish and nasturtiums 
in it.” Mrs. Alan S. Cole recalls a single tall lily springing 
from the bowl; though invited for twelve, it was wiser, she 
adds, not to arrive much before two, for to get there earlier 
was often to hear Whistler splashing in his bath somewhere 
close to the drawing-room. This was Mr. W. J. Rawlinson’s 
experience once. He had been asked for twelve, he says, and 
he got there a few minutes before as he would for a breakfast 
in Paris. Several guests had already come, others followed, 
_ a dozen perhaps; one was Lord Wolseley. For Whistler 
alone, they waited—and they waited and they waited. At 
about half-past one, while they were still waiting, they heard 
a splashing behind the folding-doors. There was a moment 
of indignation. Then Howell hurried in, beaming on them. 
‘It’s all right, it’s all right!’ he said, ‘‘ Jimmie won’t be 
1874—] IgI 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


long now—he is just having his bath!’ Howell talked, 
and they waited, and two struck before Whistler appeared, 
smiling, gracious, all in white, for it was hot, and they went 
down to breakfast. As soon as he came in, he was so 
fascinating that the waiting was forgotten. 

Sir Rennell Rodd writes us of the breakfasts at 13 Tite 
Street : 

“with the inevitable buckwheat cakes, and green corn, and 

brilliant talk. One I remember particularly, for we happened 

to be thirteen. There were two Miss C——s present, the youngest 
of whom died within a week of the breakfast, and an elderly 
gentleman, whose name I forget, who was there also, when he 

heard of it at his club, said, ‘God bless my soul,’ and had a 

stroke and died also.” 

J. was once only at one of the Chelsea breakfasts, in 1884, 
at Tite Street, when Mr. Menpes was present. But we 
often breakfasted in Paris, at the Rue du Bac, and in London, 
at the Fitzroy Street studio. It made no difference who 
was there, who sat beside you, Whistler dominated every- 
body and everything, and this was the case not only in his 
own, but in any and every house where he went. It was 
one of the many extraordinary things about him that, 
though short and small, a man of diminutive size the usual 
description, his was invariably the most commanding presence 
in a room. When he talked every one listened. At his 
own table, he had a delightful way of waiting himself upon 
his guests. He would go round the table with a bottle of 
some special Burgundy in its cradle, talking all the while, 
emphasising every point in his talk with a dramatic pause 
just before or just after filling a glass. We remember one 
Sunday in Paris, in 1898, Mr. and Mrs. Edwin A. Abbey and 
Mr. D. S. MacColl the other guests, when he told how he 
hung the pictures at the annual Liverpool exhibition in 1891 : 

“You know, the Academy baby by the dozen had been sent 


in, and I got them all in my gallery—and in the centre, at one 
192 [1874— 


LADY HADEN 


THE OPEN DOOR 


end, I placed the birth of the baby—splendid—and opposite, 
the baby with the mustard-pot, and opposite that the baby with 
the puppy—and in the centre, on one side, the baby ill, doctor 
holding its pulse, mother weeping. On the other, by the door, 
the baby dead—the baby’s funeral—baby from the cradle to 
the grave—baby in heaven—babies of all kinds and shapes all 
along the line, not crowded, you know, hung with proper respect 
for the baby. And on varnishing day, in came the artists— 
each making for his own baby—amazing! his baby on the line 
—nothing could be better! And they all shook my hand, and 
thanked me—and went to look—at the other men’s babies—and 
then they saw babies in front of them, babies behind them, babies 
to right of them, babies to left of them. And then—you know 
—their faces fell—they didn’t seem to like it—and—well—ha ! 
ha ! they never asked me to hang the pictures again at Liverpool ! 
What !” 


As he told it, he was on his feet, pouring out his Burgundy, 
minutes sometimes to fill a single glass. There were intervals 
between one guest and the next ; he seemed never to be in 
his chair ; it was fully two hours before the story and break- 
fast came to an end together. But though no one else 
had a chance to talk, no one was bored. It was the same 
wherever he went, if the people were sympathetic. If they 
were not, he could be as grim as anybody, especially if he 
was expected to ‘‘ show off”; or, he could go fast asleep. 
In sympathetic houses, he not only led the talk, but controlled 
it. There is a legend that he and Mark Twain met for 
the first time at a dinner, when they simultaneously asked 
their hostess who that very noisy fellow was? For there 
was noise, there was gaiety, and everybody was carried 
away by it, even the servants. 

Whistler was the artist in his use of words and phrases, 
by their effective repetition making them as inseparable a 
part of his personality as the white lock and the eyeglass. 
His sudden ‘ what,” his familiar ‘‘ well, you know,” his 
eloquent “‘H’m! h’m!” were placed as carefully as the 
1874—] I: N 193 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Butterfly on his card of invitation, the blue and white on 
the table. No man was ever so eloquent with his hands, 
the fingers long, thin, sensitive—“ alive to the tips, like the 
fingers of a mesmerist,’’ Mr. Arthur Symons writes of them. 
No man ever put so much into words as he into the pause 
for the laugh, into the laugh itself, the loud, sharp “‘ Ha 
ha!” from which so many learned to shrink, and into the 
deliberate adjusting of his eye-glass. So much was in his 
manner, that it is almost impossible to give an idea of his talk 
to those who never heard it. We have listened to him with 
wonder and delight, and then gone away and tried to remember 
what he said, to find it fall flat and lifeless without the play of 
his expressive hands, without the malice or the music of his 
laugh. This is why the stories of him in print often make 
people marvel at the reputation they have brought him. Not 
that the talk in itself was not good; it was. His wit was 
quick, spontaneous. ‘“‘ Providence is very good to me some- 
times,’’ he said once when we asked him how he found an 
answer. He has been compared to Degas, who, it is said, 
will lead up the talk to a witticism prepared beforehand ; 
Whistler’s wit met like a flash the word or the challenge he 
could not have anticipated. And he loved to tell a story, 
making more of the best than any other man. He loved 
gossip, and treated it with a delicacy, a humour that was 
irresistible. He could be fantastic, malicious, audacious, 
serious, everything but dull or gross. He shrank from 
grossness. No one, not his worst enemies, can recall a story 
from him with a touch or taint of it. The ugly, the unclean, 
revolted him. 

We have heard of Sundays when Whistler sketched the 
people who were there, hanging these sketches at times in 
his dining-room. One Sunday he made the dry-point of 
Lord (then Sir Garnet) Wolseley. Lord Wolseley himself 
has forgotten it : “‘ I fear beyond the recollection of an agree- 
194 [1874— 


THE OPEN DOOR 


able luncheon at his house at Chelsea, I have no reminiscence,”’ 
he wrote to us. And Lady Wolseley thinks “‘ Lord Wolseley 
may have gone to him for sittings early, and have breakfasted 
with him. I have a vague impression.” But Howell, 
helpful as well as charming, was summoned that Sunday from 
Putney to amuse the sitter and prevent his hurrying off, 
and he put the date in his diary : 

“ November 24, 1877.—Went to Whistler’s, met Sir Garnet 
Wolseley. Whistler etched him—got two first proofs, second 
one touched, 42s. Met Pellegrini and Godwin.” 

Whistler not only entertained, but also went everywhere, 
and knew everybody, though he did not allow everybody to 
know him. When somebody said to him, “ The Prince of 
Wales says he knows you,”’ Whistler’s answer was, “ That’s 
only his side.’” He lived at a rate that would have killed 
most men, and at an expense in details that was fabulous. 
‘“T never dined alone for years,” he said. If no one was 
coming to him, if no one had invited him, he dined at a club 
or a restaurant. He was a familiar figure, at different 
periods, in the Arts and Hogarth Clubs, the Arundel, the 
Beaufort Grill Club in Dover Street, or, for supper, at the 
Beefsteak Club. Many of his letters, for a period, were dated 
from ‘‘ The Fielding ”’ in King Street, Covent Garden. He 
was once put up at the Savile Club, he told us, but heard no 
more about it, and at the Savage, but that, he said, “‘ is a club 
to belong to, never to go to.” At the Reform Club, had he 
thought of it, he lost all chances of election one night when 
his laugh woke up the old gentlemen, whose snores were 
equally loud, in the reading-room. In the Lindsey Row days 
he went often to a cheap French restaurant, “‘ good of its 
kind,” with Albert Moore and Homer Martin, a man he 
delighted in. Many artists dined there, he said, and would 
sit and talk until late in the evening : 


‘“* But then, you know, the sort of Englishman who is entirely 
1874-] 195 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


outside all these things, and likes to think he is ‘in it,’ began to 
come too, and that ruined it.” 


To Pagani’s in Great Portland Street, a tiny place then, 
he also went with Pellegrini and other friends. He was 
most often seen at the Café Royal, in the ’eighties, when 
he dined there with Oscar Wilde, and, towards the end, 
when Mr. Heinemann, Mr. E. G. Kennedy, and ourselves 
were most often with him, and when, if he ordered the 
dinner, you might be sure that Poulet en Casserole would be 
the principal dish, and sweet champagne the wine. Never 
shall we forget a dinner at the Café Royal, in 1899, to Mr. 
Freer, who had just bought a picture. We were the other 
guests, with Mr. Heinemann. Much as Whistler wished 
to be amiable to Mr. Freer, he was very tired, and, somehow, 
the dinner was not quite right, and there were scenes in our 
little corner behind the screen. Mr. Freer felt it necessary 
to entertain the party, which he did by talking pictures, like 
a “‘ new critic,’ and Japanese prints, like a cultured school- 
ma’am. Whistler slept peacefully through it all, and we 
tried to be attentive, until at length, at some psychological 
moment in Hiroshige’s life or in Mr. Freer’s collection, 
Whistler snored such a tremendous snore that he woke 
himself up, crying: “‘ Good Heavens! Who is snoring ? ” 

Whistler had the great fault of being late when invited 
to dinner. One evening, an official evening, he arrived an 
hour late. ‘*‘ We areso hungry, Mr. Whistler ! ’’ said his host, 
“What a good sign!” was his answer. At times he felt 
** like a little devil,”’ and he told us of one of those occasions : 


“I arrived. In the middle of the drawing-room table was 
the new Fortnightly Review, wet from the press ; in it an article 
on Méryon by Wedmore, and there was Wedmore—the distin- 
guished guest. I felt the excitement over the great man, and 
the great things he had been doing. Wedmore took the hostess 
in to dinner; I was on her other side, seeing things, bent on 

196 [1874— 


THE OPEN DOOR 


making the most of them. And I talked—of critics, of Wedmore, 
as though I did not know who sat opposite. And I was nudged, 
my foot kicked under the table. But I talked. And whenever 
the conversation turned on Méryon, or Wedmore’s article, or 
other serious things, I told another story, and I laughed—ha ! 
ha !—and they couldn’t help it, they all laughed with me, and 
Wedmore was forgotten, and I was the hero of the evening. And 
Wedmore has never forgiven me.” 


Whistler went a great deal to the theatre in the ’seventies 
and ’eighties, and was always seen at first nights. Occasion- 
ally, in the ’seventies, as in the ’sixties, he acted in amateur 
theatricals. He and Mr. Cole, in 1876, played in Under 
the Umbrella, in Kensington Town Hall, and Whistler was 
“elated ’ by a paragraph on his performance in the Daily 
News. He showed himself at private views, and at all the 
ceremonies society approves. To see and be seen was part 
of the social game, and the world, meeting him everywhere, 
mistook him for the Butterfly for which he seemed to pose. 


1874—] 197 


CHAPTER XVI. THE PEACOCK ROOM. 
THE YEARS EIGHTEEN SEVENTY-FOUR 
TO EIGHTEEN SEVENTY-SEVEN 


OR a year after Whistler’s exhibition in Pall Mall, his 
pictures were seen nowhere but in his studio. A 
feeling prevailed among artists that his painting was not 
serious, because not finished as they understood finish. 
Whistler retorted that theirs ‘‘ might be finished, but—well— 
it never had been begun.” This was not the way to curry 
favour with selecting committees. Probably Royal Aca- 
demicians were honest, though they were malicious. Lord 
Redesdale remembers one whose work now is discredited, 
who used to say that Whistler was losing his eyesight, that 
he could not see there was no paint on his canvas. Mr. 
G. A. Holmes has told us that a few artists in Chelsea, though 
they disliked him personally, thought he was a man with 
new ideas, character, originality, one who threw new light 
on art; Henry Moore said to Mr. Holmes that Whistler put 
more atmosphere into his pictures than any man living. 
But Academicians, as a rule, were afraid of him, so much so 
that Whistler would say to Mr. Holmes: ‘* Well, you know, 
they want to treat me like a sheet of note-paper, and crumple 
me up!” 

His prints at this time appeared in exhibitions, because 
many were in the fine collection of etchings which Mr. Ander- 
son lent to the Liverpool Art Club in October 1874, and a few 
months afterwards to the Hartley Institution at Southampton. 
Shortly before the Liverpool show opened, Mr. Ralph Thomas’ 
198 [1874 


THE PEACOCK ROOM 


Catalogue, the first of Whistler’s etchings, was privately 
published by John Russell Smith of Soho Square. Of the 
fifty copies printed, only twenty-five were for sale, so that 
it became at once rare. Mr. Percy Thomas etched Whistler’s 
portrait of himself (Mr. McCullough’s) for the frontispiece, 
Mr. Ralph Thomas, who described the plates, had been with 
Whistler when many were made and printed, and it must 
always be regretted that Mr. Wedmore did not retain his 
titles. In 1875, Whistler again exhibited pictures in the 
few galleries that found a place for him when the Academy 
could not. In October he sent to the Winter Exhibition 
at the Dudley Gallery a Nocturne in Blue and Gold, No. III., 
which the name makes difficult to identify, and Nocturne in 
Black and Gold—The Falling Rocket, which Ruskin, presently 
was to identify beyond the possibility of doubt: the im- 
pression of fireworks that filled the night with beauty for 
Whistler in the gardens of Cremorne. At the Dudley, it 
created no sensation. F.G. Stephens, in the Atheneum, was 
almost alone in his praise. A month later, November 1875, 
Chelsea Reach—Harmony in Grey, and many studies of figures 
on brown paper were at the Winter Exhibition of the Society 
of French Artists, and three Nocturnes in the Spring 
Exhibition (1876) of the same Society. Thus Whistler 
managed without the Royal Academy. 

In the studio there were new portraits. When Irving 
appeared as Philip II. in 1874, Whistler was struck with 
the tall, slim, romantic figure in silvery greys and blacks, 
and got Irving to pose. Mr. Bernhard Sickert thinks it 
extraordinary that Whistler failed to suggest Irving’s char- 
acter. We think it more extraordinary for Mr. Sickert to 
be unaware that Whistler was painting Irving made up as 
Philip IJ. and not as Henry Irving. When Mr. Alan S. Cole 
saw the picture at the studio, on May 5, 1876, he found 
Whistler ‘“ quite madly enthusiastic about his power of 
1876] 199 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


painting such full-lengths in two sittings or so.” The re- 
production in M. Duret’s Whistler differs in so many details 
from the picture as it is, that we wondered if two portraits 
were painted. M. Duret tells us that his reproduction is 
from a photograph lent him by Mr. George Lucas, to whom 
Whistler gave it. Probably, M. Duret writes, the photograph 
was taken while Whistler was painting the picture, and 
afterwards, in working, he altered it. On comparing the 
photograph to the picture, we do not think there were 
two portraits, but there are many changes. In the photo- 
graph, the cloak is thrown back over the actor’s right shoulder, 
showing his arm. In the exhibited picture, his arm is hidden 
by the cloak and his hand, which before seems to have been 
thrust into his doublet, now rests upon the collar of an order. 
The trunks apparently were much altered, especially the 
right, and the legs are far better drawn, the left foot being 
entirely repainted. Though Whistler was acquiring more 
certainty in putting in these big portraits at once, he was 
becoming more and more exacting and made repeated changes. 
The portrait was not a commission. It is said that Irving 
refused the small price Whistler asked for it, but later, seeing 
his legs sticking out from under a pile of canvases in a War- 
dour Street shop, recognised them, and bought the picture 
for ten guineas. Mr. Bram Stoker writes that, at the time 
of the bankruptcy, Whistler sold it to Irving “for either 
twenty or forty pounds—I forget which.” The facts are 
that Whistler sold the Irving to Howell, for ‘‘ ten pounds and 
a sealskin coat,’ Howell recorded in his diary, and that from 
him it passed into the hands of Mr. Graves, the printseller 
in Pall Mall, who sold it to Irving for one hundred pounds. 
After Irving’s death, it came up for sale at Christie’s, and 
fetched five thousand pounds, becoming the property of 
Mr. Thomas of Philadelphia. 

A portrait of Sir Henry Cole was begun this spring. Mr. 
200 [1876 


~ 


——_—_— 


Vers 


eee NC 
Cho, 


SKETCHES FOR THE PEACOCK ROOM 


atlases ts # 
aaiead -~ 


THE PEACOCK ROOM 


Alan S. Cole, in his diary (May 19, 1876) speaks of ‘‘ a strong 
commencement upon a nearly life-size portrait of my father. 
Looking at it reflected in glass, and how the figure stood 
within the frame.” This was never finished. Whistler’s 
executrix says it was burned. 

Lord Redesdale tells us of a beautiful full-length of his 
wife in draperies of Chinese blue silk Whistler called “‘ fair,” 
which was his word then for everything he liked. With two 
or three more sittings, and a little work, it would have been 
finished. But it was a difficult moment, men were in posses- 
sion at No. 2 Lindsey Row, and, rather than risk its falling 
into their hands, he slashed the canvas to pieces. The debt 
was small, some thirty pounds or so, and the price agreed 
upon for the portrait was two hundred guineas. Lord 
Redesdale or any other friend, would gladly have settled 
the matter, but Whistler said nothing. A portrait started 
of Lord Redesdale, in Van Dyck costume, and several Noc- 
turnes went, he says, the same way. The Fur Jacket, Rosa 
Corder, Connie Gilchrist with the Skipping Rope—T he Gold Girl, 
Effie Deans, were also painted, or at least begun. The Fur 
Jacket, Arrangement in Black and Brown his final name for 
it in the exhibition at Goupil’s in 1892, is the portrait of 
“*Maud,”’ Miss Franklin, who, from now on, becomes more 
important in his life and in his art. It is one of great dignity. 
The dress is put in with a full sweeping brush in long flowing 
lines, almost classic in the fall of its folds ; the pale beautiful 
face looks out, like a flower, from the depths of the back- 
ground. In many portraits Whistler was rebuked for 
sacrificing the face to the design; here, the interest is con- 
centrated in the face, and that is why the “ shadowy figure ” 
has been criticised as a mere ghost, a mere “* rub-in of colour,” 
on the canvas. That he had carried it as far as he thought 
it should be carried to obtain his effect, is the more certain 
when it is contrasted with Rosa Corder, also an Arrangement 
1876] 201 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


in Black and Brown, in which the jacket, the feathered hat 
held, drooping, in one hand, the trailing skirt, even the fine 
face in its severe profile, are more solidly modelled. M. 
Blanche, in an article on Whistler in the Renaissance Latine 
(June 15, 1905), wrote that once Whistler, in Cheyne Walk, 
saw Miss Rosa Corder, in her brown dress, pass a door painted 
black, and was struck with the effect of colour. This may 
be true, for, as we have shown, Whistler often got the first 
idea of a pose, an arrangement, by mere chance. Connie 
Gilchrist, the Gold Girl, at the moment the most popular 
little dancer at the Gaiety, attracted Whistler by her stage 
dress, which revealed her slight girlish form in its delicate, 
youthful beauty. Whistler posed her in the studio as he had 
seen her on the stage, in the act of skipping. But the move- 
ment does not seem part of the decorative arrangement on 
his canvas. It told on the stage by its simplicity, its spon- 
taneity, but it becomes in the picture theatrical, artificial. 
The figure has the elegance of the little pastels, it is placed 
with the distinction of the Miss Alexander, but the suspended 
action gives the sense of incompleteness which his critics 
were so unnecessarily conscious of in his technique. A long 
line swept down the outline of the figure shows that he meant 
to change it. The pose and the movement haunted him. 
Often, in friends’ houses, he would make little sketches of 
pictures he was working on, and one evening he left with Mr. 
Cole sketches both of the Connie Gilchrist and the Rosa Corder 
done in this way. 

Not one of these portraits was shown in 1876, for other 
work gradually engrossed him to the exclusion of everything 
else. It was the year of the Peacock Room. 

He first proposed the scheme to Mr. W. C. Alexander, 
when he designed the decorations for the house on Campden 
Hill, and he put down a few notes in pen and ink. But the 
work went no further, and he arranged, instead, a harmony in 
202 [1876 


THE PEACOCK ROOM 


white for the drawing-room, replaced afterwards by an 
arrangement of Eastern tapestries. The scheme was still 
a@ suggestion on note-paper, when Mr. Leyland bought 
his house in Prince’s Gate. Leyland’s ambition, it is said, 
was to live the life of an ancient Venetian merchant in 
modern London, and he began to remodel the interior and 
to “fill it with beautiful things.”? He bought the gilded 
staircase from Northumberland House, recently pulled 
down to make way for Northumberland Avenue. He got 
Whistler to design the colour in the hall, and paint the 
detail of blossom and leaf in some of the panels of the dado. 
“To Leyland’s house to see Whistler’s colouring of Hall— 
very delicate cocoa-colour and gold—successful,’’ Mr. Cole 
wrote in his diary on March 24. Leyland covered the walls 
of drawing- and reception-rooms with pictures, his instinctive 
preference for the best guiding him in their selection. He 
had fine works by Filippo Lippi, Botticelli, Crivelli. He 
owned, among other things, Rossetti’s Blessed Damosel and 
Lady Lilith, Millais’ Eve of St. Agnes, Ford Madox Brown’s 
Chaucer at King Edward’s Court, Windus’ Burd Helen, Burne- 
Jones’ Mirror of Venus and Wine of Circe. He bought work 
by Legros, Watts and Albert Moore. Whistler’s Princesse 
du Pays de la Porcelaine was already his, and he hung it in his 
dining-room with his splendid collection of blue and white. 
Mr. Norman Shaw was making the alterations in the house 
for Leyland, and another architect, Jeckyll, was suggested 
by Mr. Murray Marks for the decoration of the dining-room 
and the arrangement of the blue and white. Some say the 
original scheme was that Morris and Burne-Jones should 
decorate and furnish the dining-room, though when Whistler 
stepped in, they vanished. The commission was certainly 
given to Jeckyll, and he put up a series of walnut shelves 
to hold the china. Whistler designed the side-board. A 
space was left over the mantel for the Princesse and another 
1876] 203 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


at the opposite end of the room, for paintings by Burne-Jones 
and Whistler, who wished the Three Figures, Pink and 
Grey to hang there and face the Princesse. The walls were 
hung with Norwich leather. The shelves were divided by 
rigid perpendicular lines endlessly repeated, and the panelled 
ceiling, with its pendant lamps, was heavy and oppressive. 
Whistler objected that the red border of the rug, and the 
red flowers in the centre of each panel of the leather, which 
was painted, not embossed, killed the delicate tones of his 
picture. Leyland agreed with him. The red border was 
cut off the rug, and Whistler gilded, or painted, the flowers 
on the leather with yellow and gold. The result he pro- 
nounced horrible; the yellow paint and gilding ‘“‘ swore” 
at the yellow tone of the leather. Something else must be 
done, and again Leyland agreed. The something else 
developed into the scheme of decoration first submitted to 
Mr. Alexander: the Peacock Room. 
He told us one evening, when talking of it: 


“Well, you know, I just painted as I went on, without design 
or sketch—it grew as I painted. And towards the end I reached 
such a point of perfection—putting in every touch with such 
freedom—that when I came round to the corner where I had 
started, why, I had to paint part of it over again, or the difference 
would have been too marked. And the harmony in blue and 
gold developing, you know, I forgot everything in my joy in it!” 


He had planned a journey to Venice, and new series of 
etchings to be made there and in France and Holland. The 
journey was postponed. At the end of the season, the 
Leylands went to Speke Hall. Whistler remained at Prince’s 
Gate. Town emptied, and he was still there, spending his 
days on ladders and scaffolding, lying in a hammock, painting 
with a brush fastened to a fishing-rod. His two pupils 
helped him: ‘ We laid on the gold,” Mr. Walter Greaves 
says, and there were times when the three were found with 
204 [1876 


THE PEACOCK ROOM 


mi 


| 
a i 


THE PEACOCK ROOM 


their hair and faces covered with gold. Whistler’s description 
of this whirlwind of work was “* the show’s afire,”’ an expression 
he used for years when things were “ going.”’ He was up 
every morning before six, and at Prince’s Gate an hour or so 
after ; at noon, jumping into a hansom and driving home to 
lunch ; then hurrying back to his work. At night, he was 
fit for nothing but bed, “‘ so full were my eyes of sleep and 
peacock feathers,” he told us. He thought only of the 
beauty springing up beneath his hands. Autumn set in. 
Lionel Robinson and Sir Thomas Sutherland, the friends 
with whom he was to have gone to Venice, at last started 
without him. He could not drop the work at Prince’s Gate. 

A record of his progress is contained in the short, concise 
notes of Mr. Alan S. Cole’s diary : 


“September 11, 1876.—Whistler dined. Most entertaining 
with his brilliant description of his successful decorations at 
Leyland’s. 

““ September 20.—To see Peacock Room. Peacock feather 
devices—blues and golds—extremely new and original. 

“October 26.—To see room, which is developing. The dado 
and panels greatly help it. Met Poynter, who spoke highly of 
Whistler’s decoration. 

“October 27.—Again to see room with Moody. He did not 
like the varnished surface and blocky manner of laying on the 
gold. 

“October 29.—To Peacock Room. Mitford [Lord Redesdale] 
came. 

“* November 10.—The blue over the brown (leather) background 
is most admirable in effect, and the ornament in gold on blue 
fine. W. quite mad with excitement. 

*“ November 20.—With Prince Teck to see Whistler and the 
Room. Left P. T. with Jimmy. 

““ November 29.—Golden Peacocks promise to be superb. 

“* December 4.—Peacocks superb. 

“* December 8.—Article in Morning Post on Peacock Room. 

** December 9.—Whistler in a state over article in Morning 
Post. Leyland much perturbed as I heard. 

1876] 205 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


“ December 15.—Whistler now thinking of cutting off the 
pendant ceiling lamps in Peacock Room. 

“* December 17.—My father and Probyn to see room. Jimmy 
much disgusted at my father’s telling him that, in taking so 
much pains over his work, and in the minuteness of his etched 
work, he really was like Mulready, who was equally scrupulous.” 


Lord Redesdale tells us that he had just returned from 
Scotland, and had seen nothing of the long summer’s work. 
When he went to Prince’s Gate Whistler was on top of a 
ladder, looking like a little evil imp, a gnome. 

“But what are you doing?” 

““T am doing the loveliest thing you ever saw!” 

“ But what of the beautiful old Spanish leather ? And Ley- 
land? Have you consulted him ?” 

“Why should I? I am doing the most beautiful thing 


that ever has been done, you know—the most beautiful 
room !”’ 


Everybody hurried to look at it, and Whistler began to 
hold a succession of informal receptions at Prince’s Gate. He 
was pleased when people like the Princess Louise and the 
Marquis of Westminster came, he wrote to his mother at 
Hastings, for they set the fashion, kept up the talk in London. 
Boughton said in his Reminiscences : 


“He often asked me round to the Peacock Room, and I see 
him still up on high, lying on his back often, working in ‘ gold 
on blue’ and ‘blue on gold’ over the whole expanse of the 
ceiling—and as far as I could see he let no hand touch it but 
his own.” 


Mrs. Stillman, however, remembers the two pupils working 


hard, while she drank tea with Whistler. Mrs. Richmond 
Ritchie has let us have her impressions of her visit : 


“Long, long after the Paris days, Mr. Whistler danced when 
I would rather have talked. Some one, I cannot remember 
who, it was probably one of Mr. Cole’s family, told me one day 
when I was walking up Prince’s Gate, that he was decorating a 


206 [1876 


THE PEACOCK ROOM 


house by which we were passing—and asked me if I should like 
to goin. We found ourselves, it was like a dream, in a beautiful 
Peacock Room, full of lovely lights and tints, and romantic, 
dazzling effects. James Whistler, in a painter’s smock, stood 
at one end of the room at work. Seeing us, he laid down his 
mahl-stick and brush, and greeted us warmly, and I talked of 
old Paris days to him. ‘I used to ask you to dance,’ he said, 
‘but you liked talking best,’ to which I answered, ‘ No, indeed, 
I liked dancing best ’"—and suddenly I found myself whirling 
half-way down the room.” 


Jeckyll also came, and his visit had a tragic end. When 
he saw what had been done with his work, he hurried home, 
gilded his floor, and forgot his grief in a mad-house. 

Whistler received the critics on February 9, 1877. ‘“‘ Called 
and found Whistler elated with the praises of the press of the 
Peacock Room,” is Mr. Cole’s note on the 18th of the month. 
Even then it was not finished. On March 5, Mr. Cole was 
“late at Prince’s Gate with Whistler, consoling him. He 
trying to finish the peacocks on shutters—with him till 
2 A.M., and walked home.”’ 

Whistler made no change in the architectural construction 
of the room. It was far from beautiful, with its repeated 
lines, its heavy ceiling, its hanging lamps, and its spaces so 
broken up that, only on the wall opposite the Princesse and 
on the shutters, could he carry out his design in its full 
splendour and stateliness, and give gorgeousness of form 
as well as colour: only there could he paint the peacocks 
that were his motive, so that it is by artificial light, with the 
shutters closed, that the room is seen in completeness. He 
could do no more than adapt in the most marvellous fashion 
the eye of the peacock, the throat and breast feathers to 
the broken surfaces. But in spite of all the drawbacks, the 
Peacock Room is the “noble work” he called it to his 
mother, the one perfect mural decoration of modern times. 
It was his first chance, and it will be a lasting reproach to 
1877] 207 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


his contemporaries that there was no one to offer him another 
until it was too late. 

A little leaflet, for distribution among the critics, was 
written, it is said, by Whistler, though the wording does 
not suggest it, and printed by Mr. Thomas Way. We have 
seen only one copy, Lady Haden’s. It explains that, with 
the Peacocks as motive, two patterns, derived from the 
eyes and the breast feathers, were invented and repeated 
throughout, sometimes one alone, sometimes both in com- 
bination ; along the dado, blue on gold, over the walls gold on 
blue; while the arrangement was completed by the birds, 
painted in all their splendour, in blue on the gold shutters, 
in gold on the blue space opposite the chimney place. 

Whistler, who, in his pictures, avoided literary themes, 
resorted to symbolism in his gold peacocks on the wall facing 
the Princesse. One, standing amid flying feathers and gold, 
clutches in his claws a pile of coins; the other bristles and 
spreads his wings in angry but triumphant defiance: “ the 
Rich Peacock and the Poor Peacock,’’ Whistler said, sym- 
bolising the relations between patron and artist. 

Leyland had been kept out of his house in Prince’s Gate 
for months. He had seen his beautiful old leather disappear 
beneath Whistler’s blue and gold. He had heard of recep- 
tions and press views in his house for which no invitations 
had been issued by him or to him, and he was annoyed at 
having his house turned into a public gallery. The crisis 
came when Whistler, thinking himself justified by months 
of work, asked two thousand guineas for the decoration of 
the room, as a reasonable price. Leyland, who had sanc- 
tioned only the re-touching of the leather, could restrain 
himself no longer. Like many generous men, he had a strict, 
if narrow, sense of justice. The original understanding was 
that Whistler should receive five hundred guineas. This 
grew to a thousand as the scheme developed. Leyland 
208 [1877 


WOOUW MOOOVAd AHL 


Petty 


+ 


fF afd fae fl as “AR oth. 


MERU 


PMR Lung Moa LEUEI Els watalibyds 


> ne ‘ 
i ah A ie * 


THE PEACOCK ROOM 


agreed. But when, at the end, Whistler demanded two 
thousand, and there was no contract, Leyland sent Whistler 
one thousand pounds, not even making them guineas. To 
Whistler, this was an insult. He felt he had been treated, 
not as an artist, but as a tradesman, and the years of friend- 
ship counted for nothing. He never forgave Leyland, though 
it seems that, at one moment, Leyland was prepared to pay 
the sum asked, if Whistler would leave the house. Whistler 
refused, preferring to make Leyland a gift of the decoration 
than not finish the panel of the Peacocks. 

“You know—there Leyland will sit at dinner—his back to 
the Princesse, and always before him the apotheosis of Tart et 
Pargent /” 

And this was what happened. Leyland knew that, in return 
for the loss of his leather and his irritation with Whistler, 
he had been given something beautiful, and he kept the 
dining-room as Whistler left it, toning down not a flying 
feather, not a piece of gold in that triumphant caricature. 
Until the colour fades from the panel, the world cannot 
forget the quarrel. Whistler himself never forgot it, and 
his resentment against Leyland never lessened. It may be 
that he was over-sensitive, certainly he put himself in the 
wrong by his conduct to Leyland. But he could no more 
help his manner of avenging what he thought an insult, than 
the meek man can refrain from turning the other cheek to 
the chastiser. It will ever be to Leyland’s credit that he 
left the work intact, and sat there, and admired it un- 


grudgingly. 


1877] 1:0 209 


CHAPTER XVII THE GROSVENOR 
GALLERY. THE YEARS EIGHTEEN 
SEVENTY-SEVEN TO EIGHTEEN SEVENTY- 
EIGHT. 


ANY exhibitions had been organised in opposition to 

the Royal Academy, but on too insignificant a scale 

to contend against a rich and powerful institution. Sir Coutts 
Lindsay, the founder of the Grosvenor Gallery, brought to 
the new enterprise, money, a talent for organisation, and a 
determination to show the best work in the most beautiful 
manner possible. Nothing could have been more in accord 
with Whistler’s ideas. He dropped in to smoke with Mr. 
Alan S. Cole on the evening of March 19, 1876, when, Mr. 
Cole writes, he “‘ was in great excitement over Sir Coutts 
Lindsay’s gallery for pictures—very select exhibition, which 
he carried to an extreme by saying that it might be opened 
with only one picture worthy of being shown that season.” 
The Grosvenor never reached any such height of disinterested- 
ness. Sir Coutts Lindsay proposed to maintain his standard 
by exhibiting no pictures except those invited by himself, 
and he might have succeeded had he had the strength to 
ignore the Academy, and make the Grosvenor as distinct 
from it as was the International Society of Sculptors, Painters, 
and Gravers under Whistler’s presidency. He had, what 
then seemed, the daring to invite Whistler, Rossetti, Burne- 
Jones, Holman Hunt, Walter Crane ; but he could not venture 
to leave out Watts, Millais, Alma-Tadema, Poynter. ‘* To 


those whose work he specially wanted, he gave little dinners,” 
210 : [1877 


THE GROSVENOR GALLERY 


Mr. Hallé has told us, and a very strange lot some of them 
seemed. The butler felt this even more. He stood them 
all, until one evening he could endure it no longer, and he 
came in the drawing-room, where they were, and whispered : 
“There’s a gent downstairs says he has come to dinner, 
wot’s forgot his necktie and stuck a feather in his ’air,” for 
at this period, Whistler, Mr. Hallé says, never wore a necktie 
when in evening dress. The white lock bewildered many. 
Mrs. Leyland remembers his going with her to her box at the 
opera once, where the attendant leaned over and said: “‘ Beg 
your pardon, sir, but there’s a white feather in your hair, 
just on top!” 

At first, Burne-Jones and the followers of the Pre- 
Raphaelites were most in evidence at Sir Coutts Lindsay’s 
exhibitions, and the “ greenery-yallery, Grosvenor Gallery,” 
element, parodied by Gilbert and Sullivan, and so many 
others, prevailed. But the Grosvenor, by the time its 
traditions were taken over by the New Gallery, had dwindled 
into little more than an overflow from the Academy. 

Shortly before the first exhibition in 1877, Whistler’s 
brother, the Doctor, was married to Miss Helen Ionides, a 
cousin of his old friends, Aleco and Luke Ionides. The 
wedding (April 17, 1877) was at St. George’s, Hanover Square, 
and the Greek Church, London Wall. It brought to Whistler 
a good friend for the troubled years that were to come, and 
Mrs. Whistler’s house in Wimpole Street was for long a 
home to him. | 

The first Grosvenor was a loan exhibition, and opened in 
May 1877. Whistler lent Nocturne in Black and Gold—The 
Falling Rocket, hung the year before at the Dudley ; Harmony 
an Amber and Black, the first title of The Fur Jacket; Arrange- 
ment in Brown ; Irving as Philip II. of Spain, with the title 
Arrangement in Black, No. III. From Mrs. Leyland came. 
Nocturne in Blue and Silver, the river and Battersea seen’ 
1877] 211 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


from the windows of Lindsey Row; from Mr. W. Graham, 
another Nocturne in Blue and Silver—changed later by 
Whistler to Blue and Gold—Old Battersea Bridge, now at the 
Tate Gallery; from the Hon. Mrs. Percy Wyndham, Noc- 
turne in Blue and Gold, at Westminster. The Carlyle was 
shown, though it arrived too late to be catalogued. To this 
exhibition, Boehm sent his bust of Whistler in terra-cotta, 
done in 1872, considered at the time an extremely good 
portrait. 

Whistler’s work was also seen in a frieze, described by 
Mr. Walter Crane: 


“Whistler designed the frieze—the phases of the moon, on 
the coved ceiling of the West Gallery, which has disappeared 
since its conversion into the Aolian Hall, with stars on a sub- 
dued blue ground, the moon and stars being brought out in 
silver, the frieze being divided into panels by the supports of the 
glass roof. The ‘phases’ were sufficiently separated from 
each other.” 


We have heard of this decoration from no one else. Prob- 
ably it was overshadowed by the gorgeousness of the 
crimson silk damask and green velvet hangings, the gilded 
pilasters and furniture, the monumental fireplace, of which 
complaint was heard from every side. The sumptuousness 
of Sir Coutts Lindsay’s background was disastrous to the 
pictures. Whistler’s suffered less than others, but were not 
liked the more on that account. Before the private view 
(April 30, 1877), Sir Coutts Lindsay had expressed his dis- 
appointment in the Irving and the Nocturnes. The crowd 
gathered in front of Alma-Tadema’s Bath; Burne-Jones’ 
Days of Creation ; Watts’ Love and Death ; Millais’ portraits ;. 
Holman Hunt’s Afterglow—in front of Leighton, Poynter, 
Richmond, Walter Crane, Albert Moore. The critics sneered 
at Whistler, or patronised him, as usual. The Atheneum 
seemed to grudge its meagre lines to this ‘“‘ whimsical, if 
212 [1877 


THE GROSVENOR GALLERY 


capable, artist and his vagaries.’ The Times smiled with 
condescension at “Mr. Whistler’s compartment musical 
with strange Nocturnes,’’ wondered how Irving enjoyed 
“being reduced to a mere arrangement,” and deplored the 
theory that, in practice, covered , 


“‘an entire absence of details, even details generally considered 
so important to a full-length portrait as arms and legs. In fact, 
Mr. Whistler’s full-length arrangements suggest to us a choice 
between materialised spirits and figures in a London fog.” 


But nowhere was criticism so insolent, nowhere so brutal, 
as in the notice of the Grosvenor which Ruskin delivered 
from his circulating pulpit, Fors Clavigera (July 2, 1877). 

Ruskin, though social subjects engrossed him more and 
more, was still the art critic, all powerful to the public, and 
to himself infallible. He had made the Pre-Raphaelites, he 
set to work to unmake Whistler. Already Ruskin was 
attacked by the mental malady, the ‘‘ morbid excitement,” 
in Mr. Collingwood’s words, that obscured the last years of 
his life ; he had been very ill in the winter of 1877. Nothing 
else could pardon his malice and insolence. He looked at 
The Falling Rocket, and was blind to the beauty and to the 
mastery of the painter. 
“IT have seen and heard much of cockney impudence before 
now, but never expected to hear a coxcomb ask two hundred 
guineas for flinging a pot of paint in the public’s face.” 
Boughton, in his Reminiscences, tells that Whistler first 
chanced upon this criticism when they were alone together 
in the smoking-room at the Arts Club. “It is the most 
debased style of criticism I have had thrown at me yet,” 
Whistler said. “Sounds rather like libel,’ Boughton 
suggested. ‘* Well—that I shall try to find out ! ’? Whistler 
replied. 

Till now, his answer to abuse of his work had been the 
1877] 213 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


lash of his wit. But if critics had tried him by their stupidity, 
never, before Ruskin, had they outraged him by their venom. 
The insult was made in a widely read print; he therefore 
sought redress in the most public fashion possible in England 
and sued Ruskin for libel. 

The immediate result was that he found it harder than 
ever to sell his pictures. To buy his Nocturnes was to be 
laughed at, Mr. Rawlinson, one of the few who risked it, 
assures us. Whistler put away the new anxiety as he put 
away all his troubles; he laughed and he worked, and 
devoted a great deal of time to black-and-white. The year 
before he had announced his intention to take up etching 
again. He had hoped, at last, to go to Venice, but the 
preparations for the trial kept him in London. Howell 
now made himself as useful to Whistler as he had been to 
Rossetti, and the friendship between them became close 
intimacy. 


Well, you know—it happened one summer evening in those 
old days when there was real summer, I was sitting looking out 
of the window in Lindsey Row, and there was Howell passing, 
and Miss Rosa Corder was with him. And I called to them, 
and they came in, and Howell said: ‘Why, you have etched 
many plates, haven’t you? You must get them out, you must 
print them, you must let me see to them—there’s gold waiting. 
And you have a press!’ And so I had, in a room upstairs, only 
it was rusty, it hadn’t been used for solong. But Howell wouldn’t 
listen to an objection. He said he would fix up the press, he 
would pullit. And there was no escape. And the next morning, 
there we all were, Miss Rosa Corder too, and Howell was pulling 
at the wheel, and there were basins of water, and paper being 
damped, and prints being dried, and then Howell was grinding 
more ink, and, with the plates under my fingers, I felt all the 
old love of it come back. In the afternoon Howell would go 
and see Mr. Graves, the printseller, and there were orders flying 
about, and cheques—it was all amazing, you know! Howell 
profited, of course. But he was so superb. One evening we 
had left a pile of eleven prints just pulled, and the next morning 

214 [1877 


THE GROSVENOR GALLERY 


only five were there. ‘It’s very strange!’ Howell said, ‘ we 

must have a search. No one could have taken them but me, 

and that, you know, is impossible !’ ” 

New plates, Free Trade Wharf, Putney Bridge and The 
Little Putney were published by the Fine Art Society. St. 
James’s Street was reproduced by lithography in the “‘ Season 
Number” of Vanity Fair, 1878, and the Atheneum objected 
to it because it was “‘ not done as Leech or Hogarth would have 
done it,” and the World mistook the reproduction for the 
original, and so invited from Whistler one of the letters now 
following each other fast: ‘‘ Atlas has the wisdom of ages, 
and need not grieve himself with mere matters of art.” 
Adam and Eve, Old Chelsea has a special interest, for it marks 
better than almost any plate, the transition from his early 
manner in the Thames Set to the later handling in the Venetian. 
A plate was made from the Irving as Philip of Spain, the 
only one of his portraits that Whistler reproduced on copper, 
and he did it very badly. His plates of “‘ Joe ’’ and “‘ Maud ”’ 
were never done after finished pictures, but many were made 
as studies for pictures he proposed to paint. The dry-point 
of Whistler’s Mother has no relation to the portrait. He 
was bored to death with copying himself, he would say, and, 
twenty years afterwards, when he undertook to make a 
lithograph of his Montesquiou, and failed, he said that “ it 
was impossible to produce the same masterpiece twice over,” 
that “the inspiration would not come,” that when he was 
not working at a new thing from Nature, he was not applying 
himself, “‘it was as difficult as for a hen to lay the same egg 
twice.” 

In 1878 he made his first experiments in lithography. 
His attention had been called to it by Mr. Thomas Way, 
who did more than any other man to revive the art in England. 
Lithography, appropriated by commerce, was almost for- 
gotten as a means of artistic expression. In France, it was 
1878] ; 215 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


given over for cheaper and quicker methods of illustration, 
and in England it was overweighted by the ponderous 
performances of Haghe and Nash, and hedged about by 
trade-unions, reduced to the perfection of commonplace. 
Lithographers here and there preserved its best traditions, 
and regretted the degradation. Mr. Thomas Way deter- 
mined to interest artists again in a medium that had yielded 
such splendid results. He prepared stones for them, ex- 
plained processes, and would not hear of difficulties. Some 
artists experimented, but lithography did not pay, while the 
anecdote in paint fetched a fortune. Mr. Way knew Whistler, 
had printed the leaflet on the Peacock Room, and had bought 
some of his work. And Mr. Way appealed to Whistler, 
who tried the stone, grasped at once its possibilities, and was 
delighted. In his first five lithographs he did things never 
attempted before, and found the medium peculiarly adapted 
to him. There were nine in all this year. They were drawn 
on the stone, though most of the later ones were done on 
lithographic paper. He proposed to publish these first 
lithographs as Ari Notes, but there was no demand, and the 
plan fell through. The Toilet and The Broad Bridge were 
printed in Piccadilly, edited by Mr. Watts-Dunton, and they 
had hardly appeared when the magazine came to an end. 
Neither Whistler nor lithography then meant success for 
any enterprise. 

In 1878, the Catalogue of Blue and White Nankin Porcelain 
Forming the Collection of Sir Henry Thompson was published. 
Mr. Murray Marks and Mr. W. C. Alexander own delicate 
little studies of blue and white, designed by Whistler for 
Mr. Marks, but never used. They were a good preparation 
for the drawings which, in collaboration with Sir Henry 
Thompson, he made to illustrate the Catalogue. Some were 
in brown, some in blue, reproduced by the Autotype Company. 
Nineteen out of the twenty-six are by Whistler. They are 
216 [1878 


A 


ae 
SS 


SKETCHES FOR BLUE AND WHITE 


THE GROSVENOR GALLERY 


of the utmost simplicity and directness, and the modelling 
is entirely in the drawing by the brush, exactly as the Japanese 
would have done it. As a rule, there are neither shadows 
nor any attempt at relief. The series is the complete refuta- 
tion of the assertion that he could not draw. Whenever he 
attempted drawings of this sort, or etchings like The Wine 
Glass, he eclipsed Jacquemart, and, indeed, all his contem- 
poraries. Worried, anxious, the libel case hanging over him, 
his debts increasing, the general distrust in his work growing, 
Whistler, nevertheless, gave to the catalogue his usual care. 
We have seen another set of the drawings, which differ slightly 
from those reproduced, and with which, evidently, he was 
not satisfied. The book was edited by Mr. Murray Marks, 
and issued by Messrs. Ellis and White of New Bond Street, in 
May, and Mr. Marks exhibited the drawings and the porce- 
lain, with the book, in his shop, 395 Oxford Street. The 
show was not a success, the book was a loss, though only 
two hundred and twenty copies were printed. 

Of personal notice, Whistler now had more than enough. 
He was caricatured this year in the farce of The Grasshopper 
at the Gaiety—it was in the days of Edward Terry and Nellie 
Farren; he was caricatured in Vanity Fair by “Spy,” 
Leslie Ward, then rapidly rivalling “‘ Ape” in popularity ; 
and to be so caricatured was, in London, to achieve notoriety. 

To the second Grosvenor in 1878, he sent, in defiance of 
Ruskin, another series of Nocturnes, Harmonies and Arrange- 
ments. Among them was the Arrangement in White and 
Black, No. I., the large full-length portrait of Miss Maud 
Franklin, that sometimes figures in catalogues and articles 
as L’Américaine. We believe this picture was never shown 
in England again. It passed in the early ’eighties into the 
collection of Dr. Linde at Liibeck, where it remained until 
1904, was then sold, through Paris dealers, to an American, 
and remains one of the least known of Whistler’s large full- 
1878] 217 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


lengths. We saw it in the spring of 1904, when it hung for 
a while in M. Duret’s apartment in the Rue Vignon. It is 
the only portrait, except the Connie Gilchrist and The Yellow 
Buskin, in which Whistler attempted to give movement to 
the figure. Miss Franklin wears a white gown in the ugly 
fashion of the late ’seventies, and walks towards you, one 
hand on her hip, the other holding up her skirt, the rhythm 
and spring of the movement expressed in every line of the 
body, every fold of the gown. But, because she comes 
towards you, she fails to fulfil Whistler’s own precept that 
the figure must keep well within the frame. She seems 
walking out of the dark depth of the background, breaking 
through the envelope of atmosphere. The problem was 
difficult, an unusual one for Whistler, and, interesting as is 
the result, the portrait hardly ranks with the greatest. When 
shown in 1878, it did not help to reconcile the critics. The 
Atheneum said : 


“Mr. Whistler is in great force. Last year some of his life- 
size portraits were without feet ; here we have a curiously shaped 
young lady, ostentatiously showing her foot, which is a pretty 
large one.” 


It was a “ vaporous full-length ” in the opinion of the Times, 
still babbling nonsense about the Nocturnes, and glad to turn 
from Whistler’s “‘ diet of fog to the broad table of substantial 
landscape spread for us by Cecil G. Lawson.” Whistler 
made a drawing of the Arrangement in White and Black for 
Blackburn’s Grosvenor Notes, an illustrated catalogue, pub- 
lished for the first time in 1878. For many years, after 
this, Whistler made these little sketches in pen and ink after 
his pictures, for catalogues, and also for papers that illustrated 
their notices of the exhibitions: an aid to the identification 
of works where his titles failed. 


218 [1878 


CHAPTER XVIII THE WHITE HOUSE. 
THE YEAR EIGHTEEN SEVENTY-EIGHT 


N the Paris International Exhibition of 1878, Whistler 
showed the section of aroom decorated by him, his only 
exhibit. We never knew of this until after his death. It 
may have been the design he wanted to carry out for Mr. 
Alexander; most likely, it was intended for the decoration 
of the White House, which E. W. Godwin, the architect, was 
building for him in Tite Street, Chelsea. The only reference 
to it that we have found is in the American Architect and 
Building News (July 27, 1878) : 


‘‘ Ever since the Baltimore artist, Mr. Whistler, did the famous 
Peacock Room for Mr. Leyland in Prince’s Gate, he has had a 
reputation as unique in upholstery as in higher walks of art. He 
is building a house for himself in London; like no other house, 
of course; meant, perhaps, as a protest against the sudden 
popularity of Queen Anne fronts in red brick, with their balconies 
and drawbridges. He calls this room a Harmony in Yellow and 
Gold. Outside a yellow wall is built up a chimney-piece and 
cabinet in one, of which the wood, like all the wood in the room, 
is a curiously light yellow mahogany—something very different 
from the flaming veneer known to the American for generations 
past, with drunk and straddling patterns all over it. The fire- 
place is flush with the front of the cabinet, the front panelled 
in gilt bars below the shelf and cornice, inclosing tiles of pale 
sulphur, above the shelf, a cupboard, with clear glass and tri- 
angular open niches at either side, holding bits of Kaga porcelain, 
chosen for the yellowishness of the red, which is a characteristic 
of that ware; the frame of the grate brass ; the rails in polished 
steel; the fender the same. Yellow on yellow, gold on gold, 
everywhere. The peacock reappears, the eyes and the breast 

1878] 219 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


feathers of him, but whereas in Prince’s gate it was always blue 
on gold, or gold on blue, here the feather is all gold, boldly and 
softly laid on a gold-tinted wall. The feet to the table-legs are 
tipped with brass, and rest on a yellowish brown velvet rug. 
Chairs and sofas are covered with yellow, pure rich yellow velvet, 
darker in shade than the yellow of the wall, and edged with yellow 
fringe. The framework of the sofa has a hint of the Japanese 
influence, which faintly, but only faintly, suggests itself all 
through the room. Its latticework back and wheel-patterned 
ends might pass for bamboo ; the carpentry is as light as if the 
long fingers of a saffron-faced artist had coaxed it into shape.” * 


Messrs. Obach had in their possession a set of glass panels 
for a door, taken from the house of Mr. Anderson Rose, 
which was stated to be by Whistler. But there is no evidence 
of Whistler’s work in it. The rooms of Mrs. William Whistler, 
Mr. William Heinemann, Sefior Sarasate, Mrs. Walter Sickert, 
Mrs. D’Oyly Carte, Mr. Menpes, and others were decorated 
by him. But the decoration in all these houses was simply 
a colour-scheme for the walls. Whistler mixed the colour, 
which was usually put on by house painters. He suggested 
frequently the furniture, but of design, as in the Peacock 
Room, there was nothing, nor was there in any of his own 
houses after the White House. He often gave, as in the case 
of Mrs. Whistler, elaborate directions as to what colours 
should be used, and how they were to be applied. Mrs. 
D’Oyly Carte writes us: 

“Tt would not be quite correct to say that Mr. Whistler designed 
the decorations of my house, because it is one of the old Adam 
houses in Adelphi Terrace, and it contained the original Adam 
ceiling in the drawing-room and a number of the old Adam 
mantelpieces, which Mr. Whistler much admired, as he did also 
some of the cornices, doors and other things. What he did do 


was to design a sort of colour-scheme for the house, and he mixed 
the colours for distempering the walls himself in each case, 


* Since writing the above, we have found a reference to this ‘‘ Primrose Room ” 
in an article by Mrs. Phoebe Garnaut Smalley in The Lamp, for March 1904, 
But she merely refers to its being in the Exhibition. 

220 [1878 


THE WHITE HOUSE 


leaving only the painters to apply them. In this way he got 
the exact shade he wanted, which made all the difference, as I 
think the difficulty in getting any painting satisfactorily done 
is that painters simply have their stock shades which they show 
you to choose from, and none of them seem to be the kind of 
shades that Mr. Whistler managed to achieve by the mixing of 
his ingredients. He distempered the whole of the staircase walls 
a very light pink colour ; the dining-room a different and deeper 
shade; the library he made one of those yellows he had in his 
own drawing-room at the Vale, a sort of primrose which seemed 
as if the sun was shining, however dark the day, and he painted 
the woodwork with it.green, but not like the ordinary painters’ 
green at all. He followed the same scheme in the other rooms. 
His idea was to make the house ‘ gay’ and delicate in colour.” 


To decoration, Whistler applied his scientific method of 
painting. In all his late work, there were harmonies pro- 
duced by the mixing and arrangement of colour, and it is 
to be noted that on his walls, as in his pictures, black was 
often the basis of his most delicate tones. Colour, for him, 
was as much decoration as pattern was for William Morris, 
and in the use of simple colour for wall decoration, Whistler 
has triumphed. In the painting of pictures, the idea of the 
Pre-Raphaelites was decoration, that is, convention. Their 
scheme of decoration was either wilfully or ignorantly founded 
on the realism of the Middle Ages. The great decorators 
of Italy were the realists of their day, their realism, except 
in the case of the greatest, Piero della Francesca, is now 
regarded as convention, and it is the Pre-Raphaelites who 
stirred up these dead bones. In France, Puvis de Chavannes 
carried on the traditions of Italy by means of modern sub- 
jects and modern methods, though always there was the 
convention of flatness and simplicity, quite right in mural 
decoration. Whistler’s belief was that a portrait, or a Noc- 
turne, should be as decorative as a conventional design, that, 
by the spacing of his figures or subjects on the canvas, and 
by their colour, they should be made decorative, and not by 
1878] 221 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


conventional arrangement and conventional lines. He also 
believed that walls should be in flat tones and not covered 
with design. Pictures then placed upon them were shown 
properly, and did not struggle with any pattern. Lady 
Archibald Campbell writes us a few lines that prove how 
thoroughly he made people understand his aims when they 
were willing to learn from him : 


“‘The fundamental principles of decorative art with which 
Whistler impressed me, related to the necessity of applying 
scientific methods to the treatment of all decorative work ; that 
to produce harmonious effects in line and ‘ colour-grouping,’ 
the whole plan or scheme should have to be thoroughly thought 
out so as to be finished before it was practically begun. I think 
he proved his saying to be true, that the fundamental principles 
of decorative art, as in all art, are based on laws as exact as 
those of the known sciences. He concluded that what the 
knowledge of a fundamental base has done for music, a similarly 
demonstrative method must do for painting. The musical 

' vocabulary which he used to distinguish his creations always 
struck me as singularly appropriate ; though he had no knowledge 
of music. On his teaching, I based my essay, Rainbow Music, 
a treatise on the philosophy of harmony in ‘colour-grouping.’ . . . 

- You will have heard him reiterate that a portrait was worth 
nothing unless it was decorative, and that the subject must be 
painted well inside, or within, the frame, and not outside as the 
generality of painters place it,and that what we are accustomed 
to call life-size in portraiture is. in reality colossal. I remember 
best one of his many witty sayings, ‘ Velasquez always portrayed 
his standing subjects standing on their legs.’ ” 


Before his trial came on, the idea of opening an atelier 
for students occurred to him, and as the studio at No. 2 
Lindsey Row was far too small, he decided to give up the 
house, and Godwin was commissioned to build a new one 
in Tite Street. Up to this time Whistler had never had 
a studio in Chelsea. All his pictures had been painted in 
ordinary rooms, without a top light, partly, no doubt, 
because he wanted to paint his sitters under natural, not 
222 [1878 


THE WHITE HOUSE 


artificial conditions. Even in his later studios in the Rue 
Notre-Dame-des-Champs, in Paris, and in Fitzroy Street, 
London, shades and screens were so drawn that the 
light usually came in as from an ordinary window. He was 
trying to put the figure into the atmosphere that surrounded 
it, not to cut it out of this atmosphere. But the want of 
space at Lindsey Row was a continual inconvenience to 
himself, and made students an impossibility. The scheme 
of opening an atelier seemed to promise success. Among 
artists, there were always the few who believed in Whistler. 
Though he showed no pictures in Paris in 1878, Duranty 
only expressed the prevailing feeling when, in the Gazette 
des Beaux-Arts, he referred to Whistler’s influence on the 
British painters who were hung in the Exhibition. Whistler 
had every reason to believe that, once he had a studio large 
enough to receive them, the students would come to it. The 
White House, low, three-storied, simple in ornament, is 
modest and unassuming compared to many other houses in 
Tite Street. It has been much changed, but the general 
plan still survives. When it was built, it shared the usual 
fate of everything associated with Whistler. The white 
brick of the walls, the green ‘“* EKureka”’ slate of the roof, 
the Portland stone facings, the greyish blue door and wood- 
work were as “eccentric”? and “ fantastic’? as Whistler 
himself to ordinary journalists. To architectural papers 
they were the cause of violent debate and_ reckless 
calling of names. To the Metropolitan Board of Works, the 
simplicity of design was suspiciously plain and ugly, and 
mouldings in specified places were insisted upon in return for 
the necessary licence to build. Discussion followed discussion, 
and all, as well as we can now judge, because the studio was 
the most important feature of the interior and placed at the 
top of the house, because windows and doors were made 
where they were wanted, “‘ and not with Baker Street regu- 
1878] 223 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


larity,” because Godwin and Whistler liked the “ lovely 
effect ’ of the green tiles with the white walls. Mr. Quilter, 
who bought the house in 1879 and altered it, probably 
ruined the colour-scheme which Whistler had arranged, 
and the interior decoration, if it was ever completely 
carried out, does not now exist. 

The house in Lindsey Row was let to Mr. Sydney Morse, 
whose tenancy was to begin at midsummer 1878, and who 
was to be married before taking possession. The cares 
crowding upon Whistler did not prevent those acts of kindli- 
ness for which he was seldom given credit. He arranged 
the scheme of colour throughout the house for the new tenants, 
getting his man Cossens to do the distempering. Mrs. Morse 
writes : 

‘He was so afraid that we should do it wrongly that he per- 
sonally superintended the work, and mixed the colour himself, 
though in consequence of this a whole ‘ wash’ for the dining- 
room was spoilt, as he forgot to stir it up at the right moment 
—there was great discussion about gold size. The hall had two 
fine panels in blue on white by Whistler, two ships with sails set 
at sea. The house was coloured as ‘a sunset.’ The gold dado 
on the stairs was dotted with pink and white chrysanthemum 


petals. The drawing-room was papered, also the studio, but 
not until Whistler had gone in September.” 


He went to the wedding, on June 1, at Carshalton, and the 
incident Mrs. Morse likes best to recall is his courtesy to an 
old and feeble family governess, who was returning to town 
in the same train. Whistler not only looked after her on 
the journey, but, instead of getting out at his station, went 
on to hers, and put her safely into an omnibus, so that she 
said afterwards she had never met so kind a young man. 
The one thing he could not do was to give up the house 
at the time appointed. June 25 came, and he was still there. 
July passed, and he had not gone: not until the middle of 
August could he get out, and even then he kept the studio. 
224 [1878 


VASIAHO ‘LAAMLS WLI “ASNOH ALIHM AHL 


a 


we wd 


THE WHITE HOUSE 


It was October when he moved into the White House, and 
it is surprising that he moved in at all. A man’s money 
troubles are nobody’s business save his own. But Whistler’s 
debts and difficulties had everything to do with his movements 
and his work during the next few years, while gossip seizing 
upon them, as upon all his affairs, made them public property. 
He had quarrelled with his principal patron, Leyland, to 
whose sister-in-law he had been at one time engaged. But 
the engagement was broken, his mother’s health kept her 
at Hastings, and he was alone. The criticism of the last 
few years told severely upon the sale of his pictures, upon 
his commissions for portraits, upon the man himself. Howell, 
who had “started cheques and orders flying about,” and 
who attended to most business details, kept a diary during 
part of 1877, and all of 1878, which we have been able to 
consult. To look through it is to share Whistler’s own 
indignation that so great an artist should be reduced to such 
shifts. In Kensington and St. John’s Wood palaces, Acade- 
micians could not turn pictures out fast enough for the com- 
peting crowd. Whistler was often compelled to borrow a 
few shillings from a friend. There are legends of his taking 
a hansom and driving to find somebody to lend him half a 
crown to pay for it, and before he had found anybody and 
could get rid of the cab the fare had mounted to a guinea. 
Howell’s diary shows how he raised money before he could 
lend it to Whistler. Sometimes larger sums than he could 
manage were arranged for with Mr. Anderson Rose, Whistler’s 
friend and solicitor, who also looked after his affairs. As 
‘ill and worried,’’ Howell describes Whistler on one of the 
visits to Mr. Rose, and every reason there was that he should 
be. A Mr. Blott figures largely in other transactions. 
Whistler’s letters to him got into the hands of dealers, and. 
have been sold and published, and it would be useless to 
ignore Whistler’s relations with him. Debts were pressing 
1878] eae 225 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


upon him. Money for the White House had to be obtained. 
To Mr. Blott he gave his Carlyle as security for the sum of a 
hundred and fifty pounds, agreeing to pay interest, offering 
other pictures as security, if a sum of four hundred in all 
could be advanced. Cheques were protested, writs were 
threatened. The marvel is that Whistler could work at all. 
The pictures he could not sell went wandering about as 
hostages. The Mother for a while was with Mrs. Noseda, 
the Strand printseller. We have heard that she would have 
sold it for a hundred pounds. Mr. Rawlinson, who saw it 
either there or at Mr. Graves’, has told us that he felt the 
impossibility of any friend buying it under such circumstances, 
after having seen it at Lindsey Row, where it hung in 
' Whistler’s bedroom, and was shown by him with reverence. 
When it came to Whistler’s knowledge that Mrs. Noseda 
was offering the picture for this price, he is said to have gone 
at once to remonstrate, and by his vehemence to have made 
her ill. 

One man who helped him through these troubled times 
was Mr. Graves, head of the firm in Pall Mall. Mr. Graves, 
introduced to Whistler by Howell, agreed to reproduce the 
portrait of Carlyle in mezzotint, and Howell bought the copy- 
right of the engraving from Whistler for eighty pounds and 
six proofs. W. Josey was commissioned to make the plate. 
Three hundred signed proofs of a first state were to be printed. 
The plate would not stand so large an edition ; it was steel- 
faced and, as the steel-facing of mezzotint was not possible, 
turned out a failure. The attempt to remove the steel ruined 
the ground, and Josey had to be called in to go over it again. 
In the actual first state, the floor was perfectly smooth, but, 
the steel-facing taken off, a spot appeared in the plate which 
never could be got out, and remained there through the 
edition. After every seventy proofs printed, Josey had to 
work on the plate and bring it back, as well as he could, to 
226 [1878 


THE WHITE HOUSE 


its original condition. Whistler did not like the first proofs 
and offered to show the printers how to dothem. Mr. Graves 
went with him to Mr. Holdgate, the printer in London Street. 
Whistler brought his own ink, put on a large apron, inked 
the plate as he would an etched one, while the whole shop 
stood looking on. When the plate was inked and wiped, 
and ready, it was put through the press, and it came out a 
shadow, the ink being far too weak. Whistler did not try 
a second time. Mr. Graves preserved the proof, writing on 
it that Whistler pulled it, and sold it for three guineas: to 
whom, he does not remember. Eventually, Whistler was 
satisfied, for Howell, on December 2, 1878, gave Whistler 
what he calls his first proof, and the diary says: ‘‘ Whistler 
and the Doctor [the brother] were delighted.” It is also 
recorded in the diary that one of Whistler’s six proofs was 
sold to Lord Beaconsfield. 

The print of the Carlyle was not unsuccessful. At Howell’s 
suggestion, Mr. Graves agreed to give Whistler a thousand 
pounds for a portrait of Disraeli, and the copyright : a plate 
to be made from it as a companion to the Carlyle. Another 
diary, Mr. Alan S. Cole’s, gives the date of Whistler’s visit 
to Disraeli : 

“* September 19, 1878.—Called on J., who told me of his interview 
with Lord Beaconsfield as to painting a portrait of him. He had 
been down at Hughenden—saw the old gentleman, who, however, 
declined.” 

Whistler’s version of the visit was amusing : 

** Everything was most wonderful. We were the two artists 
together—recognising each other at a glance! ‘If I sit to any 
one, it will be to you, Mr. Whistler,’ were Disraeli’s last words 
as he left me at the gate. And then he sat to Millais!” 

This scheme falling through, Mr. Graves commissioned 
Josey to reproduce the Mother, and afterwards the Miss Rosa 
Corder, painted as a commission from Howell. Whistler told 
1878] 227 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


us he offered the portrait as a present to Howell, who declined 
and insisted on paying a hundred guineas for it, and this is 
the amount entered in Howell’s diary as paid to Whistler 
on September 9, 1878. It was sold to Mr. Canfield, in 1908, 
for two thousand pounds. 

After the two pictures had been reproduced by Josey, 
Howell deposited in the same way three of the Nocturnes 
with Mr. Graves: The Falling Rocket, The Fire Wheel, Old 
Battersea Bridge—Blue and Gold, and also the portrait of 
Miss Franklin. Of these pictures no reproductions were 
made. Whistler had not a minute to spare from legal 
troubles and impatient creditors. ‘“‘ Poor J. turned up, 
depressed—very hard up, and fearful of getting old,’ Mr. 
_ Cole wrote in his diary for October 16, 1878. Whistler 
had reason for depression. It was now that Howell’s diary 
records his purchase of the Jrving for ten pounds and a 
sealskin coat. Thereis nothing more tragic in Rembrandt’s 
bankruptcy than this. A few weeks later, on November 25 
(1878), the trial began. 


228 [1878 


CHAPTER XIX. THE TRIAL. THE 
YEAR EIGHTEEN SEVENTY-EIGHT 


HE action Whistler v. Ruskin is the most notorious 

episode in Whistler’s life. And yet the reason for it, 

‘the spirit of the matter,’’ was ignored at the time, and 
has remained a mystery ever since. 

The appearance of Whistler’s pictures at the Grosvenor 
was the signal for a general outcry. The loudest voice and 
the shrillest was that of John Ruskin, leader of taste, critic 
of art, prophet and propounder of new gospels of ‘ the 
Beautiful.” He carried with him not only a following of 
believers, but the public who had been told for years that 
in him lay the truth. Whistler felt that either he or Ruskin 
must settle the question whether an artist may say what he 
wants, do what he wants, paint what he wants, honestly in 
his own way, though this may not be understood by the 
patron, the critic, the Academy, or the real judge, the man 
in the street; whether the artist should rule himself or be 
ruled. The case was, he said, ‘“‘ between the Brush and the 
Pen.” His motives were ignored, the proceedings made a 
jest, and the verdict treated as a farce. Few could, or 
do, realise even to day, that Whistler was in earnest, that 
‘the trial was a defence of his principles, and the verdict a 
public justification of his artistic belief. 

At the time of the trial, Whistler was to the British public 
a charlatan, a mountebank. Ruskin was the people’s 
prophet, and the professor of art. Whistler denied the right 
of a master of English literature, who had become the popu- 
1878] 229 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


lariser of pictures, to consider himself a prophet and a pope, 
as Ruskin undoubtedly did, his head turned by his success 
in the defence of the Pre-Raphaelites and the booming of 
Turner. So good a friend of Ruskin’s as Mr. W. M. Rossetti 
thought him “‘ substantially wrong in the matter,” and points 
out that his mind broke down at times, and that his. mental 
troubles had begun as far back as 1860. His conceit and 
his vanity, as we have said, can hardly be explained in any 
other way. Unfortunately for him, he lived in the only 
country where his arrogant pretensions would have been 
countenanced, though, owing to the present acceptance of 
England and everything English, he has become something 
of a fetich in France and Italy, just as he begins to be dis- 
credited as critic at home. He was rich, the first qualifi- 
cation for success; he was a University man, the second ; 
he was keen to contribute long letters to the Times. He 
was a more or less generous patron of the artists he admired ; 
moreover, he was a master of English: therefore he could 
commit any absurdity he wanted. As Whistler said, 
political economists considered him a great art critic, 
and artists looked upon him as a great political econo- 
mist. Sometimes we wondered, when Whistler laughed, 
if there was not another reason, beside mental illness, 
for Ruskin’s inconsequent personal venom. He never 
appreciated the great artists of the world, save certain 
Italians, recognised long before. His estimate of Velasquez 
and Rembrandt, and his comparison between Turner and 
Constable, are sufficient to prove how little his now un- 
heeded sermons were ever worth. While he failed to 
comprehend Charles Keene, he went into ecstasies over 
Kate Greenaway. Whistler, knowing all this, may have 
offended. Mr. Collingwood wrote that, long before the 
trial, Whistler “had made overtures to the great critic 
through Mr. Swinburne, the poet; but he had not been 
1230 [1878 


* WILLIE” (DR.) WHISTLER “JIMMIE” (MCNEILL) WHISTLER 
THE TWO BROTHERS AS BOYS AND MEN 


J pier? 


ei - | / sey yeaa ie) 1 e.c 0 


eta iienege sae wlio vid it ai mal | i, 
7 - pyar =) Me, Petal & Miran ate et ipsinemen 7 
, a sila Pecan one eles oh . alts 5 
7 eth pal wee te T OHS agri bee Naps dare wreath die eee 
Tale : Femplintyin ok.sall © deuce. Je hvyand Ad selec ee 


5 ee opti, oytnr ang dani! Garedds 4 tribe od ob) nll ye a 
J a * eee aens itary. Ne deorpepre Min dee, rent Lae 
ia po rruBee ult. anvaatirrey «aa ASA eh hob: rae f. fi 


f a be mead Padgett iaeehait “viel am /> bow abt cunalas* Lane 
J Vines tt tpl byve oabks piel Pap od pepe flag a ee 
a Bra att.) hee | ran sic aelal ot Le Eee _ 
‘ bes felt, aeset qrald cg we. ieee wide - 
= a (tae Belilatad By oli tsar mersis wt yeetar fee _peliagrd iat. 
| rmpret Fnkor{ese wil, oi wetert leas & ‘ptomahl Hodikk dap ii in 
Res Sgt Shaw 0 at Aa: ee SR eg ee cae th 
J rs eo Soreliny aT puis Se a hte HRRTER ERAS : 
=o eiadh sf ah evi aplinraice nt bag arth 4 Codename “totter > os r 
Be 2 eamale Palticsiah bo we) Ghat aparece sae 


age 
a is = 


me 


- 
- 


lh 
. 
= 


F 7 f a 
ss bin tnereidr Piitlaone tabby neuf sent wsltad’) oe ee 
|. lc “in ithe isles Ki Masiggltt wide “ithe ‘ =f _. 
P ‘ ° me, ae + sae he i tn! ey ye ry ae 2 = 
Me Pre vial A it yt utter, Ratha P 7 
} oy Melati Jah weibin eda Mm, ets Sa AM a it 
POAT ye ah ae A om eel doers 2d yen tele & = 
— Ra PLAY, A Ne de dees ip heen hier oy ad wah! = 1% 
r . ee ee oe - Pej Wd teal 5) vas be, bev ak oA Touttty eel "5 rs 
oc oe Pe TT thiye tel perdibdewen Lim) wee ae | di ad ime” 
» 2 ~ : mala wtsben ai, Ma hi md at tutes yi a we rha\e rh es “ “3 
| ie wrk 5 eh eevee Sil wal bastt 918,  Meolcany mal pi Me de bk on 
—_ a; - & ag a ste. . ri oh Carper at at! anti oe 
™ ba an oy ast Bac ft ‘hiten J “ wiv Ae 1s ary i i. 
' ~4 a Poe dial, swdt au bY * u hi 0-4 yet td. oa ly "hk, 16), 7 1 
ela ; sda’ Wh het + nal ee Lae 


‘ 

be aeebveaeal > ‘ng pat auld ne ie Aa. veto a oe ' 

, * ye yee" becasty ate Aad. a! he a See Setegt Saale nk 
dae a” a : . a (ees: i ' 


a 


Th ale 


THE TRIAL 


taken seriously.” It is certain Ruskin was not taken 
seriously by the great artist. 

The publication of Ruskin’s criticism of the Grosvenor in 
1877 could have had no enduring ill-effect on Whistler, and 
we do not imagine he thought it could. But he determined 
at any cost to drive this self-anointed preacher from his 
pulpit. With the support of Mr. Anderson Rose, his solicitor, 
he went to work to prepare the case, and we know the 
endless pains and trouble he took. He thought, at first, that 
the artists would be on his side, and would combine with 
him to drive the false prophet out of the temple. But 
Ruskin, the critic, was to them more powerful than Whistler, 
the painter, and when the time came they all sneaked away 
except Albert Moore. Besides, there was the unspoken hope 
that the Yankee would lose. Whistler told us 


‘* they all hoped they could drive me out of the country, or kill 
me! And if I hadn’t had the constitution of a Government 
mule, they would.” 


Even Charles Keene, whom Whistler considered the greatest 
English artist since Hogarth, could write on November 
24, 1878: 


‘“* Whistler’s case against Ruskin comes off, I believe, on 
Monday. He wants to subpoena me as a witness as to whether 
he is (as Ruskin says) an impostor or not. I told him I should 
be glad to record my opinion, but begged him to do without me 
if he could. They say it will most likely be settled on the point 
of law without going into evidence, but if the evidence is adduced, 
it will be the greatest ‘lark’ that has been known for a long 
time in the courts.” 


Keene did not dare to stand up publicly for Whistler and 
for art, and the bitterness of it all is in those last words— 
*Hatlarka’’ 

On November 25, 1878, in the Exchequer Chamber at 
Westminster, the action for libel, in which ‘‘ Mr. James 
1878] 231 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Abbott McNeill Whistler, an artist, seeks to recover damages 
against Mr. John Ruskin, the well-known author and art 
critic,” was brought up before Baron Huddleston and a 
special jury. Our account is compiled chiefly from the 
reports published in the Times and the Daily News, November 
26 and 27, 1878, from The Gentle Art and from what Whistler, 
Mr. Rossetti, Mr. Armstrong, Mr. Graves and others who 
were present have told us. According to Lady Burne-Jones, 
Ruskin had been delighted at the prospect of the trial : 


“It’s nuts and nectar to me, the notion of having to answer 
for myself in court, and the whole thing will enable me to assert 
some principles of art economy which I’ve never got into the 
public’s head by writing; but may get sent over all the world 
vividly in a newspaper report or two.” 


Nuts and nectar turned into gall and vinegar. Through the 
early winter of 1878, rumours of his ill-health reached the 
papers. Lady Burne-Jones adds that, when the action was 
brought, “‘ although he had quite recovered from his illness, 
he was not allowed to appear.” 

The case excited great interest, and the court was crowded, 
even the passages being filled. Mr. Sergeant Parry and 
Mr. Petheram were counsel for the plaintiff, and the Attorney- 
General (Sir John Holker) and Mr. Bowen for the defendant. 
Mr. Sergeant Parry opened the case for Whistler, 


‘“‘ who has followed the profession of an artist for many years, 
while Mr. Ruskin is a gentleman well known to all of us, and 
holding perhaps the highest position in Europe or America as an 
art critic. Some of his works are destined to immortality, and 
it is the more surprising, therefore, that a gentleman, holding 
such a position, could traduce another in a way that would lead 
that other to come into a court of law to ask for damages. The 
jury, after hearing the case, will come to the conclusion that a 
great injustice has beendone Mr. Whistler, in the United States, 
has earned a reputation as a painter and an artist. He is not 
merely a painter, but has likewise distinguished himself in the 
232 [1878 


FALLING ROCKET 


» 


THI 
(Noctua 


Black and Gold) 


me tn 


Adondrtais si i x ee: Ba 
ait dint 
Varemnlanin rk abeivoe: sat an. 


| : woinksial sonnets 
= ang sist 


THE TRIAL 


capacity of etcher, achieving considerable honours in that depart- 
ment of art. He has been an unwearied worker in his profession, 
always desiring to succeed, and if he had formed an erroneous 
opinion, he should not have been treated with contempt and 
ridicule. Mr. Ruskin edits a publication called Fors Clavigera, 
that has a large circulation among artists and art patrons. In 
the July number of 1877 appeared a criticism of the pictures in 
the Grosvenor, containing the paragraph which is the defamatory 
matter complained of. Sir Coutts Lindsay is described as an 
amateur, both in art and shop-keeping, who must take up one 
business or the other. Mannerisms and errors are pointed out 
in the work of Burne-Jones, but whatever their extent, his 
pictures ‘are never affected or indolent. The work is natural 
to the painter, however strange to us, wrought with the utmost 
conscience and care, however far, to his or our desire, the result 
may seem to be incomplete. Scarcely so much can be said for 
any other pictures of the modern schools. Their eccentricities 
are almost always in some degree forced, and their imperfections 
gratuitously, if not impertinently, indulged. For Mr. Whistler’s 
own sake, no less than for the protection of the purchaser, Sir 
Coutts Lindsay ought not to have admitted works into the gallery 
in which the ill-educated conceit of the artist so nearly approaches 
the aspect of wilful imposture. I have seen and heard much of 
cockney impudence before now, but never expected to hear a 
coxcomb ask two hundred guineas for flinging a pot of paint in 
the public’s face.’ Mr. Ruskin pleaded that the alleged libel 
was privileged, as being a fair and bona fide criticism upon a 
painting which the plaintiff had exposed to public view. But 
the terms in which Mr. Ruskin has spoken of the plaintiff are 
unfair and ungentlemanly, and are calculated to, and have 
done him, considerable injury, and it will be for the jury to say 
what damages the plaintiff is entitled to.” 


Whistler was the first witness called, and is reported to 
have begun his evidence by giving St. Petersburg as his 
birth-place. He continued : 


“T studied in Paris, with Du Maurier, Poynter, Armstrong. 

I was awarded a gold medal at The Hague . . . my etchings are 
in the British Museum and Windsor Castle collections. I ex- 
hibited eight pictures at the Grosvenor Gallery in the summer 
1878] 233 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


of 1877. No pictures were exhibited there save on invitation, 
I was invited by Sir Coutts Lindsay to exhibit. The first was 
a Nocturne in Black and Gold—The Falling Rocket. The second, a 
Nocturne in Blue and Silver [since called Blue and Gold—Old 
Battersea Bridge]. The third, a Nocturne in Blue and Gold, 
belonging to the Hon. Mrs. Percy Wyndham. The fourth, a 
Nocturne in Blue and Silver, belonging to Mrs. Leyland. The fifth, 
an Arrangement in Black—Irving as Philip II. of Spain. The 
sixth, a Harmony in Amber and Black. The seventh, an Arrange- 
ment in Brown. In addition to the original eight, there was a 
portrait of Mr. Carlyle. That portrait was painted from sittings 
Mr. Carlyle gave me. It hassince been engraved, and the artist’s 
proofs were all subscribed for. The Nocturnes, all but two, were 
sold before they went to the Grosvenor Gallery. One of them 
was sold to the Hon. Perey Wyndham for two hundred guineas 
—the one in Blue and Gold. One I sent to Mr. Graham in lieu 
of a former commission, the amount of which was a hundred 
and fifty guineas. A third one, Blue and Silver, I presented to 
Mrs. Leyland. The one that was for sale was in Black and Gold 
—The Falling Rocket.’ 


Curiously, the only one for sale was pounced on by Ruskin. 
The coxcomb was trying to get two hundred guineas. 

Asked whether, since the publication of the criticism, he 
had sold a Nocturne, Whistler answered: ‘“‘ Not by any 
means at the same price as before.” 

The portraits of Irving and Carlyle were produced in court, 
and he is said to have described the Irving as “‘ a large impres- 
sion—a sketch ; it was not intended as a finished picture.”’ 
We do not believe he said anything of the sort. 

He was then asked for his definition of a Nocturne : 

‘“*T have perhaps meant rather to indicate an artistic interest 
alone in the work, divesting the picture from any outside sort of 
interest which might have been otherwise attached to it. It is 
an arrangement of line, form and colour first, and I make use of 
any incident of it which shall bring about a symmetrical result. 
Among my works are some night pieces; and I have chosen the 
word Nocturne because it generalises and simplifies the whole 
set of them.” 

234 [1878 


THE TRIAL 


The Falling Rocket, though it is difficult here to follow the 
case, was evidently produced at this point upside down; 
Whistler, describing it as a night piece, said it represented 
the fireworks at Cremorne. 


Attorney-General : ‘‘ Not a view of Cremorne ?” 

Whistler: ‘‘ If it were called a view of Cremorne, it would 
certainly bring about nothing but disappointment on the part 
of the beholders. (Laughter.) It is an artistic arrangement.” 

Attorney-General : “‘ Why do you call Mr. Irving an Arrange- 
ment in Black?” (Laughter.) 


Kven the judge interposed, though in jest for there was 
more laughter, and explained that the picture, not Mr. 
Irving, was the Arrangement. 


Whistler: ‘* All these works are impressions of my own. I 
make them my study. I suppose them to appeal to none but 
those who may understand the technical matter.” 


And he added that it would be possible to see the pictures 
in Westminster Palace Hotel close by, where he had placed 
them for the purpose. 


Attorney-General.: “‘I suppose you are willing to admit that 
your pictures exhibit some eccentricities. You have been told 
that over and over again?” 

Whistler: ‘“‘ Yes, very often.” (Laughter.) 

Attorney-General: “‘ You send them to the Gallery to invite 
the admiration of the public ? ” 

Whistler : ‘That would be such vast absurdity on my part 
that I don’t think I could.” (Laughter.) 

Attorney-General : ‘Did it take you much time to paint the 
Nocturne in Black and Gold ? How soon did you knock it off ?” 
(Laughter.) 

Whistler: ‘‘I knocked it off possibly in a couple of days.” 


In The Gentle Art this is reported : 


Attorney-General: ‘‘Can you tell me how long it took you 
to knock off that Nocturne ? ”’ 
Whisiler: “I beg your pardon?” (Laughter.) 
1878] 235 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Attorney-General: “I am afraid that I am using a term that 
applies rather perhaps to my own work.” 

Whistler: . ... “ Let us say then, hw long did I take to— 
‘knock off,’ I Hack that is it—to knock off that Nocturne ; 
well, as well as I remember, about a day.... I may have 
still put a few more touches to it the next day if the painting 
were not dry. I had better say then, that I was two days at 
work on it.” 

Attorney-General : ‘‘ The labour of two days, then, is that for 
which you ask two hundred guineas ? ” 

Whistler : “No; I ask it for the knowledge of a life- 
time.” 

tiiiteys ear: “You don’t approve of criticism ? ” 

Whistler : ‘‘I should not disapprove in any way of technical 
criticism by a man whose life is passed in the practice of the science 
which he criticises; but, for the opinion of a man whose life is 
not so passed, I would have as little regard as you would, if he 
expressed an opinion on law.” 

Attorney-General : “‘ You expect to be criticised ? ” 

Whistler: ‘“* Yes, certainly ; and I do not expect to be affected 
by it until it comes to be a case of this kind.” 


The Nocturne, the Blue and Silver, was then produced. 


Whistler: “‘It represents Battersea Bridge by moonlight.” 

The Judge: ‘Is this part of the picture at the top old Battersea 
Bridge ? Are those figures on the top of the bridge intended 
for people ? ” 

Whistler: ‘* They are just what you like.” 

The Judge: ‘* That is a barge beneath ?” 

Whistler: ‘‘ Yes, I am very much flattered at your seeing 
that. The picture is simply a representation of moonlight. 
My whole scheme was only to bring about a certain harmony 
of colour.” 

The Judge: ‘‘ How long did it take you to paint that picture ? ” 

Whistler: ‘‘I completed the work in one day, after having 
arranged the idea in my mind.” * 


* This was the picture that then belonged to Mr. Graham, that some years after, 
at his sale at Christie’s was received with hisses, that was then purchased by 
Mr. Robert H.C. Harrison for sixty pounds, and that at the close of the London 
Whistler Memorial Exhibition was bought for two thousand guineas by the National 
Arts Collection Fund, presented to the nation, and hung in the National Gallery. 


236 [1878 


I ‘ON ‘HNATIS GNV FATA NI ANYALOON 


THE TRIAL 


The court adjourned, and the jury went to see the pictures 
at the Westminster Palace Hotel. When, on their return, 
the Nocturne in Black and Gold—The Falling Rocket, was 
produced, the Attorney-General asked : 


“ How long did it take you to paint that ?” 

Whistler : ‘One whole day and part of another.” 

Attorney-General: “What is the peculiar beauty of that 
picture ?” 

Whistler : ‘It would be impossible for me to explain to you, 
I am afraid, although I daresay I could to a sympathetic ear.” 

Attorney-General : ‘“‘Do you not think that anybody looking 
at the picture might fairly come to the conclusion that it had 
no particular beauty ?” 

Whistler: “I have strong evidence that Mr. Ruskin did come 
to that conclusion.” 

Attorney-General: “Do you think it fair that Mr. Ruskin 
should come to that conclusion ? ” 

Whistler: “What might be fair to Mr. Ruskin, I cannot 
answer. No artist of culture would come to that conclusion.” 

Attorney-General : “Do you offer that picture to the public 
as one of particular beauty, fairly worth two hundred guineas ?” 

Whistler: “I offer it as a work that I have conscientiously 
executed, and that I think worth the money. I would hold my 
reputation upon this, as I would upon any of my other works.” 


Mr. W. M. Rossetti was the next witness called. He had 
been subpcenaed the day before. He was Ruskin’s friend 
as well as Whistler’s, and the position was not pleasant. 
But, he has written us, he was “ compelled to act, willy-nilly, 
in opposition to Ruskin’s interest in the action.” 


Rossetti : “I consider the Blue and Silver an artistic and 
beautiful representation of a pale but bright moonlight. I 
admire Mr. Whistler’s pictures, but not without exception. I 
appreciate the meaning of the titles. The Falling Rocket is not 
one of the pictures I admire.” 

Attorney-General : “Is it a gem?” (Laughter.) 

Rossetti : ‘‘ No.” 

Attorney-General : “Is it an exquisite painting ? o 

Rossetti: “No.” 

1878] 237 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Attorney-General: “Is it very beautiful ?” 

Rossetti: “No.” 

Attorney-General: “Is it a work of art?” 

Rossetti : ‘‘ Yes, it is.”’ 

Attorney-General: “‘Is it worth two hundred guineas ? ” 
Rossetti: ‘* Yes.” 


Albert Moore, when he was called, said that Whistler’s 
pictures were beautiful works of art, and that no other 
painter could have succeeded in them as he had. The Black 
and Gold he looked upon as simply marvellous, the most 
consummate art. Asked if there was eccentricity in the 
picture, he said he should call it originality. 

W. G. Wills, Whistler’s only other witness, testified to the 
knowledge shown in the pictures; they were the works of 
a man of genius. | 

Mr. Algernon Graves had been subpoenaed, and was in 
court to give evidence to the popularity of the Carlyle. As 
the picture was not catalogued when exhibited at the Gros- 
venor, Baron Huddleston ruled that there was no proof of 
its having been exhibited in 1877, and he was not called. 

The Attorney-General submitted there was no case. But 
Baron Huddleston could not deny that the criticism, as it 
stood, held Whistler’s work up to ridicule and contempt ; 
that so far it was libellous, and must, therefore, go to the 
jury. It was for the Attorney-General to prove it fair and 
honest criticism. 

The Attorney-General’s address to the jury began with 
praise of Ruskin, it went on with ridicule of the testimony 
for the plaintiff, it finished with contempt for Whistler and 
his work. 

“‘The Nocturnes were not worthy the name of great works 
of art. He had that morning looked into the dictionary for the 
meaning of coxcomb, and found that the word carried the old 
idea of the licensed jester, who had a cap. on his head with a 
cock’s comb in it. If that were the true definition, Mr. Whistler 

238 [1878 


THE TRIAL 


should not complain, because his pictures were capital jests 
which had afforded much amusement to the public. He said, 
without fear of contradiction, that, if Mr. Whistler founded his 
reputation on the pictures he had shown in the Grosvenor Gallery, 
the Nocturne in Black and Gold, the Nocturne in Blue and Silver, 
his Arrangement of Irving in Black, his representation of the 
Ladies in Brown, and his Symphonies in Grey and Yellow, he 
was a mere pretender to the art of painting.” 


In Ruskin’s absence, Burne-Jones was the first witness 
called for the defence. Lady Burne-Jones says, in her 
Memorials of Edward Burne-Jones, that on November 2, 
Ruskin had written to him : 


““T gave your name to the blessed lawyer, as chief of men to 
whom they might refer for anything which, in their wisdom, they 
can’t discern unaided concerning me.” 


She adds that, for her husband : 


“Few positions could have been more annoying or difficult, 
for the paragraph containing the sentence in question—one of 
Ruskin’s severest condemnations—was practically a comparison 
between Mr. Whistler’s work and Edward’s own. But the subject 
covered so much wider ground than any personality that Edward 
was finally able to put this thought aside, and did with calmness 
what he had undertaken to do, namely—endorse Ruskin’s criticism 
that good workmanship was essential to a good picture.” 


Mr. Walter Crane states, in his Reminiscences, that he 
met Burne-Jones at dinner, at Leyland’s, not long before 
the trial, and that then Burne-Jones would not see Whistler’s 
merits as an artist. ‘‘ He seemed to think there was only 
one right way of painting. . . . Under the circumstances, 
he could hardly afford to allow any credit to Whistler.”” In 
court, however, Burne-Jones temporised. He admitted 
Whistler’s art, while he regretted the want of finish in 
Whistler’s pictures : so strengthening the public’s impression 
of the laziness, levity, or incompetence of Whistler. In his 
‘deliberate judgment,” Mrs. Leyland’s Blue and Silver was 
1878] 239 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


a work of art, but a very incomplete one. It did not, in 
any sense whatever, show the finish of a complete work 
of art—yet 


‘it is masterly. Neither in composition, detail, nor form has the 
picture any quality whatever, but, in colour, it has a very fine 
quality. . . . Blue and Silver—Old Battersea Bridge, in colour is 
even better than the other. It is more formless, it is bewildering 
in form. As to composition and detail, there is none whatever. 
It has no finish. I do not think Mr. Whistler intended it to be 
regarded as a finished picture.” 

Mr. Bowen: ‘“‘ Now, take the Nocturne in Black and Gold— 
The Falling Rocket, is that, in your opinion, a work of art?” 

Burne-Jones : “‘No, I cannot say that it is. It is only one 
of a thousand failures that artists have made in their efforts to 
paint night.” 

Mr. Bowen: “Is that picture in your judgment worth two 
hundred guineas ?” 

Burne-Jones : ‘* No, I cannot say it is, seeing how much careful 
work men do for much less. Mr. Whistler gave infinite promise 
at first, but I do not think he has fulfilled it. I think he has 
evaded the great difficulty of painting, and has not tested his 
powers by carrying it out. The difficulties in painting increase 
daily as the work progresses, and that is the reason why so many 
of us fail. We are none of us perfect. The danger is this, that 
if unfinished pictures become common, we shall arrive at a stage 
of mere manufacture and the art of the country will be degraded.” 


Mr. Frith, R.A., was next called. Truly, Ruskin found 
himself with strange supporters. Frith was chosen, we 
have been told, because Ruskin wanted some one who could 
not be thought biased in his favour. 


Mr. Bowen: ‘ Are the pictures works of art ?” 

Frith: ‘I should say not.” 

Mr. Bowen: Is the Nocturne in Blue and Gold a serious work 
of art?” 

Frith: “Not to me. It is not worth, in my opinion, two 
hundred guineas. Old Battersea Bridge does not convey the 
impression of moonlight to me in the slightest degree. The colour 
does not represent any more than you could get from a bit of 
wall-paper or silk.” 

240 [1878 


THE TRIAL 


In cross-examination, he flatly contradicted himself, and said 
that he thought Mr. Whistler had ‘“‘ very great power as 
an artist.” ’ 

Ruskin’s final supporter was Tom Taylor, critic of the 
Times. No, he said, the Nocturne in Black and Gold was not 
a good picture, and, to prove it, he read his own criticism 
in the Times, and his assertion there that the Nocturnes were 
worth doing because they were the only things that Whistler 
could do. 

A portrait by Titian was then shown, in order to explain 
Burne-Jones’ idea of finish, and the jury, mistaking it for 
a Whistler, would have none of it. 

Mr. Bowen, in summing up the case, said all that Ruskin 
had done was to express an opinion on Whistler’s pictures— 
an opinion to which he adhered. This was about all he 
could say, except, in conclusion, to appeal to the jury. There 
really was no defence. Mr. Sergeant Parry, in his reply, 
pointed out that they had not dared to ask if Whistler 
deserved to be stigmatised as a wilful impostor, and that, 
even if Ruskin had not been well enough to attend the court, 


“he might have been examined before a commission. His decree 
has gone forth that Mr. Whistler’s picturés were worthless. He 
has not supported that by evidence. He has not condescended 
to give reasons for the view he has taken, he has treated us with 
contempt, as he treated Mr. Whistler. He has said: ‘I, Mr. 
Ruskin, seated on my throne of art, say what I please and expect 
all the world to agree with me.’ Mr. Ruskin is great as a writer, 
but not as a man; as a man he has degraded himself. His tone 
in writing the article is personal and malicious. Mr. Ruskin’s 
criticism of Mr. Whistler’s pictures is almost exclusively in the 
nature of a personal attack, a pretended criticism of art which 
is really a criticism upon the man himself, and calculated to 
injure him. It was written recklessly, and for the purpose of 
holding him up to ridicule and contempt. Mr. Ruskin has gone 
out of his way to attack Mr. Whistler personally, and must 
answer for the consequences of having written a damnatory 
1878] 1:Q 241 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


attack upon the painter. This is what is called pungent criticism, 
stinging criticism, but it is defamatory, and I hope the jury will 
mark their disapproval by their verdict.” 


The judge in summing up, pointed out that 


“‘there are certain words by Mr. Ruskin, about which, I should 
think, no one would entertain a doubt: those words amount to 
a libel. The critic should confine himself to criticism, and not 
make it a veil for personal censure or for showing his power. 
The question for the jury is, did Mr. Whistler’s ideas of art justify 
the language used by Mr. Ruskin? And the further question is 
whether the insult offered—if insult there has been—is of such 
a gross character as to call for substantial damages ; whether 
it is a case for merely contemptuous damages to the extent of a 
farthing, or something of that sort, indicating that it is one 
which ought never to have been brought into court, and in which 
no pecuniary damage has been sustained ; or whether the case 
is one which calls for damages in some small sum as indicating 
the opinion of the jury that the offender has gone beyond the 
strict letter of the law.” 


After an hour’s deliberation, the jury gave their verdict 
for the plaintifi—damages one farthing. The judge em- 
phasised his contempt by giving judgment for the plaintiff 
without costs; that is, both sides had to pay. 

‘*The whole thing was a hateful affair,”’ Burne-Jones 
wrote to Rossetti, and many agreed with him, though for 
other reasons. The Times, the Spectator, and the Portfolio 
pronounced the verdict satisfactory to neither party, virtually 
a censure upon both, who alike would have to suffer heavily. 
Mr. Graves, who watched the trial without the responsibility 
he was well disposed to meet, says : 


‘“‘T have always felt that, had the plaintiff’s counsel impressed 
upon the jury that Mr. Ruskin had mentioned the price asked 
for the picture, a matter that has always been quite outside the 
critic’s province, as well as criticising them as works of art, the 
result to Mr. Whistler would have been more in his favour. Mr. 
Tom Taylor was in the box, and he was never asked whether 
he had ever criticised the price as well as the quality.” 

242 [1878 


THE TRIAL 


Mr. Armstrong has told us of the suppression of important 
letters that must have influenced the verdict. He writes 
US : 


“TI think I cannot have been in London when the trial took 
place; at any rate, I was not present in court. A little while 
before it came on, I met Whistler one evening at the Arts Club, 
and he told me of his hopes of a favourable result. My sympathies 
were entirely on his side. I feared, however, that a jury could 
never be brought to see any beauty in Jimmie’s pictures—even 
the best of them—and that therefore they might condone the 
brutality of Mr. Ruskin’s attack. Whistler assured me that he 
had evidence, which I believed could not fail to be effective, in 
the shape of letters from Leighton, P.R.A.; Burton, Director 
of the National Gallery ; and Poynter, R.A., then Director for 
Art at S.K., speaking highly of the moonlight pictures. These 
letters seemed to me most important (I never read them), for 
they were from the hands of people in official positions, whose 
good words would have weight with the British juryman, or the 
ordinary bourgeois. Nothing was said about these letters in the 
newspaper reports of the trial, and I asked Jimmie the reason 
for this omission of the strongest evidence on his side. He 
told me that the writers of the letters had objected to their being 
put in, and so he had refrained from using them, and without 
the personal testimony of the writers they would not have been 
accepted as evidence in court. The accounts he gave of the 
trial were very funny. He described the bewilderment of the 
jury as the paintings—the Nocturnes—were passed round for 
their inspection, and how, when, last of all, Mr. Ruskin’s Titian 
was handed to them, one exclaimed, ‘Oh, come! we have had 
enough of these Whistlers!’ He said his pictures were presented 
to them upside down. About a fortnight after the trial, I saw 
Holker, at that time Solicitor- or Attorney-General, who led 
for Mr. Ruskin, and asked him if he had been helping to smirch 
any more poor artists. He replied that he was bound to do 
the best he could for his client. I told him he would never have 
allowed the exhibition of the pictures in court if he had been 
Whistler’s counsel, and he asked : ‘ Why didn’t Jimmie have me ?’ 
I explained that I had recommended his being retained, but it 
was objected that his fee would be too heavy, and he said: 

1878] 243 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


‘I'd have done it for nothing for Jimmie.’ I was very sorry 
that Mr. Ruskin was not punished.” 


Mr. Arthur Severn writes us that, at the Ruskin trial, he 


** was on the opposite side, although my sympathies were rather 
with Whistler, whose Nocturne in Black and Gold I knew to be 
very carefully painted. Whenever we met, he was always most 
courteous, quite understanding my position. During the trial, 
two or three little incidents happened which I may menticn. 
One of the Nocturnes was handed across the court over the 
people’s heads, so that Whistler might verify it as his work. 
On its way, an old gentleman with a bald head got a tap from 
the frame, then the picture showed signs of falling out of its 
frame, and when Sergeant Parry turned to Whistler and said : 
‘Is that your work, Mr. Whistler ?’ the artist, putting his eye- 
glass up, and with his slight American twang, said: ‘ Well, it 
was, but if it goes on much longer in that way, I don’t think 
it will be.’ I thought Whistler looked anxious whilst the jury 
was away. Another trial seemed to come on, so as not to waste 
time. The court was very dark, and candles had to be brought 
in—it seemed to be about some rope, and huge coils were on the 
solicitor’s table. A very stupid clerk was being examined. 
Nothing intelligent could be got out of him, and at last Mr. Day 
one of the counsel (afterwards the judge) said: ‘Give him the 
rope’s end,’ which produced great laughter in court, in which 
Whistler heartily joined. Then, suddenly, a hush fell on the 
court; the jury returned a verdict for Whistler, damages, one 
farthing.” 


There was a report of an application for a new trial. A 
desire was expressed on many sides that friends of artist and 
critic might be allowed to adjust the dispute. But Whistler 
made no application, called for no arbitration. He accepted 
his farthing damages. The British public rallied to their 
prophet, and got up a subscription for the rich man. It was 
managed by the Fine Art Society. The account was opened 
at the Union Bank of London in the names of Mr. Burne- 
Jones, Mr. F. S. Ellis and Mr. Marcus B. Huish, and by 
December 10 a subscription list was published, amounting 
244 [1878 


THE TRIAL 


already to one hundred and fifty-one pounds, five shillings 
and sixpence, and headed by Mr. Burne-Jones, five guineas. 
The costs were estimated at three hundred and eighty-five 
pounds. 

According to Mr. W. M. Rossetti, 

“Whistler then wrote to his solicitor, Mr. Anderson Rose, 
saying (and I could not but agree with him so far) that it would 
be at least equally appropriate for a band of subscribers to pay 
his costs; and he added, with one of his not easily imitable 
touches : ‘ And in the event of a subscription, I would willingly 
contribute my own mite.’ ” 

Mr. J. P. Heseltine wished to get up a subscription for 
Whistler, started it with a contribution of twenty-five 
pounds, and a list was opened at the office of L’ Ari, 134 
New Bond Street. But nothing came of it, except that 
Whistler sent one of his pastels to Mr. Heseltine. For 
Whistler, the poor man, the costs were not paid, and he went 
through the bankruptcy court. 

It is often said that Whistler wore the farthing on his 
watch-chain. We never saw it, we never knew him to 
wear a watch-chain. But he did make a drawing of the 
farthing for The Genile Art. 


1878] 245 


CHAPTER XX. BANKRUPTCY. THE 
YEARS EIGHTEEN SEVENTY-EIGHT 
TO EIGHTEEN SEVENTY-NINE. 


HE Attorney-General said that Whistler’s pictures 
afforded amusement to the public, and the trial was 
followed by shouts of laughter from every paper that pre- 
tended to be comic, and many that did not. There were 
caricatures: Whistler ‘‘ done brown”; Whistler mounted 
on a Nocturne, tilting against Ruskin astride a note-book ; 
Whistler and Ruskin showing each other their portraits 
upside down. In Punch, Whistler masqueraded as the 
‘** Penny Whizzler,”’ a grotesque bird with a whistle broken 
in two for legs, a drawing which he described as an “ historical 
cartoon.’ It was by Mr. Sambourne, who wrote to Whistler 
to explain that he made it at the request of the editor, Tom 
Taylor. Whistler answered that, to have brought about an 
Arrangement in Frith, Jones, Punch, and Ruskin, with a 
touch of Titian, was a joy in itself sufficient to satisfy even 
his craving for curious combinations, and no sentiment need 
be thrown away upon what to Sambourne was “ this trying 
time.”” Mr. Sambourne’s letter and Whistler’s reply were 
published, to the former’s discomfiture, in the World 
(December 11, 1878), and they were afterwards reprinted in 
The Gentle Art. The Standard said : 


“Of course, Mr. Whistler has costs to pay, and the amount 
he is to receive from Mr. Ruskin, even if economically expended, 
will hardly go far to satisfy the claims of his legal advisers. But 
he has only to paint, or, as we believe he expresses it, ‘ knock off ’ 

246 [1878 


BANKRUPTCY 


three or four ‘Symphonies’ or ‘Harmonies ’—or perhaps he 

might try his hand at a ‘Set of Quadrilles in Peacock Blue ’— 

and a week’s labour will set all square.” 

The inevitable stream of letters flowed into the Times, and 
driblets into other papers. There were interviews. Witti- 
cisms went the rounds. ‘‘ What is more natural than for 
a ‘Whistler’ to go in for ‘airs’ ?” the Figaro asked, and 
Whistler himself is reported to have said, “ Well, you know, 
I don’t go so far as to Burne-Jones, but really somebody 
ought to burn Jones’s pictures ! ” 

A few papers did not forget that Whistler was an artist, 
a few people were sympathetic, and congratulations were 
received at the White House. If Whistler was disappointed, 
he kept it to himself. He would have liked better to get 
his costs and damages, he said. But the verdict was a moral 
triumph. He had gone into court, not for damages, but to 
vindicate his position, and, therefore, that of all artists. 
He made sure that the vindication should become history. 
The trial was hardly over when, in December 1878, he pub- 
lished Whistler v. Ruskin—Art and Art Critics, the first of 
his series of pamphlets in brown paper covers. It was 
printed by Messrs. Spottiswoode, published by Messrs. 
Chatto and Windus, and dedicated to Albert Moore. The 
cover bore the Butterfly, and “J. A. MeN. Whistler, The 
White House, Chelsea, December 24, 1878.’ The pamphlet 
was the simple statement of his argument to prove the folly 
of the Pen when, without knowledge or experience, it ven- 
tured to criticise the Brush. It was to him an outrage that, 
while literature is left to the literary man, and science to 
the scientist, art should be at the mercy of ‘“‘ the one who 
was never in it,’’ but whose boast it is that he is doing good 
to Art. The critics “‘ are all ‘ doing good ’—yes, they all do 
good to Art. Poor Art! what a sad state the slut is in, an 
these gentlemen shall help her.” Whistler could see no 
1878] 247 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


loss if Ruskin ceased to preach to the young what he could 
not perform, and if he resigned his Slade Professorship, as 
he had threatened to do, and promptly did. Why should 
he not fill a Chair of Ethics instead ? The cry of the art 
critic, “21 faut vivre,” Whistler said he would meet with the 
appropriate answer, “‘ Je n’en vois pas la nécessité.”” Another 
sentence often quoted: ‘“‘A life passed among pictures 
makes not a painter—else the policeman in the National 
Gallery might assert himself.’’ Whistler’s argument passed 
for a novelty, and Art and Art Critics, falling for review into 
the hands of the men it abused, was condemned as “‘nonsense,”’ 
“* precious balderdash,” absurd with its sprinkling of French ; 
as if Whistler could not write better English than any and 
allofthem. It was regretted that he should make his personal 
affairs the basis of cheap popularity. The Saturday Review 
“would not be rash enough to say of any pamphlet that it 
was the silliest ever produced, but Mr. Whistler’s certainly 
is not the wisest we have seen.”” Other comments and criti- 
cisms, the killing of Tom Taylor and the new version of 
Balaam’s ass, are all in The Gentile Art, where they can be 
consulted. 

Whistler exhibited what he could, and where he could, 
exerting himself to make a finer showing than ever at the 
Grosvenor of 1879, to which he sent Portrait of Miss Rosa 
Corder, Portrait of Miss Connie Gilchrist, The Pacific, Nocturne 
in Blue and Gold, six etchings, two studies in chalk, and three 
studies in chalk and pastel. Old Putney Bridge, the print 
published by the Fine Art Society, was in the Royal 
Academy, from which he had been absent for seven years. 
Public and critics talked the old nonsense, with here and 
there a faint voice crying in the wilderness. Duranty saw 
a beauty in Whistler’s Nocturnes worthy to report to the 
Gazette des Beaux-Arts; in the Portfolio, Hamerton—pre- 
sumably, the note is unsigned—found an amiable word for 
248 [1879 


BANKRUPTCY 


the Rosa Corder and The Pacific; Mr. Comyns Carr com- 
mitted himself in the Academy to the recognition of scope 
and strength in Whistler’s resources. The praise, however, 
was not sufficient to relieve the situation in the White House. 
We have not come upon a more characteristic statement of 
the popular estimate of Whistler at that time than an article 
by Mr. Frederick Wedmore in the Nineteenth Century (August 
1879), which he reprinted in his Four Masters of Etching 
(1883). As Whistler has been thought foolishly vindictive 
in his treatment of his critics, it is fair to remember the 
provocation they gave him. Mr. Wedmore’s article was 
mainly a review of Art and Art Critics, which, evidently, had 
goaded him into fury. In his opinion, it was a “ trivial 
pamphlet.” Whistler had exposed the critic; the critic 
tried to pay him back by sneering at the artist : 

‘Long ago he was an artist of high promise. Now he is an 
artist often of agreeable, though sometimes of incomplete and 
seemingly wayward performance. . . . We want to look a little 
at the more commendable work as well as that for which has 
been bespoken that ill-advised notoriety which is but a spurious 
equivalent for fame. ... We cannot accept the successful 
pattern where association and sentiment has been: forego 
comedy and pathos, laughter and tears for a scientific adjust- 
ment of yellow and of red. . . . That only the artist should write 
on art by continued reiteration may convince the middle-class 
public that has little of the instinct of art.. But, sirs, not so 
easily can you dispense with the services of Diderot and Ruskin.” 
Mr. Wedmore had either forgotten, or never heard of, 

Cennini and Diirer, Vasari and Cellini, Da Vinci and Reynolds, 
and Fromentin, who remain, while Diderot and Ruskin 
are discredited, if not actually forgotten as authorities 
on art. He went on to regret that the originality of 
Whistler’s ‘“‘ painted work is somewhat apt to be dependent 
on the innocent error that confuses the beginning with the 
end.” He disposed of the Portrait of Henry Irving as a 
1879] 249 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


** murky caricature of Velasquez,”’ of the Carlyle as a “‘ doleful 
canvas.” He reduced the Nocturnes to “ encouraging 
sketches,” as far as his eyes could be trusted, seeing in them 


“an effect of harmonious decoration, so that a dozen or so of 
them on the upper panels of a lofty chamber would afford even 
to the wall-papers of William Morris a welcome and justifiable 
alternative. . . . They suffer cruelly when placed against work 
not, of course, of petty and mechanical finish, but of patient 
achievement. But they have a merit of their own, and I do not 
wish to understate it.” 


Whistler had ‘“‘ never mastered the subtleties of accurate 
form”; “the interest of life—the interest of humanity ” 
had little occupied him ; but Mr. Wedmore hoped that the 
career, begun with promise, ‘‘ might not close in work too 
obstinately faithful to eccentric error.” By his etchings, 
his name might “aspire to live,” though, “for his fame, 
Mr. Whistler has etched too much, or at least has published 
too much,” though there is ‘‘ commonness and vulgarity ” 
in many figures in the prints, though he “ lacked the art, 
the patience, or the will to continue ”’ others. 


“The Future will forget his disastrous Failures, to which in 
the Present has somehow been accorded, through the activity 
of Friendship, or the activity of enmity, a publicity rarely 
bestowed upon failures at all.” 


In the same month, August 1879, another critic, an Ameri- 
can, Mr. W. C. Brownell, published anonymously an article 
on Whistler in Painting and Etching in Scribner’s Monthly. 
He treated Whistler and his work with a seriousness in 
* significant ’? contrast to Wedmore’s clumsy attempts at 
flippancy. This was the first strong article in Whistler’s 
support, and it was illustrated by an extraordinary series 
of wood-engravings after his pictures and prints. Amidst 
250 [1879 


D 


FRILTHY LUCRI 


THE GOLD SCAB, OR ERUPTION I 


FSH 


BANKRUPTCY 


the torrent of sneers and abuse, it came at the moment when 
Whistler most needed it.* 

Whistler’s financial affairs were in more hopeless confusion 
than ever. The expenses of the White House were heavier 
than he anticipated. The interference of the Metropolitan 
Board of Works, to whom every drawing and plan had to 
be submitted, resulted in delays, disagreements, alterations. 
He made what concessions he couid; he even accepted the 
stone mouldings insisted upon by the Board. The builder’s 
estimate was largely exceeded before the decorations 
Boehm was to execute had been begun. He had brought 
debts from Lindsey Row. The legends of them centre 
about a greengrocer who is said to have let him run up 
his bill for endless tomatoes and rare fruit out of season, 
until it amounted to some six hundred pounds. When the 
greengrocer insisted on payment, Whistler said : 


‘‘ How—what—why—why, of course, you have sent these 
things—most excellent things—and they have been eaten, you 
know, by most excellent people. Think what a splendid ad- 
vertisement. And sometimes, you know, the salads are not 
quite up to the mark—the fruit, you know, not quite fresh. 
And if you go into these unseemly discussions about the bill— 
well, you know, I shall have to go into discussions about all this 
—and think how it would hurt your reputation with all these 
extraordinary people. I think the best thing is not to refer to 
the past—T'll let it go. And in the future, we'll have a weekly 
account—wiser, you know!” 


The greengrocer left without his money, but received in 
payment two Nocturnes, one the blue upright Valparaiso. 
Another story of the same creditor is that he followed Whistler 
with his account to the White House, arriving as a grand 
piano was being carried in. Whistler said he was so busy 

* Perhaps it should be added that this first serious article on Whistler was by 
no means taken seriously, and that the most was made of Mr. Brownell’s mis- 


take in describing the dry-point of Joe as a portrait of Dr. Whistler. 
1879] 251 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


he couldn’t attend to the matter just then, and the green- 
grocer went away happy, thinking if grand pianos were 
being bought, it must be all right. 

Whistler used to say of stories told about him, that there 
was always some foundation for them. The fact is that the 
creditors in Lindsey Row had been many, though before 
moving to Tite Street, he wrote hopefully to his mother at 
Hastings of his economies, and his prospects for paying off 
his debts. Whistler did not know the meaning of economy. 
And the trial had to be paid for, the studio still waited for 
pupils, his most important pictures were with Mr. Graves, 
and no new commissions came. But, as far as he let the 
world see, his troubles made no difference to him. 

It was no unusual occurrence for bailiffs to be in possession 
at the White House, or for bills to cover its walls. The first 
time it happened, he told the people whom he invited that 
they might know his house by the bills on it. Of the bailiffs 
he made another “ joy,” a new feature of his Sunday break- 
fasts. Mrs. Lynedoch Moncrieff has told us of a Sunday 
when, to her surprise, two or three men waited at table with 
Whistler’s servant, John, and she said to Whistler : 

“Why, Jimmie, I am glad to see you’ve grown so wealthy.” 

“Ha ha! Bailiffs! | You know I had to put them to some 
use ! ” 

Mr. W. M. Rossetti and his wife once found the same 
** liveried attendants.” 

““* Your servants seem to be extremely attentive, Mr. Whistler, 
and anxious to please you,’ one of the guests said. ‘Oh, yes,’ 
was his answer, ‘I assure you they wouldn’t leave me.’ ” 
Others remember the Sunday when all the furniture in 

the house was numbered for a coming execution. When 
breakfast was announced by a bailiff, Whistler said : 


“They are wonderful fellows. You will see how excellently 
252 [1879 


BANKRUPTCY 


they wait at table, and to-morrow, you know, if you want, you 

can see them sell the chairs you sit on every bit as well. Amazing.” 
Mrs. Edwin Edwards wrote us that, when he had at one time 
three men in possession, he treated them, while his friends 
carted away his pictures from the back door. Other friends 
say that the bailiffs, multiplied to seven, were invited into 
the garden, and given beer “‘ with a little something in it.” 
No sooner had they drunk of it than down went their heads 
on the table round which they sat, and they slept. People 
dining with Whistler that evening were taken into the garden 
to see the seven sleepers of Ephesus: “ stick pins in them, 
shout in their ears—see—you can’t wake them!” All 
evening it rained, and it snowed, and it thundered, and it 
lightened, and it hailed. All night they slept. Morning 
came and they slept. But just at the hour at which he had 
given them their glass the day before, they all woke up and 
asked for more. 

The man who has bailiffs in his house because he cannot 
pay his debts must still manage to pay them. One of the 
“wonderful fellows’ at the end of a week demanded his 
money. Whistler answered : 


“Tf I could afford to keep you, I would do without you.” 

‘But what is to become of my wife and family, if I don’t 
get my wages ?” 

“Ha ha! You must ask those who sent you here to answer 
that question.” 

‘“‘T assure you, Mr. Whistler, I need the money badly.” 

“Why not do as I do then, and have a man in yourself?” 


Whistler made a point of being courteous and attentive 
to these gentlemen, for, “ really, it was kind of them to see 
to such tedious affairs.”” He asked the first bailiff whom 
he encountered in his house, one evening when he returned 
from the Arts Club: 


‘“¢ And how long will you remain ‘the man in possession’ ?” 
1879] 253 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


“That, Mr. Whistler, depends on your paying Mr. ’s bill.” 

“Awkward for me, but perhaps more so for you! I hope 
you won’t mind it, though, you know, I fear your stay with me 
will be a lengthy one. However, you will find it not entirely 
unprofitable. For you will see and hear much that may be 
useful to you later on!” 


When things got more desperate, bills covered the front 
of the house, announcing the approaching sale. Whistler, 
begging the bailiffs to make themselves at home, went off 
one night to dine. It was a stormy night, and, returning 
late, he found that the rain had washed loose some of the 
bills, which were flapping in the wind. He woke up the 
bailiffs, made them get a ladder, brought them into the 
street, and insisted that every bill should be pasted down 
in place again. He had allowed them, he said, to cover his 
house with their posters, but, so long as he lived in it, no 
man should leave it in a slovenly condition. 

The crash came early in May 1879, and Whistler was 
declared bankrupt. The amount of his liabilities was four 
thousand six hundred and forty-one pounds, nine shillings 
and three pence, according to Messrs. Waddell and Co.’s 
statement of affairs, dated May 7, 1879. His assets were 
estimated at one thousand eight hundred and twenty-four 
pounds nine shillings and four pence, which was ultimately 
increased by one hundred pounds. Among his debtors were 
several friends, whom he urged to press their claims. In 
his long overcoat, longer than ever, swinging his light, thin 
cane, also lengthening in defiance, his hat set jauntily on the 
black curls, he appeared at the office of one of these friends, 
in the City, during business hours. “Ha ha!” he laughed 
as he came in. “ Well, you know, here I am in the City! 
Amazing.” And he sat down and gossiped lightly. The 
friend, knowing Whistler, knew something else must come of 
the visit. And it came, but not before Whistler got up to go. 
254 [1879 


BANKRUPTCY 


“You know, on the way, I dropped in to see George Lewis, 
being in the neighbourhood, and, you know, ha ha! he gave me 

a paper for you to sign!” 

It was a petition in bankruptcy. The friend did not want 
to sign; he had lent Whistler money, but was in no hurry 
to have it back. Whistler insisted, the friend could not 
escape, and would have put down as small a sum as possible. 
No, said Whistler, it must be for as much as possible, that 
he might have the more influence in the proceedings. The 
friend put down the exact amount, which was not large, and 
Whistler sauntered away, as if he had no heavier care than 
the fit of his coat and the weight of the cane he was swinging. 

The meeting of the creditors was held at the Inns of Court 
Hotel, a few weeks later, in June. Sir Thomas Sutherland 
was in the chair, Whistler on one side, Sir George Lewis on 
the other. To Leyland, with whom he had no “ business 
contract ’ for the Peacock Room, he attributed his bank- 
ruptcy, and Leyland, therefore, was his scapegoat. Various 
Chelsea tradesmen were also there. Except the solicitor, 
they all seemed amateurs in matters of bankruptcy. Papers 
were passed by the solicitor to the chairman, who endorsed 
them. Nota word was said. At last, an impatient butcher, 
or baker, springing up, moved that some explanation be 
made to the creditors. Leyland seconded him. At that, 
Whistler was on his feet, making a speech about plutocrats, 
men with millions, and what he thought of them. Every- 
body was stupefied! No one knew what to do. With 
difficulty, solicitor and chairman pulled him down into his 
seat again. At the end of the meeting, debtor and creditors 
appeared to understand as little as at the beginning. But 
the law took its course. A committee of examiners was 
appointed, composed of Leyland, the largest creditor, Howell, 
and Mr. Thomas Way. 

Leyland was not let off easily by Whistler. As Michael 
1879] 255 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Angelo, painting the walls of the Sistine Chapel, plunged 
the critic who had offended him into the depths of hell, so 
Whistler on his canvas caricatured the man by whom he 
thought himself wronged. He painted three pictures. The 
first was The Loves of the Lobsters—an Arrangement in Rats, 
the most prominent lobster in shirt-frills like Leyland. 
‘“‘ Whom the gods wish to make ridiculous, they furnish with 
a frill!” he said to his friends, and the saying was repeated, 
until the chances are it reached Leyland, as he meant it 
should. ‘The second was Mount Ararat, a Noah’s ark stranded 
on a hill, with little figures approaching it, or perched on the 
roof, all in the obnoxious frills. The third, the cruellest, was 
The Gold Scab, or Eruption in Frilthy Lucre, a demon-like 
creature, breaking out everywhere in a strange eruption of 
golden sovereigns, wearing the now symbolic frill, seated on 
the White House playing the piano. The hideousness of the 
strange figure is more appalling because of the beauty of 
colour, the decorative charm. A malicious joke begun in 
anger, Mr. Arthur Symons has described it, from which 
‘“ beauty exudes like the scent of a poisonous flower.” Whis- 
tler’s intention was that only these caricatures should be in 
the studio when Leyland, with the committee of examiners, 
made the official inspection. But in the meanwhile, they 
were seen by everybody who came to the White House. 
Mr. Augustus Hare wrote on May 13, 1879: 


“This morning I went with Mrs. Duncan Stewart and a very 
large party to Whistler’s studio—a huge place in Chelsea. We 
were invited to see the pictures, but there was only one there, 
The Loves of the Lobsters. It was supposed to represent Niagara, 
and looked as if the artist had upset the inkstand, and left 
Providence to work out its own results. In the midst of the 
black chaos were two lobsters curvetting opposite each other, 
and looking as if they were done with red sealing-wax. * I 
wonder you did not paint the lobsters: making love before they 
were boiled,’ aptly observed a lady visitor. ‘Oh, I never thought 

256 [1879 


BANKRUPTCY 


of that,’ said Whistler! It was a joke, I suppose. The little 
man, with his plume of white hair (‘the Whistler tuft,’ he calls 
it) waving on his forehead, frisked about the room, looking most 
strange and uncanny, and rather diverted himself over our 
disappointment in coming so far and finding nothing to see. 
People admire like sheep his pictures in the Grosvenor Gallery, 
following each other’s lead because it is the fashion.” 


As Whistler would be houseless in a few months, the old 
plan for a journey to Venice was revived. Some years before, 
Whistler told us, Mr. Ernest G. Brown, then a very young 
man in the office of Messrs. Seeley and Co., had called on him 
at 2 Lindsey Row to see about the Billingsgate plate. Whistler 
made a deep impression on Mr. Brown, who could never 
forget afterwards Whistler’s taking him to the window, and 
showing him the river, with Battersea beyond, or his talk 
of its beauty. When Mr. Brown left Messrs. Seeley for the 
Fine Art Society, he carried with him this impression of 
Whistler, and through his persuasion the Society undertook 
the publication of the three London plates. On business 
connected with them Mr. Brown again came to see Whistler 
at the White House. It was not long before the bankruptcy, 
and Whistler said: ‘* Iam afraid I am going to lose my house,” 
and then spoke of work at Venice he had long wanted to do. 
Mr. Brown went back and discussed the matter with the 
directors, so well that a commission was given to Whistler 
for twelve plates to be made in Venice, and delivered to the 
Society in three months’ time. 

By September 7 (1879), Whistler, “‘ apparently in great 
spirits,’’ was ‘“‘ arranging his route to Venice ” with Mr. Cole, 
and announcing that “‘ everything was to be sold up.” The 
receiver gave him permission to destroy unfinished work, 
that it might not be displayed to the public. Copper 
plates were scratched over, and pictures painted out 
with gum, stripped off their stretchers, and rolled up. 
1879] I:R 257 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


When next to nothing was left, he packed his trunks; 
wrote over his front door: ‘‘ Except the Lord build the 
house, their labour is but lost that build it.—E. W. Godwin, 
F.S.A., built this one’’?; and started for Venice, his first 
long journey since the voyage to Valparaiso. | 

The White House was sold on September 18, 1879 to Mr. 
Harry Quilter, who paid for it two thousand seven hundred 
pounds in money at the time, and later on in Whistler’s 
endless jests at his expense. The public jeered as usual. 
The contents of the White House, the Figaro (September 
1879) said, 


* revealed a list of effects that even a broker’s man would turn 
up his nose at, and if ever the ‘seamy side’ of a fashionable 
artist’s existence was shown, it was during that auction in Cheyne 
Walk, Chelsea. . . . Truly, if Mr. Ruskin had wished to have 
his revenge, he might have enjoyed it to an unlimited extent 
at the White House, when his prosecutor’s specially built-to- 
order abode was characterised as a disgrace to the neighbourhood 
by Philistinic spectators, and its contents supplied material for 
the rude jokes of Hebrew brokers, and the special correspondent 
of the Echo.” 


‘** Two wooden spoons, a rusty knife handle and two empty 
oil tins,’’ was one of the “‘ lots ”’ described for the delectation 
of the public. Everything was sacrificed and thrown away. 
Bundles of rubbish were carried off for a few shillings, and 
not even their purchasers dreamt that they would prove 
worth thousands of pounds if ever again they appeared in 
the saleroom. Out of this “rubbish ” came the beautiful 
studies for the Six Projects, an unfinished Valparaiso, the 
Cremorne Gardens shown at the London Memorial Exhibition, 
the portrait of Miss Way and The Blue Girl, the portrait of 
Miss Elinor Leyland, in such a deplorable condition that 
nothing now remains but the two blue pots of flowers which 
stood on either side the figure. Mr. Thomas Way bought 
258 [1879 


I Me 4" ‘ ba 7 
, 4 A 1 f < i ‘ ee ee, nese 
. valk ‘+ ¢ \ \ $ a 4 é { ~ a, P 3 f 
' ; Bus i ' ‘ A bed he 
v : : at ) i : . r ; 
A " ~ ¥ ; i » ’ r + x * 
a ‘ t . Bi : , ; 1 . " "7 
i se a t i ‘ \ La f . + 
F , si y ‘ L) } . hy 4 i =: 
’. a ‘ r fi R A . 
rt ap 7 : 
* ax A ' f . 
: ¥ : : . . 
. ; z aaeemncegtiet MET 
~ = _ 7S geen dah > elm 
wal r ; ’ 5 0 4 ri = deinin, 
Wye , . J ? ; ender 


7 : 
73 
“ “ ae 
‘ = rhasiy 
> 
, ‘ ce . 
: ; 
‘: . 
a 4 m 
a. A 
Py 7 


STUDY FOR “CONNIE GILCHRIST ” 


CONNIE GILCHRIST 
(Harmony in Yellow and Gold, The Gold Girl) 


yreh® 


des 


~ibinece: Pre 


BANKRUPTCY . 


The Lobsters and Mount Ararat, and they have passed into 
the possession of Mr. Freer. 

Whistler’s china, his prints, and some of his pictures were 
reserved for a sale at Sotheby’s, on Thursday, February 12, 
1880, when Whistler had been in Venice for some few months 
already. The title-page of the catalogue gives a good idea 
of what there was to sell: ‘In Liquidation. By Order of 
the Trustees of J. A. McN. Whistler. Catalogue of the 
Decorative Porcelain, Cabinets, Paintings, and other Works 
of Art of J. A. McN. Whistler. Received from the White 
House, Fulham, comprising Numerous Pieces of Blue and 
White China ; the Painting in Oil of Connie Gilchrist Dancing 
with a Skipping Rope, styled A Girl in Gold, by Whistler ; 
A Satirical Painting of a Gentleman, styled The Creditor, by 
Whistler. Crayon Drawings and Etchings, Cabinets, and 
Miscellaneous Articles.” When Leyland learned that the 
Gold Scab, masquerading as The Creditor, was to be included 
in the sale, it is said he proposed to take legal measures to 
have it removed. 

Several of Whistler’s friends and the dealers who bought 
his work were present. Mr. Way, Oscar Wilde, the Fine 
Art Society, Messrs. Dowdeswell, Mr. Mitford, Mr. Deschamps, 
Mr. Flower and Howell were the principal purchasers of the 
blue and white, the glass and the bronzes. Howell secured 
the Japanese screen that is the background for the Princesse 
du Pays de la Porcelaine. The Japanese bath fell to Mr. 
Jarvis. The Creditor, the ‘‘ Satirical Portrait,” was bought 
by Messrs. Dowdeswell for twelve guineas. The picture 
disappeared after this, but it turned up in the King’s Road, 
Chelsea, years later, and was purchased by Mr. G. P. Jacomb- 
Hood. It has since been exhibited at the Goupil Gallery, 
when one of the serious new critics regretted that Whistler 
should have allowed himself to be influenced by Beardsley. 
Connie Gilchrist Dancing with a Skipping Rope was sold to 
1879] 259 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Mr. Wilkinson for fifty guineas. Whistler’s bust, by Boehm, 
was bought by Mr. Way for six guineas. A crayon sketch, 
catalogued as a portrait of Sarah Bernhardt, was knocked 
down for five guineas to Oscar Wilde, who asked her to sign 
it, which she did, writing also that it was very like her. It 
might have been handed down as her portrait for ever, had 
it not been bought up at Oscar Wilde’s sale, and found its 
way back to Whistler, who declared that Madame Bern- 
hardt never sat to him for that, or any other, portrait. The 
sale at Sotheby’s realised three hundred and twenty-eight 
pounds, nineteen shillings, and did not take up the whole of 
the auctioneer’s day. 


260 [1879 


CHAPTER XXI. VENICE. THE YEAR 
KIGHTEEN SEVENTY-NINE TO EIGHTEEN 
EIGHTY 


HISTLER’S work during his fourteen months in Venice 

is better known than any he ever did. He showed 

much of it as soon as he returned to London, and the rest, 
although not exhibited until later, can easily be identified, 
as his subjects were entirely Venetian and this was his 
only visit to Venice. But his life there has become more 
or less of a legend. There is one person, Maud Franklin, 
who could tell the whole truth, and she prefers to remain 
silent. Many people, still alive, were with him in Venice, but 
their memories are:vague. And yet to-day, when two or three 
artists gather together of an evening at Florian’s, or the 
Quadri, or the Orientale, it is of Whistler they talk. When 
the prize student arrives and has sufficiently raved, they say, 
“* Oh, yes, but you will have to do it better than Whistler ! ”’ 
When a new discoverer of the picturesque brags, Whistler’s 
old friends tell him of Whistler’s discovery of ‘‘a court- 
yard, you know, that no one has ever seen, a most wonderful 
courtyard, amazing!” and of Whistler’s offer to show it to 
them, though they knew Venice, and he did not as yet. And 
the next morning, he took them to it, and when they got 
there, Meissonier sat on one side and Miss Montalba on the 
other, Henry Woods in one corner, and Van Haanen opposite, 
while in the centre, in the high light was Leighton. It 
was the Abazzia. “ Yes, this subject is No. 78,” they said. 
For years Whistler had wanted to do a series of Venetian 
1879] 261 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


etchings, but scarcely was he in Venice before he found it 
no place for work. The winter was fearfully cold: there 
had been nothing like it for thirty years, and he always felt 
the cold intensely. He could not keep warm, and he suffered 
from the discomfort of the Venetian houses. It is almost 
impossible to hold a copper plate or a needle with numbed 
fingers, and Venice in ice made him long for London in fog. 
He wrote home that he would gladly have exchanged the 
square of St. Mark’s for Piccadilly, his gondola for a hansom. 
It is curious that Ruskin, in a letter to Rogers, from Venice, 
twenty-eight years before, compared “the Canal with 
Piccadilly,”’ questioning “‘ whether, for the rest of one’s life 
one would rather have a gondola within call or a hansom.”’ 

Affairs in London continued to worry Whistler. He could 
not trace pictures that had mysteriously vanished, everything 
was in confusion; even his private letters and business 
correspondence turned up unaccountably in second-hand 
bookshops.* He was ill for a while with a bad throat, 
and his brother, the Doctor, was far away. And Venice 
was new to Whistler. In the beginning it seemed to him 
to belong to the land of the opéra comique, as Spain had 
on his one visit there years before. He found the very 
language disappointing, not to be compared to Spanish. 
Venice was beautiful, he granted, most beautiful, perhaps, 
in the rain, or, “after the wet,’ when, as he wrote to his 
mother, with the colour and the reflections more gorgeous 
than ever, and “with the sun shining upon the polished 
marble, mingled with rich-toned bricks and plaster,” one 
might think this city of palaces had been created for the 
painter. But it took him some time to become familiar 
with the beauty. Mr. Otto Bacher, one of the group of 
American artists who followed Mr. Frank Duveneck from 


* It is said that even letters written as a child to his mother were found 
there. 


262 [1879 


(PION pun anpg ‘ausnjzOOAT) 
SMUVW “LS 


Woe dake ie fey ped tte, 
he — me bat 


VENICE 


Venice in 1880, tells of visits to the Scuola di San Rocco, 
of his climbing up for a closer look at the Tintoretto, of his 
delight because the technique of that master coincided with 
his own; Veronese and Titian he thought “ great swells,” 
and Canaletto and Guardi, great masters. He went to St. 
Mark’s for midnight Mass on the one Christmas he spent in 
Venice, and declared that the Peacock Room, with the delicate 
harmony of its ceiling, was more splendid in effect than the 
Byzantine church with its golden domes. Years before, 
he had written to Fantin that it was a mistake, a waste of 
time, for the artist to go in search of new subjects, and 
during the early months in Venice, the new subject was 
probably as much a difficulty as the winter days. Countess 
Rucellai, then Miss Edith Bronson, writes us that 

‘“he used to say Venice was an impossible place to sit down 


and sketch in—he always felt ‘there was something still better 
round the corner.’ ”’ 


Mr. Henry Woods has told us how, at first, he was continually 
wandering and looking among the endless mass of material 
for some inspiring motive. Mr. Woods was nearer Whistler’s 
age than many of the artists in Venice, and not susceptible 
to Whistler’s influence, but he remembers that Whistler, no 
matter how much he wandered, and how completely he 
appeared to be loafing, when he did find a subject, worked 
with a determination that no cold and cheerlessness could 
daunt. Mr. Woods writes us: 

“I remember his remarkable energy—and actual suffering— 
when doing those beautiful pastels, nearly all done during the 
coldest winter I have known in Venice, and mostly towards 
evening, when the cold was bitterest! He soon found out the 
beautiful quality of colour there is here before sunset in winter. 
No mistake about it, he had a strong constitution. He was 
only unwell once here, and with a bad cold only.” 

The Fine Art Society had asked him to make twelve 
1879] 263 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


plates, and to deliver them in three months. To Whistler, 
the quality of his work alone was of importance. The 
plates were not started for months after he got to Venice, 
though the Fine Art Society were continually demanding 
from him some sign of what he was doing. The answer he 
made was at first silence, and then to ask for more money. 
The Fine Art Society, he explained to us, were used to 
artists who agreed to definite terms and kept to the agree- 
ment. They began to have their doubts, and, at any sug- 
gestion of doubt, Whistler was furious. Then reports came 
to them that he was doing many things, and that he was 
working on enormous plates they had never ordered. 
Howell and others would say that Whistler, of course, 
would never come back, and when Academicians laughed 
at the very idea of their getting either plates or their 
money from such a “ charlatan,” they would write to him 
again. With each new suggestion of doubt or uncertainty 
on their part, Whistler’s fury grew. This was the great 
cause of the trouble between him and the Society. 
““ Amazing,” their letters and his, Whistler used to say, 
*‘ but, perhaps, not for the public.’”’ The only reason for 
the delay was his fastidiousness about his own work. 
Even Frank Duveneck, most procrastinating of mortals, 
had time to produce his series of Venetian etchings, and 
Otto Bacher to change his style and make his Venetian 
plates, before Whistler had found his subjects. 

When at last he got to work, he worked unceasingly. 
It amused him to shock the American Consul by saying that 
idleness is the virtue of the artist, but it was a virtue he 
denied himself. He was up early in the morning, at half- 
past six. He never stopped while there was light or an 
effect. He could not be dragged to dinner before dark— 
he could scarcely keep his eyes open in the evening from 
fatigue. It was “the same old story” he told his mother,; 
264 [1879 


THE BASE OF THE TOWER, VENICE 
(Pastel) 


ties anid 
barren? 
hy Sie : ae 


en 


elt ecg siv td ee Soh coon 'vel is Sid alaakdpeein 


ves : 


ape get: 
ae 4 a 


VENICE 


“IT am at my work the first thing at dawn and the last 
thing at night.” He could stand the Venetian crowd no 
better than any one else, and he worked as much as 
possible out of the windows. He did comparatively little 
from gondola or sandola. To the tourist, a gondola is a 
thing of joy; to the worker, it is a terribly unstable, un- 
satisfactory studio, and even in the old days it cost a hundred 
francs a month, but then, the gondolier was your slave. In 
choosing his subjects, he usually left the monuments of 
Venice, as of London, alone. In London he preferred 
Battersea and Wapping to Westminster and St. Paul’s; 
in Venice little canals and calli, old doorways and gar- 
dens, beggars and bridges. made a stronger appeal to him 
than churches and palaces, though there is the fine 
Nocturne of St. Mark’s, as well as a few other exceptions. 
His interest was in the Venice of the Venetians as he 
saw it. M. Duret thinks he deliberately avoided subjects 
that Guardi and Canaletto had made their own, the great 
square with the Ducal Palace, the Cathedral, the Campanile. 
But subjects such as these, Whistler, as a rule, avoided 
everywhere. He was afterwards reproached for having 
turned his back upon the architectural glory of Venice. To 
reproduce the masterpieces of the master, he said, would 
be an impertinence. 

Some say that Whistler first took rooms at the top of the 
Palazzo Rezzonico, the palace now owned by Mr. Barrett 
Browning. Mr. Ralph Curtis, who lived in Venice, thinks 
that “for a time Whistler had, as many did, one of the big 
rooms on the second floor of the Rezzonico as a studio.” 
His only etching in the immediate neighbourhood is The 
Palaces made, not from an upper window, but from a traghetto, 
or the end of a near calle. Had he had rooms or a studio 
in the upper stories, there would most likely be some record 
of it from the windows. Mr. Brooks, also in Venice at the 
1879] 265 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


time, assures us that Whistler never lived there, and describes 
a little house in the heart of Venice, where ‘“‘ Maud ” was 
with him, and where he started to paint a picture of a gon- 
dolier, who fell ill, which was a great blow to him. The 
doctor put the gondolier to bed, and bled him for pneumonia ; 
Whistler came in and took heroic measures: milk punch 
and open windows. But the cure was slow. Whistler had 
to wait, and probably he never touched the canvas again. 
Mr. Otto Bacher writes of his quarters on the opposite side 
of the Grand Canal near the Frari. Mr. Bacher had arrived 
with Duveneck’s other pupils in the summer of 1880, and 
he recalls his first impression of Whistler at the time : 


** a curious, sailor-like stranger . . . short, thin and wiry, with 
a head that seemed large and out of proportion to the lithe figure. 
His large, wide-brimmed, soft, brown hat was tilted far back, 
and suggested a brown halo. It was a background for his curly 
black hair and singular white lock, high over his right eye, like 
a fluffy feather carelessly left where it had lodged. A dark, 
sack-coat almost covered an extremely low turned-down collar, 
while a narrow black ribbon did service as a tie, the long pennant- 
like ends of which, flapping about, now and then hit his single 
eye-glass.” 


Mr. Bacher also describes Whistler in evening dress with no 
tie at all: the peculiarity with which, of recent years, he 
had startled London. Mr. Brooks recalls his coming without 
one to the Bronsons where they met constantly, and Bronson 
saying it was sad to see artists so poor that they could not 
afford a necktie. We never knew Whistler, in the many 
years of our intimacy, to speak of himself as ‘‘ Whistler,” 
though Mr. Bacher makes him substitute ‘‘ Whistler ”’ for 
‘‘T” in almost all their talks. So foolish an affectation 
seems to us little like Whistler. 

Several of Duveneck’s pupils were living in the Casa 
Jankovitz, the house that juts out squarely at the lower end 
266 [1880 


VENICE 


of the Riva degli Schiavoni, all Venice in front of it. Whistler 
was enchanted, and promptly moved there. He had one 
room, the two windows looking towards San Giorgio, the 
Salute and the Doge’s Palace, and from these the etchings 
of the Riva and the lagoon, and the pastels of the same 
subjects were made. Many things are told of this one room 
in the Casa Jankovitz, of plates bitten on the top of the 
bureau, and acid running off, and the wild scramble to save 
his shirts from being ruined in the drawers beneath. Others, 
all true, are of the old printing press, on which Canaletto’s 
plates were supposed to have been pulled and certainly 
many of Duveneck’s and Bacher’s were: the press which 
used to pull with difficulty up to a certain point, and then 
went with such a rush that it had to be stopped, for fear the 
bed would come out on the floor. 

By this time he had found friends and enemies. There 
was a large colony of foreign artists and art lovers in Venice, 
and there was a club, English in name, really cosmopolitan, 
where he met Rico, Roussoff, Van Haanen, Tito, Blaas, if 
he had not already met them on the Piazza. Alexander, 
Rolshoven, as well as Bacher, among others, were with 
Duveneck. Harper Pennington joined them in the autumn, 
and Scott, Blum, Bunney, Jobbins, and Logsdail were at 
work. The American Consul, Mr. Grist, and the Vice- 
Consul, Mr. Graham, were persons of importance, and the 
Consulate then, as ever, a meeting-place. Mrs. Bronson 
lived in the Casa Alvisi, the Brownings and the Curtises were 
in Venice, and with all three families Whistler became 
intimate. Londoners sometimes turned up. Mr. Harry 
Quilter tells of one encounter : 

“In the spring of 1880, I was, as usual in those days, in Italy, 
and spent a few weeks in Venice. I had been drawing for about 
five days, in one of the back canals, a specially beautiful doorway, 


when one morning I heard a sort of war-whoop, and there was 
1880] 267 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Whistler, in a gondola, close by, shouting out, as nearly as I 
can remember: ‘Hi! hi! What, what! Here, I say, you’ve 
got my doorway ! ’—‘ Yourdoorway ? Confound your doorway ! 
I replied, ‘ It’s my doorway, I’ve been here for the last week.’ — 
‘I don’t care a straw, I found it out first. I got that grating put 
up.’—‘ Very much obliged to you, I’m sure: it’s very nice. It 
was very good of you.’ And so for a few minutes we wrangled, 
but, seeing that the canal was very narrow, and that there was 
no room for two gondolas to be moored in front of the chosen 
spot, mine being already tied up exactly opposite, I asked him 
if he would not come and work in my gondola. He did so, and, 
I am bound to say, turned the tables on me cleverly. For, 
pretending not to know who I was, he described me to myself, 
and recounted the iniquities of the art critic of the T'mes, one 
‘*Arry Quilter.’ ” 


Whistler’s struggle for bare existence and his pluck, are 
remembered by many. He was always poor at Venice, Mr. 
Brooks has told us, always borrowing money, and there 
was a very bad moment, when he used to say he had to live 
on ‘‘ cat’s meat and cheese parings.” But even while gossip 
of his poverty was spreading there were dinners and Sunday 
breakfasts. Many were given in a little open-air trattoria, 
near the Via Garibaldi. The Panada, that noisiest of all 
noisy restaurants, was another of his haunts, and some of 
the men who were in Venice speak of a third, opposite the 
old post office. The Venetian food, nothing but fowl, as he 
described it to Mrs. William Whistler, tired him at first so much 
that he surprised himself by spending what seemed a fortune 
on tea, and carrying home strange pieces of fat, which he 
tried to boil into resemblance of the crisp slices of bacon 
served by Mrs. Cossens, his Chelsea housekeeper. Mr. Curtis 
remembers dinners in Whistler’s rooms, so does Mr. Scott: 

“Tf Whistler could not lay a table, he knew how to turn out 
tasty little dishes over a spirit-lamp ; and it was not long before 
the inevitable Sunday breakfasts were instituted in that little 


room. Polenta a l Américaine, which he had induced the land- 
268 . [1 880 


a 


ag 


« 53 
DOI 


LR Pmcmpeee 


D 


I 


NIC 


kK 


E, V 


CALL 


tel) 


(Pas 


VENICE 


lady to prepare under his direction, we used to eat with such 
sort of treacle, alias golden syrup, as could be obtained. Fish 
was cheaper and more plentiful then than now in the Water City, 
and the lanky serving-women could fry with the best of the famous 
Ciozzotte. The ‘thin red wine’ of the country, in large flasks 
at about sixpence a quart, was plentiful, and these simple things, 
with the accompanying ‘ flow of soul,’ made a feast for the gods. 
There was no room for many guests at one time, but Henry 
Woods, Ruben, W. Graham, Butler and Roussoff were often 
with us.” 


Days were spent in excursions to the Lido, and, doubtless, 
Chioggia, Murano, Burano and Torcello. These little jour- 
neys were far more costly and difficult then than now, and 
there are no plates except the Murano Glass Furnace, and no 
pastels, except one or two on the Lido, to show for them. 

Best of all Whistler loved the nights at the never-closed 
clubs in the Piazza, at Florian’s, and the Quadri, or some- 
times at the Orientale on the Riva, where the coffee was just 
as good, and two centessimi cheaper. Around these nights 
endless legends are growing, and like the legends everywhere 
else, they are such a part of Whistler they cannot be passed 
over. No one loved them better than he, no one ever told 
them so well. They became the favourite “yarns” of 
Duveneck’s “ boys,” to which we listened many an evening 
when we came to Venice four years later. It was then we 
first heard of Wolkoff, or Roussoff as he is known in Bond 
Street, and his boast that he could make pastels so like 
Whistler’s that the difference could not be detected, and 
the American’s bet of a “champagne dinner” that he 
couldn’t, and the evening in the Casa Jankovitz, when Rico, 
Duveneck, Curtis, Bacher, Woods, Van Haanen, and De 
Blaas recognised Wolkoff’s work at a glance, and every time 
one of his pastels was produced, cried in one voice: “* Take 
it away!’ The Russian said to Whistler after the dinner: 
** You know, you scratch a Russian, and you find a Tartar !,” 
1880] 269 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


—‘*‘ Ha ha!” said Whistler, ‘“‘ I’ve scratched an artist and 
found an ama-Tartar!” Another “ yarn ”’ was of the tiny 
glass figure, or maybe, a little black baby from the shrine 
of St. Anthony in Padua, dropped into Whistler’s glass of 
water where it looked like a little devil bobbing up and 
down, so that Whistler, when he saw it, thought something 
might be wrong with his eyes, and sipped the water and 
shook the glass, and the more he sipped and shook, the more 
the little devil danced, and, finally, he upset the glass over 
everybody, and the little demon fell in his own lap. And 
there was another, of the night when a gondola, with a trans- 
parency showing Nocturnes and a band playing “ Yankee- 
doodle,’”? moved up and down the Grand Canal and along 
the Riva, and never stopped until it was greeted with a loud 
‘*Ha ha!” from out the darkness of the shore. And we 
heard of the day when Whistler, seeing Bunney on a scaffold 
struggling with St. Mark’s, his life work for Ruskin, fastened 
a card, ‘‘I am totally blind,” on his back. And we were 
told too of the hot noon, when Whistler, leaning out of his 
window, discovered a bowl of goldfish far below on the 
window-ledge of his landlady, against whom he had an old 
grudge, let down a fishing-line, caught the goldfish, fried 
them, dropped them back into the bowl, and watched the 
return of their owner, who thought that her fish had been 
fried by the heat of the sun. Or it was the story of Blum 
and Whistler, without a scat, crossing the Academy Bridge, 
Blum sticking in his eye a little watch with a split second 
hand that went round so fast the keeper thought he had 
an “evil eye,” and they got over without paying ; or of the 
‘‘ boys’ ” “‘ farewell fete ” to Whistler in August when there 
was rumour of his going, and in the coal barge, which Mr. 
Bacher’s description transforms into a “ fairy-like floating 
bower festooned with the wealth of autumn,”’ the feast of 
melons and salads and Chianti was spread, and eaten as they 
270 [1880 


VENICE 


went up the Grand Canal with the tide, and the brilliancy 
of their Japanese lanterns brought every one to stare at 
them, until the rain drove them under the Rialto where 
the rest of the night was spent, and Whistler didn’t go after 
all. When Whistler was really leaving, they say that he 
asked the authors of these and many adventures up to his 
room and showed them a number of prints, and said: ‘‘ Now 
you boys have been very good to me during all this time, 
and I want to do something for you’; and then he turned 
over the prints, one at a time carefully, and said: ‘‘ and 
I have thought it out’; and he took one, a spoiled one, 
and he counted their heads, and he cut it into as many pieces 
as there were people, and solemnly presented a fragment 
to each, and as they marched downstairs, all they heard was 
““Ha ha!” These, and hundreds like them, are the legends 
you still listen to on the Piazza. 

But Whistler left more than the memory of his gaiety 
with the friends he made in Venice. Two, Mr. Harper 
Pennington and Mr. Ralph Curtis, have sent us their im- 
pressions which we give here, without change or omission, 
though Mr. Curtis’ letter does not end with the Venetian 
days. But to change or to omit would be to lessen the 
vividness of the impression. 

Mr. Harper Pennington writes us: 


“You know, he asked me to turn back when I was in Venice 
(for the first time, in September 1880), and come with him to 
London. I told him that I was not yet prepared for such a 
master: that I needed two years more, at least, to learn the 
mere dull rudiments, and to become familiar with everything 
I should avoid. ‘Perhaps you are right,’ he said reflectively, 
and very slowly, “but come to me by-and-by—don’t put it off 
too long!’ He gave me many lessons there in Venice—real ones. 
He would hook his arm in mine, and take me off to look at some 
Nocturnes that he was studying or memorising, and then he would 
show me how he went about to paint it, in the daytime. He let 

1880] 271 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


me—invited me, indeed, to stand at his elbow as he set down 
in colour some effect he loved from the natural thing in front of us. 
What became of many such—small canvases, all of them—I do 
not know. The St. George Nocturne, Canfield has. Who owns 
The Facade of San Marco ? * 

“There was an upright sunset, too, looking from my little 
terrace on the Riva degli Schiavoni over towards San Giorgio 
—or others that I saw him work on in 1880. At last, my two 
years in Italy gone by, and a season in the studio of Carolus 
Duran superimposed, to find out his cuisine, I went to look for 
Jimmy in London, found him, and said: ‘Here I am!’” 


Mr. Curtis gives details of another kind : 


“You do me the honour of asking for my ‘impressions’ of 
Whistler. Off and on, for about twenty years, I had the good 
fortune of seeing him rather intimately in London, Paris and 
Venice. Those twenty years covered a multitude of vicissitudes 
in his career—semi-successes and partial defeats in London— 
his renaissance in Italy, his reinstalment in England, his coro- 
nation in Paris, and one may almost say his subsequent deification 
by every European denomination of the cult of art. Malheur, 
bonheur, Whistler conceding nothing—his attitude to art, to 
himself, to the public, and to his rivals, past and living, never 
changed. Applauded or booed, he ever remained with the same 
high esthetic ideals, and the same shrewd eye to business. A 
rare combination. To us humble apostles of this faith, the master 
always seemed an ultra-exclusive aristocrat. In the Gotha of 
royalties of the profession, picturesquely few did he deign to 
recognise as ‘brothers.’ This ultra-fastidiousness was sincere. 
It also included, possibly, sentiments of self-defence—a sort of 
Monroe doctrine ! 

“‘ Too self-reliant to be really jealous, he nevertheless constantly 
cultivated diplomacy. And in the broadest and best sense 
Whistler was a man of the world. For example, after the opening 
soirée of an International group at the Rue de Séze, all but one 
of the exhibiting artists were standing about, Whistler seated, 
and punctuating his wit with flourishes of his famous wand, 
when the belated member stumbled in from a too good supper, 
and ventured’: ‘ Ah, te voila, mon vieux. On peut faire le charlatan 


* Mr. J. J. Cowan. 


272 [1880 


VENICE 


@ Londres, mais ici, tu sats, ca ne prendra pas.’ General consterna- 
tion was relieved by the self-restrained reply : ‘ Ecoutez-moi bien, 
monsteur—dans mes voyages jai toujours remarqué, dans tous les 
pays, que les gentilshommes se grisent en gentilshommes, et les 
voyous en voyous. Allez, allez’ (with a wave of the wand). 
The blasphemer was hurried away, and the incident closed. 

“Shortly before his return to England with portfolios of the 
famous etchings and delicious pastels, he gave his friends a tea- 
dinner. As seeing the best of his Venetian work was the real 
feast, the hour for the hors d’auvres, consisting of sardines, hard- 
boiled eggs, fruit, cigarettes, and excellent coffee prepared by 
the ever-admirable Maud, was arranged for six o’clock. Effective 
pauses succeeded the presentation of each masterpiece, for with 
Japanese precision they had to be most carefully fixed in the 
one mount available. During these enér’actes, Whistler amused 
his guests with witty conjectures as to the verdict of the grave 
critics in London on ‘ these things.’ One of his favourite types 
for sarcasm used to be the eminently respectable Londoner, 
who is ‘ always called at 8.30, close-shaved at quarter to 9, and 
in the City at 10.2 ‘What will he make of this? Serve him 
right, too. Ha ha!’ 

“Whistler was a constant and ever-welcome guest at Casa 
Alvisi, the hospitable house of Mrs. Bronson, whom he often 
called Santa Cattarina Seconda. During happy years, from 
lunch till long past bed-time her house was the open rendezvous 
for the rich and poor—the famous and the famished—les rois 
en extl and the heirs-presumptive to the thrones of fame. Whistler 
there had his seat from the first, but to the delight of all he 
generally held the floor. One night, a curious contrast was the 
great and genial Robert Browning commenting on the projected 
form of a famous ‘Jimmy letter’ to the World. Those little 
arrows of wit, poisoned with veritable hellebore of sarcasm, were 
the result of infinite pains of gestation, pondered over, reforged, 
polished, and sharpened to the keenest edge. They might, 
better than by the Butterfly, have been signed by the symbol 
of the Wasp ! 

“Very late, on hot strocco nights, long after the concert crowd 
had dispersed, one little knot of men might often be seen in the 
deserted Piazza San Marco, sipping refreshment in front of 
Florian’s. You might be sure that was Whistler, in white duck, 
praising France, abusing England, and thoroughly enjoying 

1880] 1:8 273 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Italy. He was telling how he had seen painting in Paris revolu- 
tionised by innovators of ‘ powerful handling ’: Manet, Courbet, 
Vollon, Regnault, Carolus Duran. He felt far more enthusiasm 
for the then recently resuscitated popularity of Velasquez and 
Hals. 

** The ars celare artem of Terborgh and Vermeer always delighted 
him—the mysterious technique, the discreet distinction of exe- 
cution, the ‘ one skin all over it,’ of the minor masters of Holland 
was one of his eloquent themes. To Whistler it was a treat 
when a Frenchman arrived in Venice. If he could not like his 
paint, he certainly enjoyed his language. French seemed to 
give him extra exhilaration. From beginning to end, he owed 
much to the French for first recognising what he had learned 
from Japan. 

“Was Whistler not the pioneer to graft on to the tired stump 
of Europe the vital shoots of Oriental Art? From Hiroshige 
especially he appears to have assimilated those nicely weighed 
laws of balance in design, the tender chord of colour and un- 
conventional arrangements which have long since become 
vulgarised—even to the posters of Part nouveau. 

“Some Japanese delight in Whistler’s tonalities, but are 
reserved as to the timidity of his drawing—innately sensitive 
to the fine beauty of line-rhythm in general composition, can 
we contend that he was often an accomplished draughtsman of 
detail? It is admitted that Whistler felt as few the supreme 
effect of an elegant silhouette, but it was only after hard work 
that he ever attained the purity of detail contour he so patiently 
aimed at. Witness the legs in the portrait of little Miss Alexander, 
which, nevertheless, posterity will perhaps pronounce his most 
perfect masterpiece. 

“To continental comrades the American’s mentality seemed 
far more Gallic than Anglo-Saxon—Parisians loved equally his 
sense of humour and his bump of combativity. They also 
relished his shafts of revenge at the artistic pretensions of the 
English, as compared with the national instincts of the French. 
Except for his exaggerated attitude during the Boer War, this 
revenge was atoned for by his equally deep gratitude to Paris, 
where, as a boy, his qualities had been at once recognised, and 
though he made, and lost, friends, money and notoriety in 
London, it was again Paris which gave him his official diplomas 
as one of the very greatest men of the day. 

274 [1880 


VENICE 


“ Already posterity has corrected its rough proofs, and Whistler 
is henceforth classed as a classic. His delicate sense of order, 
proportion and spacing in pictorial composition was consistently 
carried out in the tidiness of all his surroundings and in the 
quaint coquetry of his dress, while even his most informal notes 
were invariably models of precise execution. Later, as a printer, 
he showed positive genius in personally supervising to the smallest 
minutiz the perfect presentation of his literary work, which 
remains, we are told, a model of faultless taste—Taste is prob- 
ably the epitaph he himself would prefer. And by that hack- 
neyed word, meaning perhaps the rarest quality in modern life, 
Whistler, of all others, seems unreservedly entitled to be charac- 
terised.”’ 


1880] 275 


CHAPTER XXII. VENICE. THE YEAR 
KIGHTEEN SEVENTY-NINE TO EIGHTEEN 
EIGHTY CONTINUED 


OTHING in the various phases of Whistler’s art is more 
astonishing than the storm of praise and abuse raised 
by the Venetian pastels, as will be seen when we come to 
their exhibition in London. Before this, when they were 
being done in Venice, the entire artistic community fought 
over them, for and against. To some, they were perfectly 
original, they expressed the character of Venice; to others, 
they appeared cheap, anybody could do them. Both sides 
were wrong, as both sides always were about Whistler. 
“Anybody”? cannot do them, and he had been making 
drawings of the kind ever since, if not before, the early 
days in Chelsea; the subject, not the method, was new to 
him. Had some of the enthusiasts visited the collection 
of drawings in the Academy at Venice, they might have 
discovered his inspiration in the drawings of the Old 
Masters, where Whistler had found it years before at the 
Louvre. He was, as usual, inventing nothing, only carrying 
on tradition. 

The method was simple. He drew on brown paper, 
sometimes taken from the grocer’s or the colourman’s parcel, 
putting in the composition with black chalk, and adding a 
few touches of colour. In this way, he made his studies for 
his pictures, especially for his classical subjects in the ’sixties, 
and a great number were in the possession of Mr. Thomas 
Way. The design for the mosaic for South Kensington, notes 
276 [1880 


VENICE 


of costumes for his sitters, decorative schemes, and scores | 
of other subjects, many forgotten by him though they filled 
a large cabinet in the studio in the Rue Notre-Dame-des- 
Champs, and another in Fitzroy Street, were all done ten 
or fifteen years before he went to Venice. We do not know 
whether the little Chelsea shops belong to a later period. 
But to the day of his death he never gave up the method, 
and in his colour lithographs, he carried out the same idea. 
The early sketches on brown paper were mostly not known 
until the Memorial Exhibitions of his work. The few pre- 
viously shown in London had attracted so little attention 
that he was generally believed to have taken up pastel in 
Venice, and to have made his wonderful drawings there 
without any technical preparation. 

There were two reasons why Whistler used coloured 
papers for the pastels. One was that they gave him, 
without any work at all, the foundation of a colour- 
scheme which could be carried out in the simplest manner 
in the black chalk outline, and the few touches of pastel 
that completed the harmony. The other reason was that, 
having the sympathetic colour of the paper, he worked 
straight away on it, and did not ruin the surface and tire 
himself in getting the tone. When in Venice, Mr. Jobbins 
showed him some beautiful old brown, blue and pink paper, 
found in an old warehouse just off the Merceria, since cleared 
out, Whistler was completely equipped, not only with ex- 
perience, but with better materials than he ever had before. 
It was natural that he should get to work in the way he had 
made his own. Mr. Bacher describes him in his gondola 
laden with pastels. But his materials were so few that, 
with them, he could wander on foot in the narrow 
streets, the best way to work, as every one who has lived in. 
Venice knows. For it is far from easy to find again a place 
come upon by chance, and it is virtually impossible ever to 
1880] 277 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


see again the effect that has fascinated you. He carried 
only a little portfolio or drawing-board, some sheets of 
tinted paper, black chalk, half a dozen pastels, and varnished 
or silver-coated paper to place over the drawing, when 
finished. When he once found what he wanted, he made 
his sketch in black chalk, and then just hinted, but beauti- 
fully, the colour of the old walls, the green shutters, the 
brilliant spots of the women’s dresses: the colour put in 
as in a mosaic or stained glass, mostly a flat tint, the pastel 
between the black lines. He always remembered the limita- 
tions of the medium and never attempted to paint with his 
stick of colour, using greater pressure to obtain greater 
brilliancy and less for his more delicate tones, but keeping 
his colour pure and fresh, as you can see in the “ foolish 
sunsets ’’ he sometimes did in Venice, though rarely after- 
ward. The surprise was that it could be so simple, so easy 
—“ only the doing it was the difficulty,’ he would say. It 
is doubtful if he ever worked more than a day on any one 
subject. It is almost certain that he finished each before 
he left the place. People were not often given the chance to 
learn much about Whistler’s methods, or to know what he 
was doing. But when he finished a series of these Venetian 
drawings, the fact did become known, and he gave an ex- 
hibition of them in the club at Venice. He showed them 
also at Mrs. Bronson’s, and in his room. After the Sunday 
breakfast, Mr. Scott writes: 

“The latest pastels used to be brought out for inspection. 
Whistler would always show his sketches in his own way, or 
not at all. In the absence of a proper easel and a proper light, 
they were usually laid on the floor.” 

The “ painter fellows ’’ were startled by the brilliancy of 
the pastels, Whistler said, and he told his mother that he 
thought rather well of them himself. 

The drawing in many has been praised with the reckless 
278 [1880 


MARBLE PALACE, 
(Pastel) 


VENICH 


VENICE 


inconsequence characteristic of most of the praise bestowed 
on Whistler’s work. The drawing is often either not good 
in itself, or so slight as to be of little importance. The 
beauty is altogether in the suggestion of colour, the arrange- 
ment of lines that he hints at. It is all suggestion. Though 
he passed the spring, summer, winter, and part of two 
autumns in the city, there is no attempt, save in some of 
the sunsets, to give atmospheric effects, or the effect of the 
season, of the time of the year. What he saw that pastel 
would do, what he made it do, was to record certain lines 
and to suggest certain colours. Critics and artists, having 
at that time never studied pastel, were unaware of what had 
been done in the medium. In fact, the revival in the art 
of drawing in pastel did not come for some years after 
Whistler showed his Venetian series, when there was a 
** boom ”’ all over the world, and pastel societies were started, 
most of which have since collapsed. 

The ‘“‘ boom ” in etching commenced ten or twelve years 
before Whistler went to Venice. If nothing was known 
till then of the possibilities of etching, much was known of 
its history. There were accepted standards: Rembrandt, 
Haden, Méryon. Whistler had already accomplished great 
things, done after a more or less definite formula laid down 
by Diirer, Rembrandt and Hollar. Therefore, when he 
produced etchings which struck the uncritical, and even 
those who cared, as something new and untried, the un- 
critical were shocked because their preconceived notions 
were upset, and those who cared were astonished. The 
difference between the Venetian and the London plates was, 
Mr. Duret says, so great that the two series might be attri- 
buted to two men. This was due partly to the difference 
between London and Venice seen by an artist sensitive to 
the character of places, but more to the difference of tech- 
nique between the earlier and the later plates. Not so 
1880] 279 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


many years ago, talking to him about this subject, we said 
that the Venetian plates seemed to be executed in an 
absolutely new and original technique. It so happened that 
the Adam and Eve, Old Chelsea, and The Traghetto were, as 
they are now, hanging almost side by side on our walls. 
In a five minutes’ demonstration he proved one to be but 
the outgrowth of the other, and had he carried the demon- 
stration further back, he could have proved that both, as 
we can now see, grew out of The Coast Survey plate, and that 
there was a natural and logical growth all the way through. 
Until the London Memorial Exhibition of his work, it was 
impossible to trace this growth, because the prints were 
never before hung together chronologically. Even the 
Grolier Club, in New York, was forced, for want of space, to 
make two separate shows. Before Whistler exhibited his 
Venetian plates, even artists knew nothing but the French 
Set and the Thames Set. The intermediate stages in 
the gradual development were not known, and the Venetian 
plates seemed a new thing. But the only difference between 
these and the Thames series is entirely one of development. 
Whistler always spoke of the Black Lion Wharf as boyish, 
though it is impossible to conceive of anything in its way 
more complete in drawing. His estimate of it has been 
accepted by many. Mr. Bernhard Sickert, in writing of 
the plate, thinks it misleading to say that every tile, every 
beam has been drawn. ‘“* These details are merely filled in 
with a certain number of strokes of a certain shape, accepted 
as indicating the materials of which they are constructed.” 
When an etching is in pure line and owes little to the printer, 
as in this case, it is the wonderful arrangement of lines, the 
wonderful lines themselves, which make you feel that every- 
thing, every beam and every tile, has been drawn ; that ‘every 
detail actually has been drawn, we did not suppose anybody 
would be so absurd as to imagine. The character of the 
280 [1880 


VENICE 


lines gives you this impression, which is exactly what the 
artist wanted. It has been said by another critic that 
Whistler exhausted all his blacks on the houses. He did 
nothing of the sort. He concentrated them there, and did 
not take away from the interest of the wharf he was drawing 
by an equal elaboration in the boats, the barges, and the 
figures. As he grew older and practised more, he gave up 
his literal, definite, firm method of work. Instead of drawing 
the panes of a window in firm outline, for instance, he sug- 
gested them by drawing the shadows and the reflected light 
with short crisp strokes, and scarcely any outline at all. 
In the Black Lion Whar}, he got the light and shade on his 
building by different bitings. In Venice, it was done by 
suggesting the shadows. In both series, the small figures 
in movement are nearly the same, but there is a great advance 
in the drawing in the Venice plates, where they are simply 
indicated to give the idea of motion and life. If you compare 
the Millbank and the Lagoon, you find in both the subject, 
or the dominating lines in the subject, to be the same, a 
series of posts carrying the eye from the foreground to the 
extreme distance, but their treatment in the Venetian plate 
is far more direct and expressive. Simplicity of expression 
has never been carried further. Probably the finest plate, 
in its simplicity and directness, is The Bridge. Whistler now 
obtained the same quality of richness by his manner of 
suggesting detail, and also by his printing. In The Traghetto 
in Venice, there is the same scheme as in the early prints of 
The Miser and The Kitchen, but the Venice plate is more 
painter-like in quality. Without taking away from the 
etched line, he has given a fulness of tone which makes the 
background of The Burgomaster Six seem weak in comparison. 

He was now doing his own printing for the first time to 
any extent. There were a hundred prints of the first Series 


of Twelve in Venice. Of a few plates, the prints were not 
1880] ) 281 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


all pulled by him, and the difference between his printing 
and Goulding’s is unmistakable. In the hand of any pro- 
fessional printer, save Mr. Goulding, plates like The Traghetto 
and The Beggars would be a mass of scratches, though scratches 
of interest to the artist; it required Whistler’s skill as a 
printer to bring out what he wanted, and to make them 
what they are. And it was the more surprising that he 
could develop his printing as he did in Venice, because the 
conditions were so primitive. Mr. Bacher had a portable 
press which interested him, but most of his printing was done 
on the old press to which we have referred. Whistler vehe- 
mently protested, as we often heard him, against the printer, 
his pot of treacle and his couches of ink. But no great 
artist ever carried the printing of etchings further than he, 
or ever made such use of printer’s ink as he did in some of 
these plates. Without the wash of ink, all it is however, 
they would be the faintest ghosts of themselves, with no 
interest, and he was justified in using ink as he wished, when 
it made his proof better. And he used it in all sorts of ways 
on the same plates, to try endless experiments with ever- 
varying results, even to cover up the rather weak lines of | 
an indifferent design, as in Nocturne—Palaces, prized highly 
by collectors, but one of his poorest plates. It and The 
Garden, Nocturne—Shipping, and one or two besides are by 
no means equal to the others. But there are no such perfect 
plates in the world as The Beggars, The Traghetto, the two 
Rivas and The Bridge. 

Mr. Frank Short has written us an interesting note on 
Whistler as printer, and since it relates partly to the Venetian 
plates and to his methods when he printed them, it can 
appropriately be quoted here : 

‘Tam very bad at remembering dates, &c., but my acquaintance 
with Whistler began about 1885. We used in those days to 


send things that were going to exhibitions, the day before sending 
282 [1880 


VENICE 


in, to the Hogarth Club, and an etching of mine was there that 
Whistler liked ; and next day he came to my very small studio 
in Chelsea to tell me so, and gave me at the same time a ticket 
for his Ten o’Clock. I always look upon this visit as an ex- 
ceedingly kind thing for him to do. After that, when I had a 
studio in the Wentworth Yard, he often came in to talk on 
technical matters in etching, &c., and sometimes brought in a 
batch of plates for me to lay rebiting grounds for him. I never 
remember laying a first ground for him; but he several times 
asked me to take out or lighten lines on plates, which I did. I 
must have had a considerable number, one time and another, 
but I cannot recall which they were. He used occasionally to 
come in to prove a plate and a good many of the Venice plates 
were defaced in my studio (with the heaviest needles I could 
find him), and a couple of proofs were taken with the scratches 
on. I never printed an edition with him. The last time he 
printed with me was in July 1900, when he came down here 
[Brook Green] with nine or ten plates, and we printed a few 
proofs of each. Some of these plates were slight, but several 
carried a good way.* He, as usual, worked a little in dry-point 
between each proof. I think he intended coming to print, &c., 
a good deal at this time, but I think he got ill. I remember he 
said the ‘ etching fit’ was on him again. I think he liked some 
one to print with him—some one that he could leave the ink 
and the press to, and be only concerned himself with the wiping. 
I was always a little surprised that he left the ink mixing to me— 
‘Make it your own way,’ he would say, ‘ a dark nutty brown.’ He 
said he had come to the conclusion that too brown (or too light) 
an ink was an affectation. 

“TI think he knew that I was always delighted to give him 
any help I could; but yet he was careful to bring me a proof, 
now and again, that he thought I should like. I remember he 
insisted on the Fine Art Society giving me a proof of one of the 
Venice plates, because I lacquered the plates when they were 
defaced. He said: ‘I have told them they must let you choose 
a proof, so you must go up and choose one.’ I did—one of the 
best proofs of The Traghetto I know ! 

** As to the printing: when with me he always kept the plate 
slightly warm in the usual manner. If he was using very weak 


* These were the last Paris plates. 
1880] 283 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


ink, I daresay he would work with a cold plate, as one sometimes 
does. Also, he always left his plate rag-wiped, but, as years 
went on, he seemed more and more particular to get the surface 
as clean as possible (with the muslin), His continual grumble 
was ‘not clean enough.’ As for retroussage, he would have none 
of it. So that (and this I like to think) his printing was perfectly 
simple. I remember once, with a much under-bitten plate, I 
suggested hand-wiping. He said: ‘ Well, I have done that 
sometimes,’ and proceeded to do it: but he had just before been 
putting on dry-point and hadn’t taken off the burr, which, of 
course, shouted out with the hand-wiping ; and he said, it won’t 
do, and finished again with the muslin. Nevertheless, I could 
have got a better proof off that plate with the hand!” 


While printing, Whistler was continually working on his 
plates, which accounts for the extraordinary variety existing 
in different examples of the same etching. A curious fact 
about The Traghetto and The Beggars is that, of each, there 
were two plates. He was displeased with the first T'raghetto, 
and etched it over again, and the same thing must have 
happened to The Beggars. Mr. Bacher writes that The 
Traghetto *“‘ troubled him very much.” He pulled one fine 
proof and then overworked the plate so that he had to prepare 
a second one. He had another copper of the same size and 
thickness made by the Venetian from whom they all got 
their plates. When this was ready, the first plate was 
“inked ” with white paint, instead of black ink, passed 
through the press, and a proof pulled. This was placed on 
the second plate, already varnished, which was then run 
through the press. The result was “a replica in white upon 
the black etching ground.”” Mr. Bacher says that upon the 
new plate Whistler worked for days and weeks with the first 
proof before him, that he might find and etch only the lines 
in the original. 


“The printing of this plate was an exciting moment. As 
the gentle old printer of Venice pulled the plate through the 
284 [1880 


VENICE 


massive wooden rollers, heavily padded with felt blankets, 
nothing was heard but the squeaking of the old wooden press, 
It was the supreme moment of joy or of keen disappointment— 
it was the end of the journey and, fortunately, the new proof was 
exquisite. It was another T’raghetio, the one we now know, but 
it was not a duplicate of that marvellous first proof. Whistler 
placed the two proofs side by side and minutely compared them.” 


And he was pleased, for the examination ended in the one 
song he allowed himself in Venice : 


** We don’t want to fight, 
But, by jingo! if we do, 
We've got the ships, 
We've got the men, 
And got the money too-00-00 ! ” 

The first proofs of other plates, we believe, were very 
unsatisfactory. Each proof, therefore, was a trial, and, as 
each was pulled, he worked upon the plate, not, of course, 
taking out large slabs or putting in new passages to make quite 
a new state of it, but strengthening lines or lightening them, 
giving richness to a shadow or modelling to a little figure. 
It would be impossible, if you had not the hundred proofs 
of one of these Venetian plates by you, to say how much 
he did do or what he did in each, but the first proof is abso- 
lutely different from the last, and probably no two are alike. 
Some of them, from the veriest ghost, became the richest, 
fullest prints. 

In his Venice etchings, Whistler also developed what he 
called the Japanese method of drawing, Bacher calls his 
secret, and Menpes the secret of drawing. Whistler always 
spoke frankly about it to us, from the first time J. saw him 
etching, and he followed the same method in his lithographs. 
In etching or lithography, where it is difficult to make correc- 
tions, and where the surface of the plate or the stone should 
not be disturbed, it is not easy, by the ordinary manner in 
which drawing is taught, to put a complicated design on the 
1880] 285 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


plate properly, without elaborate spacing, tracing, or a pre- 
‘liminary sketch. Frequently, when the design is half made 
in the usual fashion, the artist finds that the point of greatest 
interest, the subject of his picture, will not come on the plate 
where he wants it. The Japanese always seem to get the 
design in their colour-prints in the right place, and yet 
their technique adds to the difficulty of changing or altering 
a design, especially in their prints. But whether this is 
because they have the method of drawing Whistler attributed 
to them, whether he got his idea from Japanese prints or 
evolved it, we do not know. We do know that the idea was 
his long before he painted the “‘ Japanese pictures.’”’ You 
can see the beginning of it in the Isle de la Cité, and Fumette’s 
Bent Head, and the unfinished Temple Bar. The system, 
scientific as all his systems were, is this: to select the exact 
spot on the canvas, the lithographic stone, the etching 
plate, or the piece of paper, where the centre of interest is 
to be, and to draw this part of his subject. It might be 
somewhat near the side of a plate, though he insisted that 
the composition should always be placed well within the frame 
or the plate, contrary as such treatment is to Japanese 
methods and his own early practice. As we have already 
pointed out, in the early paintings, sprays of flowers, or 
branches of trees run into the picture to give the impression 
that it is carried beyond the frame, as is done repeatedly 
in Japanese art. But his theory, perfected before the Venetian 
period and adhered to as long as he lived, was that every- 
thing of any interest should be well within the frame or plate 
mark, as far within as the subject was from him. Having 
then selected the point of principal interest, he drew that, 
and drew it completely, and there, on his plate, or his stone, 
was a picture. It might be, as Mr. Menpes says, a distant 
view of palaces and the shipping beneath a bridge; in 
London it was frequently a shop window ; in Paris, a dark 
286 [1880 


VENICE 


doorway ; in portraits, the sitter’s head. Whatever it was, 
once he had put it down, he drew in the surrounding objects, 
or those next in importance, all the while carrying out the 
work completely and making it into one harmonious whole. 
The result was that the picture was finished—* finished 
from the beginning ’’—and there was always about it, on 
the plate, paper or stone, a space which he could fill up with 
less important details, or leave as he chose. With his 
painting, it was a different problem. When the subject 
was arranged, it grew together, all over at the same time. 
But, in some of the earlier pictures, Old Battersea Bridge, for 
example, a piece of canvas seems to have been added, though 
he maintained that the artist should confine himself to the 
size of the canvas he selected, and not get over his blunders, 
as so many do, by adding to, or taking from it. All this 
requires the greatest care in just what Whistler considered 
so important, the placing of the subject. Working in this 
manner, always with the completed picture before him, he 
could return to it again and add further work, if he thought 
it was needed, knowing he had his subject down. It sounds 
simple, so simple that one day, when he had been explaining 
it to Mr. E. A. Walton, and the latter said: ‘‘ But there is no 
secret !’’ Whistler’s answer was: ‘“‘ Yes, there is, the secret 
is in doing it.” It is just this, in the doing it, that the 
excellence of his work lies. As a matter of fact, it is difficult 
to restrain one’s self to drawing completely the heart of a 
subject, while, in painting, still more restraint is necessary 
the restraint imposed by colour. 

Besides etchings and pastels, Whistler made water-colours 
in Venice, but as they were never all shown together, it is 
impossible to say how many; and there were a few oils. 
The most important is Nocturne, Blue and Gold, St. Mark’s, 
exhibited at the British Artists’ and the London Memorial 
Exhibition, to which it was lent by Mr. J. J. Cowan. Mr. 
1880] 287 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Bacher speaks of one from the windows of the Casa Jankovitz, 
‘the Salute and a great deal of sky and water, with the 
buildings very small,” and of a third, a scene at night, from 

a café near the Royal Gardens. Mr. Brooks has told us of 
another, a Nocturne of the Giudecca, with shipping, on a panel, 
which Whistler gave to Mr. Jobbins, who thought so little 
of it that he painted a sketch on the back, and then sold it 
to Mr. Brooks, who still has it. Doubtless there were others, 
but we know of none that were included in exhibitions and 
catalogues, and can so be identified. 


288 [1880 


PORTRAIT: OF SIR HENRY IRVING AS PHILIP OF SPAIN 
Arrangement in Black No. III, 


STUDY FOR THE “IRVING” 


(Htching) 


ee 


gf Aaa 


a, as 


wigiter 
PEE, 
‘eae 


CHAPTER XXIII. BACK IN LONDON. THE 
YEARS EIGHTEEN EIGHTY TO EIGHTEEN 
EIGHTY-ONE 


Y the end of November 1880, Whistler was in London 

again. ‘“ Years of battle,’ M. Duret calls the period 

that followed, and Whistler had come back prepared for 
the fight. 

He arrived when the Fine Art Society least expected him. 
A show of Twelve Great Etchers had opened, a press was in 
the gallery, Mr. Goulding was giving practical demonstrations 
of printing, etching was “‘ upon the town.” / 


“Well, you know, I was just home—nobody had seen me— 
and I drove up in a hansom. Nobody expected me. In one 
hand, I held my long cane; with the other, I led by a ribbon a 
beautiful little white Pomeranian dog—it too, had turned up 
suddenly. As I walked in, I spoke to no one, but putting up 
my glass, I looked at the prints on the wall. ‘Dear me! dear 
me!’ I said, ‘ still the same old sad work! Dear me!’ And 
Haden was there, talking hard to Brown, and laying down the 
law—and as he said ‘ Rembrandt,’ I said ‘Ha ha!’ and he 
vanished, and then uy 


He was without house and studio, and lived in Wimpole 
Street with his brother until he took lodgings in Langham 
Street and then in Alderney Street.* He at once set to work 
printing the hundred sets of the twelve plates, for few had 
been pulledin Venice. The Fine Art Society moved the press 
to a room upstairs, over their shop, and here old friends came 

* The record of this is in the etching published in the Gazette des Beaua-Aris, 


April 1881. 
1880] 127 289 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


to see him, W. M. Rossetti and Pellegrini especially remem- 
bered among the many, andhere Mr. Mortimer Menpes says, he 
first met Whistler, and, dropping Poynter, South Kensington 
and his own ambition, hastened to throw himself at the feet 
of ‘“‘the master’’ and inscribe himself a pupil. It was 
not an ideal workshop, and the Fine Art Society took two 
rooms for Whistler in Air Street, Regent Street, on the first 
floor of a house with a bow window looking out under the 
colonnade: the window from which he etched the plate of 
the now demolished Quadrant. 

According to Mr. T. R. Way, he and his father often came 
to Air Street to help Whistler with the printing. The press 
was in the front room, and Mr. Way made a sketch of it in 
colour, his father damping the paper, Whistler inking a plate, 
the press between them; an interesting document, for in 
this little room a number of prints for the Series of Twelve 
Etchings were pulled. The work was interrupted by occasional 
excitements. Mr. Way says, one day Whistler placed on his 
heater a bottle of nitric acid and water tightly stopped up. 
The stopper blew out, steaming acid fumes filled the room, 
and they had to run for their lives into a bedroom where 
Whistler never seems to have slept. Another time, they 
took corrosive sublimate, or something as deadly, to get the 
dried ink from the lines of plates not properly cleaned in 
Venice, and they dropped the corrosive sublimate on the 
floor, and, Mr. Way adds, there was not much left of the 
carpet. Why anything was left of the floor or of themselves 
is a mystery. Then, Mr. Menpes says: 


‘** Whistler drifted into a room in my own house, which I had 
fitted up with printing materials, and it was in this little printing- 
room of mine that most of the series of Venetian etchings were 
printed.” 


The edition of a hundred sets was, however, not completed 
290 ; [1880 


BACK IN LONDON 


during Whistler’s lifetime. It was only after his death that 
Mr. Goulding finished the work. 

The first series of Venetian plates was exhibited in 
December 1880, and hung by themselves in the Middle Room 
at the Fine Art Society’s. The Twelve were selected 
from the forty plates Whistler brought back with him. The 
critics could see nothing in them. The Academy thought 
that they might have been enjoyed at home, but to make 
of them an exhibition was a mistake. Truth dismissed them 
as “ another crop of Whistler’s little jokes.”” They did not 
represent any Venice that the Times cared to remember, 
‘for who wants to remember the degradation of what has 
been noble, the foulness of what has been fair ? ”’ They 
were “too slight in execution and unimportant in size” to 
satisfy the World. One after another, the popular authorities 
repeated the Attorney-General’s decision that Whistler was 
amusing, and Burne-Jones’ regret that he had not fulfilled 
his early promise. Whistler carefully collected the criticisms 
for future use, though one of them he answered immediately, 
the World’s: 


“Seriously, then, my Atlas, an etching does not depend, for its 
importance, upon its size. ‘I am not arguing with you—I am 
telling you.’ . . . Be severe with your man. Tell him his ‘job’ 
should be ‘neatly done.’ I could cut my own throat better ; 
and if need be, in case of his dismissal, I offer my services. 
Meanwhile, yours joyously.” 


*“ What a funny dog it is!’ was the editorial comment, 
and the public endorsed it. 

Mr. Brown, of the Fine Art Society, was going to New 
York before Christmas, and it was arranged that he should 
take with him a set of the Twelve. Whistler spent a Sunday 
pulling prints for the purpose, Mr. Brown at his side, the 
press never left, except for a sandwich. The journey was 
not a success, The etchings were no more appreciated or 
1880] 291 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


wanted in New York than in London. Only eight sets were 
ordered. 

In the meanwhile, Whistler was preparing for his show 
of pastels. 


‘“* Jimmy called—as self-reliant and sure as ever, full of con- 
fidence in the superlative merit of his pastels, which we are to 
go and see,” 


is Mr. Alan S. Cole’s note of Whistler’s first visit after his 
return (January 2, 1881). Thisshow also was at the Fine Art 
Society’s. Whistler designed the frames; he saw to the 
catalogue, which had the brown paper cover but not quite 
the form eventually adopted, and was printed by Mr. Way ; 
he decorated the gallery, an arrangement in gold and brown; 
which was enjoyed as “ another of his little jokes ” by the 
critics on press day (January 28). Godwin was one of the 
few who admitted its beauty, and his description in the British 
Architect (February 1881) has the value of a contemporary 
record : 


“ First, a low skirting of yellow gold, then a high dado of dull 
yellow green cloth, then a moulding of green gold, and then a 
frieze and ceiling of pale reddish brown. The frames are arranged 
on the line ; but here and there one is placed over another. Most 
of the frames and mounts are of rich yellow gold, but a dozen 
out of the fifty-three are in green gold, dotted about with a view 
of decoration, and eminently successful in attaining it.” 


On the evening of the press view, Mr. Cole says : 


“Whistler turned up for dinner very full of his private view 
to-morrow. Later on, we concocted a letter inviting Prince Teck 
to come to it. His last draft was all right, but he would insist 
on beginning it ‘ Prince,’ although I assured him ‘Sir’ was the 
us al way of addressing him in a letter.” 


The private view, the next day (January 29), was a crush, 
Bond Street blocked with carriages, the sidewalk crowded 
292 [1881 


BACK IN LONDON 


with people struggling to get in. Nothing like the excite- 
ment was ever known at the Fine Art Society’s. Millais, 
giving an exhibition in the adjoining room, was one of the 
first to see the pastels. ‘‘ Magnificent, fine—very cheeky— 
but fine ! ”’ he was heard to say in his big voice, and afterwards 
he wrote to Whistler to tell him so, and the letter pleased 
Whistler. The crowd did not know what to say, and, had 
they known, would have been afraid to say it. For Whistler 
was there, his laugh louder, shriller, than ever. He let no 
one forget the trial. An admirer asked the price of a pastel, 
and when told, exclaimed: ‘‘ Sixty guineas! That’s enor- 
mous!’ Whistler heard, though he was not meant to; 
he always heard everything. “‘Ha ha! Enormous! why 
not at all! I can assure you it took me quite half an hour 
to draw it!” 

People laughed at Whistler’s work, because they thought 
laughter was what he expected of them. Because he was the 
gayest man who ever lived, they refused to see that he was 
also the most serious artist: the combination bewildered 
them. When they treated his art as part of his gaiety, it 
hurt, for he was acutely sensitive, but he had his revenge by 
mystifying them still further : 


“Well, you know. they thought it was an amiability to me 
for them to be amused. One day, when I was on my way to the 
Fine Art Society’s, while the show was going on, I met Sir and 
Lady , face to face, at the door, as they were coming out. 
Both looked very much bored, but they couldn’t escape me. So 
the old man grasped my hand and chuckled: ‘We have just 
been looking at your things, and have been so much amused !’ 
He had an idea that the drawings on the wall were drolleries 
of some sort, though he could not understand why, and that it 
was his duty to be amused. I laughed with him. I always did 
with people of that kind, and then they said I was not serious.” 


A shriek of execration went up from the press. The critics 
1881] 293 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


too, laughed, but there was venom in their laughter. They 
liked to take themselves, if they couldn’t take Whistler, 
seriously, and they hated work they could not understand. 
The pastels were sensational, Whistler was clever, with “a 
sort of transatlantic impudence.” They objected to the 
brown paper, to the technique, to the frames, to the decora- 
tions, to the subjects ; they became unexpectedly concerned 
for the past glory of Venice. Godwin again was an exception. 
**'No one who has listened, as the writer of those brief little 
notes has, o Whistler’s graphic descriptions of the fairy-like, 
open arcaded, winding staircase that lifts its tall stem far into 
the blue sky, or of the remarkable facades, yet unrestored, that 
speak of the art power of the Venetian architect, can doubt that 
he who can so remember and describe has failed to admire. It 

is by reason of the strength of this admiration and high appre- 


ciation that he holds back in reverence, and exercises this reticence 
of the pencil, the needle and the brush.” 


A number of people expressed their belief in the pastels 
by buying them, and the show was a success financially. 
The prices ranged from twenty to sixty guineas, the total 
receipts amounted to eighteen hundred. Mr. Bacher quotes 
a letter written to him just after the show opened and signed 
“Maud Whistler ” : 


“The best of it is, all the pastels are selling. Four hundred 
pounds’ worth the first day, now over a thousand pounds’ worth 
are sold.” 


Before the exhibition closed, towards the end of February, 
Whistler was summoned to Hastings. His mother had been 
living there since her illness of 1876-77, from which she never 
entirely recovered, but there were often long intervals between 
the attacks when her family had no immediate cause for 
anxiety. In the end her death was sudden. Those who 
refused to see in Whistler any other good quality could not 
deny his devotion to his mother ; those to whom he revealed 
204. [1881 


BACK IN LONDON 


the tenderness, under the defiant masque with which he 
faced the world, knew what his love for her meant to him. 
She had lived with him whenever it was possible. His visits 
and letters to Hastings had been frequent. He never forgot 
her birthday. He told her of all his success, all his hopes, 
and made as light to her as he could of his debts and dis- 
appointments. But in the miserable week before the funeral 
at Hastings, he was full of remorse; he should have been 
kinder and more considerate, he said; he had not written 
often enough from Venice. Dr. Whistler was with him 
part of the time, and the Doctor’s wife throughout the 
long week. In the afternoons they would wander together 
on the windy cliffs above the town, and there was one 
grey, miserable afternoon when he broke down utterly. 
‘‘Tt would have been better,” he regretted, “ had I been 
a parson as she wished!” He had nothing to reproach 
himself with. The days in Chelsea were for her as happy 
as for him, and she whose pride had been in his first 
childish promise at St. Petersburg lived to see the full develop- 
ment of his genius. She was buried at Hastings. 

It was fortunate for him that, when he got back to town, 
events to distract his thoughts from his grief followed fast. 
The new Society of Painter-Etchers had arranged to open 
their first exhibition in April at the Hanover Gallery. Ameri- 
can artists who were just starting etching, and had never 
shown prints in London, were invited. Mr. Frank Duveneck, 
one of them, sent a series of Venetian prints. This was the 
occasion of “the storm in an esthetic teapot ?? which, had 
not Whistler thought it important as “ history,’’ would now 
be forgotten. We quote, as he did, from The Cuckoo (April 
11, 1881) : 

“ Some etchings, exceedingly like Mr. Whistler’s in manner, but 
signed ‘Frank Duveneck,’ were sent to the Painter-Etchers’ 


Exhibition from Venice. The Painter-Etchers appear to have 
1881] 295 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


suspected for a moment that the works were really Mr. Whistler’s ; 

_ and, not desiring to be the victims of an easy hoax on the part 
of that gentlemen, three of their members—Dr. Seymour Haden, 
Dr. Hamilton and Mr. Legros—went to the Fine Art Society’s 
Gallery in Bond Street, and asked one of the assistants there to 
show them some of Mr. Whistler’s Venetian plates. From this 
assistant they learned that Mr. Whistler was under an arrangement 
to exhibit and sell his Venetian etchings only at the Fine Art 
Society’s Gallery.” 


Whistler heard of this. On March 18 he called on Mr. 
Cole, who found him “‘ highly incensed with Haden and Legros 
conspiring to make out he was breaking his contract with 
the Fine Art Society.” In his first indignation, Whistler 
went straight to the Hanover Gallery, Mr. Menpes with him, 
but the three members were not to be found there. Haden 
then wrote to the Fine Art Society that they knew all about 
Mr. Duveneck, and were delighted with his etchings, and he 
expressed regret. But it is incredible that two etchers like 
Haden and Legros could have mistaken the work of Duveneck 
for that of Whistler. 

Whistler published the whole story in a pamphlet called 
The Piker Papers. Piker was the name of a newsagent who 
had become involved. With its interest a little dulled by 
time, the correspondence may be read in The Gentle Art. 

Whistler had not forgotten the pictures left, before the 
bankruptcy, with Mr. Graves in Pall Mall. By degrees he 
bought them back. When Mr. Algernon Graves consulted 
his father about letting Whistler have the pictures upon 
which the full amount was not paid, as well as the Nocturnes, 
for three of which Whistler had repaid a hundred pounds, 
the father said: ‘“‘ Let him take the whole lot, and don’t be 
a fool; the pictures aren’t worth twenty-five pounds apiece.” 
The Rosa Corder was sold at Christie’s with Howell’s other 
effects, Mr. Algernon Graves agreeing that, if it brought more 
than the money Howell owed the firm, Howell’s executors 
296 [1881 


wr 


aa 


STUDY FOR “ROSA CORDER” 


ROSA CORDER 


BACK IN LONDON 


could have the balance. The father maintained the picture 
wouldn’t fetch ten pounds, but it brought more than the 
amount of their bill, some hundred and thirty pounds. The 
Irving was sold to Sir Henry for a hundred pounds, and 
the Miss Franklin went to Messrs. Dowdeswell. Whistler 
continued to pay his bills regularly as they came due, to 
Graves’ great astonishment ; there was only one exception 
and then Whistler came down to ask to have the payment 
postponed, and this was not settled until long after the 
pictures were in Whistler’s possession. When Whistler 
paid the final sum, Mr. Graves expressed his surprise. But 
Whistler said : 


“You have been a very good friend to me—in fact you have 
been my banker. You have acted honourably to me in the whole 
matter. I meant to pay, and I have done so.” 


These business details and his own exhibitions left 
Whistler no time to think of the annual shows of 1881. He 
had nothing in the Salon, and in the Grosvenor only Miss 
Alexander, painted and exhibited in London years before. 
In the autumn, however, borrowing the Mother from Mr. 
Graves, he sent it to the Academy in Philadelphia, the 
arrangements being made for him by Mrs. Anna Lea Merritt. 
She writes us: 


“In the autumn of 1881, I was asked by the Pennsylvania 
Academy of Fine Arts to receive pictures by American artists, 
and have them forwarded for exhibition, and especially they 
entreated me to persuade Mr. Whistler to send a picture. He 
had never been represented in any American exhibition. I 
obtained a chance, when meeting him at a dinner, of pressing the 
subject more vigorously than I could have done by writing, and 
he promised to send his mother’s portrait. It was collected in 
due course and deposited in my studio, then in the ‘ Avenue.’ 
Mr. Whistler came immediately after and as the canvas was 
breaking away from the stretcher, he directed the packing agents 
who were skilful frame makers, to restrain it and then left me. 

1881] 297 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


As soon as the canvas was made tight, spots of crushed varnish 
appeared on the surface. The varnish, in fact, broke or crumbled 
and I feared the canvas might have broken. I flew down the 
street, overtook him, and brought him back, dreading that he 
would blame us and even that some injury had been done. To 
my surprise, he took the misfortune with perfect composure 
and kindness, and stippled the spots with some solvent varnish 
that soon restored the even surface. And there was never @ 
word of suggestion that we had done any harm. Of course, I 
knew the fault was not in anything that had been done, and it 
was by his own order, but from all I had heard about him I 
trembled. The greatest difficulty in connection with that 
exhibition was to persuade him to journey to the American 
Consulate in St. Helen’s Place and make his affidavit for the 
invoice. It had to be done by himself and it was not pleasant, 
as we know, to waste a day, the very middle of the day, in this 
dull declaration of American citizen sojourning in England. 
After the cases were ready for shipment, there was still delay 
to get this task accomplished, and I think the Pennsylvania 
Academy hardly guess how much persuading it took. What a 
pity they did not secure the beautiful picture for his own country. 
Now that it hangs in the Luxembourg, they envy it.” 


The Mother was exhibited in two or three other American 
cities before it was returned, in June 1882, and could have been 
bought for twelve hundred dollars. Although it did not 
fetch this trumpery price, it stimulated interest in the artist 
and in his etchings when they were shown in several American 
galleries. Societies of etchers were at this period being formed 
by American artists, and exhibitions of etchings organised in 
the principal towns. There was a show of American etchings 
in the Boston Museum of Fine Arts in 1881, another in 1882 in 
the New York Etching Club, while the Philadelphia Society 
of Etchers gave in this year its first international exhibition. 
Haden, encouraged by Mr. Frederick Keppel, came to the 
United States to lecture on etching. Articles in Scribner’s 
on Whistler and Haden, helped to increase the interest. We 


remember the excitement made by Haden’s lectures which 
298 [1881 


BACK IN LONDON 


prepared the public for a more criticalstudy of Whistler, whose 
prints were in both the New York and Philadelphia Exhibi- 
tions. Mr. Claghorn, almost the only Philadelphian who 
then cared for etchings, had already collected Whistler’s 
prints. Mr. Avery, in New York, had some years before 
begun his collection and secured for it many of the rarest 
proofs. But, generally speaking, in America more had been 
heard of Whistler’s eccentricities than of his work. It could, 
however, no longer remain unknown, once his etchings and 
the portrait of the Mother were seen, and The White Girl was 
lent to the Metropolitan Museum in New York, where it hung 
for some time. And, gradually the young men who had 
been with him in Venice, coming back, helped to spread his 
fame at home, and, when Americans got to know his work, 
they became the keenest to possess it. 


1881] 299 


CHAPTER XXIV. THE JOY OF LIFE. 
THE YEARS EIGHTEEN EIGHTY-ONE 
TO EIGHTEEN EIGHTY-FOUR 


Q~* May 26, 1881, Mr. Alan S. Cole 


““met Jimmie, who is taking a new studio in Tite Street, where 
he is going to paint all the fashionables—views of crowds com- 
peting for sittings—carriages along the streets.” 

It was at No. 18, close to the White House. Whistler 
decorated it with a scheme of yellow: one felt in it as if 
standing inside an egg, Howell said. He again picked up 
blue and white, and old silver; he again gave his Sunday 
breakfasts, and they again became the talk of the town, and 
he the fashion. If the town was determined to talk, Whistler 
was determined it should have good reason. He was never 
so malicious, never so extravagant, never so ‘‘ joyous,” as 
at this period. He deliberately wrapped himself for pro- 
tection, as he afterwards said, ‘in a species of misunder- 
standing.” He filled the papers with letters, each a 
delicately barbed little arrow, meant to hurt. London 
re-echoed with his laugh. His white lock stood up more 
defiantly above his curls; his cane lengthened; a series 
of collars sprang from the neck of the long overcoat, his 
hat borrowed a flatter brim, a lower tilt over his eyes; he 
invented amazing costumes—“in great form, with a new 
fawn-coloured long-skirted frock-coat, and extraordinary 
long cane,” Mr. Cole found him one summer day in 1882. 
He allowed no break in the gossip, no pause for the town 
to take breath. 

300 [1881 


THE JOY OF LIFE 


The carriages brought the expected crowds, but not the 
sitters. Few had been eager to sit to him before the trial, 
now there were fewer. In the ’eighties, as M. Duret says, 
it needed courage to be painted by Whistler: to do so was 
to risk notoriety, if not ridicule. Mrs. (now Lady) Meux, 
was the first to give him a commission at this difficult moment, 
and she has been well repaid for her heroism. The two large 
full-lengths he painted of her are amongst his most distin- 
guished portraits. She was handsome, of a more luxuriant 
type than the women who usually sat to him, her full-blown 
beauty a contrast to the elusive loveliness of ‘‘ Maud ”’ in 
the Fur Jacket, or of Mrs. Leyland, and to the quiet dignity of 
Mrs. Huth. Whistler found for her harmonies appropriate 
to her beauty. The first was an Arrangement in White and 
Black, which few people have seen. There is a sumptuousness 
in the black of the shadowy background and the velvet 
gown, in the white of the fur of the long cloak, that Whistler 
never surpassed. M. Duret, who often saw the portrait in the 
studio, found in it something “mysterious and fantastic ”’; 
to us, the firm modelling of the face and beautiful bare neck 
and arms, gives to the almost regal figure more solidity than 
Whistler usually tried for, and less of the spirit, the phantom, 
that Desnoyers, and Huysmans after him, found in Whistler’s 
paintings of women. Whistler was pleased with it, and 
spoke of it as his “‘ beautiful Black Lady.” Lady Meux was 
so well satisfied that she at once posed for a second portrait. 
This time the Harmony was in Flesh-Colour and Pink, after- 
wards changed to Pink and Grey. She was once more painted 
standing, wearing a curious round hat low over her head 
and face, and a high bodice with long sleeves, cut in the 
ugly fashion of the day, which cannot conceal or deform 
the beauty of her figure. 

There was a third, smaller portrait which, as far as 
we can find out, was never finished. Mr. Menpes has 
1881] 301 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


published the reproduction of a pen-and-ink drawing, in 
the possession of Mr. C. W. Dowdeswell, of Lady Meux in 
bonnet and coat, her hands in a muff, which may have been 
the study or suggestion for it. Mr. Harper Pennington, 
writing of this picture, says, 


“The only time I saw Jimmy ‘stumped’ for a reply was at 
a sitting of Lady Meux (for the portrait in sables). For some 
. reason Jimmy became nervous—exasperated—and impertinent. 
Touched by something he had said, her ladyship turned softly 
towards him and remarked, quite softly: ‘See here, Jimmy 
Whistler! You keep a civil tongue in that head of yours, or 
I will have in some one to finish those portraits you have made 
of me ! ’—with the faintest emphasis on ‘finish.’ Jimmy fairly 
danced with rage. He came up to Lady Meux, his long brush 
tightly grasped, and actually quivering in his hand, held tight 
against his side. He stammered, spluttered—and finally gasped 
out: ‘How dare you? How dare you ?’—but that, after all, 
was not an answer, wasit ? Lady Meux did notsitagain. Jimmy 
never spoke of the incident afterwards, and I was sorry to have 
witnessed it.” 


Sir Henry Cole posed again for his portrait. Mr. Alan S. 
Cole saw it in the studio on February 26, 1882: 
“‘Found his commencement of my father, good but slight, 


full length, evening clothes, long dark cloak thrown back, red 
ribbon of Bath.” 


Another sitting, of which there is a note, was on April 17: 


“In spite of his illness, my father to Whistler’s, who fretted 
him by not painting—my father thought that Jimmy had merely 
touched the light on his shoes, and nothing else—although he 
stood and sat for over an hour and a half.” 


This was the last sitting. The next day Sir Henry Cole 
died suddenly, a distinguished official lost to England, a good 
friend lost to Whistler. Eldon, who was in the studio on 
the 17th, recalled afterwards that his last words on leaving 
were: “ Death waits for no man!” Whistler meant to go 
302 [1882 


THE JOY OF LIFE 


on with the portrait. On May 2, Mr. Cole went again to 
Tite Street : 


“ After a long delay, Jimmy showed me his painting of my 
father, which J. can make into a very good thing.” 


But it was never finished. Neither was a full-length 
of Eldon, a friend much with him at the time. We 
have seen a photograph of it, a fine thing evidently, but it 
also has vanished, though a small version was sent to the 
London Memorial Exhibition, where, however, it was not 
hung. During the next few years, innumerable other portraits 
were begun, but though we have photographs of several, 
it is not always possible to identifythem. One, an Arrange- 
ment in Yellow, of which he hoped great things, was 
of Mrs. Langtry. In another, he returned to the old 
scheme of “‘ blue upon blue.”’ Miss Elinor Leyland, ‘‘ Maud,” 
Connie Gilchrist, had stood for it; Miss Maud Waller now 


succeeded them. Mrs. Marzetti, her sister, who always 
went with her to the studio, writes : 


“‘ As far as I can remember, the sittings commenced in the 
early part of 1882. We went two or three times, and then 
Whistler painted the face out, as it was not to his liking, although 
most people thought it excellent. In those days Maud was very 
beautiful. The picture was started on a canvas that already 
had a figure on it, and it was turned upside down, and the Blue 
Girls head painted in between the legs. The dress was made 
by Mme. Alias, the theatrical costumier, to Whistler’s design, 
and I believe cost a good deal. In the end the picture was 
finished from another model (I do not know who), and was hung 
in one of Whistler’s exhibitions in Bond Street: it is No. 31 in 
the catalogue, and called Scherzo in Blue—The Blue Girl. This 
was the same exhibition in which he hung the picture he gave 
me, and which in the end I never got (No. 66, Bravura in Brown). 
I should have treasured it for two reasons: Whistler’s painting, 
and also that it was a portrait of Mr. Ridley. The picture, as 
Maud stood for it, was to have been in that season’s exhibition 
at the Grosvenor Gallery, but was not finished. However, it 

1882] 303 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


was sent in for the private view, and taken away again the same 
night or next morning. We used thoroughly to enjoy our visits 
to the studio, that is to say, I did, because I sat and looked on, 
I can’t say whether Maud enjoyed them as much, probably 
not, as we used to get down there about 11 o’clock, have 
lunch, and stay all the afternoon, most of which time she 
was standing. 

‘“‘T cannot remember all the callers we used to see there, as 
there were so many; but some of the more frequent visitors I 
remember well. There was one man who was always there, all 
day long, and we just hated him: I don’t know why, as he 
seemed very harmless. He was Whistler’s shadow. I don’t 
know who he was, but have an idea that he used to write a bit. 
I think he was very poor, and that Whistler pretty well kept him, 
I heard some few years ago that he died in a lunatic asylum. 
Oscar Wilde was a frequent visitor, also Walter Sickert. Whistler 
used to say ‘ Nice boy, Walter’; he was very fond of him then. 
Others I remember were two brothers named Story, Frank Miles 
(who had a studio just opposite Whistler’s)—Renée Rodd as 
Whistler used to call him—Major Templar, Lady Archie Camp- 
bell, and Mrs. Hungerford. These were all pretty constant 
visitors, but there were many others whom I cannot remember. 
Whistler was just finishing the portrait of Lady Meux at the 
time, and I remember standing for him one day for about five 
minutes, while he put the lights in the eyes. If I remember 
rightly, it was a full-length portrait in black evening dress, with 
a big white cloak over the shoulders. 

“ Whistler was a most entertaining companion: he was very 
fond of telling us Edgar Allen Poe’s stories, and also of reciting 
The Lost Lenore, which he said was his favourite poem. He 
dined with us several times in Lyall Street, he was always late 
for dinner, sometimes half an hour, and I think, on more than 
one occasion, was sound asleep at the table before the end of 
dinner. 

“‘ Whistler’s usual breakfast, which he often had after we 
arrived at the studio, was two eggs in a tumbler, beaten up with 
pepper, salt and vinegar, bread and coffee... . 

“ Whistler’s mode of painting was most comical: he stood 
yards away from the picture with his brush, and would move 
it as though he were painting; he would then take a hop, skip 
and jump across the room, and put a dab of paint on the canvas ; 

304 [1882 


* 


5 
val re 


“s ey ee eee 
ee a eR 


THE YELLOW BUSKIN (Lapy Arcuipatp Camppett) 
Arrangement in Black, No, VII. 


THE JOY OF LIFE 


he also used to wet his finger, and gently rub portions of 
his picture. I have often seen him take a sponge with soap 
and water, and wash the Blue Girl’s face (on the canvas, I 
mean).”’ 


Lady Archibald Campbell, whom Mrs. Marzetti met in 
the studio, was a woman of great’ distinction and beauty, 
with the intelligence to see in Whistler a master. She 
writes us : 


“He was a great friend of ours. I think I sat to him during 
a year or so, off and on, for a very great many studies in different 
costumes and poses. His first idea was to paint me in court dress. 
The dress was black velvet, the train was silver satin with the 
Argyle arms embroidered in appliqué in their proper colours. He 
made a sketch of me in the dress. The fatigue of standing with 
the train was too great, and he abandoned the idea. In all 
these studies I remember he called my attention to his method 
of placing his subject well within the frame, and explaining that 
a portrait must be more than a portrait, must be of value deco- 
ratively, that is to say, it must be decorative in purpose. He 
never patched up defects, but if with any portion of his work 
he became dissatisfied, he covered the canvas over afresh with 
his first impression freshly recorded. The first impression 
thrown on the canvas he often put away, often destroyed. Among 
others, he made in oil colour an impression of me as Orlando, in 
the forest scene of As You Inke It, at Coombe. He considered 
this successful. A picture which he called The Grey Lady was a 
harmony in silver greys. JI remember thinking it was a master- 
piece of drawing, giving the impression of movement. I was 
descending the steps of a stair, the canvas was of a great height, 
and the general effect very striking. That picture was almost 
completed, when my absence from town prevented a continuance 
of the sittings. When I returned, he asked to make a study of 
me in the dress in which I called upon him. This is the picture 
which he exhibited under the name of The Brodequin Jaune, or 
The Yellow Buskin. I understand it is now at Philadelphia. As 
far as I remember, it was painted in a very few sittings. ‘When 
I saw him very shortly before his death, I remember asking 
after The Grey Lady. He laughed, and said he had destroyed 
her.” 
1882] I:U 305 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


M. Duret suggests that, in the end, the ridicule of her 
friends had their effect on Lady Archibald Campbell, or 
perhaps that her beauty gave her the right to capriciousness ; 
anyhow, she suggested changes to Whistler, who, though 
he seldom accepted suggestions from his sitters, did his best 
to meet her wishes until it seemed as if, to please her, he 
must repaint his picture, and he was seized with discourage- 
ment. We have heard of a dramatic scene just outside the 
studio: Lady Archibald Campbell in a hansom, on the point 
of driving away never to return; M. Duret springing on the 
step, representing to her the loss to the world of the master- 
piece if she refused to stand for it again, and arguing so well 
that she did come back, and The Yellow Buskin was saved 
from the fate of The Grey Lady and The Lady in Court Dress. 
Her story of the sittings shows that her social duties, her 
absences from town, were the reason of apparent unwilling- 
ness. Some think the one portrait of her that was finished 
is Whistler’s greatest. It has not only the decorative value 
she says he insisted upon, but great distinction in the figure 
and face, character in the pose as she stands there fastening 
her glove, and splendid colour. It is one of Whistler’s several 
Arrangements in Black. Critics of the day could discover 
in the series only dinginess and dirt. One wit described the 
picture as the portrait of a lady pursuing the last train 
through the smoke of the Underground. Now, however, 
people have learned to see, or at least to know they should 
see, beauty and variety in Whistler’s blacks and greys, and 
few would deny that the picture is a masterpiece of colour. 
Whistler exhibited it first as the portrait of Lady Archibald 
Campbell, but afterwards as The Yellow Buskin, its title 
in the Wilstach Collection, Philadelphia, to which it now 
belongs. 

M. Duret was posing to Whistler at the same time. When 
Lady Archibald Campbell could not come, Whistler would 
306 [1882 


THE JOY OF LIFE 


telegraph for him. Almost day by day, he watched the 
progress of her portrait as he saw his own growing under 
Whistler’s brush. Business brought M. Duret often to 
London at this time, and Whistler had no truer friend. He 
had always been much with artists in Paris, had been inti- 
mate with Courbet, and was still with Fantin, Manet and 
Bracquemond. He saw the genius of men at whom the 
world still scoffed. It was he, who, by his article on Whistler, 
in the Gazette des Beaux-Arts, April 1881, reprinted in Critique 
d’ Avant Garde (1885), made the French realise their mistake 
of many years, and again give Whistler the recognition they 
had long denied him. 

The etching of Alderney Street was printed with M. Duret’s 
article in the Gazette, though three years earlier the editor 
could not “afford ’? Whistler’s price, and Whistler regretted 
that he could not “‘ afford ” to be born in the Gazetie. The 
absence of sitters left Whistler leisure to carry out many of 
his pictorial schemes. M. Duret says that one evening in 
1883, after a private view, they were talking over the pictures, 
and in discussing the portrait of the President of some 
Society, Whistler decided that the red robes of office were 
not in character with the modern head, and that a man should 
be painted in clothes as modern as himself, and he asked M. 
Duret to come and pose to him that he might show what 
could be done with evening dress, the despair of painters. 
The experiment was not so original as M. Duret seems to 
think. The portrait of Leyland was done ten years before, 
and in it Whistler proved the truth of Baudelaire’s assertion 
that the great colourist can get colour from materials as 
simple as a black coat, a white cravat or shirt, and a dark 
background. Sir Henry Cole also stood for him in evening 
clothes. Nor did Whistler rely entirely upon so simple a 
scheme in his portrait of M. Duret, who was made to stand 
with a pink domino hanging over his arm, anda red fan in 
1882] 307 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


his hand, and the portrait was an Arrangement in Flesh 
Colour and Black. 

M. Duret describes Whistler at work. He marked slightly 
with chalk the place for the figure on the canvas, and began 
at once to put in his colours as they were to remain in the 
finished work, so that, at the end of the first sitting, the 
design of the portrait was seen. This was the rapid method 
of sketching in a full-length figure, that delighted Whistler 
in the Irving. The difficulty with him was not to begin a 
portrait, but to finish it. The picture was brought almost 
to completion, scraped down, begun again, and repainted 
ten times. From many of Whistler’s sitters come stories 
of his struggles as draughtsman. M. Duret, who lived much 
with painters, saw that it was a question not of drawing, but 
of colour, of tone, and understood Whistler’s theory that to 
bring the whole into harmonious relation, and preserve it, 
the whole must be repainted as a whole, if there is any re- 
painting at all, and not merely in parts. There are finer 
portraits, but not many that show so well Whistler’s meaning 
when he said that colour is ‘the arrangement of colour.” 
The rose of the domino, the fan, and the flesh, is so skilfully 
managed that it flushes the cold grey of the background with 
rose. M. Duret, when he shows you the picture, in his 
apartment at Paris, will take a sheet of paper, cut a hole in 
it, and place it against the background, to prove that the 
grey, when surrounded by white, is pure and cold, without 
a touch of rose, and that Whistler got his effect by his know- 
ledge of the relation of colours, and his mastery of the tones 
he wished to obtain. 

Whistler lost little time in showing the portraits as he 
finished them. His Lady Meux, the “ beautiful Black 
Lady,” went to the Salon of 1882, where it was catalogued 
as Portrait de M. Harry—Men, to the confusion ofj;com- 
mentators and cataloguers ever since. The Harmony in 
308 [1882 


LADY MEUX 


(Arrangement in Black and White) 


THE JOY OF LIFE 


Flesh Colour and Pink was shown at the Grosvenor 
with several other pictures. The critics were again at a 
loss how to take them. The Times was unable to decide 
whether Whistler was making fun of them all, or whether 
something was wrong with his eyes; the Pall Mall regretted 
that 


“if the Lady Meux was full of fine and subtle qualities of drawing, 
the Scherzo in Blue was the sketch of a scarecrow in a blue dress 
without form and void. It is very difficult to believe that Mr. 
Whistler is not openly laughing at us when he holds up before 
us such a piece as this. His counterpart in Paris, the eccentric 
M. Manet, has at least more sincerity than to exhibit his work 
in such an imperfect condition.” 


But Whistler now had his defenders. An ‘‘ Art Student ’”’ 
wrote the next day to the Pall Mall to point out that 


“at the private, and therefore, presumably, the press view, The 
Blue Girl was seen in an unfinished state, having been sent there 
merely to take up its space on the wall. It was removed imme- 
diately, and has been since finished. Had the critic seen it 
since, he would hardly have called it without form and void. 
The want of artistic sincerity is certainly the last charge 
that can be brought against a man who has followed his artistic 
intention with such admirable and unswerving singleness of 
purpose.” 


From this time onward, Whistler was no longer alone in 
fighting his battles. 

1882 was the year of The Paddon Papers. Mr. Cole wrote 
on September 24: k 


“To Jimmy’s. He lent me proof of his Paddon and Howell 
correspondence. Amusing, but too personal for general interest.” 


We agree with Mr. Cole. There were complications of no 
importance with Howell, in which Paddon, a diamond 
merchant, figured ; and further complications over the Chinese 
cabinet Mr. Morse bought from Whistler when he moved into 
1882] ; 309 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


No. 2 Lindsey Row. For long Mr. Morse was left with only 
the lower part, while Howell had the top. Whistler, who 
thought nothing concerning him trivial, printed these letters 
in a pamphlet, called The Paddon Papers ; or, The Owl and 
the Cabinet, interesting now, only because it is rare, and 
because it marks the end of all relations between himself 
and Howell. 


In the early winter of 1883, Whistler gave the second 
exhibition of his Venetian etchings at the Fine Art Society’s. 
The prints, fifty-one in number, included several London 
subjects. He decorated the gallery in a scheme of white 
and yellow. The wall was white with yellow hangings, the 
floor was covered with pale yellow matting, and the couches 
with pale yellow serge. The few light, cane-bottomed chairs 
were painted yellow. There were yellow flowers in yellow 
pots, a white and yellow livery for the door attendant, and 
white and yellow Butterflies in paper and silk for his friends. 
It is remembered that, at the private view, Whistler wore 
yellow socks just showing now and then above his low shoes, 
and that the young assistants wore yellow neckties. He 
prepared the catalogue, its brown paper cover, form and 
size now established, and after each title he printed a quotation 
from his critics in the past. ‘ Out of their own mouths 
shall ye judge them ” was the motto on his title-page. A 
friend much with him at the time says that he looked over 
the proofs with Whistler : 


‘* We came to ‘ there is merit in them, and I do not wish to 
understand it’ [a quotation from Wedmore’s article in the 
Nineteenth Century]. Jimmy yelled with joy, and thanked the 
printer for his intelligent misreading of understate. ‘I think we 
will let that stand as it is,’ he said. I was amused at the private 
view to see him discussing the question with Mr. Wedmore, who 

‘naturally, did not think it quite fair.” 
310 [1883 


THE JOY OF LIFE 


The result was another little chapter in The Gentle Art. 
Before the end of February, the catalogue went into a third 
edition. We have a copy of the sixth. 

Even before the show opened, it. was, 


‘Well, you know, a source of constant anxiety to everybody 
and of fun tome. On the ladder, when I was hanging the prints 
I could hear whispers—no one would be able to see the etchings ! 
And then I would laugh, ‘ Dear me, of course not! that’s all 
right. In an exhibition of etchings, the etchings are the last 
things people come to see!’ And then there was the private 
view, and I had my box of wonderful little Butterflies, and I 
distributed them only among the select few, so that, naturally, 
everybody was eager to be decorated. And when the crowd was 
greatest, Royalty appeared—quite unprecedented at a private 
view, and the crowd was hustled into another room while the 
Prince and Princess of Wales went round the gallery, looking 
at everything, the Prince chuckling over the catalogue. ‘I say, 
Mr. Whistler, what is this?’ he asked when he came to the 
Nocturne—Palaces. ‘I am afraid you are very malicious, Mr. 
Whistler,’ the Princess said.” 


Those who received the little Butterflies thought them 
charming. Mrs. Marzetti writes : 


“T have a few treasures which I guard most jealously ; one 
is the golden Butterfly that he made us wear at the private 
view of one of his exhibitions in Bond Street, in the original 
little card box in which he sent them (three, I think) to mother, 
with a message written on the lid, and signed with his 
Butterfly.” 


But by the public at large everything was laughed at. The 
Butterflies added to the “‘ screaming farce,” the “‘ foppery ” 
of the whole thing. The attendant in yellow and white 
livery was nicknamed “ the poached egg.”. The catalogue 
was the worst offence. Mr. Wedmore could hardly like to 
have it recalled that fourteen months before he had disposed 
of Whistler as “‘ years ago . . . a person of high promise,” 
1883] 311 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


or the gentleman of the Atheneum to be reminded of his 
earlier decision that “‘ in Mr. Whistler’s productions one might 
safely say that there is no culture.”” They tried to make 
the best of it by refusing to see in him anything save the 
jester. The Times compared his humour to Mark Twain’s. 
The Daily News found the general effect of the show 
“excruciatingly agreeable.”” Funny Folks likened him to 
Barnum, and Punch agreed. The Echo thought his work 
rubbish—his last little joke was dull without being cheap. 
Their ridicule has become ridiculous. As for Whistler’s 
etchings, the price of the series of Twelve, as of the T'wenty- 
Siz issued a year or so later, in which many of these prints 
were published, was fifty guineas ; on May 27, 1908, the single 
print, Nocturne—Palaces, sold in Paris for one hundred and 
sixty eight guineas. 

For the large exhibitions of this year, he had no new work, 
but sent two of the earlier Nocturnes to the Grosvenor, and 
to the Salon the Mother, for which he was awarded a third- 
class medal, the first and only recompense he ever received 
at the Salon. In the winter of 1883-84 he worked a great 
deal out of doors, spending many weeks at St. Ives, Cornwall. 
He took no interest in landscape—“‘ there were too many 
trees in the country,” he always said. But he loved the sea, 
from the days of The Blue Wave at Biarritz and The Shores 
of Brittany until one of the last summers of all when he 
painted it at Domburg in Holland. The Cornish sketches 
were sent to his show of Notes, Harmonies, Nocturnes at the 
Dowdeswell’s Gallery in May 1884. It was the first exhibition 
in which he included many water-colours. The medium had 
been difficult to him at first; now he was its master. He 
used it to record subjects as characteristic of London as the 
subjects of his pastels were of Venice: the little shops of 
Chelsea, the old church, the streets wrapped in the London 
atmosphere, the rows of old houses by the river. There were 
312 [1884 


THE JOY OF LIFE 


also studies and sketches brought back from an occasional 
journey to Holland, for he was always running about now, 
or from the sea-shore near London. The interest of the Cata- 
logue this time was in the Preface, L’Envote he called it. It 
gives the Propositions No. 2 which have become famous: that 
a picture is finished when all traces of the means that pro- 
duced it have disappeared ; that industry in Artis a necessity, 
not a virtue; that the work of the master reeks not of the 
sweat of the brow ; that the masterpiece should appear as the 
flower to the painter, perfect in its bud as in its bloom. He 
decorated the gallery: delicate rose-colour on the walls, 
white dado, white chairs and pale azaleas in rose-flushed 
jars. The Butterfly, tinted in flesh-colour like the walls, was 
on the card of invitation. The Arrangement in Flesh-Colour 
and Grey was as little appreciated as the Yellow and White 
in 1883, and the critics refused to see in it anything but a 
new affectation. 

Still signs were not missing of appreciation, and when, in 
1884, Whistler sent the Carlyle to the Loan Exhibition 
of Scottish National Portraits at Edinburgh, it created 
a deep impression. There had already been attempts to 
sell the picture. M. Duret tried to interest an Irish collector 
who, however, did not dare to buy it in the face of general 
hostility and ridicule. It was offered to Mr. Scharfe, director 
of the National Portrait Gallery in London, who not only 
refused to consider the offer, but laughed at the idea that 
such work should pass for painting at all. The first serious 
endeavour to secure it for a national collection came from 
Mr. George R. Halkett, then quite a young man, who urged 
its purchase for the Scottish National Gallery, in a letter to 
the Scotsman (October 6, 1884). 

“S1r,—Will you give me permission to express a very wide- 
spread feeling that an effort should be made to obtain for the 


Scottish National Gallery the magnificent portrait of Carlyle, by 
1884] 13x 313 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


Mr. Whistler, now in the Loan Exhibition. There can be no 
question that a National Portrait Gallery, endowed by the 
generosity and public spirit of a Scotsman, should possess a 
portrait of one of the most eminent of Scotland’s sons, and there 
can be as little doubt that a more faithful portrait than this of 
Whistler’s will not readily be obtainable. Mr. Whistler’s un- 
conventional methods and personal eccentricities, perhaps even 
more than Mr. Ruskin’s ‘ pot of paint’ criticism, have tended 
unduly to discredit him in the popular estimation, and in certain 
varieties of his work there may be room for doubt whether he 
should be regarded quite seriously. But the present picture is 
in truth, one of the most serious and impressive of his productions, 
and has been accepted as such by artists and critics. The 
criticism applied by Mr. Brownell in his Scribner article to another 
portrait by Whistler—that of his mother—is equally applicable 
here: ‘in a grave dignity, not without sensibility, a quiet and 
almost severe grace that is full of character, it is difficult to 
conceive a more charming union of portraiture and picturesque- 
ness.’ At last year’s Salon, Mr. Whistler was awarded a medal 
by a jury composed of the leading artists in Paris, and including 
men so eminent in their art and yet so opposite in their tendencies 
and methods as Bonnat, Cabanel and Bouguereau; and this 
year, as we learn from a competent authority in the Magazine 
of Art, this portrait of Carlyle and another exhibit were among 
the most popular of the pictures at the Salon. Apart from its 
distinctive merits as a work of art, it has been freely admitted 
by those who knew Carlyle well to be thoroughly faithful, as 
well as a most pathetic, rendering of the ‘Sage of Chelsea’ in 
his age. ... 


** It would be a great thing for Edinburgh if she were the first 
city in this country publicly to recognise what the art-lovers 
of France and America have been proclaiming for many a day, 
and, while encouraging Mr. Whistler’s art, at the same time 
obtain a worthy portrait of Thomas Carlyle, himself one of 
the earliest and most ardent advocates of a Scottish National 
Portrait Gallery. Unlike the national galleries in London 
and Dublin we in Scotland have to depend in the meantime 
upon private liberality for our art treasures, and it is to be 
hoped, in the present instance, that this, our only resource, will 
not fail us.” 


314 [1884 


THE JOY OF LIFE 


Mr. William Hole supported Mr. Halkett the following 
day: 


“ The picture is one of the best examples of a master who, at 
his best, and within his own limits, is almost beyond criticism, 
and, considering the great advance in art knowledge made of late 
years in Scotland, there are few, I think, who have given the 
work careful study and thought, who will not endorse the opinion 
already formed by many of the best critics at home and abroad, 
that Whistler’s Carlyle is one of the noblest examples of modern 
portraiture, that its possession, therefore, would add lustre to 
any art gallery, and that its subject renders the national collection 
of Scotland its most fitting resting-place.” 


Unfortunately, it was reported that the subscription paper 
disclaimed all approval of Whistler’s art and theories on the 
part of subscribers. Whistler was indignant. He tele- 
graphed to Edinburgh: ‘“‘ The price of the Carlyle has 
advanced to one thousand guineas. Dinna ye hear the 
bagpipes ?”? The price originally was four hundred, and 
this ended the negotiations. 

Why, about this time, Whistler should have become in- 
volved in a Church Congress in the Lake Country, unless he 
was coming from, or going to, Scotland, we never have been 
able toexplain. He told us about it years later, and he seemed 
no less amazed than we. J. was just about to start for the 
Lakes, and Whistler was reminded of his excursion there. 
We give the note made at the time, as it is: 


Sunday, September 16 (1900).—“ Whistler dined, and Agnes 
Repplier—not a successful combination. The dinner dragged 
until E, J. Sullivan happened to come in, and Whistler woke up, 
and, all of a sudden, we hardly know how, he was plunged into 
the midst of the Lake Country and a Church Congress, travelling 
third class with the clergy and their families, eating jam and 
strange meals with quantities of tea, and visiting the Rev. Mr. 
Green in his prison, shut up by his bishop for burning candles, 

1884] 315 


JAMES McNEILL WHISTLER 


and altogether the hero and important person he would never be 
on coming out. An amazing story, but what Whistler was, 
doing in the Lakes with the clergy, he did not beEpeas to know— 
the story was enough.” 


The one and only result of the etnatition was his impression 
of the unpicturesqueness of the Lakes: the mountains 
* were all little round hills with little round trees out of a 
Noah’s Ark.” 


END OF VOL. I. 


Printed by BALLANTYNE & Co. LiMiTED 
Tavistock Street, Covent Garden, London 


3 9088 


Tn